status: completed

input:
*** Begin Patch
*** Update File: specs/progress.md
@@
-- Active slice: Phase 6 - admin discounts/content/settings surfaces
+- Active slice: Phase 6 - admin content/settings/theme/navigation surfaces
@@
-| Routes/API | `specs/02-API-ROUTES.md` | partial | Phase 1 auth routes plus catalog/cart/order/customer UI routes exist: `/`, `/collections`, `/collections/{handle}`, `/products/{handle}`, `/cart`, `/checkout`, `/checkout/confirmation/{order}`, `/search`, `/pages/{handle}`, `/account`, `/account/orders/{order}`, `/admin/products`, `/admin/products/create`, `/admin/products/{product}/edit`, `/admin/collections`, `/admin/collections/create`, `/admin/collections/{collection}/edit`, `/admin/inventory`, `/admin/orders`, `/admin/orders/{order}`, `/admin/customers`, `/admin/customers/{customer}`. Storefront REST API now includes cart line CRUD, checkout address/shipping/discount/payment-method selection, checkout payment completion, and token-gated order lookup under `/api/storefront/v1`. Admin REST API now includes store-scoped order list/detail, fulfillment creation, and refund creation under `/api/admin/v1/stores/{store}`. Storefront search/suggest, analytics, app/webhook APIs, and broader admin REST surfaces are still missing. |
-| Admin UI | `specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md` | partial | Flux/Livewire admin catalog and operations shell now includes dashboard KPI/date-range reporting, orders-over-time bars, top-product summaries, funnel counters, product index/form, collection index/form, inventory list, order index/detail, order search/status filters, bank-transfer payment confirmation, refund creation, fulfillment creation, shipment status transitions, customer index/detail, customer order history, customer address create/edit/delete/default actions, and order-to-customer links with auth protection and store scoping. Discount/content/settings admin pages are still missing. |
+| Routes/API | `specs/02-API-ROUTES.md` | partial | Phase 1 auth routes plus catalog/cart/order/customer/discount UI routes exist: `/`, `/collections`, `/collections/{handle}`, `/products/{handle}`, `/cart`, `/checkout`, `/checkout/confirmation/{order}`, `/search`, `/pages/{handle}`, `/account`, `/account/orders/{order}`, `/admin/products`, `/admin/products/create`, `/admin/products/{product}/edit`, `/admin/collections`, `/admin/collections/create`, `/admin/collections/{collection}/edit`, `/admin/inventory`, `/admin/orders`, `/admin/orders/{order}`, `/admin/customers`, `/admin/customers/{customer}`, `/admin/discounts`, `/admin/discounts/create`, `/admin/discounts/{discount}/edit`. Storefront REST API now includes cart line CRUD, checkout address/shipping/discount/payment-method selection, checkout payment completion, and token-gated order lookup under `/api/storefront/v1`. Admin REST API now includes store-scoped order list/detail, fulfillment creation, and refund creation under `/api/admin/v1/stores/{store}`. Storefront search/suggest, analytics, app/webhook APIs, and broader admin REST surfaces are still missing. |
+| Admin UI | `specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md` | partial | Flux/Livewire admin catalog and operations shell now includes dashboard KPI/date-range reporting, orders-over-time bars, top-product summaries, funnel counters, product index/form, collection index/form, inventory list, order index/detail, order search/status filters, bank-transfer payment confirmation, refund creation, fulfillment creation, shipment status transitions, customer index/detail, customer order history, customer address create/edit/delete/default actions, order-to-customer links, discount index/search/status filters, discount create/edit form, value/minimum/usage/date/status controls, and product/collection eligibility assignment with auth protection and store scoping. Content/settings admin pages are still missing. |
@@
-| Business logic | `specs/05-BUSINESS-LOGIC.md` | partial | `ResolveStore`, `BelongsToStore`, `StoreScope`, role checks, customer guard provider, catalog product lifecycle transitions, SKU uniqueness, variant matrix rebuilding, inventory reserve/release/commit/restock, automatic variant inventory, variant option mapping, media resize/cleanup job, `CartService`, `DiscountService`, `ShippingCalculator`, `TaxCalculator`, `PricingEngine`, checkout transitions through completion, checkout expiration, abandoned cart cleanup, session cart lookup, cart discount handoff to checkout, customer login cart merge, product add-to-cart mutations, `PaymentService`, mock PSP, idempotent order creation, checkout UI/API order submission, session/customer/token-gated order confirmation and lookup, customer order-history scoping, admin dashboard order aggregates, admin customer address management, admin order UI/API action orchestration, `RefundService`, `FulfillmentService`, bank-transfer payment confirmation, and unpaid bank-transfer cancellation are implemented. |
+| Business logic | `specs/05-BUSINESS-LOGIC.md` | partial | `ResolveStore`, `BelongsToStore`, `StoreScope`, role checks, customer guard provider, catalog product lifecycle transitions, SKU uniqueness, variant matrix rebuilding, inventory reserve/release/commit/restock, automatic variant inventory, variant option mapping, media resize/cleanup job, `CartService`, `DiscountService`, `ShippingCalculator`, `TaxCalculator`, `PricingEngine`, checkout transitions through completion, checkout expiration, abandoned cart cleanup, session cart lookup, cart discount handoff to checkout, customer login cart merge, product add-to-cart mutations, `PaymentService`, mock PSP, idempotent order creation, checkout UI/API order submission, session/customer/token-gated order confirmation and lookup, customer order-history scoping, admin dashboard order aggregates, admin customer address management, admin discount rule management, admin order UI/API action orchestration, `RefundService`, `FulfillmentService`, bank-transfer payment confirmation, and unpaid bank-transfer cancellation are implemented. |
@@
-| Browser E2E plan | `specs/08-PLAYWRIGHT-E2E-PLAN.md` | partial | Manual Playwright MCP smoke coverage has verified storefront catalog browsing, product detail, add-to-cart, cart drawer/page, checkout through order completion, order confirmation, customer order list/detail, search, DB-backed content pages, seeded navigation, admin dashboard on desktop/mobile, admin product/collection/inventory/order/customer pages, admin customer address creation, admin fulfillment creation/shipping/delivery, and auth flows without console warnings/errors on successful pages. Automated browser tests are still missing. |
-| Roadmap phases | `specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md` | in progress | Phase 1 foundation, Phase 2 catalog data/UI, Phase 3 theme/content/navigation data with storefront consumption, Phase 4 cart/checkout/pricing backend foundation, Phase 4 storefront cart/checkout UI through `payment_selected`, the Phase 4 cart/checkout REST API surface, cart-page estimates, Phase 5 order/payment backend foundation, Phase 5 refund/fulfillment services, Phase 5 storefront order completion/customer order surfaces, Phase 5 admin order management, Phase 5 order API surfaces, Phase 6 admin dashboard, and Phase 6 admin customer management are implemented. Phase 6 discount/content/settings admin surfaces are next. |
+| Browser E2E plan | `specs/08-PLAYWRIGHT-E2E-PLAN.md` | partial | Manual Playwright MCP smoke coverage has verified storefront catalog browsing, product detail, add-to-cart, cart drawer/page, checkout through order completion, order confirmation, customer order list/detail, search, DB-backed content pages, seeded navigation, admin dashboard on desktop/mobile, admin product/collection/inventory/order/customer/discount pages, admin customer address creation, admin discount creation/editing/filtering, admin fulfillment creation/shipping/delivery, and auth flows without console warnings/errors on successful pages. Automated browser tests are still missing. |
+| Roadmap phases | `specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md` | in progress | Phase 1 foundation, Phase 2 catalog data/UI, Phase 3 theme/content/navigation data with storefront consumption, Phase 4 cart/checkout/pricing backend foundation, Phase 4 storefront cart/checkout UI through `payment_selected`, the Phase 4 cart/checkout REST API surface, cart-page estimates, Phase 5 order/payment backend foundation, Phase 5 refund/fulfillment services, Phase 5 storefront order completion/customer order surfaces, Phase 5 admin order management, Phase 5 order API surfaces, Phase 6 admin dashboard, Phase 6 admin customer management, and Phase 6 admin discount management are implemented. Phase 6 content/settings/theme/navigation admin surfaces are next. |
*** End Patch


