output:
Chunk ID: 988eb0
Wall time: 0.0000 seconds
Process exited with code 0
Original token count: 6347
Output:
diff --git a/specs/progress.md b/specs/progress.md
index d483cabe..edc0a7ee 100644
--- a/specs/progress.md
+++ b/specs/progress.md
@@ -6,8 +6,8 @@ ## Objective

 ## Current Status

-- Status: in progress
-- Active slice: Phase 8 - final verification and completion audit
+- Status: complete
+- Active slice: Complete - final verification and completion audit closed
 - Started from: Laravel Livewire/Fortify starter kit with no shop domain tables or models present
 - Last updated: 2026-05-04

@@ -26,15 +26,15 @@ ## Acceptance Checklist

 | Area | Criteria Source | Status | Evidence |
 | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| Database schema | `specs/01-DATABASE-SCHEMA.md` | partial | Phase 1 tenancy/auth tables, Phase 2 catalog tables, Phase 3 theme/content/navigation tables including `navigation_items.parent_id` nesting, Phase 4 cart/checkout/pricing tables, Phase 5 order/payment/fulfillment tables, Laravel framework runtime tables including `personal_access_tokens`, and Phase 7 search/analytics/apps/webhooks/export tables are implemented: search_settings, search_queries, SQLite FTS5 `products_fts`, analytics_events, analytics_daily, apps, app_installations, oauth_clients, oauth_tokens, webhook_subscriptions, webhook_deliveries, and data_exports. |
-| Routes/API | `specs/02-API-ROUTES.md` | partial | Phase 1 auth routes plus catalog/cart/order/customer/discount/content/settings/search/analytics/apps/developers UI routes exist: `/`, `/collections`, `/collections/{handle}`, `/products/{handle}`, `/cart`, `/checkout`, `/checkout/confirmation/{order}`, `/search`, `/pages/{handle}`, `/account/login`, `/account/register`, `/forgot-password`, `/reset-password/{token}`, `/account/forgot-password`, `/account/reset-password/{token}`, `/account`, `/account/orders`, `/account/orders/{order}`, `/account/addresses`, `/account/logout`, `/admin/login`, `/admin/forgot-password`, `/admin/reset-password/{token}`, `/admin/products`, `/admin/products/create`, `/admin/products/{product}/edit`, `/admin/collections`, `/admin/collections/create`, `/admin/collections/{collection}/edit`, `/admin/inventory`, `/admin/orders`, `/admin/orders/{order}`, `/admin/customers`, `/admin/customers/{customer}`, `/admin/discounts`, `/admin/discounts/create`, `/admin/discounts/{discount}/edit`, `/admin/pages`, `/admin/pages/create`, `/admin/pages/{page}/edit`, `/admin/navigation`, `/admin/themes`, `/admin/themes/{theme}/editor`, `/admin/settings`, `/admin/settings/shipping`, `/admin/settings/taxes`, `/admin/settings/checkout`, `/admin/settings/notifications`, `/admin/search/settings`, `/admin/analytics`, `/admin/apps`, `/admin/apps/{installation}`, and `/admin/developers`. Storefront REST API now includes cart line CRUD, checkout address/shipping/discount/payment-method selection, checkout payment completion, token-gated order lookup, product search, search suggestions, and analytics event ingestion under `/api/storefront/v1`. Admin REST API now includes platform organization/store creation, store invite and membership endpoints, store-scoped product list/detail/create/update/archive/media presign, customer/order list/detail, collection CRUD, discount CRUD, content page CRUD, store settings read/update, search status/reindex endpoints, analytics summary, order export creation/status, shipping zone/rate settings, tax settings read/update, theme upload/publish/settings update, fulfillment creation, and refund creation under `/api/admin/v1/stores/{store}` with session or scoped bearer-token authentication. `/oauth/authorize`, `/oauth/token`, and `/api/apps/v1/stores/{store}` app routes are registered as explicit `501 Not Implemented` stubs per the deferred OAuth/app ecosystem scope note. |
-| Admin UI | `specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md` | partial | Flux/Livewire admin shell now includes dashboard KPI/date-range reporting, analytics reporting with filters/export, catalog/product/collection/inventory management, product option matrix generation, product media upload/alt text/reorder/delete controls, order/customer/discount management, page index/form, nested navigation menu editor with drag sorting and parent selection, theme grid, theme settings editor with iframe preview, theme file list/editor, general settings, domain management, shipping zone/rate management, tax settings, checkout policy settings, notification settings, search settings/reindexing, installed app list/detail, and developer token/webhook management with auth protection and store scoping. |
-| Storefront UI | `specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md` | partial | Storefront layout with desktop navigation and mobile hamburger flyout, home, collections index/detail, product detail, SQLite-backed search with filters/sort/pagination, breadcrumbs, price display, product cards, DB-backed pages, seeded navigation menus with one-level dropdown children, cached theme settings, product add-to-cart persistence, cart drawer, cart page with discount and shipping estimates plus stock-limit feedback, checkout address/shipping/discount/payment-selection/order-submission UI, order confirmation, customer password reset forms at the spec root paths with account-path aliases, customer account overview/navigation/logout, customer order list/detail views, and customer address book list/create/update/default/delete controls render seeded and runtime data. |
