<teammate-message teammate_id="code-reviewer-p2" color="yellow" summary="Phase 2 code review complete, all 10 items PASS">
Phase 2 code review is complete. Report written to `work/phase-2/code-review.md`.

**Summary: All 10 checklist items PASS. Self-assessment: 9/10.**

Key findings:
- 0 Pint violations in Phase 2 files
- 283 tests passing (48 new, 0 regressions)
- All models, services, enums, factories, migrations, and tests reviewed

Minor observations (none warrant a FAIL):
1. String literals used instead of enum constants in a few service method calls (e.g., `'active'` instead of `VariantStatus::Active` in `ProductService::create()` and `VariantMatrixService`). Functionally correct due to model casts, but enum constants would be more refactor-safe.
2. Small `hasOrderReferences()` duplication between `ProductService` and `VariantMatrixService` (justified cross-phase dependency pattern).
3. SKU uniqueness not enforced at service layer (documented as known limitation).

No blocking issues. Phase 2 is ready to proceed.
</teammate-message>

<teammate-message teammate_id="code-reviewer-p2" color="yellow">
{"type":"idle_notification","from":"code-reviewer-p2","timestamp":"2026-03-20T07:44:52.204Z","idleReason":"available"}
</teammate-message>


Code review passed 9/10, all items PASS. Moving to QA. Let me shut down the code reviewer and spawn the QA analyst.


SendMessage

Code review complete. All items PASS. Your work is done.

Code review complete. All items PASS. Your work is done.


Shutdown request sent to code-reviewer-p2. Request ID: shutdown-1773992697306@code-reviewer-p2


Agent

Phase 2 QA Analyst

Prompt:
You are the **QA Analyst** for Phase 2: Catalog of the shop project.

## Your Task
Verify all Phase 2 functionality using Playwright (via MCP Playwright tools) and by confirming Pest test results. Track all checks in `work/phase-2/qa-report.md`.

## IMPORTANT: Use Playwright MCP Tools
- `browser_navigate`, `browser_snapshot`, `browser_click`, `browser_fill_form`, `browser_console_messages`, `browser_take_screenshot`
- Use `get-absolute-url` to get the correct base URL

## What to Test

Phase 2 is primarily backend (models, services, migrations). Browser-testable areas are limited since admin product management UI comes in Phase 7. Focus on:

### Browser Tests (where applicable)
1. Storefront still works (regression from Phase 1) - homepage loads, admin login works
2. Any new routes that were added

### Backend Verification via Pest
Run `php artisan test --compact` and verify ALL tests pass (both Phase 1 and Phase 2).

For each Gherkin feature area, verify the corresponding Pest tests cover it:
- **Migrations**: Schema tests verify table structure
- **Models**: Relationship and factory tests
- **ProductService**: CRUD + state machine tests (ProductCrudTest)
- **VariantMatrixService**: Matrix rebuild tests (VariantTest)
- **InventoryService**: Reserve/release/commit/restock tests (InventoryTest)
- **HandleGenerator**: Slug generation tests (HandleGeneratorTest)
- **Collections**: CRUD tests (CollectionTest)
- **Media Upload**: Upload and processing tests (MediaUploadTest)

### Database Verification
Use `database-schema` MCP tool to verify all 9 new tables exist with correct columns and constraints.

## Output Format for `work/phase-2/qa-report.md`

### For each Gherkin scenario area:
- What was tested
- How it was tested (Playwright actions or "Verified via Pest test suite")
- Expected result
- Actual result
- PASS/FAIL

### Asset Verification Section
For every page visited via browser, check for broken assets.

### URL Verification Section
Verify any new URLs/routes work.

### Regression Check
Verify Phase 1 functionality still works:
- Admin login at /admin/login
- Customer login at /account/login
- Homepage loads

### Self-Assessment
Honest evaluation of testing coverage.

## Rules
- Every check PASS or FAIL only. No UNKNOWN/SKIPPED/PARTIAL/N/A/blank.
- Never use em-dash characters.
- Send message to team lead when done.


Spawned successfully.
agent_id: qa-analyst-p2@vivid-launching-llama
name: qa-analyst-p2
team_name: vivid-launching-llama
The agent is now running and will receive instructions via mailbox.

Prompt:
You are the **QA Analyst** for Phase 2: Catalog of the shop project.

## Your Task
Verify all Phase 2 functionality using Playwright (via MCP Playwright tools) and by confirming Pest test results. Track all checks in `work/phase-2/qa-report.md`.

## IMPORTANT: Use Playwright MCP Tools
- `browser_navigate`, `browser_snapshot`, `browser_click`, `browser_fill_form`, `browser_console_messages`, `browser_take_screenshot`
- Use `get-absolute-url` to get the correct base URL

## What to Test

Phase 2 is primarily backend (models, services, migrations). Browser-testable areas are limited since admin product management UI comes in Phase 7. Focus on:

### Browser Tests (where applicable)
1. Storefront still works (regression from Phase 1) - homepage loads, admin login works
2. Any new routes that were added

### Backend Verification via Pest
Run `php artisan test --compact` and verify ALL tests pass (both Phase 1 and Phase 2).

For each Gherkin feature area, verify the corresponding Pest tests cover it:
- **Migrations**: Schema tests verify table structure
- **Models**: Relationship and factory tests
- **ProductService**: CRUD + state machine tests (ProductCrudTest)
- **VariantMatrixService**: Matrix rebuild tests (VariantTest)
- **InventoryService**: Reserve/release/commit/restock tests (InventoryTest)
- **HandleGenerator**: Slug generation tests (HandleGeneratorTest)
- **Collections**: CRUD tests (CollectionTest)
- **Media Upload**: Upload and processing tests (MediaUploadTest)

### Database Verification
Use `database-schema` MCP tool to verify all 9 new tables exist with correct columns and constraints.

## Output Format for `work/phase-2/qa-report.md`

### For each Gherkin scenario area:
- What was tested
- How it was tested (Playwright actions or "Verified via Pest test suite")
- Expected result
- Actual result
- PASS/FAIL

### Asset Verification Section
For every page visited via browser, check for broken assets.

### URL Verification Section
Verify any new URLs/routes work.

### Regression Check
Verify Phase 1 functionality still works:
- Admin login at /admin/login
- Customer login at /account/login
- Homepage loads

### Self-Assessment
Honest evaluation of testing coverage.

## Rules
- Every check PASS or FAIL only. No UNKNOWN/SKIPPED/PARTIAL/N/A/blank.
- Never use em-dash characters.
- Send message to team lead when done.


<teammate-message teammate_id="system">
{"type":"teammate_terminated","message":"code-reviewer-p2 has shut down."}
</teammate-message>

<teammate-message teammate_id="code-reviewer-p2" color="yellow">
{"type":"shutdown_approved","requestId":"shutdown-1773992697306@code-reviewer-p2","from":"code-reviewer-p2","timestamp":"2026-03-20T07:45:01.572Z","paneId":"in-process","backendType":"in-process"}
</teammate-message>


Code reviewer shut down. Waiting for QA analyst to complete Phase 2 verification.


<teammate-message teammate_id="qa-analyst-p2" color="purple" summary="Phase 2 QA complete: 65/65 PASS, 0 FAIL">
Phase 2 QA is complete. Full report written to `work/phase-2/qa-report.md`.

**Results: 65/65 checks PASS, 0 FAIL.**

Summary:
- **Pest tests:** 283 passed (452 assertions), 0 failures. Full suite including Phase 1 and Phase 2.
- **Database schema:** All 9 new tables verified with correct columns, types, defaults, foreign keys, indexes, and check constraint triggers matching the Gherkin specifications.
- **Gherkin scenario coverage:** All 48 scenarios across ProductCrudTest (13), VariantTest (8), InventoryTest (8), HandleGeneratorTest (6), CollectionTest (7), and MediaUploadTest (6) pass.
- **Browser regression:** Homepage, admin login (/admin/login), and customer login (/account/login) all load correctly with no console errors and no broken assets.
- **Routes:** No new routes expected in Phase 2 (backend-only phase), and none found. Existing routes work.

**Limitations noted (not failures):**
- ProcessMediaUpload job falls back to queue dispatch test since intervention/image is not installed. Test handles this correctly.
- Order line reference tests branch conditionally since order_lines table is Phase 5. Tests handle both cases.

Phase 2 is fully implemented and verified.
</teammate-message>

<teammate-message teammate_id="qa-analyst-p2" color="purple">
{"type":"idle_notification","from":"qa-analyst-p2","timestamp":"2026-03-20T07:47:28.362Z","idleReason":"available"}
</teammate-message>


Phase 2 QA: 65/65 PASS. Sending all artifacts to the Controller for sign-off.


SendMessage

Phase 2 is complete. All artifacts ready for final sign-off. Please read each file and apply criteria A-F.

**Artifacts:**
1. `work/phase-2/gherkin-specs.md` - Already APPROVED
2. `work/phase-2/gherkin-review.md` - Already APPROVED
3. `work/phase-2/dev-report.md` - Developer report (48 tests, architecture decisions)
4. `work/phase-2/code-review.md` - Code review (9/10, all 10 items PASS)
5. `work/phase-2/qa-report.md` - QA report (65/65 checks PASS, 283 total tests, regression OK)

Apply criteria B-F (A already approved):
- B: Dev report exists, tests mapped to Gherkin, deviations documented, self-assessment
- C: Code review metrics, all PASS, static analysis numbers, self-assessment
- D: QA entries for scenarios, all PASS, asset/URL verification, regression, self-assessment
- E: Counts match across chain, no gaps
- F: No bare checklists, self-assessments substantive, risks resolved

If ALL criteria MET, produce `work/signoff-phase-2.md`. Otherwise VETO with specifics.

Summary: Review all Phase 2 artifacts for sign-off

Phase 2 is complete. All artifacts ready for final sign-off. Please read each file and apply criteria A-F.

**Artifacts:**
1. `work/phase-2/gherkin-specs.md` - Already APPROVED
2. `work/phase-2/gherkin-review.md` - Already APPROVED
3. `work/phase-2/dev-report.md` - Developer report (48 tests, architecture decisions)
4. `work/phase-2/code-review.md` - Code review (9/10, all 10 items PASS)
5. `work/phase-2/qa-report.md` - QA report (65/65 checks PASS, 283 total tests, regression OK)

Apply criteria B-F (A already approved):
- B: Dev report exists, tests mapped to Gherkin, deviations documented, self-assessment
- C: Code review metrics, all PASS, static analysis numbers, self-assessment
- D: QA entries for scenarios, all PASS, asset/URL verification, regression, self-assessment
- E: Counts match across chain, no gaps
- F: No bare checklists, self-assessments substantive, risks resolved

If ALL criteria MET, produce `work/signoff-phase-2.md`. Otherwise VETO with specifics.


Message sent to controller's inbox

Summary: Review all Phase 2 artifacts for sign-off

Phase 2 is complete. All artifacts ready for final sign-off. Please read each file and apply criteria A-F.

**Artifacts:**
1. `work/phase-2/gherkin-specs.md` - Already APPROVED
2. `work/phase-2/gherkin-review.md` - Already APPROVED
3. `work/phase-2/dev-report.md` - Developer report (48 tests, architecture decisions)
4. `work/phase-2/code-review.md` - Code review (9/10, all 10 items PASS)
5. `work/phase-2/qa-report.md` - QA report (65/65 checks PASS, 283 total tests, regression OK)

Apply criteria B-F (A already approved):
- B: Dev report exists, tests mapped to Gherkin, deviations documented, self-assessment
- C: Code review metrics, all PASS, static analysis numbers, self-assessment
- D: QA entries for scenarios, all PASS, asset/URL verification, regression, self-assessment
- E: Counts match across chain, no gaps
- F: No bare checklists, self-assessments substantive, risks resolved

If ALL criteria MET, produce `work/signoff-phase-2.md`. Otherwise VETO with specifics.

Message sent to controller's inbox


Phase 2 QA passed. Your work is complete.

Phase 2 QA passed. Your work is complete.


Shutdown request sent to dev-backend-p2. Request ID: shutdown-1773992864961@dev-backend-p2


Phase 2 QA complete. Your work is done.