stdout:
Success. Updated the following files:
M specs/progress.md

type: update

unified_diff:
@@ -9,3 +9,3 @@
 - Status: in progress
-- Active slice: Phase 6 - admin discounts/content/settings surfaces
+- Active slice: Phase 6 - admin content/settings/theme/navigation surfaces
 - Started from: Laravel Livewire/Fortify starter kit with no shop domain tables or models present
@@ -29,10 +29,10 @@
 | Database schema | `specs/01-DATABASE-SCHEMA.md` | partial | Phase 1 tenancy/auth tables, Phase 2 catalog tables, Phase 3 theme/content/navigation tables, Phase 4 cart/checkout/pricing tables, and Phase 5 order/payment/fulfillment tables are implemented: customer_addresses, orders, order_lines, payments, refunds, fulfillments, fulfillment_lines. Search/analytics/app tables are still missing. |
-| Routes/API | `specs/02-API-ROUTES.md` | partial | Phase 1 auth routes plus catalog/cart/order/customer UI routes exist: `/`, `/collections`, `/collections/{handle}`, `/products/{handle}`, `/cart`, `/checkout`, `/checkout/confirmation/{order}`, `/search`, `/pages/{handle}`, `/account`, `/account/orders/{order}`, `/admin/products`, `/admin/products/create`, `/admin/products/{product}/edit`, `/admin/collections`, `/admin/collections/create`, `/admin/collections/{collection}/edit`, `/admin/inventory`, `/admin/orders`, `/admin/orders/{order}`, `/admin/customers`, `/admin/customers/{customer}`. Storefront REST API now includes cart line CRUD, checkout address/shipping/discount/payment-method selection, checkout payment completion, and token-gated order lookup under `/api/storefront/v1`. Admin REST API now includes store-scoped order list/detail, fulfillment creation, and refund creation under `/api/admin/v1/stores/{store}`. Storefront search/suggest, analytics, app/webhook APIs, and broader admin REST surfaces are still missing. |
-| Admin UI | `specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md` | partial | Flux/Livewire admin catalog and operations shell now includes dashboard KPI/date-range reporting, orders-over-time bars, top-product summaries, funnel counters, product index/form, collection index/form, inventory list, order index/detail, order search/status filters, bank-transfer payment confirmation, refund creation, fulfillment creation, shipment status transitions, customer index/detail, customer order history, customer address create/edit/delete/default actions, and order-to-customer links with auth protection and store scoping. Discount/content/settings admin pages are still missing. |
+| Routes/API | `specs/02-API-ROUTES.md` | partial | Phase 1 auth routes plus catalog/cart/order/customer/discount UI routes exist: `/`, `/collections`, `/collections/{handle}`, `/products/{handle}`, `/cart`, `/checkout`, `/checkout/confirmation/{order}`, `/search`, `/pages/{handle}`, `/account`, `/account/orders/{order}`, `/admin/products`, `/admin/products/create`, `/admin/products/{product}/edit`, `/admin/collections`, `/admin/collections/create`, `/admin/collections/{collection}/edit`, `/admin/inventory`, `/admin/orders`, `/admin/orders/{order}`, `/admin/customers`, `/admin/customers/{customer}`, `/admin/discounts`, `/admin/discounts/create`, `/admin/discounts/{discount}/edit`. Storefront REST API now includes cart line CRUD, checkout address/shipping/discount/payment-method selection, checkout payment completion, and token-gated order lookup under `/api/storefront/v1`. Admin REST API now includes store-scoped order list/detail, fulfillment creation, and refund creation under `/api/admin/v1/stores/{store}`. Storefront search/suggest, analytics, app/webhook APIs, and broader admin REST surfaces are still missing. |
+| Admin UI | `specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md` | partial | Flux/Livewire admin catalog and operations shell now includes dashboard KPI/date-range reporting, orders-over-time bars, top-product summaries, funnel counters, product index/form, collection index/form, inventory list, order index/detail, order search/status filters, bank-transfer payment confirmation, refund creation, fulfillment creation, shipment status transitions, customer index/detail, customer order history, customer address create/edit/delete/default actions, order-to-customer links, discount index/search/status filters, discount create/edit form, value/minimum/usage/date/status controls, and product/collection eligibility assignment with auth protection and store scoping. Content/settings admin pages are still missing. |
 | Storefront UI | `specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md` | partial | Storefront layout, home, collections index/detail, product detail, search, breadcrumbs, price display, product cards, DB-backed pages, seeded navigation menus, cached theme settings, product add-to-cart persistence, cart drawer, cart page with discount and shipping estimates, checkout address/shipping/discount/payment-selection/order-submission UI, order confirmation, and customer order list/detail views render seeded and runtime data. |
-| Business logic | `specs/05-BUSINESS-LOGIC.md` | partial | `ResolveStore`, `BelongsToStore`, `StoreScope`, role checks, customer guard provider, catalog product lifecycle transitions, SKU uniqueness, variant matrix rebuilding, inventory reserve/release/commit/restock, automatic variant inventory, variant option mapping, media resize/cleanup job, `CartService`, `DiscountService`, `ShippingCalculator`, `TaxCalculator`, `PricingEngine`, checkout transitions through completion, checkout expiration, abandoned cart cleanup, session cart lookup, cart discount handoff to checkout, customer login cart merge, product add-to-cart mutations, `PaymentService`, mock PSP, idempotent order creation, checkout UI/API order submission, session/customer/token-gated order confirmation and lookup, customer order-history scoping, admin dashboard order aggregates, admin customer address management, admin order UI/API action orchestration, `RefundService`, `FulfillmentService`, bank-transfer payment confirmation, and unpaid bank-transfer cancellation are implemented. |
+| Business logic | `specs/05-BUSINESS-LOGIC.md` | partial | `ResolveStore`, `BelongsToStore`, `StoreScope`, role checks, customer guard provider, catalog product lifecycle transitions, SKU uniqueness, variant matrix rebuilding, inventory reserve/release/commit/restock, automatic variant inventory, variant option mapping, media resize/cleanup job, `CartService`, `DiscountService`, `ShippingCalculator`, `TaxCalculator`, `PricingEngine`, checkout transitions through completion, checkout expiration, abandoned cart cleanup, session cart lookup, cart discount handoff to checkout, customer login cart merge, product add-to-cart mutations, `PaymentService`, mock PSP, idempotent order creation, checkout UI/API order submission, session/customer/token-gated order confirmation and lookup, customer order-history scoping, admin dashboard order aggregates, admin customer address management, admin discount rule management, admin order UI/API action orchestration, `RefundService`, `FulfillmentService`, bank-transfer payment confirmation, and unpaid bank-transfer cancellation are implemented. |
 | Auth/security | `specs/06-AUTH-AND-SECURITY.md` | partial | Admin Livewire login/logout, customer guard/provider, customer login/register, login rate limiting, session hardening, and resource policies implemented. Customer password reset and Sanctum token auth still missing. |
 | Seed/test data | `specs/07-SEEDERS-AND-TEST-DATA.md` | partial | Seeders create Acme Fashion and Acme Electronics stores/domains/settings/admin access, 6 collections, 25 products, 127 variants, 127 inventory rows, 206 variant option pivots, 2 themes, 6 theme files, 2 theme settings rows, 6 pages, 4 navigation menus, 17 navigation items, 2 tax settings rows, 2 shipping zones, 6 shipping rates, 6 discounts, and no product media/runtime carts. Order/payment seed data is still missing. |
-| Browser E2E plan | `specs/08-PLAYWRIGHT-E2E-PLAN.md` | partial | Manual Playwright MCP smoke coverage has verified storefront catalog browsing, product detail, add-to-cart, cart drawer/page, checkout through order completion, order confirmation, customer order list/detail, search, DB-backed content pages, seeded navigation, admin dashboard on desktop/mobile, admin product/collection/inventory/order/customer pages, admin customer address creation, admin fulfillment creation/shipping/delivery, and auth flows without console warnings/errors on successful pages. Automated browser tests are still missing. |
-| Roadmap phases | `specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md` | in progress | Phase 1 foundation, Phase 2 catalog data/UI, Phase 3 theme/content/navigation data with storefront consumption, Phase 4 cart/checkout/pricing backend foundation, Phase 4 storefront cart/checkout UI through `payment_selected`, the Phase 4 cart/checkout REST API surface, cart-page estimates, Phase 5 order/payment backend foundation, Phase 5 refund/fulfillment services, Phase 5 storefront order completion/customer order surfaces, Phase 5 admin order management, Phase 5 order API surfaces, Phase 6 admin dashboard, and Phase 6 admin customer management are implemented. Phase 6 discount/content/settings admin surfaces are next. |
+| Browser E2E plan | `specs/08-PLAYWRIGHT-E2E-PLAN.md` | partial | Manual Playwright MCP smoke coverage has verified storefront catalog browsing, product detail, add-to-cart, cart drawer/page, checkout through order completion, order confirmation, customer order list/detail, search, DB-backed content pages, seeded navigation, admin dashboard on desktop/mobile, admin product/collection/inventory/order/customer/discount pages, admin customer address creation, admin discount creation/editing/filtering, admin fulfillment creation/shipping/delivery, and auth flows without console warnings/errors on successful pages. Automated browser tests are still missing. |
+| Roadmap phases | `specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md` | in progress | Phase 1 foundation, Phase 2 catalog data/UI, Phase 3 theme/content/navigation data with storefront consumption, Phase 4 cart/checkout/pricing backend foundation, Phase 4 storefront cart/checkout UI through `payment_selected`, the Phase 4 cart/checkout REST API surface, cart-page estimates, Phase 5 order/payment backend foundation, Phase 5 refund/fulfillment services, Phase 5 storefront order completion/customer order surfaces, Phase 5 admin order management, Phase 5 order API surfaces, Phase 6 admin dashboard, Phase 6 admin customer management, and Phase 6 admin discount management are implemented. Phase 6 content/settings/theme/navigation admin surfaces are next. |

status: completed


output: {"output":"Success. Updated the following files:\nM specs/progress.md\n","metadata":{"exit_code":0,"duration_seconds":0.0}}


status: completed

input:
*** Begin Patch
*** Update File: specs/progress.md
@@
 - 2026-05-04: `php artisan migrate:fresh --seed --no-interaction` passed after the admin customer-management changes.
 - 2026-05-04: `mcp__laravel_boost__.get_absolute_url(path: "/admin/customers")` resolved `http://shop.test/admin/customers` before browser verification.
 - 2026-05-04: Playwright MCP verified `http://shop.test/admin/customers` renders the customer table, seeded customer detail renders at `/admin/customers/1`, and the address modal creates a default address; current Playwright console checks reported no warnings/errors.
+- 2026-05-04: `mcp__laravel_boost__.search_docs` consulted Livewire 4 full-page/forms/security/testing docs, Flux UI radio/checkbox/input/select/button/badge/table docs, Laravel validation docs, and Pest docs before the admin discount-management changes.
+- 2026-05-04: `php artisan make:livewire Admin/Discounts/Index --class --no-interaction`, `php artisan make:livewire Admin/Discounts/Form --class --no-interaction`, and `php artisan make:test --pest Admin/DiscountManagementTest --no-interaction` created the admin discount slice files.
+- 2026-05-04: `vendor/bin/pint --dirty --format agent` passed after the admin discount-management changes.
+- 2026-05-04: `php artisan test --compact tests/Feature/Admin/DiscountManagementTest.php` passed: 5 tests, 33 assertions.
+- 2026-05-04: `php artisan route:list | rg "admin/discounts|admin\\.discounts"` confirmed `admin.discounts.index`, `admin.discounts.create`, and `admin.discounts.edit` Livewire routes.
+- 2026-05-04: `npm run build` passed after the discount admin Blade/sidebar changes.
+- 2026-05-04: `php artisan test --compact` passed after the admin discount-management changes: 142 tests, 700 assertions.
+- 2026-05-04: `php artisan migrate:fresh --seed --no-interaction` passed after browser verification to restore the local SQLite database to seeded fixtures.
+- 2026-05-04: `mcp__laravel_boost__.get_absolute_url(path: "/admin/discounts")` resolved `http://shop.test/admin/discounts` before browser verification.
+- 2026-05-04: Playwright MCP verified `http://shop.test/admin/discounts` renders seeded discounts, search filters to a created discount, `/admin/discounts/create` saves a browser-created discount through Livewire, and `/admin/discounts/{discount}/edit` renders the saved rule controls; current Playwright console checks reported no errors after adding persistent admin/store middleware to Livewire action requests.
@@
 - Customer account order list/detail routes use the `customer` guard and reload orders through explicit store/customer constraints.
 - The cart REST API exposes `cart_version` as the public optimistic concurrency field while the service layer keeps its `expectedVersion` argument; `expected_version` remains accepted as a compatibility alias in API requests.
 - Cart page discount codes are validated with `DiscountService`, saved in session, and applied to the checkout when the customer proceeds.
+- Admin discount forms persist minimum purchase, product eligibility, collection eligibility, and one-per-customer flags in the existing `discounts.rules_json` keys consumed by `DiscountService`.
 - `orders.checkout_id` is intentionally added beyond the original schema table to enforce idempotent checkout completion without duplicate orders.
@@
 - Admin dashboard sales and top-product metrics are derived from paid or partially refunded orders; visitor counts remain zero until the analytics event tables are implemented.
 - Customer addresses are scoped through the locked customer id because `customer_addresses` intentionally belongs to customers and has no direct `store_id` column.
+- Admin/store Livewire route middleware is registered with Livewire persistent middleware so component POST requests keep `current_store` binding and store-role checks after the initial full-page route load.
@@
-- Discount and theme/page/navigation admin management UI is still missing even though the relevant data layer, seeders, services, and storefront/checkout consumption exist.
+- Theme/page/navigation/settings admin management UI is still missing even though the relevant data layer, seeders, services, and storefront consumption exist.
@@
-Not complete. Phase 1 foundation, Phase 2 catalog data/UI surfaces, Phase 3 storefront theme/content/navigation data, the Phase 4 cart/checkout/pricing backend foundation, cart/checkout storefront UI through order completion, cart-page estimates, cart/checkout REST APIs, Phase 5 order/payment backend foundation, Phase 5 refund/fulfillment services, customer order views, admin dashboard/order/customer management, and order API surfaces are implemented, with known auth/token, media UI, discount/content/settings admin UI, search/analytics/app/webhook API, browser-test, and database CHECK constraint gaps tracked above.
+Not complete. Phase 1 foundation, Phase 2 catalog data/UI surfaces, Phase 3 storefront theme/content/navigation data, the Phase 4 cart/checkout/pricing backend foundation, cart/checkout storefront UI through order completion, cart-page estimates, cart/checkout REST APIs, Phase 5 order/payment backend foundation, Phase 5 refund/fulfillment services, customer order views, admin dashboard/order/customer/discount management, and order API surfaces are implemented, with known auth/token, media UI, content/settings admin UI, search/analytics/app/webhook API, browser-test, and database CHECK constraint gaps tracked above.
*** End Patch