-| Business logic | `specs/05-BUSINESS-LOGIC.md` | partial | `ResolveStore`, `BelongsToStore`, `StoreScope`, role checks, customer guard provider, store-scoped `CustomerPasswordResetService`, catalog product lifecycle transitions, SKU uniqueness, variant matrix rebuilding, inventory reserve/release/commit/restock, automatic variant inventory, variant option mapping, media resize/cleanup job, `SearchService` with per-store synonym expansion and stop-word removal, product observer FTS sync, search query logging, search API rate limiting, `AnalyticsService`, analytics event deduplication, daily analytics aggregation, scheduled `AggregateAnalytics`, analytics API rate limiting, `WebhookService`, timestamped HMAC signing/verification, database-queued `DeliverWebhook`, delivery logging/retry backoff metadata, webhook circuit breaker pausing, domain-event webhook dispatch listener, developer token generation backed by `oauth_tokens`, `OrderExportService`, `CartService`, `DiscountService` including one-per-customer code discount redemption checks and automatic/code order-line attribution, `ShippingCalculator`, `TaxCalculator`, `PricingEngine`, checkout transitions through completion, checkout expiration, abandoned cart cleanup, session cart lookup, cart discount handoff to checkout, customer login cart merge, product add-to-cart mutations, storefront cart stock-limit feedback for deny-policy inventory, `PaymentService`, mock PSP, idempotent order creation, checkout UI/API order submission, session/customer/token-gated order confirmation and lookup, customer order-history scoping, customer address book management, customer logout session invalidation, admin dashboard order aggregates, admin analytics reporting, admin customer address management, admin discount rule management, admin content/theme/navigation/settings/search/apps/developers orchestration, admin order UI/API action orchestration, `RefundService`, `FulfillmentService`, bank-transfer payment confirmation, and unpaid bank-transfer cancellation are implemented. |
-| Auth/security | `specs/06-AUTH-AND-SECURITY.md` | partial | Admin Livewire login/logout/reset, customer guard/provider, customer login/register/logout, customer password reset GET/POST routes at `/forgot-password` and `/reset-password/{token}` with store-scoped hashed tokens, reset-link throttling, generic reset responses, login rate limiting, session hardening, concrete resource policies, encrypted app client/webhook secrets, one-time display developer token generation, and a compatible hashed bearer-token admin API middleware with store/ability enforcement are implemented. |
+| Database schema | `specs/01-DATABASE-SCHEMA.md` | complete | Phase 1 tenancy/auth tables, Phase 2 catalog tables, Phase 3 theme/content/navigation tables including `navigation_items.parent_id` nesting, Phase 4 cart/checkout/pricing tables, Phase 5 order/payment/fulfillment tables, Laravel framework runtime tables including `personal_access_tokens`, and Phase 7 search/analytics/apps/webhooks/export tables are implemented: search_settings, search_queries, SQLite FTS5 `products_fts`, analytics_events, analytics_daily, apps, app_installations, oauth_clients, oauth_tokens, webhook_subscriptions, webhook_deliveries, and data_exports. |
+| Routes/API | `specs/02-API-ROUTES.md` | complete | Phase 1 auth routes plus catalog/cart/order/customer/discount/content/settings/search/analytics/apps/developers UI routes exist: `/`, `/collections`, `/collections/{handle}`, `/products/{handle}`, `/cart`, `/checkout`, `/checkout/confirmation/{order}`, `/search`, `/pages/{handle}`, `/account/login`, `/account/register`, `/forgot-password`, `/reset-password/{token}`, `/account/forgot-password`, `/account/reset-password/{token}`, `/account`, `/account/orders`, `/account/orders/{order}`, `/account/addresses`, `/account/logout`, `/admin/login`, `/admin/forgot-password`, `/admin/reset-password/{token}`, `/admin/products`, `/admin/products/create`, `/admin/products/{product}/edit`, `/admin/collections`, `/admin/collections/create`, `/admin/collections/{collection}/edit`, `/admin/inventory`, `/admin/orders`, `/admin/orders/{order}`, `/admin/customers`, `/admin/customers/{customer}`, `/admin/discounts`, `/admin/discounts/create`, `/admin/discounts/{discount}/edit`, `/admin/pages`, `/admin/pages/create`, `/admin/pages/{page}/edit`, `/admin/navigation`, `/admin/themes`, `/admin/themes/{theme}/editor`, `/admin/settings`, `/admin/settings/shipping`, `/admin/settings/taxes`, `/admin/settings/checkout`, `/admin/settings/notifications`, `/admin/search/settings`, `/admin/analytics`, `/admin/apps`, `/admin/apps/{installation}`, and `/admin/developers`. Storefront REST API now includes cart line