Shutdown request sent to qa-analyst-p2. Request ID: shutdown-1773992865092@qa-analyst-p2


Waiting for Controller sign-off on Phase 2.


<teammate-message teammate_id="system">
{"type":"teammate_terminated","message":"qa-analyst-p2 has shut down."}
</teammate-message>


QA analyst shut down. Waiting for the Controller's Phase 2 sign-off.


<teammate-message teammate_id="system">
{"type":"teammate_terminated","message":"dev-backend-p2 has shut down."}
</teammate-message>

<teammate-message teammate_id="controller" color="blue" summary="APPROVE verdict for Phase 2 full sign-off">
## Phase 2 Final Sign-Off Review -- Controller Assessment

All five artifacts read in full. Evaluation against criteria A-F:

---

### A. Gherkin Specs -- PASS (previously approved)

No change since prior approval. 145 scenarios, 139 requirements, complete traceability.

### B. Dev Report -- PASS

**Exists and explains what was built:** Lines 1-51 walk through all 5 steps with specific details on tables, models, relationships, services, factories, and seeders. Prose, not just a list.

**Tests mapped to Gherkin:** Lines 53-63 provide a table mapping 6 test files (48 tests) to Gherkin steps. Each test file names the step it covers.

**Deviations documented:** Lines 77-86 document 4 deviations from the task brief, each citing the database schema spec as the authoritative source. Lines 65-75 document 5 architecture decisions with reasoning.

**Self-assessment:** Lines 95-103 list passing test counts, regression status, and Pint compliance. Lines 87-93 identify 3 known limitations (intervention/image dependency, Schema::hasTable cost, SKU uniqueness not enforced at DB level).

### C. Code Review -- PASS

**Metrics and thresholds:** Lines 3-10 provide quantitative metrics (36 files, 48 tests/452 assertions, 283 total, 0 Pint violations). Lines 14-98 evaluate 10 items, each with explicit PASS.

**Every item PASS:** All 10 (Code Style, Type Safety, Eloquent, Security, SOLID, PHP 8, Test Quality, Laravel Conventions, Code Duplication, Error Handling) are PASS. No UNKNOWN/SKIPPED/PARTIAL/blank.

**Static analysis:** Pint: 0 violations. 48 tests, 452 assertions. 283 total passing. Specific code smell checks documented.

**Self-assessment:** Lines 112-119: Rating 9/10, deductions itemized (string literals vs enums, hasOrderReferences duplication, SKU validation gap). 3 additional observations (lines 100-106) flagged as non-issues.

### D. QA Report -- PASS

**Entries for scenarios:** Sections 3.1-3.6 (lines 96-175) provide individual entries for all 48 Pest test scenarios across 6 test files. Section 2 (lines 33-93) provides individual entries for all 9 database tables with column-level verification. 3 browser regression entries. Total: 65 checks.

**Every entry has what/how/expected/actual/PASS-FAIL:** Yes. Database entries show columns, FKs, indexes, triggers with PASS. Pest scenario entries show scenario name, test name, result. Browser entries show URL, what tested, how, expected, actual, console errors, result.

**All PASS:** 65/65 checks PASS. 283/283 Pest tests PASS.

**Asset verification:** Lines 212-219, 3 pages, all PASS.

**URL verification:** Lines 222-226. "No new routes were added in Phase 2" -- correct for a backend-only phase. Verified via route:list. PASS.

**Regression:** Lines 178-208. 3 Phase 1 browser tests re-run (homepage, admin login, customer login). All PASS.

**Self-assessment:** Lines 249-265. High confidence. 3 limitations documented (no admin UI yet, intervention/image fallback, order_lines conditional logic).

### E. Completeness and Consistency -- PASS

Counts:
- Gherkin: 139 requirements, 145 scenarios
- Dev report: 48 tests in 6 files
- Code review: 48 tests, 452 assertions, 283 total
- QA report: 65 checks (48 Pest scenarios + 9 tables + 3 browser + 3 assets + 1 URL + 1 test suite run), all PASS

The 48 Pest tests < 145 Gherkin scenarios. However, many Gherkin scenarios cover database schema verification (34 scenarios) and model relationship/enum definitions (41 scenarios) that are verified through the database schema inspection in the QA report (Section 2) and through the Pest test assertions. The dev report's 48 tests map to the 70 Gherkin scenarios in Steps 2.3-2.5 (service logic, CRUD, inventory, media). The remaining 75 migration/model/enum scenarios are verified by QA's direct database inspection and Pest test assertions that exercise models and relationships.

No requirement is unaccounted for.

### F. Artifact Quality -- PASS

**No bare checklists:** All artifacts include narrative. Code review items have multi-line prose. Dev report explains decisions in sentences.

**Self-assessments:** All 5 artifacts have self-assessments.

**Risks resolved or accepted:** SKU uniqueness at DB level (accepted as known limitation), intervention/image dependency (graceful degradation), hasOrderReferences duplication (justified, to be resolved in Phase 5), string literals vs enum constants (cosmetic, not functional).

---

## VERDICT: APPROVE

All criteria A-F met. Producing sign-off file now.
</teammate-message>

<teammate-message teammate_id="controller" color="blue" summary="Phase 2 sign-off file created, APPROVED">
Sign-off file produced at `work/signoff-phase-2.md`. Phase 2: Catalog is APPROVED. All criteria A-F met. Five accepted risks documented. Ready for Phase 3.
</teammate-message>

<teammate-message teammate_id="controller" color="blue">
{"type":"idle_notification","from":"controller","timestamp":"2026-03-20T07:49:20.106Z","idleReason":"available"}
</teammate-message>

<teammate-message teammate_id="qa-analyst-p2" color="purple">
{"type":"shutdown_approved","requestId":"shutdown-1773992865092@qa-analyst-p2","from":"qa-analyst-p2","timestamp":"2026-03-20T07:47:49.257Z","paneId":"in-process","backendType":"in-process"}
</teammate-message>

<teammate-message teammate_id="dev-backend-p2" color="green">
{"type":"shutdown_approved","requestId":"shutdown-1773992864961@dev-backend-p2","from":"dev-backend-p2","timestamp":"2026-03-20T07:47:50.423Z","paneId":"in-process","backendType":"in-process"}
</teammate-message>


Phase 2 APPROVED. Let me update progress, commit, and start Phase 3.


Updated task #2 status


Edit

| 2 | Catalog (Products, Variants, Inventory, Collections, Media) | NOT STARTED | - | - |

| 2 | Catalog (Products, Variants, Inventory, Collections, Media) | COMPLETE | 2026-03-20 | 2026-03-20 |


The file /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/work/progress.md has been updated successfully.

# Project Progress

## Overview
Self-contained e-commerce platform with multi-tenant support, 12 implementation phases.

## Phases

| Phase | Name | Status | Started | Completed |
|-------|------|--------|---------|-----------|
| 1 | Foundation (Migrations, Models, Middleware, Auth) | COMPLETE | 2026-03-20 | 2026-03-20 |
| 2 | Catalog (Products, Variants, Inventory, Collections, Media) | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 3 | Themes, Pages, Navigation, Storefront Layout | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 4 | Cart, Checkout, Discounts, Shipping, Taxes | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 5 | Payments, Orders, Fulfillment | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 6 | Customer Accounts | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 7 | Admin Panel | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 8 | Search | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 9 | Analytics | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 10 | Apps and Webhooks | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 11 | Polish | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 12 | Full Test Suite Execution | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| - | Final E2E QA (143 test cases) | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| - | Adversarial QA | NOT STARTED | - | - |

## Current Phase
Phase 2: Catalog (Products, Variants, Inventory, Collections, Media)

-| 2 | Catalog (Products, Variants, Inventory, Collections, Media) | NOT STARTED | - | - |

+| 2 | Catalog (Products, Variants, Inventory, Collections, Media) | COMPLETE | 2026-03-20 | 2026-03-20 |


Bash

git add -A && git commit -m "$(cat <<'EOF'
Phase 2: Catalog - products, variants, inventory, collections, media

Implements the complete catalog system:
- 9 migrations (products, product_options, product_option_values, product_variants, variant_option_values, inventory_items, collections, collection_products, product_media)
- 7 models with relationships, factories, and seeders
- 7 enums (ProductStatus, VariantStatus, CollectionStatus, CollectionType, MediaType, MediaStatus, InventoryPolicy)
- ProductService (CRUD + state machine transitions)
- VariantMatrixService (cartesian product matrix rebuild)
- InventoryService (reserve/release/commit/restock with transactions)
- HandleGenerator (unique store-scoped slug generation)
- ProcessMediaUpload job (image resizing)
- InsufficientInventoryException, InvalidProductTransitionException
- 48 new Pest tests (283 total, all passing)

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
EOF
)"

Commit Phase 2


[2026-03-18-claude-code-team 392114e4] Phase 2: Catalog - products, variants, inventory, collections, media
 52 files changed, 4606 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-)
 create mode 100644 app/Enums/CollectionStatus.php
 create mode 100644 app/Enums/CollectionType.php
 create mode 100644 app/Enums/InventoryPolicy.php
 create mode 100644 app/Enums/MediaStatus.php
 create mode 100644 app/Enums/MediaType.php
 create mode 100644 app/Enums/ProductStatus.php
 create mode 100644 app/Enums/VariantStatus.php
 create mode 100644 app/Exceptions/InsufficientInventoryException.php
 create mode 100644 app/Exceptions/InvalidProductTransitionException.php
 create mode 100644 app/Jobs/ProcessMediaUpload.php
 create mode 100644 app/Models/Collection.php
 create mode 100644 app/Models/InventoryItem.php
 create mode 100644 app/Models/Product.php
 create mode 100644 app/Models/ProductMedia.php
 create mode 100644 app/Models/ProductOption.php
 create mode 100644 app/Models/ProductOptionValue.php
 create mode 100644 app/Models/ProductVariant.php
 create mode 100644 app/Services/InventoryService.php
 create mode 100644 app/Services/ProductService.php
 create mode 100644 app/Services/VariantMatrixService.php
 create mode 100644 app/Support/HandleGenerator.php
 create mode 100644 database/factories/CollectionFactory.php
 create mode 100644 database/factories/InventoryItemFactory.php
 create mode 100644 database/factories/ProductFactory.php
 create mode 100644 database/factories/ProductMediaFactory.php
 create mode 100644 database/factories/ProductOptionFactory.php
 create mode 100644 database/factories/ProductOptionValueFactory.php
 create mode 100644 database/factories/ProductVariantFactory.php
 create mode 100644 database/migrations/2026_03_20_073214_create_product_options_table.php
 create mode 100644 database/migrations/2026_03_20_073214_create_products_table.php
 create mode 100644 database/migrations/2026_03_20_073215_create_product_option_values_table.php
 create mode 100644 database/migrations/2026_03_20_073216_create_product_variants_table.php
 create mode 100644 database/migrations/2026_03_20_073216_create_variant_option_values_table.php
 create mode 100644 database/migrations/2026_03_20_073217_create_collections_table.php
 create mode 100644 database/migrations/2026_03_20_073217_create_inventory_items_table.php
 create mode 100644 database/migrations/2026_03_20_073218_create_collection_products_table.php
 create mode 100644 database/migrations/2026_03_20_073219_create_product_media_table.php
 create mode 100644 database/seeders/ProductSeeder.php
 create mode 100644 tests/Feature/HandleGeneratorTest.php
 create mode 100644 tests/Feature/Products/CollectionTest.php
 create mode 100644 tests/Feature/Products/InventoryTest.php
 create mode 100644 tests/Feature/Products/MediaUploadTest.php
 create mode 100644 tests/Feature/Products/ProductCrudTest.php
 create mode 100644 tests/Feature/Products/VariantTest.php
 create mode 100644 work/phase-2/code-review.md
 create mode 100644 work/phase-2/dev-report.md
 create mode 100644 work/phase-2/gherkin-review.md
 create mode 100644 work/phase-2/gherkin-specs.md
 create mode 100644 work/phase-2/qa-report.md
 create mode 100644 work/signoff-phase-2.md


Phase 2 committed. Now starting Phase 3: Themes, Pages, Navigation, Storefront Layout. This is a frontend-heavy phase.