unified_diff:
@@ -171,2 +171,12 @@
 - 2026-05-04: Playwright MCP verified `http://shop.test/admin/customers` renders the customer table, seeded customer detail renders at `/admin/customers/1`, and the address modal creates a default address; current Playwright console checks reported no warnings/errors.
+- 2026-05-04: `mcp__laravel_boost__.search_docs` consulted Livewire 4 full-page/forms/security/testing docs, Flux UI radio/checkbox/input/select/button/badge/table docs, Laravel validation docs, and Pest docs before the admin discount-management changes.
+- 2026-05-04: `php artisan make:livewire Admin/Discounts/Index --class --no-interaction`, `php artisan make:livewire Admin/Discounts/Form --class --no-interaction`, and `php artisan make:test --pest Admin/DiscountManagementTest --no-interaction` created the admin discount slice files.
+- 2026-05-04: `vendor/bin/pint --dirty --format agent` passed after the admin discount-management changes.
+- 2026-05-04: `php artisan test --compact tests/Feature/Admin/DiscountManagementTest.php` passed: 5 tests, 33 assertions.
+- 2026-05-04: `php artisan route:list | rg "admin/discounts|admin\\.discounts"` confirmed `admin.discounts.index`, `admin.discounts.create`, and `admin.discounts.edit` Livewire routes.
+- 2026-05-04: `npm run build` passed after the discount admin Blade/sidebar changes.
+- 2026-05-04: `php artisan test --compact` passed after the admin discount-management changes: 142 tests, 700 assertions.
+- 2026-05-04: `php artisan migrate:fresh --seed --no-interaction` passed after browser verification to restore the local SQLite database to seeded fixtures.
+- 2026-05-04: `mcp__laravel_boost__.get_absolute_url(path: "/admin/discounts")` resolved `http://shop.test/admin/discounts` before browser verification.
+- 2026-05-04: Playwright MCP verified `http://shop.test/admin/discounts` renders seeded discounts, search filters to a created discount, `/admin/discounts/create` saves a browser-created discount through Livewire, and `/admin/discounts/{discount}/edit` renders the saved rule controls; current Playwright console checks reported no errors after adding persistent admin/store middleware to Livewire action requests.

@@ -192,2 +202,3 @@
 - Cart page discount codes are validated with `DiscountService`, saved in session, and applied to the checkout when the customer proceeds.
+- Admin discount forms persist minimum purchase, product eligibility, collection eligibility, and one-per-customer flags in the existing `discounts.rules_json` keys consumed by `DiscountService`.
 - `orders.checkout_id` is intentionally added beyond the original schema table to enforce idempotent checkout completion without duplicate orders.
@@ -202,2 +213,3 @@
 - Customer addresses are scoped through the locked customer id because `customer_addresses` intentionally belongs to customers and has no direct `store_id` column.
+- Admin/store Livewire route middleware is registered with Livewire persistent middleware so component POST requests keep `current_store` binding and store-role checks after the initial full-page route load.

@@ -212,3 +224,3 @@
 - Product options can be displayed and edited as text in the admin form, but full option matrix generation and option-value reassignment UI are not complete.
-- Discount and theme/page/navigation admin management UI is still missing even though the relevant data layer, seeders, services, and storefront/checkout consumption exist.
+- Theme/page/navigation/settings admin management UI is still missing even though the relevant data layer, seeders, services, and storefront consumption exist.
 - Storefront search/suggest, analytics event capture, app/webhook APIs, and broader admin REST endpoints outside order management are still missing.
@@ -220,2 +232,2 @@

-Not complete. Phase 1 foundation, Phase 2 catalog data/UI surfaces, Phase 3 storefront theme/content/navigation data, the Phase 4 cart/checkout/pricing backend foundation, cart/checkout storefront UI through order completion, cart-page estimates, cart/checkout REST APIs, Phase 5 order/payment backend foundation, Phase 5 refund/fulfillment services, customer order views, admin dashboard/order/customer management, and order API surfaces are implemented, with known auth/token, media UI, discount/content/settings admin UI, search/analytics/app/webhook API, browser-test, and database CHECK constraint gaps tracked above.
+Not complete. Phase 1 foundation, Phase 2 catalog data/UI surfaces, Phase 3 storefront theme/content/navigation data, the Phase 4 cart/checkout/pricing backend foundation, cart/checkout storefront UI through order completion, cart-page estimates, cart/checkout REST APIs, Phase 5 order/payment backend foundation, Phase 5 refund/fulfillment services, customer order views, admin dashboard/order/customer/discount management, and order API surfaces are implemented, with known auth/token, media UI, content/settings admin UI, search/analytics/app/webhook API, browser-test, and database CHECK constraint gaps tracked above.


output: {"output":"Success. Updated the following files:\nM specs/progress.md\n","metadata":{"exit_code":0,"duration_seconds":0.0}}


cmd: rg "Discount|discount|Active slice|admin discount|persistent middleware|Completion Summary|Open Issues" specs/progress.md -n


command: rg "Discount|discount|Active slice|admin discount|persistent middleware|Completion Summary|Open Issues" specs/progress.md -n

type: search

cmd: rg 'Discount|discount|Active slice|admin discount|persistent middleware|Completion Summary|Open Issues' specs/progress.md -n

query: Discount|discount|Active slice|admin discount|persistent middleware|Completion Summary|Open Issues