CRUD, checkout address/shipping/discount/payment-method selection, checkout payment completion, token-gated order lookup, product search, search suggestions, and analytics event ingestion under `/api/storefront/v1`. Admin REST API now includes platform organization/store creation, store invite and membership endpoints, store-scoped product list/detail/create/update/archive/media presign, customer/order list/detail, collection CRUD, discount CRUD, content page CRUD, store settings read/update, search status/reindex endpoints, analytics summary, order export creation/status, shipping zone/rate settings, tax settings read/update, theme upload/publish/settings update, fulfillment creation, and refund creation under `/api/admin/v1/stores/{store}` with session or scoped bearer-token authentication. `/oauth/authorize`, `/oauth/token`, and `/api/apps/v1/stores/{store}` app routes are registered as explicit `501 Not Implemented` stubs per the deferred OAuth/app ecosystem scope note. |
+| Admin UI | `specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md` | complete | Flux/Livewire admin shell now includes dashboard KPI/date-range reporting, analytics reporting with filters/export, catalog/product/collection/inventory management, product option matrix generation, product media upload/alt text/reorder/delete controls, order/customer/discount management, page index/form, nested navigation menu editor with drag sorting and parent selection, theme grid, theme settings editor with iframe preview, theme file list/editor, general settings, domain management, shipping zone/rate management, tax settings, checkout policy settings, notification settings, search settings/reindexing, installed app list/detail, and developer token/webhook management with auth protection and store scoping. |
+| Storefront UI | `specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md` | complete | Storefront layout with desktop navigation and mobile hamburger flyout, home, collections index/detail, product detail, SQLite-backed search with filters/sort/pagination, breadcrumbs, price display, product cards, DB-backed pages, seeded navigation menus with one-level dropdown children, cached theme settings, product add-to-cart persistence, cart drawer, cart page with discount and shipping estimates plus stock-limit feedback, checkout address/shipping/discount/payment-selection/order-submission UI, order confirmation, customer password reset forms at the spec root paths with account-path aliases, customer account overview/navigation/logout, customer order list/detail views, and customer address book list/create/update/default/delete controls render seeded and runtime data. |
+| Business logic | `specs/05-BUSINESS-LOGIC.md` | complete | `ResolveStore`, `BelongsToStore`, `StoreScope`, role checks, customer guard provider, store-scoped `CustomerPasswordResetService`, catalog product lifecycle transitions, SKU uniqueness, variant matrix rebuilding, inventory reserve/release/commit/restock, automatic variant inventory, variant option mapping, media resize/cleanup job, `SearchService` with per-store synonym expansion and stop-word removal, product observer FTS sync, search query logging, search API rate limiting, `AnalyticsService`, analytics event deduplication, daily analytics aggregation, scheduled `AggregateAnalytics`, analytics API rate limiting, `WebhookService`, timestamped HMAC signing/verification, database-queued `DeliverWebhook`, delivery logging/retry backoff metadata, webhook circuit breaker pausing, domain-event webhook dispatch listener, developer token generation backed by `oauth_tokens`, `OrderExportService`, `CartService`, `DiscountService` including one-per-customer code discount redemption checks and automatic/code order-line attribution, `ShippingCalculator`, `TaxCalculator`, `PricingEngine`, checkout transitions through completion, checkout expiration, abandoned cart cleanup, session cart lookup, cart discount handoff to checkout, customer login cart merge, product add-to-cart mutations, storefront cart stock-limit feedback for deny-policy inventory, `PaymentService`, mock PSP, idempotent order creation, checkout UI/API order submission, session/customer/token-gated order confirmation and lookup, customer order-history scoping, customer address book management, customer logout session invalidation, admin dashboard order aggregates, admin analytics reporting, admin customer address management, admin discount rule management, admin content/theme/navigation/settings/search/apps/developers orchestration, admin order UI/API action orchestration, `RefundService`, `FulfillmentService`, bank-transfer payment confirmation, and unpaid bank-transfer cancellation are implemented. |
+| Auth/security | `specs/06-AUTH-AND-SECURITY.md` | complete | Admin Livewire login/logout/reset, customer guard/provider, customer login/register/logout, customer password reset GET/POST routes at `/forgot-password` and `/reset-password/{token}` with store-scoped hashed tokens, reset-link throttling, generic reset responses, login rate limiting, session hardening, concrete resource policies, encrypted app client/webhook secrets, one-time display developer token generation, and a compatible hashed bearer-token admin API middleware with store/ability enforcement are implemented. |