Updated task #3 owner, status


Edit

| 3 | Themes, Pages, Navigation, Storefront Layout | NOT STARTED | - | - |

| 3 | Themes, Pages, Navigation, Storefront Layout | IN PROGRESS | 2026-03-20 | - |


# Project Progress

## Overview
Self-contained e-commerce platform with multi-tenant support, 12 implementation phases.

## Phases

| Phase | Name | Status | Started | Completed |
|-------|------|--------|---------|-----------|
| 1 | Foundation (Migrations, Models, Middleware, Auth) | COMPLETE | 2026-03-20 | 2026-03-20 |
| 2 | Catalog (Products, Variants, Inventory, Collections, Media) | COMPLETE | 2026-03-20 | 2026-03-20 |
| 3 | Themes, Pages, Navigation, Storefront Layout | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 4 | Cart, Checkout, Discounts, Shipping, Taxes | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 5 | Payments, Orders, Fulfillment | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 6 | Customer Accounts | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 7 | Admin Panel | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 8 | Search | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 9 | Analytics | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 10 | Apps and Webhooks | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 11 | Polish | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 12 | Full Test Suite Execution | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| - | Final E2E QA (143 test cases) | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| - | Adversarial QA | NOT STARTED | - | - |

## Current Phase
Phase 2: Catalog (Products, Variants, Inventory, Collections, Media)

-| 3 | Themes, Pages, Navigation, Storefront Layout | NOT STARTED | - | - |

+| 3 | Themes, Pages, Navigation, Storefront Layout | IN PROGRESS | 2026-03-20 | - |


Agent

Phase 3 BDD Expert

Prompt:
You are the **BDD Expert** for Phase 3: Themes, Pages, Navigation, Storefront Layout of the shop project.

## Your Task
Read the Phase 3 requirements from `specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md` (Steps 3.1 through 3.5, starting around line 349) and rewrite them as Gherkin specifications. Save output to `work/phase-3/gherkin-specs.md`.

## Phase 3 Scope
- Step 3.1: Migrations (themes, theme_files, theme_settings, pages, navigation_menus, navigation_items)
- Step 3.2: Models (Theme, ThemeFile, ThemeSettings, Page, NavigationMenu, NavigationItem) with relationships, factories, seeders + Enums (ThemeStatus, PageStatus, NavigationItemType)
- Step 3.3: Storefront Blade Layout (app.blade.php, all page templates, checkout templates, account templates, error pages, components) with dark mode support
- Step 3.4: Storefront Livewire Components (Home, Collections/Index, Collections/Show, Products/Show, Cart/Show, CartDrawer, Search/Index, Search/Modal, Pages/Show)
- Step 3.5: Navigation Service (buildTree, resolveUrl, caching)

Also reference:
- `specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md` for storefront UI details
- `specs/01-DATABASE-SCHEMA.md` for schema

## Output Format
1. Every acceptance criterion mapped to Gherkin scenarios
2. Traceability table
3. Self-assessment section

Create `work/phase-3/` directory if needed. Never use em-dash characters. Send message to team lead when done.


Spawned successfully.
agent_id: bdd-expert-p3@vivid-launching-llama
name: bdd-expert-p3
team_name: vivid-launching-llama
The agent is now running and will receive instructions via mailbox.

Prompt:
You are the **BDD Expert** for Phase 3: Themes, Pages, Navigation, Storefront Layout of the shop project.

## Your Task
Read the Phase 3 requirements from `specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md` (Steps 3.1 through 3.5, starting around line 349) and rewrite them as Gherkin specifications. Save output to `work/phase-3/gherkin-specs.md`.

## Phase 3 Scope
- Step 3.1: Migrations (themes, theme_files, theme_settings, pages, navigation_menus, navigation_items)
- Step 3.2: Models (Theme, ThemeFile, ThemeSettings, Page, NavigationMenu, NavigationItem) with relationships, factories, seeders + Enums (ThemeStatus, PageStatus, NavigationItemType)
- Step 3.3: Storefront Blade Layout (app.blade.php, all page templates, checkout templates, account templates, error pages, components) with dark mode support
- Step 3.4: Storefront Livewire Components (Home, Collections/Index, Collections/Show, Products/Show, Cart/Show, CartDrawer, Search/Index, Search/Modal, Pages/Show)
- Step 3.5: Navigation Service (buildTree, resolveUrl, caching)

Also reference:
- `specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md` for storefront UI details
- `specs/01-DATABASE-SCHEMA.md` for schema

## Output Format
1. Every acceptance criterion mapped to Gherkin scenarios
2. Traceability table
3. Self-assessment section

Create `work/phase-3/` directory if needed. Never use em-dash characters. Send message to team lead when done.


**Progress:**
- Phase 1: COMPLETE (committed)
- Phase 2: COMPLETE (committed)
- Phase 3: IN PROGRESS (BDD Expert writing Gherkin specs)


<teammate-message teammate_id="team-lead">
{"type":"task_assignment","taskId":"3","subject":"Phase 3: Themes, Pages, Navigation, Storefront Layout","description":"Implement Phase 3: Theme/Page/Navigation models, Storefront Blade layout, Livewire storefront components, NavigationService. Depends on Phase 1.","assignedBy":"team-lead","timestamp":"2026-03-20T07:50:00.815Z"}
</teammate-message>


BDD Expert for Phase 3 is working. Waiting for Gherkin specs.


<teammate-message teammate_id="bdd-expert-p3" color="orange" summary="Phase 3 Gherkin specs complete, 203 scenarios">
Phase 3 BDD Gherkin specifications are complete and saved to `work/phase-3/gherkin-specs.md`.

**Summary:**
- 203 total Gherkin scenarios across all 5 steps
- Step 3.1 (Migrations): 15 scenarios covering all 6 tables (themes, theme_files, theme_settings, pages, navigation_menus, navigation_items) with columns, FKs, check constraints, and indexes
- Step 3.2 (Models/Enums/Seeders): 38 scenarios covering all 6 models, 3 enums, and seeders
- Step 3.3 (Layout/Templates/Components): 58 scenarios covering base layout (head, skip link, announcement bar, header desktop/mobile, sticky header, footer, dark mode), all page/checkout/account/error templates, 8 Blade components, and ThemeSettings service
- Step 3.4 (Livewire Components): 80 scenarios covering all 9 components (Home, Collections/Index, Collections/Show, Products/Show, Cart/Show, CartDrawer, Search/Index, Search/Modal, Pages/Show)
- Step 3.5 (Navigation Service): 12 scenarios covering buildTree, resolveUrl (all 4 item types + fallback), and caching (per-store key, 5-min TTL)

**Traceability table** maps every spec reference to its Gherkin feature and scenarios.
**Self-assessment** confirms full coverage with notes on 3 minor potential gaps (nesting depth, image zoom, checkout logic deferred to later phases).
</teammate-message>

<teammate-message teammate_id="bdd-expert-p3" color="orange">
{"type":"idle_notification","from":"bdd-expert-p3","timestamp":"2026-03-20T07:56:05.194Z","idleReason":"available"}
</teammate-message>


Phase 3 Gherkin specs complete with 203 scenarios. Let me spawn the reviewer, and shut down the BDD Expert.


Phase 3 Gherkin Reviewer

Prompt:
You are the **Gherkin Reviewer** for Phase 3: Themes, Pages, Navigation, Storefront Layout.

## Your Task
Review `work/phase-3/gherkin-specs.md` for completeness vs the Phase 3 spec. Save review to `work/phase-3/gherkin-review.md`.

## Steps
1. Read `specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md` (Steps 3.1-3.5, around lines 349-438)
2. Read `specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md` for storefront UI details
3. Read `work/phase-3/gherkin-specs.md`
4. Count requirements, count scenarios, verify every requirement is covered
5. Check consistency with Phase 2 (done) and Phase 4 (next - cart/checkout)
6. Write review with exact counts, gaps, self-assessment

Never use em-dash characters. Send message to team lead when done.


Spawned successfully.
agent_id: gherkin-reviewer-p3@vivid-launching-llama
name: gherkin-reviewer-p3
team_name: vivid-launching-llama
The agent is now running and will receive instructions via mailbox.

Prompt:
You are the **Gherkin Reviewer** for Phase 3: Themes, Pages, Navigation, Storefront Layout.

## Your Task
Review `work/phase-3/gherkin-specs.md` for completeness vs the Phase 3 spec. Save review to `work/phase-3/gherkin-review.md`.

## Steps
1. Read `specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md` (Steps 3.1-3.5, around lines 349-438)
2. Read `specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md` for storefront UI details
3. Read `work/phase-3/gherkin-specs.md`
4. Count requirements, count scenarios, verify every requirement is covered
5. Check consistency with Phase 2 (done) and Phase 4 (next - cart/checkout)
6. Write review with exact counts, gaps, self-assessment

Never use em-dash characters. Send message to team lead when done.


SendMessage

Phase 3 Gherkin specs complete. Your work is done.

Phase 3 Gherkin specs complete. Your work is done.


Shutdown request sent to bdd-expert-p3. Request ID: shutdown-1773993376094@bdd-expert-p3


BDD Expert shut down. Waiting for the Gherkin Reviewer to complete.


<teammate-message teammate_id="system">
{"type":"teammate_terminated","message":"bdd-expert-p3 has shut down."}
</teammate-message>


Waiting for Phase 3 Gherkin Reviewer.


<teammate-message teammate_id="gherkin-reviewer-p3" color="pink" summary="Phase 3 Gherkin review: APPROVED, 176 scenarios">
Phase 3 Gherkin review complete. Saved to `work/phase-3/gherkin-review.md`.

**Verdict: APPROVED**

**176 scenarios** covering all Phase 3 requirements across Steps 3.1-3.5:
- Step 3.1 Migrations: 20 scenarios, 6 tables, all columns/FKs/indexes/constraints verified against DB schema spec
- Step 3.2 Models/Enums/Seeders: 41 scenarios, 6 models, 3 enums, 3 seeders
- Step 3.3 Blade Layout/Components/Service: 52 scenarios covering base layout (head, skip link, announcement bar, header desktop+mobile, sticky header, footer, dark mode), 6 page templates, 2 checkout templates, 6 account templates, 2 error pages, 8 Blade components, ThemeSettings service
- Step 3.4 Livewire Components: 51 scenarios covering all 9 components (Home, Collections/Index, Collections/Show, Products/Show, Cart/Show, CartDrawer, Search/Index, Search/Modal, Pages/Show)
- Step 3.5 Navigation Service: 12 scenarios covering buildTree, resolveUrl (all 4 types + fallback), caching (per-store, 5-min TTL)

**Consistency:** Follows same structure and conventions as the approved Phase 2 Gherkin specs. Clean boundary with Phase 4 - Phase 3 covers UI rendering/interaction, Phase 4 will cover backend cart/checkout/discount business logic.

**5 minor non-blocking gaps noted** (navigation nesting depth, image zoom on hover, breadcrumbs structured data, eager-load requirements, checkout/account template placeholders). None are blocking.
</teammate-message>

<teammate-message teammate_id="gherkin-reviewer-p3" color="pink">
{"type":"idle_notification","from":"gherkin-reviewer-p3","timestamp":"2026-03-20T07:59:21.897Z","idleReason":"available"}
</teammate-message>


Approved. Let me send to Controller and shut down the reviewer. I'll also spawn the developer in parallel since the Gherkin specs are solid.


Phase 3 Gherkin specs ready for your review. Please read both files and apply acceptance criteria A:

1. `work/phase-3/gherkin-specs.md` - Gherkin specifications (176+ scenarios covering Steps 3.1-3.5)
2. `work/phase-3/gherkin-review.md` - Reviewer confirms all requirements covered, APPROVED with 5 minor non-blocking gaps

Respond with APPROVE or VETO.

Summary: Review Phase 3 Gherkin specs

Phase 3 Gherkin specs ready for your review.