aggregated_output:
10:- Active slice: Phase 6 - admin content/settings/theme/navigation surfaces
19:4. Cart/checkout/pricing: cart API/UI, discount, shipping, tax, checkout state machine, and tests.
30:| Routes/API | `specs/02-API-ROUTES.md` | partial | Phase 1 auth routes plus catalog/cart/order/customer/discount UI routes exist: `/`, `/collections`, `/collections/{handle}`, `/products/{handle}`, `/cart`, `/checkout`, `/checkout/confirmation/{order}`, `/search`, `/pages/{handle}`, `/account`, `/account/orders/{order}`, `/admin/products`, `/admin/products/create`, `/admin/products/{product}/edit`, `/admin/collections`, `/admin/collections/create`, `/admin/collections/{collection}/edit`, `/admin/inventory`, `/admin/orders`, `/admin/orders/{order}`, `/admin/customers`, `/admin/customers/{customer}`, `/admin/discounts`, `/admin/discounts/create`, `/admin/discounts/{discount}/edit`. Storefront REST API now includes cart line CRUD, checkout address/shipping/discount/payment-method selection, checkout payment completion, and token-gated order lookup under `/api/storefront/v1`. Admin REST API now includes store-scoped order list/detail, fulfillment creation, and refund creation under `/api/admin/v1/stores/{store}`. Storefront search/suggest, analytics, app/webhook APIs, and broader admin REST surfaces are still missing. |
31:| Admin UI | `specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md` | partial | Flux/Livewire admin catalog and operations shell now includes dashboard KPI/date-range reporting, orders-over-time bars, top-product summaries, funnel counters, product index/form, collection index/form, inventory list, order index/detail, order search/status filters, bank-transfer payment confirmation, refund creation, fulfillment creation, shipment status transitions, customer index/detail, customer order history, customer address create/edit/delete/default actions, order-to-customer links, discount index/search/status filters, discount create/edit form, value/minimum/usage/date/status controls, and product/collection eligibility assignment with auth protection and store scoping. Content/settings admin pages are still missing. |
32:| Storefront UI | `specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md` | partial | Storefront layout, home, collections index/detail, product detail, search, breadcrumbs, price display, product cards, DB-backed pages, seeded navigation menus, cached theme settings, product add-to-cart persistence, cart drawer, cart page with discount and shipping estimates, checkout address/shipping/discount/payment-selection/order-submission UI, order confirmation, and customer order list/detail views render seeded and runtime data. |
33:| Business logic | `specs/05-BUSINESS-LOGIC.md` | partial | `ResolveStore`, `BelongsToStore`, `StoreScope`, role checks, customer guard provider, catalog product lifecycle transitions, SKU uniqueness, variant matrix rebuilding, inventory reserve/release/commit/restock, automatic variant inventory, variant option mapping, media resize/cleanup job, `CartService`, `DiscountService`, `ShippingCalculator`, `TaxCalculator`, `PricingEngine`, checkout transitions through completion, checkout expiration, abandoned cart cleanup, session cart lookup, cart discount handoff to checkout, customer login cart merge, product add-to-cart mutations, `PaymentService`, mock PSP, idempotent order creation, checkout UI/API order submission, session/customer/token-gated order confirmation and lookup, customer order-history scoping, admin dashboard order aggregates, admin customer address management, admin discount rule management, admin order UI/API action orchestration, `RefundService`, `FulfillmentService`, bank-transfer payment confirmation, and unpaid bank-transfer cancellation are implemented. |
35:| Seed/test data | `specs/07-SEEDERS-AND-TEST-DATA.md` | partial | Seeders create Acme Fashion and Acme Electronics stores/domains/settings/admin access, 6 collections, 25 products, 127 variants, 127 inventory rows, 206 variant option pivots, 2 themes, 6 theme files, 2 theme settings rows, 6 pages, 4 navigation menus, 17 navigation items, 2 tax settings rows, 2 shipping zones, 6 shipping rates, 6 discounts, and no product media/runtime carts. Order/payment seed data is still missing. |
36:| Browser E2E plan | `specs/08-PLAYWRIGHT-E2E-PLAN.md` | partial | Manual Playwright MCP smoke coverage has verified storefront catalog browsing, product detail, add-to-cart, cart drawer/page, checkout through order completion, order confirmation, customer order list/detail, search, DB-backed content pages, seeded navigation, admin dashboard on desktop/mobile, admin product/collection/inventory/order/customer/discount pages, admin customer address creation, admin discount creation/editing/filtering, admin fulfillment creation/shipping/delivery, and auth flows without console warnings/errors on successful pages. Automated browser tests are still missing. |
37:| Roadmap phases | `specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md` | in progress | Phase 1 foundation, Phase 2 catalog data/UI, Phase 3 t…263 chars truncated…end foundation, Phase 5 refund/fulfillment services, Phase 5 storefront order completion/customer order surfaces, Phase 5 admin order management, Phase 5 order API surfaces, Phase 6 admin dashboard, Phase 6 admin customer management, and Phase 6 admin discount management are implemented. Phase 6 content/settings/theme/navigation admin surfaces are next. |
78:- 2026-05-03: Phase 4 explorer QA mapped the cart, checkout, discount, shipping, tax, pricing, and cleanup-job boundary; order creation/payment capture were kept for Phase 5 because order/payment tables are not implemented yet.
80:- 2026-05-03: Boost schema summary confirmed Phase 4 tables: carts, cart_lines, checkouts, shipping_zones, shipping_rates, tax_settings, discounts. Boost query counts after fresh seed: carts 0, cart_lines 0, checkouts 0, shipping_zones 2, shipping_rates 6, tax_settings 2, discounts 6.
92:- 2026-05-03: Playwright MCP verified `http://shop.test/products/classic-cotton-t-shirt` add-to-cart, `http://shop.test/cart`, and `http://shop.test/checkout` render and progress through shipping, discount, and reserve-items payment selection with Livewire update requests returning 200 and no new console warnings/errors. Missing favicon links were fixed with `public/favicon.svg`.
94:- 2026-05-03: `php artisan route:list --path=api/storefront/v1` confirmed 12 storefront API routes for carts, cart lines, checkouts, checkout address, shipping method, discount apply/remove, and payment method selection.
103:- 2026-05-04: Playwright MCP verified `http://shop.test/products/classic-cotton-t-shirt` add-to-cart, `http://shop.test/cart` discount application and shipping rates, and checkout handoff with discounted totals at `http://shop.test/checkout`; Livewire requests returned 200 and browser console had no warnings/errors.
172:- 2026-05-04: `mcp__laravel_boost__.search_docs` consulted Livewire 4 full-page/forms/security/testing docs, Flux UI radio/checkbox/input/select/button/badge/table docs, Laravel validation docs, and Pest docs before the admin discount-management changes.
173:- 2026-05-04: `php artisan make:livewire Admin/Discounts/Index --class --no-interaction`, `php artisan make:livewire Admin/Discounts/Form --class --no-interaction`, and `php artisan make:test --pest Admin/DiscountManagementTest --no-interaction` created the admin discount slice files.
174:- 2026-05-04: `vendor/bin/pint --dirty --format agent` passed after the admin discount-management changes.
175:- 2026-05-04: `php artisan test --compact tests/Feature/Admin/DiscountManagementTest.php` passed: 5 tests, 33 assertions.
176:- 2026-05-04: `php artisan route:list | rg "admin/discounts|admin\\.discounts"` confirmed `admin.discounts.index`, `admin.discounts.create`, and `admin.discounts.edit` Livewire routes.
177:- 2026-05-04: `npm run build` passed after the discount admin Blade/sidebar changes.
178:- 2026-05-04: `php artisan test --compact` passed after the admin discount-management changes: 142 tests, 700 assertions.
180:- 2026-05-04: `mcp__laravel_boost__.get_absolute_url(path: "/admin/discounts")` resolved `http://shop.test/admin/discounts` before browser verification.
181:- 2026-05-04: Playwright MCP verified `http://shop.test/admin/discounts` renders seeded discounts, search filters to a created discount, `/admin/discounts/create` saves a browser-created discount through Livewire, and `/admin/discounts/{discount}/edit` renders the saved rule controls; current Playwright console checks reported no errors after adding persistent admin/store middleware to Livewire action requests.
196:- Cart, checkout, and pricing runtime records are not seeded; only deterministic tax, shipping, and discount configuration is seeded. Runtime carts/checkouts are created by services and tests.
202:- Cart page discount codes are validated with `DiscountService`, saved in session, and applied to the checkout when the customer proceeds.
203:- Admin discount forms persist minimum purchase, product eligibility, collection eligibility, and one-per-customer flags in the existing `discounts.rules_json` keys consumed by `DiscountService`.
214:- Admin/store Livewire route middleware is registered with Livewire persistent middleware so component POST requests keep `current_store` binding and store-role checks after the initial full-page route load.
216:## Open Issues
231:## Completion Summary
233:Not complete. Phase 1 foundation, Phase 2 catalog data/UI surfaces, Phase 3 storefront theme/content/navigation data, the Phase 4 cart/checkout/pricing backend foundation, cart/checkout storefront UI through order completion, cart-page estimates, cart/checkout REST APIs, Phase 5 order/payment backend foundation, Phase 5 refund/fulfillment services, customer order views, admin dashboard/order/customer/discount management, and order API surfaces are implemented, with known auth/token, media UI, content/settings admin UI, search/analytics/app/webhook API, browser-test, and database CHECK constraint gaps tracked above.


command:
/bin/zsh
-lc
git diff --stat

type: unknown

cmd: git diff --stat

aggregated_output:
 app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php          | 12 ++++++++++++
 resources/views/layouts/app/sidebar.blade.php |  4 ++++
 routes/web.php                                |  5 +++++
 specs/progress.md                             | 28 +++++++++++++++++++--------
 4 files changed, 41 insertions(+), 8 deletions(-)


command:
/bin/zsh
-lc
git status --short

cmd: git status --short

aggregated_output:
 M app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php
 M resources/views/layouts/app/sidebar.blade.php
 M routes/web.php
 M specs/progress.md
?? app/Livewire/Admin/Discounts/
?? resources/views/livewire/admin/discounts/
?? tests/Feature/Admin/DiscountManagementTest.php


output:
Chunk ID: 3e09c5
Wall time: 0.0000 seconds
Process exited with code 0
Original token count: 2566
Output:
10:- Active slice: Phase 6 - admin content/settings/theme/navigation surfaces
19:4. Cart/checkout/pricing: cart API/UI, discount, shipping, tax, checkout state machine, and tests.
30:| Routes/API | `specs/02-API-ROUTES.md` | partial | Phase 1 auth routes plus catalog/cart/order/customer/discount UI routes exist: `/`, `/collections`, `/collections/{handle}`, `/products/{handle}`, `/cart`, `/checkout`, `/checkout/confirmation/{order}`, `/search`, `/pages/{handle}`, `/account`, `/account/orders/{order}`, `/admin/products`, `/admin/products/create`, `/admin/products/{product}/edit`, `/admin/collections`, `/admin/collections/create`, `/admin/collections/{collection}/edit`, `/admin/inventory`, `/admin/orders`, `/admin/orders/{order}`, `/admin/customers`, `/admin/customers/{customer}`, `/admin/discounts`, `/admin/discounts/create`, `/admin/discounts/{discount}/edit`. Storefront REST API now includes cart line CRUD, checkout address/shipping/discount/payment-method selection, checkout payment completion, and token-gated order lookup under `/api/storefront/v1`. Admin REST API now includes store-scoped order list/detail, fulfillment creation, and refund creation under `/api/admin/v1/stores/{store}`. Storefront search/suggest, analytics, app/webhook APIs, and broader admin REST surfaces are still missing. |
31:| Admin UI | `specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md` | partial | Flux/Livewire admin catalog and operations shell now includes dashboard KPI/date-range reporting, orders-over-time bars, top-product summaries, funnel counters, product index/form, collection index/form, inventory list, order index/detail, order search/status filters, bank-transfer payment confirmation, refund creation, fulfillment creation, shipment status transitions, customer index/detail, customer order history, customer address create/edit/delete/default actions, order-to-customer links, discount index/search/status filters, discount create/edit form, value/minimum/usage/date/status controls, and product/collection eligibility assignment with auth protection and store scoping. Content/settings admin pages are still missing. |
32:| Storefront UI | `specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md` | partial | Storefront layout, home, collections index/detail, product detail, search, breadcrumbs, price display, product cards, DB-backed pages, seeded navigation menus, cached theme settings, product add-to-cart persistence, cart drawer, cart page with discount and shipping estimates, checkout address/shipping/discount/payment-selection/order-submission UI, order confirmation, and customer order list/detail views render seeded and runtime data. |
33:| Business logic | `specs/05-BUSINESS-LOGIC.md` | partial | `ResolveStore`, `BelongsToStore`, `StoreScope`, role checks, customer guard provider, catalog product lifecycle transitions, SKU uniqueness, variant matrix rebuilding, inventory reserve/release/commit/restock, automatic variant inventory, variant option mapping, media resize/cleanup job, `CartService`, `DiscountService`, `ShippingCalculator`, `TaxCalculator`, `PricingEngine`, checkout transitions through completion, checkout expiration, abandoned cart cleanup, session cart lookup, cart discount handoff to checkout, customer login cart merge, product add-to-cart mutations, `PaymentService`, mock PSP, idempotent order creation, checkout UI/API order submission, session/customer/token-gated order confirmation and lookup, customer order-history scoping, admin dashboard order aggregates, admin customer address management, admin discount rule management, admin order UI/API action orchestration, `RefundService`, `FulfillmentService`, bank-transfer payment confirmation, and unpaid bank-transfer cancellation are implemented. |
35:| Seed/test data | `specs/07-SEEDERS-AND-TEST-DATA.md` | partial | Seeders create Acme Fashion and Acme Electronics stores/domains/settings/admin access, 6 collections, 25 products, 127 variants, 127 inventory rows, 206 variant option pivots, 2 themes, 6 theme files, 2 theme settings rows, 6 pages, 4 navigation menus, 17 navigation items, 2 tax settings rows, 2 shipping zones, 6 shipping rates, 6 discounts, and no product media/runtime carts. Order/payment seed data is still missing. |
36:| Browser E2E plan | `specs/08-PLAYWRIGHT-E2E-PLAN.md` | partial | Manual Playwright MCP smoke coverage has verified storefront catalog browsing, product detail, add-to-cart, cart drawer/page, checkout through order completion, order confirmation, customer order list/detail, search, DB-backed content pages, seeded navigation, admin dashboard on desktop/mobile, admin product/collection/inventory/order/customer/discount pages, admin customer address creation, admin discount creation/editing/filtering, admin fulfillment creation/shipping/delivery, and auth flows without console warnings/errors on successful pages. Automated browser tests are still missing. |
37:| Roadmap phases | `specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md` | in progress | Phase 1 foundation, Phase 2 catalog data/UI, Phase 3 theme/content/navigation data with storefront consumption, Phase 4 cart/checkout/pricing backend foundation, Phase 4 storefront cart/checkout UI through `payment_selected`, the Phase 4 cart/checkout REST API surface, cart-page estimates, Phase 5 order/payment backend foundation, Phase 5 refund/fulfillment services, Phase 5 storefront order completion/customer order surfaces, Phase 5 admin order management, Phase 5 order API surfaces, Phase 6 admin dashboard, Phase 6 admin customer management, and Phase 6 admin discount management are implemented. Phase 6 content/settings/theme/navigation admin surfaces are next. |
78:- 2026-05-03: Phase 4 explorer QA mapped the cart, checkout, discount, shipping, tax, pricing, and cleanup-job boundary; order creation/payment capture were kept for Phase 5 because order/payment tables are not implemented yet.
80:- 2026-05-03: Boost schema summary confirmed Phase 4 tables: carts, cart_lines, checkouts, shipping_zones, shipping_rates, tax_settings, discounts. Boost query counts after fresh seed: carts 0, cart_lines 0, checkouts 0, shipping_zones 2, shipping_rates 6, tax_settings 2, discounts 6.
92:- 2026-05-03: Playwright MCP verified `http://shop.test/products/classic-cotton-t-shirt` add-to-cart, `http://shop.test/cart`, and `http://shop.test/checkout` render and progress through shipping, discount, and reserve-items payment selection with Livewire update requests returning 200 and no new console warnings/errors. Missing favicon links were fixed with `public/favicon.svg`.
94:- 2026-05-03: `php artisan route:list --path=api/storefront/v1` confirmed 12 storefront API routes for carts, cart lines, checkouts, checkout address, shipping method, discount apply/remove, and payment method selection.
103:- 2026-05-04: Playwright MCP verified `http://shop.test/products/classic-cotton-t-shirt` add-to-cart, `http://shop.test/cart` discount application and shipping rates, and checkout handoff with discounted totals at `http://shop.test/checkout`; Livewire requests returned 200 and browser console had no warnings/errors.
172:- 2026-05-04: `mcp__laravel_boost__.search_docs` consulted Livewire 4 full-page/forms/security/testing docs, Flux UI radio/checkbox/input/select/button/badge/table docs, Laravel validation docs, and Pest docs before the admin discount-management changes.
173:- 2026-05-04: `php artisan make:livewire Admin/Discounts/Index --class --no-interaction`, `php artisan make:livewire Admin/Discounts/Form --class --no-interaction`, and `php artisan make:test --pest Admin/DiscountManagementTest --no-interaction` created the admin discount slice files.
174:- 2026-05-04: `vendor/bin/pint --dirty --format agent` passed after the admin discount-management changes.
175:- 2026-05-04: `php artisan test --compact tests/Feature/Admin/DiscountManagementTest.php` passed: 5 tests, 33 assertions.
176:- 2026-05-04: `php artisan route:list | rg "admin/discounts|admin\\.discounts"` confirmed `admin.discounts.index`, `admin.discounts.create`, and `admin.discounts.edit` Livewire routes.
177:- 2026-05-04: `npm run build` passed after the discount admin Blade/sidebar changes.
178:- 2026-05-04: `php artisan test --compact` passed after the admin discount-management changes: 142 tests, 700 assertions.
180:- 2026-05-04: `mcp__laravel_boost__.get_absolute_url(path: "/admin/discounts")` resolved `http://shop.test/admin/discounts` before browser verification.
181:- 2026-05-04: Playwright MCP verified `http://shop.test/admin/discounts` renders seeded discounts, search filters to a created discount, `/admin/discounts/create` saves a browser-created discount through Livewire, and `/admin/discounts/{discount}/edit` renders the saved rule controls; current Playwright console checks reported no errors after adding persistent admin/store middleware to Livewire action requests.
196:- Cart, checkout, and pricing runtime records are not seeded; only deterministic tax, shipping, and discount configuration is seeded. Runtime carts/checkouts are created by services and tests.
202:- Cart page discount codes are validated with `DiscountService`, saved in session, and applied to the checkout when the customer proceeds.
203:- Admin discount forms persist minimum purchase, product eligibility, collection eligibility, and one-per-customer flags in the existing `discounts.rules_json` keys consumed by `DiscountService`.
214:- Admin/store Livewire route middleware is registered with Livewire persistent middleware so component POST requests keep `current_store` binding and store-role checks after the initial full-page route load.
216:## Open Issues
231:## Completion Summary
233:Not complete. Phase 1 foundation, Phase 2 catalog data/UI surfaces, Phase 3 storefront theme/content/navigation data, the Phase 4 cart/checkout/pricing backend foundation, cart/checkout storefront UI through order completion, cart-page estimates, cart/checkout REST APIs, Phase 5 order/payment backend foundation, Phase 5 refund/fulfillment services, customer order views, admin dashboard/order/customer/discount management, and order API surfaces are implemented, with known auth/token, media UI, content/settings admin UI, search/analytics/app/webhook API, browser-test, and database CHECK constraint gaps tracked above.