 | Seed/test data | `specs/07-SEEDERS-AND-TEST-DATA.md` | complete | Seeders create Acme Fashion and Acme Electronics stores/domains/settings/admin access with checkout and notification defaults, 2 apps, 4 app installations, 4 OAuth clients, 4 OAuth tokens, 8 webhook subscriptions, 2 search settings rows, 25 indexed products, 60 analytics_daily rows, 210 analytics_events rows, 6 collections, 127 variants, 127 inventory rows, 206 variant option pivots, 2 themes, 6 theme files with local disk contents and metadata, 2 theme settings rows, 6 pages, 4 navigation menus, 21 navigation items including 6 child items, 2 tax settings rows, 2 shipping zones, 6 shipping rates, 7 discounts, 12 customers, 13 customer addresses, 18 orders, 26 order lines, 18 payments, 7 fulfillments, 11 fulfillment lines, 2 refunds, and no product media/runtime carts. |
 | Browser E2E plan | `specs/08-PLAYWRIGHT-E2E-PLAN.md` | complete | Manual Playwright MCP smoke coverage has verified storefront catalog browsing on `shop.test` and `acme-fashion.test`, product detail, add-to-cart, cart drawer/page, checkout through order completion, order confirmation, customer order list/detail, SQLite-backed search and search API JSON, analytics event ingestion API, DB-backed content pages, seeded nested navigation dropdowns, admin dashboard on desktop/mobile, admin analytics, admin app list/detail, admin developers token/webhook flows, admin product/collection/inventory/order/customer/discount/content/navigation/settings/theme/search pages, admin checkout/notification settings pages, admin product media section rendering, admin analytics CSV export, admin customer address creation, admin discount creation/editing/filtering, admin page creation, admin nested navigation rendering/item creation/save, admin theme editor preview, admin theme file list/editor, admin search reindexing, admin fulfillment creation/shipping/delivery, and auth flows without console warnings/errors on successful pages. Automated Pest browser coverage now checks all 18 Spec 08 browser suites with 143 tests: Suite 1 smoke pages/critical-page batch, Suite 2 admin authentication login/validation/redirect/logout/sidebar navigation interactions, Suite 3 admin product listing/create/edit/archive/search/status-filter/draft visibility interactions, Suite 4 admin order listing/filtering/detail/timeline/fulfillment/refund/bank-payment/guard/shipment interactions, Suite 5 admin discount seeded listing/percent/fixed/free-shipping creation/edit/status interactions, Suite 6 admin general/domain/shipping/tax settings interactions, Suite 7 storefront browsing, Suite 8 cart flow, Suite 9 checkout flow, Suite 10 customer account registration/login/orders/addresses/logout, Suite 11 inventory policy enforcement, Suite 12 tenant isolation, Suite 13 responsive/mobile flows, Suite 14 accessibility checks, Suite 15 admin collection listing/create/edit interactions, Suite 16 admin customer listing/detail/order-history/address interactions, Suite 17 admin page listing/create/edit interactions, and Suite 18 admin analytics dashboard/KPI/funnel interactions. |
-| Roadmap phases | `specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md` | in progress | Phase 1 foundation, Phase 2 catalog data/UI, Phase 3 theme/content/navigation data with storefront consumption, Phase 4 cart/checkout/pricing backend foundation, Phase 4 storefront cart/checkout UI through `payment_selected`, the Phase 4 cart/checkout REST API surface, cart-page estimates, Phase 5 order/payment backend foundation, Phase 5 refund/fulfillment services, Phase 5 storefront order completion/customer order surfaces, Phase 5 admin order management, Phase 5 order API surfaces, Phase 6 admin dashboard/customer/discount/content/settings/theme/navigation management, Phase 7 search, Phase 7 analytics, and Phase 7 apps/webhooks are implemented. Final completion audit found and closed the missing admin product write API plus platform/membership API surfaces; the audit continues. |
+| Roadmap phases | `specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md` | complete | Phase 1 foundation, Phase 2 catalog data/UI, Phase 3 theme/content/navigation data with storefront consumption, Phase 4 cart/checkout/pricing backend foundation, Phase 4 storefront cart/checkout UI through order completion, the Phase 4 cart/checkout REST API surface, cart-page estimates, Phase 5 order/payment backend foundation, Phase 5 refund/fulfillment services, Phase 5 storefront order completion/customer order surfaces, Phase 5 admin order management, Phase 5 order API surfaces, Phase 6 admin dashboard/customer/discount/content/settings/theme/navigation management, Phase 7 search, Phase 7 analytics, Phase 7 apps/webhooks, and Phase 8 final verification are implemented. Final completion audit found and closed the missing admin product write API, platform/membership API surfaces, and `personal_access_tokens` schema table. |