Message sent to controller's inbox

Summary: Review Phase 3 Gherkin specs

Phase 3 Gherkin specs ready for your review. Please read both files and apply acceptance criteria A:

1. `work/phase-3/gherkin-specs.md` - Gherkin specifications (176+ scenarios covering Steps 3.1-3.5)
2. `work/phase-3/gherkin-review.md` - Reviewer confirms all requirements covered, APPROVED with 5 minor non-blocking gaps

Respond with APPROVE or VETO.

Message sent to controller's inbox

Summary: Review Phase 3 Gherkin specs


Phase 3 Gherkin review complete. Your work is done.

Phase 3 Gherkin review complete. Your work is done.


Shutdown request sent to gherkin-reviewer-p3. Request ID: shutdown-1773993573950@gherkin-reviewer-p3


Waiting for Controller's Phase 3 Gherkin approval.


Reviewer shut down. Waiting for Controller.


<teammate-message teammate_id="system">
{"type":"teammate_terminated","message":"gherkin-reviewer-p3 has shut down."}
</teammate-message>


Waiting for Controller's Phase 3 Gherkin verdict.


<teammate-message teammate_id="system"> {"type":"teammate_terminated","message":"gherkin-reviewer-p3 has shut down."} </teammate-message>


<teammate-message teammate_id="controller" color="blue" summary="Phase 3 Gherkin specs APPROVED with count note">
**Phase 3 Gherkin Specs Review -- Criterion A**

**Verdict: APPROVE**

I have read both files in full:
- `work/phase-3/gherkin-specs.md` (1705 lines)
- `work/phase-3/gherkin-review.md` (201 lines)

**Criterion A sub-criteria:**

1. **Both files exist:** PASS. Specs file (1705 lines) and review file (201 lines) both present and substantive.

2. **Traceability table completeness:** PASS. The traceability table (lines 1630-1664) maps every roadmap step (3.1-3.5) and cross-references Spec 04 sections (3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 11.1, 11.2, 12) to Gherkin features. All 6 migration tables, 6 models, 3 enums, 3 seeders, 8 Blade components, 9 Livewire components, and the Navigation Service are traced.

3. **Exact counts:** PASS WITH NOTE. The review document consistently reports 176 scenarios (20 + 41 + 52 + 51 + 12). The traceability table in the specs file is consistent with this count. However, the specs file's own self-assessment summary (lines 1699-1704) claims 203 scenarios (15 + 38 + 58 + 80 + 12), which does not match. This appears to be a drafting error in the self-assessment summary section -- the actual Gherkin scenarios in the body of the document align with the review's 176 count. The review document (line 153) also notes that Scenario Outlines with multiple examples could push the count to ~183 depending on counting methodology. This discrepancy is confined to the self-assessment summary and does not indicate missing or phantom scenarios.

4. **Substantive self-assessments:** PASS. The specs file has a detailed coverage analysis (lines 1670-1695) covering all 5 steps with per-component breakdowns. The review file has thorough per-step verification tables with line-level cross-referencing against the database schema spec, implementation roadmap, and storefront UI spec.

5. **Concerns addressed:** PASS. The review identifies 5 minor non-blocking gaps (navigation nesting, image zoom, breadcrumbs structured data, product card eager-load, checkout/account placeholders). All are correctly assessed as non-blocking. The specs self-assessment identifies 3 overlapping gaps. None require resolution before implementation.

**Note for downstream:** The scenario count discrepancy (176 in review vs 203 in specs self-assessment) should be corrected in the specs file's self-assessment section to avoid confusion during dev report mapping. The authoritative count is 176 scenarios (or ~183 counting Scenario Outline examples individually).
</teammate-message>

<teammate-message teammate_id="controller" color="blue">
{"type":"idle_notification","from":"controller","timestamp":"2026-03-20T08:02:06.415Z","idleReason":"available"}
</teammate-message>


Phase 3 Gherkin specs APPROVED. The Controller noted a count discrepancy in the self-assessment (cosmetic, not blocking). Spawning the Phase 3 developer now. Phase 3 is frontend-heavy (Blade layouts, Livewire components, storefront UI).


Agent

Phase 3 Fullstack Developer

Prompt:
You are the **Fullstack Developer** for Phase 3: Themes, Pages, Navigation, Storefront Layout of the shop project.

## Your Task
Implement Phase 3 using TDD with Pest, following the approved Gherkin specs in `work/phase-3/gherkin-specs.md` and the roadmap in `specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md` (Steps 3.1-3.5).

## IMPORTANT: Skills to Activate
- Activate `livewire-development` skill for Livewire components
- Activate `fluxui-development` skill for Flux UI components
- Activate `tailwindcss-development` skill for Tailwind CSS styling
- Activate `pest-testing` skill for tests
- Use `search-docs` MCP tool before implementing to check docs

## Context: What Exists Already
- Phase 1: Foundation (models, auth, middleware, tenant isolation)
- Phase 2: Catalog (Product, Collection, ProductVariant, etc. models and services)
- Existing layouts: `layouts/guest.blade.php`, `layouts/admin.blade.php`, `layouts/storefront.blade.php`
- Existing storefront components: basic customer auth pages

## Implementation Order

### Step 3.1: Migrations (6 tables)
1. `create_themes_table` - FK: store_id. Columns: name, handle, status (TEXT CHECK), is_active (boolean), version
2. `create_theme_files_table` - FK: theme_id. Columns: filename, content_type, body, size_bytes
3. `create_theme_settings_table` - PK: theme_id. Columns: settings_json (theme configuration)
4. `create_pages_table` - FK: store_id. Columns: title, handle, body_html, status (TEXT CHECK), seo_title, seo_description, published_at
5. `create_navigation_menus_table` - FK: store_id. Columns: title, handle, location
6. `create_navigation_items_table` - FK: menu_id. Columns: title, type (TEXT CHECK), url, resource_id, position, parent_id (nullable self-ref)

### Step 3.2: Models with relationships, factories, seeders
- Theme (BelongsToStore, hasMany ThemeFile, hasOne ThemeSettings)
- ThemeFile (belongsTo Theme)
- ThemeSettings (belongsTo Theme)
- Page (BelongsToStore)
- NavigationMenu (BelongsToStore, hasMany NavigationItem)
- NavigationItem (belongsTo NavigationMenu, self-referential parent/children)

Enums: ThemeStatus (Draft, Published), PageStatus (Draft, Published, Archived), NavigationItemType (Link, Page, Collection, Product)

Seeders: ThemeSeeder (default theme with settings), PageSeeder ("About" page with handle "about", published), NavigationSeeder (main menu with links to collections, about page)

### Step 3.3: Storefront Blade Layout
Create a proper storefront layout at `resources/views/storefront/layouts/app.blade.php` (or update the existing one). Must include:
- Head with meta tags, Vite assets, Flux scripts
- Skip-to-content link for accessibility
- Announcement bar (from theme settings)
- Header with logo, navigation, search trigger, cart icon with count, account link
- Mobile header with hamburger menu
- Main content area with `{{ $slot }}`
- Footer with links and copyright
- Dark mode support via `dark:` prefix throughout

Create storefront page templates:
- `storefront/pages/home.blade.php`
- `storefront/pages/collection.blade.php`
- `storefront/pages/product.blade.php`
- `storefront/pages/cart.blade.php`
- `storefront/pages/search.blade.php`
- `storefront/pages/page.blade.php`
- `storefront/checkout/index.blade.php`
- `storefront/checkout/confirmation.blade.php`
- `storefront/errors/404.blade.php`
- `storefront/errors/503.blade.php`

Create Blade components:
- `storefront/components/product-card.blade.php` - product card with image, title, price, badges
- `storefront/components/price.blade.php` - formatted price with compare-at
- `storefront/components/badge.blade.php` - status badges (sale, sold out)
- `storefront/components/quantity-selector.blade.php` - +/- buttons
- `storefront/components/breadcrumbs.blade.php`
- `storefront/components/pagination.blade.php`

ThemeSettings Service: singleton in AppServiceProvider, loads and caches active theme settings.

### Step 3.4: Storefront Livewire Components
Create all 9 components:
- `Storefront\Home` - dynamic sections from theme settings
- `Storefront\Collections\Index` - all collections grid
- `Storefront\Collections\Show` - product grid with filters, sort, pagination
- `Storefront\Products\Show` - variant selection, image gallery, add-to-cart
- `Storefront\Cart\Show` - full cart page (placeholder for now, logic in Phase 4)
- `Storefront\CartDrawer` - slide-out cart drawer (placeholder)
- `Storefront\Search\Index` - search results (placeholder for Phase 8)
- `Storefront\Search\Modal` - search modal (placeholder)
- `Storefront\Pages\Show` - CMS page rendering

Register routes in `routes/web.php` for storefront:
- GET / -> Home
- GET /collections -> Collections\Index
- GET /collections/{handle} -> Collections\Show
- GET /products/{handle} -> Products\Show
- GET /cart -> Cart\Show
- GET /search -> Search\Index
- GET /pages/{handle} -> Pages\Show

### Step 3.5: Navigation Service
`App\Services\NavigationService`:
- `buildTree(NavigationMenu $menu): array` - builds hierarchical navigation from flat items
- `resolveUrl(NavigationItem $item): string` - resolves URLs for Link, Page, Collection, Product types
- Cache per store with 5-minute TTL

## Pest Tests to Create
Phase 3 is mostly UI, but create tests for:
- Navigation Service (buildTree, resolveUrl)
- Theme/Page/Navigation model tests (relationships, factories)
- Route accessibility tests (all storefront routes return 200)

## When Done
1. Run `vendor/bin/pint --dirty --format agent`
2. Run `php artisan test --compact` to verify ALL tests pass
3. Run `npm run build` to compile frontend assets
4. Write `work/phase-3/dev-report.md`
5. Send message to team lead

## Rules
- Use `php artisan make:` commands with `--no-interaction`
- Follow Tailwind CSS v4 conventions
- Use Flux UI components where appropriate
- Ensure dark mode support with `dark:` prefix
- Never use em-dash characters
- Do not commit


Spawned successfully.
agent_id: dev-fullstack-p3@vivid-launching-llama
name: dev-fullstack-p3
team_name: vivid-launching-llama
The agent is now running and will receive instructions via mailbox.

Prompt:
You are the **Fullstack Developer** for Phase 3: Themes, Pages, Navigation, Storefront Layout of the shop project.

## Your Task
Implement Phase 3 using TDD with Pest, following the approved Gherkin specs in `work/phase-3/gherkin-specs.md` and the roadmap in `specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md` (Steps 3.1-3.5).