output:
Chunk ID: 2c345c
Wall time: 0.0000 seconds
Process exited with code 0
Original token count: 64
Output:
 M app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php
 M resources/views/layouts/app/sidebar.blade.php
 M routes/web.php
 M specs/progress.md
?? app/Livewire/Admin/Discounts/
?? resources/views/livewire/admin/discounts/
?? tests/Feature/Admin/DiscountManagementTest.php


output:
Chunk ID: f40e7c
Wall time: 0.0000 seconds
Process exited with code 0
Original token count: 78
Output:
 app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php          | 12 ++++++++++++
 resources/views/layouts/app/sidebar.blade.php |  4 ++++
 routes/web.php                                |  5 +++++
 specs/progress.md                             | 28 +++++++++++++++++++--------
 4 files changed, 41 insertions(+), 8 deletions(-)


command:
/bin/zsh
-lc
git diff --check

cmd: git diff --check


output:
Chunk ID: 66ff36
Wall time: 0.0000 seconds
Process exited with code 0
Original token count: 0
Output:


message: The local checks are clean. Per the persistent goal’s QA loop, I’m sending the uncommitted discount slice to independent reviewers now: one focused on spec coverage and one on Laravel/Livewire correctness.

phase: commentary


type: message

role: assistant

text: The local checks are clean. Per the persistent goal’s QA loop, I’m sending the uncommitted discount slice to independent reviewers now: one focused on spec coverage and one on Laravel/Livewire correctness.


agent_type: explorer

message: Independent QA analyst task for the current uncommitted slice in /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop. Review the admin discount-management changes against specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md, specs/05-BUSINESS-LOGIC.md, specs/08-PLAYWRIGHT-E2E-PLAN.md, and specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md. Do not edit files. Focus on missing requirements, acceptance gaps, or high-risk behavior. Return findings ordered by severity with exact file/line references where possible, plus any test or browser coverage gaps.


message: Independent Laravel/Livewire code review for the current uncommitted admin discount-management slice in /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop. Do not edit files. Review App\Livewire\Admin\Discounts\Index, Form, the discount Blade views, routes/sidebar changes, AppServiceProvider Livewire persistent middleware, and tests. Look for bugs, security/authorization issues, Livewire lifecycle problems, store-scoping leaks, validation mistakes, query issues, and missing tests. Return only actionable findings, ordered by severity, with file/line references.


output: Full-history forked agents inherit the parent agent type, model, and reasoning effort; omit agent_type, model, and reasoning_effort, or spawn without a full-history fork.


output: Full-history forked agents inherit the parent agent type, model, and reasoning effort; omit agent_type, model, and reasoning_effort, or spawn without a full-history fork.


message: Independent QA analyst task in /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop. Review the current uncommitted admin discount-management slice against specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md, specs/05-BUSINESS-LOGIC.md, specs/08-PLAYWRIGHT-E2E-PLAN.md, and specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md. Do not edit files. Focus on missing requirements, acceptance gaps, or high-risk behavior. Return findings ordered by severity with exact file/line references where possible, plus any test or browser coverage gaps. Relevant changed files include app/Livewire/Admin/Discounts/*, resources/views/livewire/admin/discounts/*, routes/web.php, resources/views/layouts/app/sidebar.blade.php, app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php, tests/Feature/Admin/DiscountManagementTest.php, and specs/progress.md.


message: Independent Laravel/Livewire code review in /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop for the current uncommitted admin discount-management slice. Do not edit files. Review App\Livewire\Admin\Discounts\Index, Form, the discount Blade views, routes/sidebar changes, AppServiceProvider Livewire persistent middleware, and tests. Look for bugs, security/authorization issues, Livewire lifecycle problems, store-scoping leaks, validation mistakes, query issues, and missing tests. Return only actionable findings, ordered by severity, with file/line references. Relevant changed files include app/Livewire/Admin/Discounts/*, resources/views/livewire/admin/discounts/*, routes/web.php, resources/views/layouts/app/sidebar.blade.php, app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php, tests/Feature/Admin/DiscountManagementTest.php.


prompt: Independent Laravel/Livewire code review in /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop for the current uncommitted admin discount-management slice. Do not edit files. Review App\Livewire\Admin\Discounts\Index, Form, the discount Blade views, routes/sidebar changes, AppServiceProvider Livewire persistent middleware, and tests. Look for bugs, security/authorization issues, Livewire lifecycle problems, store-scoping leaks, validation mistakes, query issues, and missing tests. Return only actionable findings, ordered by severity, with file/line references. Relevant changed files include app/Livewire/Admin/Discounts/*, resources/views/livewire/admin/discounts/*, routes/web.php, resources/views/layouts/app/sidebar.blade.php, app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php, tests/Feature/Admin/DiscountManagementTest.php.

reasoning_effort: medium


prompt: Independent QA analyst task in /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop. Review the current uncommitted admin discount-management slice against specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md, specs/05-BUSINESS-LOGIC.md, specs/08-PLAYWRIGHT-E2E-PLAN.md, and specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md. Do not edit files. Focus on missing requirements, acceptance gaps, or high-risk behavior. Return findings ordered by severity with exact file/line references where possible, plus any test or browser coverage gaps. Relevant changed files include app/Livewire/Admin/Discounts/*, resources/views/livewire/admin/discounts/*, routes/web.php, resources/views/layouts/app/sidebar.blade.php, app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php, tests/Feature/Admin/DiscountManagementTest.php, and specs/progress.md.

reasoning_effort: medium


output: collab spawn failed: agent thread limit reached


output: collab spawn failed: agent thread limit reached


message: The thread already has the maximum number of sub-agent threads from earlier slices. I’m closing stale agents from prior work so this slice can get fresh QA without mixing responsibilities.


text: The thread already has the maximum number of sub-agent threads from earlier slices. I’m closing stale agents from prior work so this slice can get fresh QA without mixing responsibilities.


receiver_agent_nickname: Halley

receiver_agent_role: explorer

completed:
Read-only audit completed. `specs/progress.md` is not present.

**Current Repo State**
The repo is still mostly the Livewire/Fortify starter kit. Evidence: only 3 non-vendor app routes from `php artisan route:list --except-vendor`, no `routes/api.php`, only `App\Models\User`, 4 starter migrations, `UserFactory` only, and Boost reports an empty current SQLite schema. Key refs: [routes/web.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/routes/web.php:1), [bootstrap/app.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/bootstrap/app.php:1), [config/auth.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/config/auth.php:1), [09 roadmap](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md:74).

**Acceptance Checklist By Vertical Slice**

**1. Foundation, Tenancy, Auth**
- [ ] Domain schema exists for organizations, stores, domains, store users/settings, with SQLite PRAGMAs and FK/index strategy from [01 schema](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/01-DATABASE-SCHEMA.md:23) and [01 SQLite config](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/01-DATABASE-SCHEMA.md:1482).
- [ ] `ResolveStore`, `BelongsToStore`, `StoreScope`, `CheckStoreRole`, customer guard/provider, customer password broker, admin/customer rate limits, policies/gates implemented per [05 tenancy](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/05-BUSINESS-LOGIC.md:20) and [06 auth/security](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/06-AUTH-AND-SECURITY.md:7).
- [ ] Evidence: tenancy isolation tests, auth guard tests, policy matrix tests, `php artisan route:list --except-vendor`, and fresh migrate/seed.

**2. Catalog, Inventory, Media**
- [ ] Product/options/variants/inventory/collections/media tables, models, factories, enums, services, and upload job exist per [09 Phase 2](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md:245).
- [ ] Product lifecycle, SKU uniqueness, variant matrix, inventory reserve/release/commit/restock are transaction-tested per [05 product/inventory](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/05-BUSINESS-LOGIC.md:111).
- [ ] Evidence: Product CRUD, variant matrix, inventory policy, media upload tests.

**3. Storefront And Theme**
- [ ] Theme/pages/navigation schema, active theme settings cache, storefront layout, product/collection/search/page views, cart drawer, SEO, accessibility patterns implemented per [04 storefront](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md:43).
- [ ] Storefront routes match [02 storefront routes](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/02-API-ROUTES.md:146).
- [ ] Evidence: browser smoke, responsive, accessibility, no console/JS errors.

**4. Cart, Checkout, Pricing**
- [ ] Carts, checkouts, discounts, shipping, taxes schema/services/API endpoints implemented per [09 Phase 4](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md:442).
- [ ] Pricing pipeline is integer-only and snapshots totals; checkout state machine enforces transitions and idempotent completion per [05 pricing/checkout](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/05-BUSINESS-LOGIC.md:349).
- [ ] Evidence: cart API 409 version conflict, discount errors, tax/shipping calculations, full checkout browser flow.

**5. Payments, Orders, Fulfillment**
- [ ] Mock PSP, payments, orders, refunds, fulfillments, bank transfer confirmation/cancel, digital auto-fulfillment implemented per [09 Phase 5](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md:599).
- [ ] Inventory behavior differs correctly for card/PayPal vs bank transfer.
- [ ] Evidence: magic card success/decline tests, idempotent order creation, fulfillment guard, refund/restock tests.

**6. Customer Accounts**
- [ ] Store-scoped customer login/register/reset, dashboard, orders, addresses, guest cart linking implemented per [04 account UI](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md:1240) and [06 customer auth](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/06-AUTH-AND-SECURITY.md:120).
- [ ] Evidence: same email can exist across stores; customers cannot access another store/customer’s orders.

**7. Admin Panel**
- [ ] `/admin` shell, sidebar/topbar/store selector, dashboard, products, collections, inventory, orders, customers, discounts, settings, themes, pages, navigation, analytics, search, apps/developers implemented per [03 admin UI](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md:1).
- [ ] Evidence: browser CRUD tests, policy-denied actions per role, destructive action modal coverage.

**8. Search, Analytics, Apps/Webhooks**
- [ ] SQLite FTS5 search, search logging/settings, analytics ingestion/aggregation, apps/webhook delivery/signing/retry/circuit breaker implemented per [05 search/events](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/05-BUSINESS-LOGIC.md:1110) and [09 Phases 8-10](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md:856).
- [ ] Evidence: sanitized FTS queries, tenant-scoped search, webhook HMAC and retry tests, analytics aggregation tests.

**9. Seed And Full Verification**
- [ ] Deterministic seeders create Acme Fashion/Electronics, products, orders, discounts, pages, analytics, and credentials per [07 seed data](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/07-SEEDERS-AND-TEST-DATA.md:7).
- [ ] Browser suite structure exists and covers 18 files / 143 tests per [08 E2E plan](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/08-PLAYWRIGHT-E2E-PLAN.md:1).
- [ ] Evidence: `php artisan migrate:fresh --seed`, `php artisan test --compact`, browser tests, `vendor/bin/pint --dirty --format agent`, Vite build.

**Key Risks / Spec Gaps**
- `laravel/sanctum` is required by specs for API tokens, but it is not in `composer.json`; dependency approval or spec adjustment is needed.
- Current starter uses `users.password`; specs require `password_hash` plus `getAuthPassword()`. Fortify actions/tests will need coordinated migration and auth updates.
- E2E counts conflict: top summary says Admin Orders 11 and Checkout 13, later summary says 7 and 8 in [08](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/08-PLAYWRIGHT-E2E-PLAN.md:3118).
- `routes/api.php` is absent, while specs define extensive storefront/admin APIs.
- Current config still defaults sessions to database/unencrypted, not spec file/encrypted/shop session.


receiver_agent_nickname: Euler

completed:
**Critical**
No critical findings found.

**High**
- Media processing is only a status flip, not the required pipeline. [ProcessMediaUpload.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Jobs/ProcessMediaUpload.php:20) only checks that the original exists and sets `ready`; it does not resize thumbnail/small/medium/large images, populate metadata, generate WebP, retry 3 times, or clean up files on media deletion as required by [specs/05-BUSINESS-LOGIC.md](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/05-BUSINESS-LOGIC.md:1490).
  Suggested verification: dispatch the job against a real/fake image and assert expected resized paths, metadata fields, failure status, retry behavior, and deletion cleanup.

- Catalog seed data is materially non-compliant. Spec 07 requires two stores, Acme Fashion 20 products with 107 variants, Acme Electronics 5 products, exact handles/statuses/inventory, and no seeded `ProductMedia` rows. Current seeders create one store in [StoreSeeder.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/database/seeders/StoreSeeder.php:18), simplified products in [ProductSeeder.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/database/seeders/ProductSeeder.php:162), and media rows in [ProductSeeder.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/database/seeders/ProductSeeder.php:139). I verified current DB counts: 20 products, 22 variants, 20 media rows, 1 store.
  Suggested verification: after `php artisan migrate:fresh --seed`, assert the exact product/variant/collection matrix from Spec 07, including Acme Electronics isolation and `product_media` count `0`.

- `ProductService::create()` does not wire variant option selections. It creates options and variants separately in [ProductService.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/ProductService.php:45), but `createVariant()` ignores any selected option values and never inserts `variant_option_values` rows in [ProductService.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/ProductService.php:145). This leaves nested option/variant creation without the required variant matrix mapping.
  Suggested verification: create a product with Size/Color options and explicit variant option selections through `ProductService`, then assert each variant has the expected pivot rows.

- Progress Phase 2 scope includes admin catalog CRUD and storefront browsing, but no catalog routes/components exist. [progress.md](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/progress.md:17) lists those in Catalog scope, while [routes/web.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/routes/web.php:9) only registers home, admin auth/dashboard, and account routes. `php artisan route:list --path=products --except-vendor` and `--path=collections` both returned no matching routes.
  Suggested verification: add route/component smoke tests for admin products/collections and storefront collection/product browsing before claiming Phase 2 UI evidence.

**Medium**
- SQLite enum/check constraints are not actually enforced. The migrations use `$table->enum(...)`, for example [products](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/database/migrations/2026_05_03_213856_create_products_table.php:19), [inventory_items](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/database/migrations/2026_05_03_213901_create_inventory_items_table.php:20), and [product_media](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/database/migrations/2026_05_03_213904_create_product_media_table.php:17), but Boost schema inspection reported empty `check_constraints`. Spec 01 requires `CHECK IN` constraints for these fields.
  Suggested verification: inspect `sqlite_master` table SQL or attempt direct invalid inserts for status/policy/type fields and confirm they fail.

- Variant matrix no-option handling is partial. [VariantMatrixService.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/VariantMatrixService.php:28) returns after `ensureDefaultVariant()`, and [ensureDefaultVariant()](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/VariantMatrixService.php:72) exits if any variant already exists. If options are removed from a product with multiple variants, the service can leave multiple unmapped variants instead of the specified single default variant.
  Suggested verification: create a product with multiple option variants, remove all options/values, rebuild, and assert only one default variant remains or define the intended archival behavior.

- Progress evidence is stale and cannot support Phase 2 acceptance. [progress.md](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/progress.md:9) still says the active slice is Phase 1, and [progress.md](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/progress.md:33) says catalog services are missing despite catalog code/tests existing. Current catalog tests pass: `10 passed, 33 assertions`, but that evidence is not recorded.
  Suggested verification: update progress only after mapping each Phase 2 requirement to concrete tests, schema inspection, seed assertions, and route/browser evidence.


receiver_agent_nickname: Kuhn

completed:
**Findings**
- **High:** `ProductService::create()` and `update()` bypass the product lifecycle rules. Both methods accept `status`/`published_at` directly and never route through `transitionStatus()`, so callers can create an `active` product with no priced variant or update a referenced product back to `draft`. See [ProductService.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/ProductService.php:31), [ProductService.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/ProductService.php:81), and the guarded lifecycle path at [ProductService.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/ProductService.php:103).

- **High:** Tenant isolation is incomplete for child catalog records. `ProductMedia`, `ProductVariant`, `ProductOption`, and `ProductOptionValue` have no `store_id` or global tenant scope, and `ProcessMediaUpload` mutates media by global ID only. Any route/job/action that accepts one of these IDs can cross store boundaries unless every caller manually scopes through the parent product. See [ProductMedia.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Models/ProductMedia.php:11), [ProductVariant.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Models/ProductVariant.php:12), and [ProcessMediaUpload.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Jobs/ProcessMediaUpload.php:16).

- **High:** `inventory_items.store_id` can disagree with the variant’s product store, and nothing enforces the invariant. The migration has independent FKs only, while `InventoryItemFactory` can create a variant for one store and then allow a caller to override `store_id` to another. That makes store-scoped inventory rows capable of pointing at another tenant’s variant. See [create_inventory_items_table.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/database/migrations/2026_05_03_213901_create_inventory_items_table.php:16) and [InventoryItemFactory.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/database/factories/InventoryItemFactory.php:23).

- **Medium:** `ProcessMediaUpload` is effectively a status flip, not media processing. It does not verify the file is an image/video of the expected type, does not resize to thumbnail/medium/large, and does not update dimensions/output paths. A non-image file at `storage_key` can become `ready`. See [ProcessMediaUpload.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Jobs/ProcessMediaUpload.php:24).

- **Medium:** Seed data does not create the full variant matrix for products with options. Example: `Classic Cotton T-Shirt` defines 4 sizes and 3 colors but seeds only 3 variants, leaving most option combinations unavailable. This weakens storefront/cart/E2E coverage and contradicts the seeded catalog shape. See [ProductSeeder.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/database/seeders/ProductSeeder.php:171) and [ProductSeeder.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/database/seeders/ProductSeeder.php:175).

- **Medium:** Factories can generate invalid or flaky catalog records. `ProductFactory` creates active/published products without variants or inventory by default, while option/value factories default every sibling to `position = 0` despite unique `(parent_id, position)` indexes. See [ProductFactory.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/database/factories/ProductFactory.php:26), [ProductOptionFactory.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/database/factories/ProductOptionFactory.php:20), and [create_product_options_table.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/database/migrations/2026_05_03_213857_create_product_options_table.php:20).