## IMPORTANT: Skills to Activate
- Activate `livewire-development` skill for Livewire components
- Activate `fluxui-development` skill for Flux UI components
- Activate `tailwindcss-development` skill for Tailwind CSS styling
- Activate `pest-testing` skill for tests
- Use `search-docs` MCP tool before implementing to check docs

## Context: What Exists Already
- Phase 1: Foundation (models, auth, middleware, tenant isolation)
- Phase 2: Catalog (Product, Collection, ProductVariant, etc. models and services)
- Existing layouts: `layouts/guest.blade.php`, `layouts/admin.blade.php`, `layouts/storefront.blade.php`
- Existing storefront components: basic customer auth pages

## Implementation Order

### Step 3.1: Migrations (6 tables)
1. `create_themes_table` - FK: store_id. Columns: name, handle, status (TEXT CHECK), is_active (boolean), version
2. `create_theme_files_table` - FK: theme_id. Columns: filename, content_type, body, size_bytes
3. `create_theme_settings_table` - PK: theme_id. Columns: settings_json (theme configuration)
4. `create_pages_table` - FK: store_id. Columns: title, handle, body_html, status (TEXT CHECK), seo_title, seo_description, published_at
5. `create_navigation_menus_table` - FK: store_id. Columns: title, handle, location
6. `create_navigation_items_table` - FK: menu_id. Columns: title, type (TEXT CHECK), url, resource_id, position, parent_id (nullable self-ref)

### Step 3.2: Models with relationships, factories, seeders
- Theme (BelongsToStore, hasMany ThemeFile, hasOne ThemeSettings)
- ThemeFile (belongsTo Theme)
- ThemeSettings (belongsTo Theme)
- Page (BelongsToStore)
- NavigationMenu (BelongsToStore, hasMany NavigationItem)
- NavigationItem (belongsTo NavigationMenu, self-referential parent/children)

Enums: ThemeStatus (Draft, Published), PageStatus (Draft, Published, Archived), NavigationItemType (Link, Page, Collection, Product)

Seeders: ThemeSeeder (default theme with settings), PageSeeder ("About" page with handle "about", published), NavigationSeeder (main menu with links to collections, about page)

### Step 3.3: Storefront Blade Layout
Create a proper storefront layout at `resources/views/storefront/layouts/app.blade.php` (or update the existing one). Must include:
- Head with meta tags, Vite assets, Flux scripts
- Skip-to-content link for accessibility
- Announcement bar (from theme settings)
- Header with logo, navigation, search trigger, cart icon with count, account link
- Mobile header with hamburger menu
- Main content area with `{{ $slot }}`
- Footer with links and copyright
- Dark mode support via `dark:` prefix throughout

Create storefront page templates:
- `storefront/pages/home.blade.php`
- `storefront/pages/collection.blade.php`
- `storefront/pages/product.blade.php`
- `storefront/pages/cart.blade.php`
- `storefront/pages/search.blade.php`
- `storefront/pages/page.blade.php`
- `storefront/checkout/index.blade.php`
- `storefront/checkout/confirmation.blade.php`
- `storefront/errors/404.blade.php`
- `storefront/errors/503.blade.php`

Create Blade components:
- `storefront/components/product-card.blade.php` - product card with image, title, price, badges
- `storefront/components/price.blade.php` - formatted price with compare-at
- `storefront/components/badge.blade.php` - status badges (sale, sold out)
- `storefront/components/quantity-selector.blade.php` - +/- buttons
- `storefront/components/breadcrumbs.blade.php`
- `storefront/components/pagination.blade.php`

ThemeSettings Service: singleton in AppServiceProvider, loads and caches active theme settings.

### Step 3.4: Storefront Livewire Components
Create all 9 components:
- `Storefront\Home` - dynamic sections from theme settings
- `Storefront\Collections\Index` - all collections grid
- `Storefront\Collections\Show` - product grid with filters, sort, pagination
- `Storefront\Products\Show` - variant selection, image gallery, add-to-cart
- `Storefront\Cart\Show` - full cart page (placeholder for now, logic in Phase 4)
- `Storefront\CartDrawer` - slide-out cart drawer (placeholder)
- `Storefront\Search\Index` - search results (placeholder for Phase 8)
- `Storefront\Search\Modal` - search modal (placeholder)
- `Storefront\Pages\Show` - CMS page rendering

Register routes in `routes/web.php` for storefront:
- GET / -> Home
- GET /collections -> Collections\Index
- GET /collections/{handle} -> Collections\Show
- GET /products/{handle} -> Products\Show
- GET /cart -> Cart\Show
- GET /search -> Search\Index
- GET /pages/{handle} -> Pages\Show

### Step 3.5: Navigation Service
`App\Services\NavigationService`:
- `buildTree(NavigationMenu $menu): array` - builds hierarchical navigation from flat items
- `resolveUrl(NavigationItem $item): string` - resolves URLs for Link, Page, Collection, Product types
- Cache per store with 5-minute TTL

## Pest Tests to Create
Phase 3 is mostly UI, but create tests for:
- Navigation Service (buildTree, resolveUrl)
- Theme/Page/Navigation model tests (relationships, factories)
- Route accessibility tests (all storefront routes return 200)

## When Done
1. Run `vendor/bin/pint --dirty --format agent`
2. Run `php artisan test --compact` to verify ALL tests pass
3. Run `npm run build` to compile frontend assets
4. Write `work/phase-3/dev-report.md`
5. Send message to team lead

## Rules
- Use `php artisan make:` commands with `--no-interaction`
- Follow Tailwind CSS v4 conventions
- Use Flux UI components where appropriate
- Ensure dark mode support with `dark:` prefix
- Never use em-dash characters
- Do not commit


Phase 3 developer spawned and working. This is a larger phase with significant frontend work (Blade layouts, Livewire components, Tailwind styling). Waiting for completion.


<teammate-message teammate_id="controller" color="blue">
{"type":"idle_notification","from":"controller","timestamp":"2026-03-20T08:11:09.636Z","idleReason":"available"}
</teammate-message>


Controller standing by. Developer still working on Phase 3 implementation.


<teammate-message teammate_id="dev-fullstack-p3" color="cyan" summary="Phase 3 complete, 337 tests pass, dev report written">
Phase 3 implementation is complete. All steps (3.1-3.5) have been implemented and tested.

**What was built:**
- 6 migrations (themes, theme_files, theme_settings, pages, navigation_menus, navigation_items)
- 6 models with relationships, 3 enums, 6 factories, 3 seeders
- ThemeSettingsService (singleton, caches active theme settings per store)
- NavigationService (builds nav trees, resolves URLs for link/page/collection/product types)
- Full storefront Blade layout (announcement bar, desktop/mobile header, footer, cart drawer, dark mode, skip-to-content)
- 9 Livewire components (Home, Collections Index/Show, Products Show, Cart Show, CartDrawer, Search Index/Modal, Pages Show)
- 6 Blade components (product-card, price, badge, quantity-selector, breadcrumbs, pagination)
- Error pages (404, 503)
- 7 storefront routes registered with storefront middleware

**Tests:** 54 new tests across 9 test files (models, services, route accessibility)

**Full suite result:** 337 passed (535 assertions), 0 failures

**Post-build checks completed:**
- `vendor/bin/pint --dirty --format agent` - ran, 1 file fixed
- `npm run build` - frontend assets compiled
- Dev report written to `work/phase-3/dev-report.md`
</teammate-message>

<teammate-message teammate_id="dev-fullstack-p3" color="cyan">
{"type":"idle_notification","from":"dev-fullstack-p3","timestamp":"2026-03-20T08:15:04.935Z","idleReason":"available"}
</teammate-message>


Phase 3 implementation complete with 54 new tests (337 total). Spawning code reviewer and QA analyst in parallel since they work independently.


Phase 3 Code Reviewer

Prompt:
You are the **Code Reviewer** for Phase 3: Themes, Pages, Navigation, Storefront Layout.

## Your Task
Review ALL Phase 3 code for clean code, SOLID, Laravel best practices. Produce `work/phase-3/code-review.md`.

## What Was Implemented
Read `work/phase-3/dev-report.md` for details. Key areas to review:

**Migrations:** 6 tables (themes, theme_files, theme_settings, pages, navigation_menus, navigation_items)
**Models:** Theme, ThemeFile, ThemeSettings, Page, NavigationMenu, NavigationItem (check `app/Models/`)
**Enums:** ThemeStatus, PageStatus, NavigationItemType (check `app/Enums/`)
**Services:** ThemeSettingsService, NavigationService (check `app/Services/`)
**Livewire Components:** 9 components in `app/Livewire/Storefront/`
**Blade Views:** Layout, page templates, components in `resources/views/storefront/`
**Tests:** In `tests/Feature/` and `tests/Unit/`

## Review Checklist (10 items, PASS or FAIL)
1. Code Style (Pint, 0 violations)
2. Type Safety (return types, parameter types)
3. Eloquent Best Practices
4. Security
5. SOLID Principles
6. PHP 8 Features
7. Test Quality
8. Laravel Conventions
9. Code Duplication
10. Error Handling

Run `vendor/bin/pint --test --format agent` and `php artisan test --compact`. Write report with metrics, PASS/FAIL per item, static analysis, self-assessment (1-10). Never use em-dash characters. Send message to team lead when done.


Spawned successfully.
agent_id: code-reviewer-p3@vivid-launching-llama
name: code-reviewer-p3
team_name: vivid-launching-llama
The agent is now running and will receive instructions via mailbox.

Prompt:
You are the **Code Reviewer** for Phase 3: Themes, Pages, Navigation, Storefront Layout.

## Your Task
Review ALL Phase 3 code for clean code, SOLID, Laravel best practices. Produce `work/phase-3/code-review.md`.

## What Was Implemented
Read `work/phase-3/dev-report.md` for details. Key areas to review:

**Migrations:** 6 tables (themes, theme_files, theme_settings, pages, navigation_menus, navigation_items)
**Models:** Theme, ThemeFile, ThemeSettings, Page, NavigationMenu, NavigationItem (check `app/Models/`)
**Enums:** ThemeStatus, PageStatus, NavigationItemType (check `app/Enums/`)
**Services:** ThemeSettingsService, NavigationService (check `app/Services/`)
**Livewire Components:** 9 components in `app/Livewire/Storefront/`
**Blade Views:** Layout, page templates, components in `resources/views/storefront/`
**Tests:** In `tests/Feature/` and `tests/Unit/`

## Review Checklist (10 items, PASS or FAIL)
1. Code Style (Pint, 0 violations)
2. Type Safety (return types, parameter types)
3. Eloquent Best Practices
4. Security
5. SOLID Principles
6. PHP 8 Features
7. Test Quality
8. Laravel Conventions
9. Code Duplication
10. Error Handling

Run `vendor/bin/pint --test --format agent` and `php artisan test --compact`. Write report with metrics, PASS/FAIL per item, static analysis, self-assessment (1-10). Never use em-dash characters. Send message to team lead when done.


Phase 3 QA Analyst

Prompt:
You are the **QA Analyst** for Phase 3: Themes, Pages, Navigation, Storefront Layout.

## Your Task
Verify all Phase 3 functionality using Playwright MCP tools and Pest test results. Write `work/phase-3/qa-report.md`.

## IMPORTANT: Use Playwright MCP Tools
- `browser_navigate`, `browser_snapshot`, `browser_click`, `browser_fill_form`, `browser_console_messages`, `browser_take_screenshot`
- Use `get-absolute-url` to get the correct base URL first

## What to Test

### Browser Tests (Phase 3 is heavily UI-focused)

**Storefront Layout:**
1. Homepage loads at / with store name, navigation, footer
2. Header has navigation links (collections, about)
3. Mobile menu works (resize viewport, check hamburger)
4. Dark mode classes present
5. Skip-to-content link exists
6. Footer renders with copyright

**Collection Pages:**
7. /collections shows all collections
8. /collections/{handle} shows products in collection
9. Products show with images, titles, prices
10. Pagination works if enough products

**Product Pages:**
11. /products/{handle} shows product details
12. Variant selector shows options (Size, Color)
13. Price displays correctly
14. Image gallery renders
15. Add-to-cart button present

**CMS Pages:**
16. /pages/about renders the About page content

**Search:**
17. /search page loads (placeholder OK for now)

**Cart:**
18. /cart page loads (placeholder OK for now)

**Error Pages:**
19. Invalid URL returns 404 page
20. Test 503 page if possible

**Navigation:**
21. All nav links point to correct destinations
22. Navigation items resolve correctly

### Pest Test Verification
Run `php artisan test --compact` and confirm all 337 tests pass.

### Regression
Verify Phase 1 and Phase 2 functionality still works:
- Admin login
- Customer login

## Output Format
For each test: what, how, expected, actual, PASS/FAIL.
Asset verification section. URL verification section. Regression check. Self-assessment.

Every check PASS or FAIL only. Never use em-dash characters. Send message to team lead when done.


Spawned successfully.
agent_id: qa-analyst-p3@vivid-launching-llama
name: qa-analyst-p3
team_name: vivid-launching-llama
The agent is now running and will receive instructions via mailbox.

Prompt:
You are the **QA Analyst** for Phase 3: Themes, Pages, Navigation, Storefront Layout.

## Your Task
Verify all Phase 3 functionality using Playwright MCP tools and Pest test results. Write `work/phase-3/qa-report.md`.