- **Medium:** SKU uniqueness is only checked in one private creation path. Direct `ProductVariant` saves, seeders, future variant update flows, and factory-created variants bypass the store-level SKU collision rule. See [ProductService.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/ProductService.php:145), [ProductService.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/ProductService.php:216), and [ProductVariant.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Models/ProductVariant.php:20).

**Verification**
Ran `php artisan test --compact tests/Feature/Catalog` and `php artisan test --compact`; both passed. No files were edited.


receiver_agent_nickname: Zeno

completed:
Read-only pass complete. No files edited.

**Minimum Checklist**

- Admin catalog routes:
  - `/admin/products`, `/admin/products/create`, `/admin/products/{product}/edit`
  - `/admin/collections`, `/admin/collections/create`, `/admin/collections/{collection}/edit`
  - `/admin/inventory` if Phase 2 claims inventory UI, since it is in the catalog admin spec but lacks a dedicated E2E suite.
  - Admin login/access prerequisite: `/admin/login` and protected catalog redirects.

- Admin catalog components:
  - `App\Livewire\Admin\Products\Index`
  - `App\Livewire\Admin\Products\Form` shared by create/edit
  - `App\Livewire\Admin\Collections\Index`
  - `App\Livewire\Admin\Collections\Form` shared by create/edit
  - `App\Livewire\Admin\Inventory\Index`
  - Admin shell pieces needed for usability: sidebar nav, top bar, breadcrumbs, toast messages.

- Storefront browsing routes:
  - `/`
  - `/collections`
  - `/collections/{handle}`
  - `/products/{handle}`
  - `/search`
  - `/pages/{handle}` because Suite 7 includes the About page and main-nav browsing.

- Storefront browsing components:
  - Storefront layout with header, main navigation, footer, skip link, search trigger.
  - `FeaturedProducts`
  - `CollectionPage`
  - `ProductPage`
  - `SearchResults`
  - `SearchModal`
  - Reusable Blade components: `storefront-product-card`, `storefront-price`, `storefront-badge`, `storefront-breadcrumbs`, `storefront-pagination`, and quantity selector rendering on product pages.

- Required browser coverage before calling it implemented:
  - Smoke tests for catalog/browsing routes: home, collection detail, product detail, collections index, search, about page, and critical-page no-JS-errors batch.
  - Admin auth prerequisite: can log in, protected `/admin/products` redirects when unauthenticated.
  - Admin product tests: list seeded products, create, edit, archive, admin search, status filter, draft visible only in admin and absent from storefront/search.
  - Admin collection tests: list seeded collections, create collection, edit collection.
  - Storefront browsing Suite 7: all 15 tests, including featured products, collection grid, collection-to-product navigation, product variants, compare-at pricing, search success/empty states, draft exclusion, sold-out/backorder messaging, new arrivals, about page, and main navigation.

Key spec anchors: [02 routes](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/02-API-ROUTES.md:31), [admin catalog UI](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md:337), [storefront catalog UI](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md:376), [browser suites](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/08-PLAYWRIGHT-E2E-PLAN.md:1185).


receiver_agent_nickname: Fermat

completed:
Read-only inspection complete. Phase 3 data layer is not implemented yet; existing storefront pages/components are partly scaffolded but still hardcoded.

**Required Checklist**

Migrations:
- `themes`: `store_id`, `name`, `version`, `status`, `published_at`, timestamps, indexes on `store_id`, `store_id/status`
- `theme_files`: `theme_id`, `path`, `storage_key`, `sha256`, `byte_size`, unique `theme_id/path`
- `theme_settings`: primary FK `theme_id`, `settings_json`, `updated_at`
- `pages`: `store_id`, `title`, `handle`, `body_html`, `status`, `published_at`, timestamps, unique `store_id/handle`
- `navigation_menus`: `store_id`, `handle`, `title`, timestamps, unique `store_id/handle`
- `navigation_items`: `menu_id`, `type`, `label`, `url`, `resource_id`, `position`, indexes on `menu_id`, `menu_id/position`

Models:
- `Theme`, `Page`, `NavigationMenu` should use `BelongsToStore` + `HasFactory`
- `ThemeFile`, `ThemeSettings`, `NavigationItem` need parent-based relationships and likely custom current-store scoping if direct querying matters
- Add relationships back onto `Store`: `themes()`, `pages()`, `navigationMenus()`
- `ThemeSettings` should mirror [StoreSettings](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Models/StoreSettings.php): non-incrementing primary key, no `created_at`, JSON cast

Enums:
- `ThemeStatus`: `Draft = 'draft'`, `Published = 'published'`
- `PageStatus`: `Draft`, `Published`, `Archived`
- `NavigationItemType`: `Link`, `Page`, `Collection`, `Product`

Factories:
- One per model, matching existing enum-backed defaults
- Useful states: `ThemeFactory::published()`, `PageFactory::published()/archived()`, navigation item type states

Seeders:
- `ThemeSeeder`: active/published theme per seeded store, files, settings JSON
- `PageSeeder`: at least `about`, likely `faq`, per seeded store
- `NavigationSeeder`: `main-menu`, `footer-menu`, linked to seeded pages/collections/products
- Register them in [DatabaseSeeder](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/database/seeders/DatabaseSeeder.php), after stores/catalog/pages exist in dependency order

Services:
- `ThemeSettingsService`: singleton in [AppServiceProvider](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php), cache per current store/published theme
- `NavigationService`: `buildTree(NavigationMenu $menu): array`, `resolveUrl(NavigationItem $item): string`, cache per store/menu for 5 minutes

Tests:
- Feature test for schema + seeded fixtures, like existing [CatalogFoundationTest](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/tests/Feature/Catalog/CatalogFoundationTest.php)
- Store scoping tests for `Theme`, `Page`, `NavigationMenu`
- Parent-scope tests for `ThemeFile`, `ThemeSettings`, `NavigationItem`
- Service tests for active theme settings cache and navigation URL resolution
- Storefront page test replacing current hardcoded [Pages/Show](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Livewire/Storefront/Pages/Show.php) behavior with DB-backed published pages

**Gotchas / Risks**

- Spec says `NavigationService::buildTree()` supports trees, but `navigation_items` has no `parent_id`; only `position`. True nesting is impossible without adding a parent column or defining a convention.
- Existing route names are `pages.show`, `collections.show`, `products.show`; `resolveUrl()` should use `route(..., absolute: false)` and handles fetched from resource IDs.
- Current [storefront layout](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/layouts/storefront.blade.php) has hardcoded nav/footer links. Phase 3 should swap those to `NavigationService`.
- Roadmap mentions `resources/views/storefront/layouts/app.blade.php`, but current convention is Livewire views under `resources/views/livewire/storefront/*` plus layout `resources/views/layouts/storefront.blade.php`. Follow the current convention unless intentionally reorganizing.
- Existing status naming differs: collections use `active`; Phase 3 pages/themes use `published`. Don’t reuse `CollectionStatus`.
- Policies for `PagePolicy` and `ThemePolicy` already exist but reference `object`; once models exist, consider typing them if aligning policy conventions later.


receiver_agent_nickname: Erdos

completed:
Read-only review completed. I did not edit files or run tests.

**Implementation Checklist**

1. Add Phase 4 schema from [specs/01-DATABASE-SCHEMA.md](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/01-DATABASE-SCHEMA.md:526):
   `carts`, `cart_lines`, `checkouts`, `shipping_zones`, `shipping_rates`, `tax_settings`, `discounts`.
   Use existing migration style, indexes, foreign keys, integer money fields, JSON text columns cast through models.

2. Add enums:
   `CartStatus`, `CheckoutStatus`, `DiscountType`, `DiscountValueType`, `DiscountStatus`, `ShippingRateType`, `TaxMode`.

3. Add models/factories/seeders:
   `Cart`, `CartLine`, `Checkout`, `ShippingZone`, `ShippingRate`, `TaxSettings`, `Discount`.
   Follow current conventions: `casts()` method, `$attributes`, `$fillable`, typed relationships, `HasFactory`, `BelongsToStore` where `store_id` exists.

4. Add `CartService`:
   create cart, session cart lookup, add/update/remove lines, merge guest/customer carts, recalculate line amounts, increment `cart_version` on every mutation.

5. Add discount foundation:
   `DiscountService`, `InvalidDiscountException`, likely `DiscountResult` / `DiscountValidationResult`.
   Implement case-insensitive code lookup, date/status/usage/minimum checks, product/collection applicability, proportional allocation.

6. Add shipping foundation:
   `ShippingCalculator` with zone matching, active rate filtering, flat/weight/price/carrier-stub calculations, digital-only skip, mixed-cart physical weight only.

7. Add tax foundation:
   `TaxCalculator`, `TaxProvider` contract, `ManualTaxProvider`, `StripeTaxProvider` stub, `TaxLine` / tax result objects.
   Implement integer basis-point math, inclusive extraction with `intdiv()`, exclusive tax rounding per line.

8. Add `PricingEngine`:
   deterministic subtotal -> discount -> shipping -> tax -> total pipeline, persist result snapshot to `checkouts.totals_json`.

9. Add `CheckoutService` state machine:
   address, shipping method, payment method selection, inventory reservation, expiry.
   Keep payment/order creation as Phase 5 boundary unless stubbing only what Phase 4 tests require.

10. Add jobs/schedule:
   `ExpireAbandonedCheckouts` and `CleanupAbandonedCarts` in `routes/console.php`.

**Service Edge Cases To Test**

- Cart duplicate variant add increments quantity, does not create duplicate line.
- Cart line price snapshots do not change when variant price changes later.
- Cart mutation with stale `expected_version` returns/conflicts before changing data.
- Guest/customer merge uses max quantity for duplicate variants and abandons guest cart.
- Inactive product, archived variant, wrong-store variant, and insufficient stock are rejected.
- `InventoryPolicy::Continue` allows reservation beyond stock.
- Updating line quantity to zero removes the line.
- Discount codes are matched case-insensitively and scoped per store.
- Discount status/date/usage/min purchase/product restriction failures return stable reason codes.
- Fixed discount never exceeds qualifying subtotal.
- Percentage/fixed allocations handle rounding remainder deterministically.
- Product and collection restrictions are union logic, not intersection.
- Free-shipping discount zeroes shipping but still keeps selected shipping method.
- Shipping zone specificity prefers country+region over country-only; tied zones use lowest id.
- No matching shipping zone blocks checkout for physical carts.
- Digital-only cart skips shipping; mixed cart weights only physical lines.
- Weight/price ranges handle open-ended max and boundary values exactly.
- Tax-exclusive rounds per discounted line, then sums.
- Tax-inclusive extracts tax after discounts using `intdiv()`.
- Tax on shipping is clearly decided and tested because the spec says “plus shipping if taxable” but the schema lacks an explicit shipping-taxable flag.
- Checkout cannot skip invalid state transitions.
- Selecting payment twice does not double-reserve inventory.
- Expiring checkout releases reserved inventory only when it had been reserved.
- Cleanup abandoned carts also handles active checkout reservations for those carts.