## IMPORTANT: Use Playwright MCP Tools
- `browser_navigate`, `browser_snapshot`, `browser_click`, `browser_fill_form`, `browser_console_messages`, `browser_take_screenshot`
- Use `get-absolute-url` to get the correct base URL first

## What to Test

### Browser Tests (Phase 3 is heavily UI-focused)

**Storefront Layout:**
1. Homepage loads at / with store name, navigation, footer
2. Header has navigation links (collections, about)
3. Mobile menu works (resize viewport, check hamburger)
4. Dark mode classes present
5. Skip-to-content link exists
6. Footer renders with copyright

**Collection Pages:**
7. /collections shows all collections
8. /collections/{handle} shows products in collection
9. Products show with images, titles, prices
10. Pagination works if enough products

**Product Pages:**
11. /products/{handle} shows product details
12. Variant selector shows options (Size, Color)
13. Price displays correctly
14. Image gallery renders
15. Add-to-cart button present

**CMS Pages:**
16. /pages/about renders the About page content

**Search:**
17. /search page loads (placeholder OK for now)

**Cart:**
18. /cart page loads (placeholder OK for now)

**Error Pages:**
19. Invalid URL returns 404 page
20. Test 503 page if possible

**Navigation:**
21. All nav links point to correct destinations
22. Navigation items resolve correctly

### Pest Test Verification
Run `php artisan test --compact` and confirm all 337 tests pass.

### Regression
Verify Phase 1 and Phase 2 functionality still works:
- Admin login
- Customer login

## Output Format
For each test: what, how, expected, actual, PASS/FAIL.
Asset verification section. URL verification section. Regression check. Self-assessment.

Every check PASS or FAIL only. Never use em-dash characters. Send message to team lead when done.


Standard Intelephense false positives (Pest properties, Livewire layout method, model cross-references). Code reviewer and QA analyst are both working in parallel. Waiting for results.


<teammate-message teammate_id="code-reviewer-p3" color="red" summary="Phase 3 code review complete, 10/10 PASS">
Phase 3 code review is complete. Report written to `work/phase-3/code-review.md`.

**Result: 10/10 PASS** | Self-Assessment: **8/10**

Summary of findings:
- All Phase 3 PHP files (11 source + 9 test files) pass Pint with 0 violations
- All 337 tests pass (535 assertions, 7.04s)
- Type safety is strong across all models, services, and Livewire components
- Eloquent best practices followed: proper relationships, eager loading in Products\Show, correct use of withoutGlobalScopes() for cross-model lookups
- Security is appropriate: escaped output where needed, unescaped HTML only for admin-authored content, draft pages correctly return 404
- SOLID principles well applied: focused services, clean enum-based match expressions
- PHP 8 features used throughout: backed enums, match, nullsafe operator, arrow functions
- 54 tests across 9 files covering models, services, and route accessibility
- Laravel conventions followed consistently (directory structure, naming, factory/seeder patterns)
- No meaningful code duplication
- Error handling is clean with firstOrFail() and graceful fallbacks

Two minor non-blocking observations for future phases:
1. NavigationSeeder hardcodes resource_id values (1, 2) instead of querying by handle
2. Layout performs inline NavigationMenu queries rather than fully delegating to NavigationService
</teammate-message>

<teammate-message teammate_id="code-reviewer-p3" color="red">
{"type":"idle_notification","from":"code-reviewer-p3","timestamp":"2026-03-20T08:19:13.592Z","idleReason":"available"}
</teammate-message>


Code review passed 10/10. Shutting down the code reviewer. Waiting for QA analyst.


SendMessage

Code review complete. All items PASS. Your work is done.

Code review complete. All items PASS. Your work is done.


Shutdown request sent to code-reviewer-p3. Request ID: shutdown-1773994764485@code-reviewer-p3


Code reviewer shut down. Waiting for QA analyst to complete browser testing.


<teammate-message teammate_id="system">
{"type":"teammate_terminated","message":"code-reviewer-p3 has shut down."}
</teammate-message>


Waiting for Phase 3 QA analyst results.


<teammate-message teammate_id="qa-analyst-p3" color="blue" summary="Phase 3 QA complete - all 26 tests PASS">
Phase 3 QA report complete at `work/phase-3/qa-report.md`.

**Results:**
- 337 Pest tests: all PASS (535 assertions, 7.10s)
- 26 browser tests: all PASS
- 13 URLs verified: all PASS
- 2 regression checks (admin login, customer login): both PASS
- 0 console errors across all pages

**Key findings:**
- Storefront layout fully functional with responsive design (desktop nav + mobile hamburger)
- Collections display products with images, titles, prices, sort options
- Product pages show variant selectors (Size/Color), quantity controls, add-to-cart
- CMS pages (About, Contact) render correctly with breadcrumbs
- Search and cart placeholder pages load
- 404 and 503 error pages implemented
- Navigation driven by database menus (main-menu + footer-menu)
- Dark mode classes across 35+ template files
- Accessibility: skip-to-content link, breadcrumb nav, ARIA landmarks

**Overall: PASS - Phase 3 is ready to proceed.**
</teammate-message>

<teammate-message teammate_id="qa-analyst-p3" color="blue">
{"type":"idle_notification","from":"qa-analyst-p3","timestamp":"2026-03-20T08:20:00.700Z","idleReason":"available"}
</teammate-message>


Phase 3 QA: all 26 browser tests PASS, 337 Pest tests PASS. Sending to Controller for sign-off and cleaning up teammates.


Phase 3 is complete. All artifacts ready for final sign-off. Please read each file and apply criteria A-F.

**Artifacts:**
1. `work/phase-3/gherkin-specs.md` - Already APPROVED
2. `work/phase-3/gherkin-review.md` - Already APPROVED
3. `work/phase-3/dev-report.md` - Developer report (54 tests, 9 Livewire components, full storefront layout)
4. `work/phase-3/code-review.md` - Code review (8/10, all 10 items PASS)
5. `work/phase-3/qa-report.md` - QA report (26 browser tests PASS, 337 total Pest tests PASS, 13 URLs verified, regression OK)

If ALL criteria MET, produce `work/signoff-phase-3.md`. Otherwise VETO with specifics.

Summary: Review all Phase 3 artifacts for sign-off

Phase 3 is complete. All artifacts ready for final sign-off.


Message sent to controller's inbox

Summary: Review all Phase 3 artifacts for sign-off

Phase 3 is complete. All artifacts ready for final sign-off. Please read each file and apply criteria A-F.

**Artifacts:**
1. `work/phase-3/gherkin-specs.md` - Already APPROVED
2. `work/phase-3/gherkin-review.md` - Already APPROVED
3. `work/phase-3/dev-report.md` - Developer report (54 tests, 9 Livewire components, full storefront layout)
4. `work/phase-3/code-review.md` - Code review (8/10, all 10 items PASS)
5. `work/phase-3/qa-report.md` - QA report (26 browser tests PASS, 337 total Pest tests PASS, 13 URLs verified, regression OK)

If ALL criteria MET, produce `work/signoff-phase-3.md`. Otherwise VETO with specifics.

Message sent to controller's inbox


Phase 3 QA passed. Your work is complete.

Phase 3 QA passed. Your work is complete.


Shutdown request sent to dev-fullstack-p3. Request ID: shutdown-1773994812533@dev-fullstack-p3


Phase 3 QA complete. Your work is done.


Shutdown request sent to qa-analyst-p3. Request ID: shutdown-1773994813592@qa-analyst-p3


Waiting for Controller sign-off on Phase 3.


Waiting for Controller and QA analyst shutdown.


<teammate-message teammate_id="system">
{"type":"teammate_terminated","message":"dev-fullstack-p3 has shut down."}
</teammate-message>

<teammate-message teammate_id="system">
{"type":"teammate_terminated","message":"qa-analyst-p3 has shut down."}
</teammate-message>

<teammate-message teammate_id="qa-analyst-p3" color="blue">
{"type":"shutdown_approved","requestId":"shutdown-1773994813592@qa-analyst-p3","from":"qa-analyst-p3","timestamp":"2026-03-20T08:20:19.766Z","paneId":"in-process","backendType":"in-process"}
</teammate-message>


All Phase 3 teammates shut down cleanly. Waiting for Controller's sign-off verdict.


<teammate-message teammate_id="controller" color="blue" summary="Phase 3 APPROVED, sign-off file created">
**Phase 3 Final Sign-Off -- Criteria A-F**

**Verdict: APPROVED**

Sign-off file created at `work/signoff-phase-3.md`.

**Criteria results:**

| Criterion | Result |
|-----------|--------|
| A - Gherkin Specs | PASS (176 scenarios, traceability table complete, self-assessments substantive) |
| B - Dev Report | PASS (54 tests mapped in 9 files, 337 total passing, placeholders documented) |
| C - Code Review | PASS (10/10 items PASS, 8/10 rating, 0 Pint violations, 337/535 tests/assertions) |
| D - QA Report | PASS (26/26 browser tests, 13 URLs verified, asset verification, regression OK) |
| E - Completeness & Consistency | PASS (337 tests / 535 assertions consistent across all three artifacts) |
| F - Artifact Quality | PASS (all artifacts have narrative content and self-assessments) |

**5 accepted risks documented:**
1. Scenario count discrepancy in specs self-assessment (203 vs 176) -- drafting error, not missing scenarios
2. Two Blade components deferred (address-form, order-summary) -- checkout-specific, belong to Phase 4/5
3. Placeholder Livewire components (Cart, CartDrawer, Search) -- scaffolded cleanly, full implementation in later phases
4. NavigationSeeder hardcodes resource_id values -- fragile but functional
5. Livewire interaction tests are minimal -- acceptable given placeholder status, will expand in later phases

Phase 3 is signed off. Ready for Phase 4.
</teammate-message>

<teammate-message teammate_id="controller" color="blue">
{"type":"idle_notification","from":"controller","timestamp":"2026-03-20T08:21:41.957Z","idleReason":"available"}
</teammate-message>


Phase 3 APPROVED. Let me update progress, commit, and start Phase 4.


Updated task #3


Edit

| 3 | Themes, Pages, Navigation, Storefront Layout | IN PROGRESS | 2026-03-20 | - |

| 3 | Themes, Pages, Navigation, Storefront Layout | COMPLETE | 2026-03-20 | 2026-03-20 |


The file /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/work/progress.md has been updated successfully.

# Project Progress

## Overview
Self-contained e-commerce platform with multi-tenant support, 12 implementation phases.

## Phases

| Phase | Name | Status | Started | Completed |
|-------|------|--------|---------|-----------|
| 1 | Foundation (Migrations, Models, Middleware, Auth) | COMPLETE | 2026-03-20 | 2026-03-20 |
| 2 | Catalog (Products, Variants, Inventory, Collections, Media) | COMPLETE | 2026-03-20 | 2026-03-20 |
| 3 | Themes, Pages, Navigation, Storefront Layout | IN PROGRESS | 2026-03-20 | - |
| 4 | Cart, Checkout, Discounts, Shipping, Taxes | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 5 | Payments, Orders, Fulfillment | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 6 | Customer Accounts | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 7 | Admin Panel | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 8 | Search | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 9 | Analytics | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 10 | Apps and Webhooks | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 11 | Polish | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 12 | Full Test Suite Execution | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| - | Final E2E QA (143 test cases) | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| - | Adversarial QA | NOT STARTED | - | - |

## Current Phase
Phase 2: Catalog (Products, Variants, Inventory, Collections, Media)

-| 3 | Themes, Pages, Navigation, Storefront Layout | IN PROGRESS | 2026-03-20 | - |

+| 3 | Themes, Pages, Navigation, Storefront Layout | COMPLETE | 2026-03-20 | 2026-03-20 |


Bash

git add -A && git commit -m "$(cat <<'EOF'
Phase 3: Themes, Pages, Navigation, Storefront Layout

Implements the complete storefront presentation layer:
- 6 migrations (themes, theme_files, theme_settings, pages, navigation_menus, navigation_items)
- 6 models with relationships, factories, seeders, 3 enums
- ThemeSettingsService (singleton, caches active theme settings per store)
- NavigationService (builds nav trees, resolves URLs for all item types)
- Full storefront Blade layout (announcement bar, responsive header, footer, dark mode, accessibility)
- 9 Livewire components (Home, Collections Index/Show, Products Show, Cart, CartDrawer, Search Index/Modal, Pages Show)
- 6 Blade components (product-card, price, badge, quantity-selector, breadcrumbs, pagination)
- Error pages (404, 503)
- 7 storefront routes with middleware
- 54 new Pest tests (337 total, all passing)

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
EOF
)"

Commit Phase 3


[2026-03-18-claude-code-team bf1741d9] Phase 3: Themes, Pages, Navigation, Storefront Layout
 74 files changed, 5323 insertions(+), 49 deletions(-)
 create mode 100644 app/Enums/NavigationItemType.php
 create mode 100644 app/Enums/PageStatus.php
 create mode 100644 app/Enums/ThemeStatus.php
 create mode 100644 app/Livewire/Storefront/Cart/Show.php
 create mode 100644 app/Livewire/Storefront/CartDrawer.php
 create mode 100644 app/Livewire/Storefront/Collections/Index.php
 create mode 100644 app/Livewire/Storefront/Collections/Show.php
 create mode 100644 app/Livewire/Storefront/Home.php
 create mode 100644 app/Livewire/Storefront/Pages/Show.php
 create mode 100644 app/Livewire/Storefront/Products/Show.php
 create mode 100644 app/Livewire/Storefront/Search/Index.php
 create mode 100644 app/Livewire/Storefront/Search/Modal.php
 create mode 100644 app/Models/NavigationItem.php
 create mode 100644 app/Models/NavigationMenu.php
 create mode 100644 app/Models/Page.php
 create mode 100644 app/Models/Theme.php
 create mode 100644 app/Models/ThemeFile.php
 create mode 100644 app/Models/ThemeSettings.php
 create mode 100644 app/Services/NavigationService.php
 create mode 100644 app/Services/ThemeSettingsService.php
 create mode 100644 database/factories/NavigationItemFactory.php
 create mode 100644 database/factories/NavigationMenuFactory.php
 create mode 100644 database/factories/PageFactory.php
 create mode 100644 database/factories/ThemeFactory.php
 create mode 100644 database/factories/ThemeFileFactory.php
 create mode 100644 database/factories/ThemeSettingsFactory.php
 create mode 100644 database/migrations/2026_03_20_080349_create_themes_table.php
 create mode 100644 database/migrations/2026_03_20_080350_create_theme_files_table.php
 create mode 100644 database/migrations/2026_03_20_080351_create_pages_table.php
 create mode 100644 database/migrations/2026_03_20_080351_create_theme_settings_table.php
 create mode 100644 database/migrations/2026_03_20_080352_create_navigation_menus_table.php
 create mode 100644 database/migrations/2026_03_20_080353_create_navigation_items_table.php
 create mode 100644 database/seeders/NavigationSeeder.php
 create mode 100644 database/seeders/PageSeeder.php
 create mode 100644 database/seeders/ThemeSeeder.php
 create mode 100644 resources/views/livewire/storefront/cart-drawer.blade.php
 create mode 100644 resources/views/livewire/storefront/cart/show.blade.php
 create mode 100644 resources/views/livewire/storefront/collections/index.blade.php
 create mode 100644 resources/views/livewire/storefront/collections/show.blade.php
 create mode 100644 resources/views/livewire/storefront/home.blade.php
 create mode 100644 resources/views/livewire/storefront/pages/show.blade.php
 create mode 100644 resources/views/livewire/storefront/products/show.blade.php
 create mode 100644 resources/views/livewire/storefront/search/index.blade.php
 create mode 100644 resources/views/livewire/storefront/search/modal.blade.php
 create mode 100644 resources/views/storefront/components/badge.blade.php
 create mode 100644 resources/views/storefront/components/breadcrumbs.blade.php
 create mode 100644 resources/views/storefront/components/pagination.blade.php
 create mode 100644 resources/views/storefront/components/price.blade.php
 create mode 100644 resources/views/storefront/components/product-card.blade.php
 create mode 100644 resources/views/storefront/components/quantity-selector.blade.php
 create mode 100644 resources/views/storefront/errors/404.blade.php
 create mode 100644 resources/views/storefront/errors/503.blade.php
 create mode 100644 tests/Feature/Models/NavigationItemTest.php
 create mode 100644 tests/Feature/Models/NavigationMenuTest.php
 create mode 100644 tests/Feature/Models/PageTest.php
 create mode 100644 tests/Feature/Models/ThemeFileTest.php
 create mode 100644 tests/Feature/Models/ThemeSettingsTest.php
 create mode 100644 tests/Feature/Models/ThemeTest.php
 create mode 100644 tests/Feature/Services/NavigationServiceTest.php
 create mode 100644 tests/Feature/Services/ThemeSettingsServiceTest.php
 create mode 100644 tests/Feature/Storefront/RouteAccessibilityTest.php
 create mode 100644 work/phase-3/code-review.md
 create mode 100644 work/phase-3/dev-report.md
 create mode 100644 work/phase-3/gherkin-review.md
 create mode 100644 work/phase-3/gherkin-specs.md
 create mode 100644 work/phase-3/qa-report.md
 create mode 100644 work/signoff-phase-3.md


Phase 3 committed. Now starting Phase 4: Cart, Checkout, Discounts, Shipping, Taxes. This is the core shopping flow - the heaviest business logic phase.


Updated task #4 owner, status


Edit

| 4 | Cart, Checkout, Discounts, Shipping, Taxes | NOT STARTED | - | - |

| 4 | Cart, Checkout, Discounts, Shipping, Taxes | IN PROGRESS | 2026-03-20 | - |


# Project Progress

## Overview
Self-contained e-commerce platform with multi-tenant support, 12 implementation phases.

## Phases

| Phase | Name | Status | Started | Completed |
|-------|------|--------|---------|-----------|
| 1 | Foundation (Migrations, Models, Middleware, Auth) | COMPLETE | 2026-03-20 | 2026-03-20 |
| 2 | Catalog (Products, Variants, Inventory, Collections, Media) | COMPLETE | 2026-03-20 | 2026-03-20 |
| 3 | Themes, Pages, Navigation, Storefront Layout | COMPLETE | 2026-03-20 | 2026-03-20 |
| 4 | Cart, Checkout, Discounts, Shipping, Taxes | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 5 | Payments, Orders, Fulfillment | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 6 | Customer Accounts | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 7 | Admin Panel | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 8 | Search | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 9 | Analytics | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 10 | Apps and Webhooks | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 11 | Polish | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| 12 | Full Test Suite Execution | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| - | Final E2E QA (143 test cases) | NOT STARTED | - | - |
| - | Adversarial QA | NOT STARTED | - | - |

## Current Phase
Phase 2: Catalog (Products, Variants, Inventory, Collections, Media)

-| 4 | Cart, Checkout, Discounts, Shipping, Taxes | NOT STARTED | - | - |

+| 4 | Cart, Checkout, Discounts, Shipping, Taxes | IN PROGRESS | 2026-03-20 | - |


Agent

Phase 4 BDD Expert

Prompt:
You are the **BDD Expert** for Phase 4: Cart, Checkout, Discounts, Shipping, Taxes of the shop project.

## Your Task
Read the Phase 4 requirements from `specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md` (Steps 4.1 through 4.9, starting around line 442) and rewrite them as Gherkin specifications. Save output to `work/phase-4/gherkin-specs.md`.

## Phase 4 Scope
- Step 4.1: Migrations (carts, cart_lines, checkouts, shipping_zones, shipping_rates, tax_settings, discounts)
- Step 4.2: Models (Cart, CartLine, Checkout, ShippingZone, ShippingRate, TaxSettings, Discount) + Enums (CartStatus, CheckoutStatus, DiscountType, DiscountValueType, DiscountStatus, ShippingRateType, TaxMode)
- Step 4.3: Cart Service (create, addLine, updateLineQuantity, removeLine, getOrCreateForSession, mergeOnLogin, cart versioning)
- Step 4.4: Discount Service (validate, calculate with proportional allocation)
- Step 4.5: Shipping Calculator (getAvailableRates, calculate by type)
- Step 4.6: Tax Calculator (calculate, extractInclusive, addExclusive, basis points)
- Step 4.7: Pricing Engine (full pipeline: subtotals -> discount -> shipping -> tax -> total)
- Step 4.8: Checkout State Machine (started -> addressed -> shipping_selected -> payment_selected -> completed, plus expiry)
- Step 4.9: Storefront Cart/Checkout UI (CartDrawer, Cart/Show, Checkout/Show, Confirmation)

Also reference:
- `specs/05-BUSINESS-LOGIC.md` for business logic
- `specs/01-DATABASE-SCHEMA.md` for schema
- The Pest test spec in `specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md` Section 3 for test cases (CartServiceTest, CartApiTest, CheckoutFlowTest, CheckoutStateTest, PricingIntegrationTest, DiscountTest, ShippingTest, TaxTest, and unit tests)

## Output Format
1. Every acceptance criterion mapped to Gherkin scenarios
2. Traceability table
3. Self-assessment section

Create `work/phase-4/` directory. Never use em-dash characters. Send message to team lead when done.


Spawned successfully.
agent_id: bdd-expert-p4@vivid-launching-llama
name: bdd-expert-p4
team_name: vivid-launching-llama
The agent is now running and will receive instructions via mailbox.

Prompt:
You are the **BDD Expert** for Phase 4: Cart, Checkout, Discounts, Shipping, Taxes of the shop project.

## Your Task
Read the Phase 4 requirements from `specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md` (Steps 4.1 through 4.9, starting around line 442) and rewrite them as Gherkin specifications. Save output to `work/phase-4/gherkin-specs.md`.

## Phase 4 Scope
- Step 4.1: Migrations (carts, cart_lines, checkouts, shipping_zones, shipping_rates, tax_settings, discounts)
- Step 4.2: Models (Cart, CartLine, Checkout, ShippingZone, ShippingRate, TaxSettings, Discount) + Enums (CartStatus, CheckoutStatus, DiscountType, DiscountValueType, DiscountStatus, ShippingRateType, TaxMode)
- Step 4.3: Cart Service (create, addLine, updateLineQuantity, removeLine, getOrCreateForSession, mergeOnLogin, cart versioning)
- Step 4.4: Discount Service (validate, calculate with proportional allocation)
- Step 4.5: Shipping Calculator (getAvailableRates, calculate by type)
- Step 4.6: Tax Calculator (calculate, extractInclusive, addExclusive, basis points)
- Step 4.7: Pricing Engine (full pipeline: subtotals -> discount -> shipping -> tax -> total)
- Step 4.8: Checkout State Machine (started -> addressed -> shipping_selected -> payment_selected -> completed, plus expiry)
- Step 4.9: Storefront Cart/Checkout UI (CartDrawer, Cart/Show, Checkout/Show, Confirmation)

Also reference:
- `specs/05-BUSINESS-LOGIC.md` for business logic
- `specs/01-DATABASE-SCHEMA.md` for schema
- The Pest test spec in `specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md` Section 3 for test cases (CartServiceTest, CartApiTest, CheckoutFlowTest, CheckoutStateTest, PricingIntegrationTest, DiscountTest, ShippingTest, TaxTest, and unit tests)

## Output Format
1. Every acceptance criterion mapped to Gherkin scenarios
2. Traceability table
3. Self-assessment section

Create `work/phase-4/` directory. Never use em-dash characters. Send message to team lead when done.


**Progress:**
- Phase 1: COMPLETE
- Phase 2: COMPLETE
- Phase 3: COMPLETE
- Phase 4: IN PROGRESS (BDD Expert writing Gherkin specs)


<teammate-message teammate_id="team-lead">
{"type":"task_assignment","taskId":"4","subject":"Phase 4: Cart, Checkout, Discounts, Shipping, Taxes","description":"Implement Phase 4: Cart/Checkout/Discount/Shipping/Tax models, CartService, DiscountService, ShippingCalculator, TaxCalculator, PricingEngine, CheckoutService state machine, checkout UI. Depends on Phases 2 and 3.","assignedBy":"team-lead","timestamp":"2026-03-20T08:22:05.251Z"}
</teammate-message>


BDD Expert working on Phase 4 Gherkin specs. Waiting for completion.


<teammate-message teammate_id="bdd-expert-p4" color="green" summary="Phase 4 Gherkin specs complete, ready for review">
Phase 4 BDD Expert work is complete. Gherkin specifications saved to `work/phase-4/gherkin-specs.md`.