**Naming / Convention Risks**

- Spec mismatch: roadmap Step 4.2 lists `CheckoutStatus::PaymentPending`, but business logic/schema use `payment_selected`. Use `PaymentSelected` backed by `payment_selected` to match schema and Section 6.
- `TaxSettings` is plural as a model name. Laravel convention would normally be singular `TaxSetting`, but the roadmap explicitly says `TaxSettings`; choose deliberately and keep relation names consistent.
- `checkouts.shipping_method_id` actually points to a `shipping_rates` row. Consider model relation name `shippingRate()` even if the DB column remains spec-compatible.
- `DiscountService::validate()` conflicts across specs: roadmap says it returns `Discount` and throws `InvalidDiscountException`; business logic says it returns `DiscountValidationResult`. Pick one API before implementation to avoid duplicate patterns.
- Error codes differ in wording: roadmap examples like `expired`, business spec uses `discount_expired`. Prefer the full spec codes for API/UI stability.
- Current `InventoryService` methods accept `InventoryItem`, while checkout pseudocode says commit/reserve variant. Phase 4 services should resolve `$line->variant->inventoryItem` before calling inventory.
- Existing tenant scoping uses `current_store`; service jobs and checkout/order flows may need `withoutGlobalScopes()` or explicit store binding to avoid hidden cross-store bugs.
- Existing tests use Pest `test(...)` with `RefreshDatabase`; new Phase 4 tests should match that style.


output: {"previous_status":{"completed":"Read-only audit completed. `specs/progress.md` is not present.\n\n**Current Repo State**\nThe repo is still mostly the Livewire/Fortify starter kit. Evidence: only 3 non-vendor app routes from `php artisan route:list --except-vendor`, no `routes/api.php`, only `App\\Models\\User`, 4 starter migrations, `UserFactory` only, and Boost reports an empty current SQLite schema. Key refs: [routes/web.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/routes/web.php:1), [bootstrap/app.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/bootstrap/app.php:1), [config/auth.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/config/auth.php:1), [09 roadmap](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md:74).\n\n**Acceptance Checklist By Vertical Slice**\n\n**1. Foundation, Tenancy, Auth**\n- [ ] Domain schema exists for organizations, stores, domains, store users/settings, with SQLite PRAGMAs and FK/index strategy from [01 schema](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/01-DATABASE-SCHEMA.md:23) and [01 SQLite config](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/01-DATABASE-SCHEMA.md:1482).\n- [ ] `ResolveStore`, `BelongsToStore`, `StoreScope`, `CheckStoreRole`, customer guard/provider, customer password broker, admin/customer rate limits, policies/gates implemented per [05 tenancy](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/05-BUSINESS-LOGIC.md:20) and [06 auth/security](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/06-AUTH-AND-SECURITY.md:7).\n- [ ] Evidence: tenancy isolation tests, auth guard tests, policy matrix tests, `php artisan route:list --except-vendor`, and fresh migrate/seed.\n\n**2. Catalog, Inventory, Media**\n- [ ] Product/options/variants/inventory/collections/media tables, models, factories, enums, services, and upload job exist per [09 Phase 2](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md:245).\n- [ ] Product lifecycle, SKU uniqueness, variant matrix, inventory reserve/release/commit/restock are transaction-tested per [05 product/inventory](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/05-BUSINESS-LOGIC.md:111).\n- [ ] Evidence: Product CRUD, variant matrix, inventory policy, media upload tests.\n\n**3. Storefront And Theme**\n- [ ] Theme/pages/navigation schema, active theme settings cache, storefront layout, product/collection/search/page views, cart drawer, SEO, accessibility patterns implemented per [04 storefront](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md:43).\n- [ ] Storefront routes match [02 storefront routes](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/02-API-ROUTES.md:146).\n- [ ] Evidence: browser smoke, responsive, accessibility, no console/JS errors.\n\n**4. Cart, Checkout, Pricing**\n- [ ] Carts, checkouts, discounts, shipping, taxes schema/services/API endpoints implemented per [09 Phase 4](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md:442).\n- [ ] Pricing pipeline is integer-only and snapshots totals; checkout state machine enforces transitions and idempotent completion per [05 pricing/checkout](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/05-BUSINESS-LOGIC.md:349).\n- [ ] Evidence: cart API 409 version conflict, discount errors, tax/shipping calculations, full checkout browser flow.\n\n**5. Payments, Orders, Fulfillment**\n- [ ] Mock PSP, payments, orders, refunds, fulfillments, bank transfer confirmation/cancel, digital auto-fulfillment implemented per [09 Phase 5](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md:599).\n- [ ] Inventory behavior differs correctly for card/PayPal vs bank transfer.\n- [ ] Evidence: magic card success/decline tests, idempotent order creation, fulfillment guard, refund/restock tests.\n\n**6. Customer Accounts**\n- [ ] Store-scoped customer login/register/reset, dashboard, orders, addresses, guest cart linking implemented per [04 account UI](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md:1240) and [06 customer auth](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/06-AUTH-AND-SECURITY.md:120).\n- [ ] Evidence: same email can exist across stores; customers cannot access another store/customer’s orders.\n\n**7. Admin Panel**\n- [ ] `/admin` shell, sidebar/topbar/store selector, dashboard, products, collections, inventory, orders, customers, discounts, settings, themes, pages, navigation, analytics, search, apps/developers implemented per [03 admin UI](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md:1).\n- [ ] Evidence: browser CRUD tests, policy-denied actions per role, destructive action modal coverage.\n\n**8. Search, Analytics, Apps/Webhooks**\n- [ ] SQLite FTS5 search, search logging/settings, analytics ingestion/aggregation, apps/webhook delivery/signing/retry/circuit breaker implemented per [05 search/events](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/05-BUSINESS-LOGIC.md:1110) and [09 Phases 8-10](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md:856).\n- [ ] Evidence: sanitized FTS queries, tenant-scoped search, webhook HMAC and retry tests, analytics aggregation tests.\n\n**9. Seed And Full Verification**\n- [ ] Deterministic seeders create Acme Fashion/Electronics, products, orders, discounts, pages, analytics, and credentials per [07 seed data](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/07-SEEDERS-AND-TEST-DATA.md:7).\n- [ ] Browser suite structure exists and covers 18 files / 143 tests per [08 E2E plan](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/08-PLAYWRIGHT-E2E-PLAN.md:1).\n- [ ] Evidence: `php artisan migrate:fresh --seed`, `php artisan test --compact`, browser tests, `vendor/bin/pint --dirty --format agent`, Vite build.\n\n**Key Risks / Spec Gaps**\n- `laravel/sanctum` is required by specs for API tokens, but it is not in `composer.json`; dependency approval or spec adjustment is needed.\n- Current starter uses `users.password`; specs require `password_hash` plus `getAuthPassword()`. Fortify actions/tests will need coordinated migration and auth updates.\n- E2E counts conflict: top summary says Admin Orders 11 and Checkout 13, later summary says 7 and 8 in [08](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/08-PLAYWRIGHT-E2E-PLAN.md:3118).\n- `routes/api.php` is absent, while specs define extensive storefront/admin APIs.\n- Current config still defaults sessions to database/unencrypted, not spec file/encrypted/shop session."}}


output: {"previous_status":{"completed":"**Critical**\nNo critical findings found.\n\n**High**\n- Media processing is only a status flip, not the required pipeline. [ProcessMediaUpload.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Jobs/ProcessMediaUpload.php:20) only checks that the original exists and sets `ready`; it does not resize thumbnail/small/medium/large images, populate metadata, generate WebP, retry 3 times, or clean up files on media deletion as required by [specs/05-BUSINESS-LOGIC.md](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/05-BUSINESS-LOGIC.md:1490).\n  Suggested verification: dispatch the job against a real/fake image and assert expected resized paths, metadata fields, failure status, retry behavior, and deletion cleanup.\n\n- Catalog seed data is materially non-compliant. Spec 07 requires two stores, Acme Fashion 20 products with 107 variants, Acme Electronics 5 products, exact handles/statuses/inventory, and no seeded `ProductMedia` rows. Current seeders create one store in [StoreSeeder.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/database/seeders/StoreSeeder.php:18), simplified products in [ProductSeeder.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/database/seeders/ProductSeeder.php:162), and media rows in [ProductSeeder.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/database/seeders/ProductSeeder.php:139). I verified current DB counts: 20 products, 22 variants, 20 media rows, 1 store.\n  Suggested verification: after `php artisan migrate:fresh --seed`, assert the exact product/variant/collection matrix from Spec 07, including Acme Electronics isolation and `product_media` count `0`.\n\n- `ProductService::create()` does not wire variant option selections. It creates options and variants separately in [ProductService.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/ProductService.php:45), but `createVariant()` ignores any selected option values and never inserts `variant_option_values` rows in [ProductService.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/ProductService.php:145). This leaves nested option/variant creation without the required variant matrix mapping.\n  Suggested verification: create a product with Size/Color options and explicit variant option selections through `ProductService`, then assert each variant has the expected pivot rows.\n\n- Progress Phase 2 scope includes admin catalog CRUD and storefront browsing, but no catalog routes/components exist. [progress.md](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/progress.md:17) lists those in Catalog scope, while [routes/web.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/routes/web.php:9) only registers home, admin auth/dashboard, and account routes. `php artisan route:list --path=products --except-vendor` and `--path=collections` both returned no matching routes.\n  Suggested verification: add route/component smoke tests for admin products/collections and storefront collection/product browsing before claiming Phase 2 UI evidence.\n\n**Medium**\n- SQLite enum/check constraints are not actually enforced. The migrations use `$table->enum(...)`, for example [products](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/database/migrations/2026_05_03_213856_create_products_table.php:19), [inventory_items](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/database/migrations/2026_05_03_213901_create_inventory_items_table.php:20), and [product_media](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/database/migrations/2026_05_03_213904_create_product_media_table.php:17), but Boost schema inspection reported empty `check_constraints`. Spec 01 requires `CHECK IN` constraints for these fields.\n  Suggested verification: inspect `sqlite_master` table SQL or attempt direct invalid inserts for status/policy/type fields and confirm they fail.\n\n- Variant matrix no-option handling is partial. [VariantMatrixService.php](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/VariantMatrixService.php:28) returns after `ensureDefaultVariant()`, and [ensureDefaultVariant()](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/VariantMatrixService.php:72) exits if any variant already exists. If options are removed from a product with multiple variants, the service can leave multiple unmapped variants instead of the specified single default variant.\n  Suggested verification: create a product with multiple option variants, remove all options/values, rebuild, and assert only one default variant remains or define the intended archival behavior.\n\n- Progress evidence is stale and cannot support Phase 2 acceptance. [progress.md](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/progress.md:9) still says the active slice is Phase 1, and [progress.md](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/progress.md:33) says catalog services are missing despite catalog code/tests existing. Current catalog tests pass: `10 passed, 33 assertions`, but that evidence is not recorded.\n  Suggested verification: update progress only after mapping each Phase 2 requirement to concrete tests, schema inspection, seed assertions, and route/browser evidence."}}