**What was produced:**
- 10 Gherkin features with 100+ scenarios covering all Phase 4 steps (4.1-4.9)
- Features: Cart Service, Cart API, Discount Service, Shipping Calculator, Tax Calculator, Pricing Engine, Checkout State Machine, Checkout Flow (E2E), Storefront UI, Scheduled Jobs
- Full traceability table mapping every spec reference (Steps 4.1-4.9, Business Logic sections 4-9, DB schema Epic 5) to Gherkin scenarios and test files
- Self-assessment section with coverage analysis

**Key coverage highlights:**
- All 6 CartService methods with happy paths, validation, and edge cases
- All 5 checkout state transitions with required data validation
- All discount error codes (6 reason codes) and all 3 value types (percent, fixed, free_shipping)
- All shipping rate types (flat, weight, price) plus zone matching with specificity
- Both tax modes (exclusive/inclusive) with integer division and per-line rounding
- Full pricing pipeline (7-step deterministic calculation)
- Both scheduled jobs (ExpireAbandonedCheckouts, CleanupAbandonedCarts)
- All test cases from the roadmap test specification are mapped
- Storefront UI behavioral scenarios for all 4 Livewire components
</teammate-message>

<teammate-message teammate_id="bdd-expert-p4" color="green">
{"type":"idle_notification","from":"bdd-expert-p4","timestamp":"2026-03-20T08:26:40.129Z","idleReason":"available"}
</teammate-message>


Phase 4 Gherkin specs complete. Spawning reviewer and shutting down BDD Expert.


Phase 4 Gherkin Reviewer

Prompt:
You are the **Gherkin Reviewer** for Phase 4: Cart, Checkout, Discounts, Shipping, Taxes.

## Your Task
Review `work/phase-4/gherkin-specs.md` for completeness vs Phase 4 spec. Save review to `work/phase-4/gherkin-review.md`.

## Steps
1. Read `specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md` (Steps 4.1-4.9, around lines 442-597)
2. Read `specs/05-BUSINESS-LOGIC.md` for business logic details
3. Read `work/phase-4/gherkin-specs.md`
4. Count requirements, count scenarios, verify every requirement covered
5. Check consistency with Phase 3 (done) and Phase 5 (next - payments/orders)
6. Write review with exact counts, gaps, self-assessment

Never use em-dash characters. Send message to team lead when done.


Spawned successfully.
agent_id: gherkin-reviewer-p4@vivid-launching-llama
name: gherkin-reviewer-p4
team_name: vivid-launching-llama
The agent is now running and will receive instructions via mailbox.

Prompt:
You are the **Gherkin Reviewer** for Phase 4: Cart, Checkout, Discounts, Shipping, Taxes.

## Your Task
Review `work/phase-4/gherkin-specs.md` for completeness vs Phase 4 spec. Save review to `work/phase-4/gherkin-review.md`.

## Steps
1. Read `specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md` (Steps 4.1-4.9, around lines 442-597)
2. Read `specs/05-BUSINESS-LOGIC.md` for business logic details
3. Read `work/phase-4/gherkin-specs.md`
4. Count requirements, count scenarios, verify every requirement covered
5. Check consistency with Phase 3 (done) and Phase 5 (next - payments/orders)
6. Write review with exact counts, gaps, self-assessment

Never use em-dash characters. Send message to team lead when done.


SendMessage

Phase 4 Gherkin specs complete. Your work is done.

Phase 4 Gherkin specs complete. Your work is done.


Shutdown request sent to bdd-expert-p4. Request ID: shutdown-1773995214993@bdd-expert-p4


<teammate-message teammate_id="gherkin-reviewer-p4" color="yellow" summary="Phase 4 Gherkin review: APPROVED, 123 scenarios, 4 minor gaps">
Phase 4 Gherkin review complete. Saved to `work/phase-4/gherkin-review.md`.

**Verdict: APPROVED WITH MINOR GAPS**

**123 Gherkin scenarios** across 10 features covering all roadmap steps 4.1-4.9 and all business logic sections (Spec 05 Sections 4-9).

Breakdown:
- Cart Service: 19 scenarios
- Cart API: 10 scenarios
- Discount Service: 19 scenarios
- Shipping Calculator: 11 scenarios
- Tax Calculator: 8 scenarios
- Pricing Engine: 10 scenarios
- Checkout State Machine: 19 scenarios
- Checkout Flow E2E: 8 scenarios
- Storefront Cart/Checkout UI: 11 scenarios
- Scheduled Jobs: 8 scenarios

**4 gaps found:**

1. **Gap #1 (Behavioral Discrepancy):** Cart merge scenario uses addition (2+1=3) but Spec 05 Section 4.1 says MAX(existingQty, guestQty). Should be MAX(2,1)=2. Fix before implementation.

2. **Gap #2 (Medium):** No "Checkout API" feature section. Cart API has dedicated HTTP-layer scenarios but checkout endpoints (POST /checkouts, PUT /address, PUT /shipping-method, PUT /payment-method, POST /apply-discount, DELETE /discount, POST /pay) lack API-level testing for HTTP status codes (especially 410 expired), rate limiting (10/min checkout tier), and request/response schemas. Recommend adding 10-12 Checkout API scenarios.

3. **Gap #3 (Low):** Missing "Cannot ship to this address" blocking behavior at checkout level when zero shipping zones match. Spec 05 Sec 9.1 requires blocking checkout progression.

4. **Gap #4 (Low):** Discount status lifecycle transitions (draft->active, active->disabled, disabled->active) not tested. Primarily an admin concern (Phase 7) but could be unit-tested here.

All 7 models, 7 enums, 2 value objects, and both scheduled jobs are verified. Phase 3/Phase 5 boundary consistency is clean -- no conflicts.
</teammate-message>

<teammate-message teammate_id="gherkin-reviewer-p4" color="yellow">
{"type":"idle_notification","from":"gherkin-reviewer-p4","timestamp":"2026-03-20T08:30:30.392Z","idleReason":"available"}
</teammate-message>

<teammate-message teammate_id="bdd-expert-p4" color="green">
{"type":"shutdown_approved","requestId":"shutdown-1773995214993@bdd-expert-p4","from":"bdd-expert-p4","timestamp":"2026-03-20T08:27:00.940Z","paneId":"in-process","backendType":"in-process"}
</teammate-message>


Gap #1 (cart merge behavior: MAX vs addition) is a real spec interpretation issue. I'll instruct the developer to follow the spec (MAX). The other gaps are minor/deferred. Let me send to Controller for Gherkin approval.


Phase 4 Gherkin specs ready for your review. Please read both files and apply acceptance criteria A:

1. `work/phase-4/gherkin-specs.md` - 123 Gherkin scenarios covering Steps 4.1-4.9
2. `work/phase-4/gherkin-review.md` - Reviewer found 4 minor gaps, verdict APPROVED WITH MINOR GAPS

Team lead assessment of the 4 gaps:
- Gap #1 (cart merge MAX vs addition): Will instruct developer to follow spec (MAX behavior). Does not require Gherkin rewrite since implementation will be spec-correct.
- Gap #2 (Checkout API scenarios): Checkout endpoints are tested as feature tests per the roadmap test spec. Separate API-level scenarios not required.
- Gap #3 (shipping zone blocking): Will be handled during implementation.
- Gap #4 (discount lifecycle): Phase 7 admin concern, correctly deferred.

Respond with APPROVE or VETO.

Summary: Review Phase 4 Gherkin specs

Phase 4 Gherkin specs ready for review with 4 minor gaps assessed.


Message sent to controller's inbox

Summary: Review Phase 4 Gherkin specs

Phase 4 Gherkin specs ready for your review. Please read both files and apply acceptance criteria A:

1. `work/phase-4/gherkin-specs.md` - 123 Gherkin scenarios covering Steps 4.1-4.9
2. `work/phase-4/gherkin-review.md` - Reviewer found 4 minor gaps, verdict APPROVED WITH MINOR GAPS

Team lead assessment of the 4 gaps:
- Gap #1 (cart merge MAX vs addition): Will instruct developer to follow spec (MAX behavior). Does not require Gherkin rewrite since implementation will be spec-correct.
- Gap #2 (Checkout API scenarios): Checkout endpoints are tested as feature tests per the roadmap test spec. Separate API-level scenarios not required.
- Gap #3 (shipping zone blocking): Will be handled during implementation.
- Gap #4 (discount lifecycle): Phase 7 admin concern, correctly deferred.

Respond with APPROVE or VETO.

Message sent to controller's inbox

Summary: Review Phase 4 Gherkin specs


Phase 4 Gherkin review complete. Your work is done.

Phase 4 Gherkin review complete. Your work is done.


Shutdown request sent to gherkin-reviewer-p4. Request ID: shutdown-1773995455590@gherkin-reviewer-p4


Waiting for Controller's Phase 4 Gherkin verdict.


<teammate-message teammate_id="system">
{"type":"teammate_terminated","message":"bdd-expert-p4 has shut down."}
</teammate-message>

<teammate-message teammate_id="system">
{"type":"teammate_terminated","message":"gherkin-reviewer-p4 has shut down."}
</teammate-message>

<teammate-message teammate_id="gherkin-reviewer-p4" color="yellow">
{"type":"shutdown_approved","requestId":"shutdown-1773995455590@gherkin-reviewer-p4","from":"gherkin-reviewer-p4","timestamp":"2026-03-20T08:30:59.828Z","paneId":"in-process","backendType":"in-process"}
</teammate-message>


All Phase 4 spec teammates shut down. Waiting for Controller verdict.


<teammate-message teammate_id="controller" color="blue" summary="Phase 4 Gherkin specs APPROVED, 123 scenarios">
**Phase 4 Gherkin Specs Review -- Criterion A**

**Verdict: APPROVE**

I have read both files in full:
- `work/phase-4/gherkin-specs.md` (1130 lines)
- `work/phase-4/gherkin-review.md` (286 lines)

**Criterion A sub-criteria:**

1. **Both files exist:** PASS. Specs file (1130 lines) and review file (286 lines) both present and substantive.

2. **Traceability table completeness:** PASS. The traceability table (lines 1029-1083, 55 rows) maps all roadmap steps 4.1-4.9 and Spec 05 Sections 4-9 to Gherkin features and anticipated test files. All 7 models, all 7 enums, all service methods (CartService x6, DiscountService x2, ShippingCalculator x2, TaxCalculator x3, PricingEngine x1, CheckoutService transitions x5), both scheduled jobs, Cart API endpoints, and 4 Livewire UI components are traced.

3. **Exact counts:** PASS. Review reports 123 scenarios (19 + 10 + 19 + 11 + 8 + 10 + 19 + 8 + 11 + 8 = 123). The specs file's scenario counts are consistent with this total. No discrepancy like Phase 3.

4. **Substantive self-assessments:** PASS. The specs self-assessment (lines 1089-1129) is thorough -- covers fully covered areas, UI coverage, lighter coverage with justification, boundary conditions (8 listed), and traceability completeness. The review has detailed per-feature requirement tables with spec source cross-references.

5. **Concerns addressed:** PASS. The review identified 4 minor gaps. Your dispositions are sound:
   - Gap #1 (merge MAX vs addition): Developer instruction to follow spec is appropriate. The Gherkin scenario text says qty "3" (addition) but implementation will use MAX. This is a known divergence -- acceptable since the developer is instructed.
   - Gap #2 (Checkout API): Feature-level testing covers the service behavior. API endpoint concerns (HTTP status codes, rate limits) are secondary.
   - Gap #3 (shipping zone blocking): Implementation-time concern, not a spec gap.
   - Gap #4 (discount lifecycle): Correctly deferred to Phase 7.

No blocking issues found. Phase 4 Gherkin specs are approved.
</teammate-message>

<teammate-message teammate_id="controller" color="blue">
{"type":"idle_notification","from":"controller","timestamp":"2026-03-20T08:31:36.974Z","idleReason":"available"}
</teammate-message>


Phase 4 Gherkin specs APPROVED. Spawning the Phase 4 developer now. This is the heaviest business logic phase.