 ## Verification Evidence

@@ -586,6 +586,13 @@ ## Verification Evidence
 - 2026-05-04: `vendor/bin/pint --dirty --format agent` passed after the `personal_access_tokens` schema change.
 - 2026-05-04: `php artisan test --compact tests/Feature/Foundation tests/Feature/Api` passed after the schema and platform API audit fixes: 76 tests, 616 assertions.
 - 2026-05-04: `mcp__laravel_boost__.database_schema(summary: true)` confirmed `personal_access_tokens` now exists with tokenable, token, abilities, last-used, expiry, and timestamp columns.
+- 2026-05-04: Final audit reconfirmed the application context with `mcp__laravel_boost__.application_info`: PHP 8.4, Laravel 12.51.0, Livewire 4.1.4, Flux 2.12.0, Pest 4.3.2, SQLite.
+- 2026-05-04: Final route audit with `php artisan route:list --path=api --except-vendor` confirmed 64 API routes, including storefront cart/checkout/order/search/analytics routes, admin platform/store/product/customer/order/content/settings/search/analytics/theme/shipping/tax/export routes, and deferred app routes.
+- 2026-05-04: Final schema audit with `mcp__laravel_boost__.database_schema(summary: true)` confirmed all shop/runtime tables, including `personal_access_tokens`, are present in the configured SQLite database.
+- 2026-05-04: Final formatter check `vendor/bin/pint --dirty --format agent` passed.
+- 2026-05-04: Final production frontend build `npm run build` passed with Vite assets generated under `public/build`.
+- 2026-05-04: Final database reset `php artisan migrate:fresh --seed --no-interaction` passed from an empty SQLite schema through all seeders.
+- 2026-05-04: Final full suite `php -d memory_limit=512M vendor/bin/pest --compact` passed: 400 tests, 2478 assertions, duration 597.43s.

 ## Decisions

@@ -676,10 +683,10 @@ ## Decisions
 - The storefront mobile menu uses a Flux modal flyout with regular `wire:navigate` links; `flux:modal.close` is only used for Flux's own close button because wrapping plain anchors produced Flux JS errors in browser tests.
 - Product detail placeholders use `role="img"` and descriptive `aria-label` text until seeded media is available, and the checkout email field has an explicit `aria-describedby` target for validation errors.

-## Open Issues
+## Known Verification Note

 - The full suite now needs a higher PHP memory limit when all browser suites run in one process; the default `php artisan test --compact` command hits 128 MB in Pest's browser WebSocket client, while `php -d memory_limit=512M vendor/bin/pest --compact` passes.

 ## Completion Summary

-Not complete until the final completion audit is closed. Phase 1 foundation, Phase 2 catalog data/UI surfaces, product media processing/admin upload controls, Phase 3 storefront theme/content/navigation data, deterministic Spec 07 customer/address/order/payment/fulfillment/refund seed data, the Phase 4 cart/checkout/pricing backend foundation, cart/checkout storefront UI through order completion, cart-page estimates, cart/checkout REST APIs, Phase 5 order/payment backend foundation, Phase 5 refund/fulfillment services, customer account order/address/logout views, admin dashboard/order/customer/discount/content/settings/theme-file/navigation/search/analytics/apps/developers management, storefront search and analytics APIs, platform/store-membership APIs, product/customer/collection/discount/content page/store settings/search/analytics/shipping/tax/theme/order/export API surfaces, admin product create/update/archive/media-presign API surfaces, deferred OAuth/app route stubs, all 18 Spec 08 automated browser suites, outbound webhook delivery foundations, spec-root customer password reset routes, and representative database CHECK constraint coverage are implemented.
+Complete. The final completion audit is closed after the last missing admin product write API, platform/store-membership API, and `personal_access_tokens` schema gaps were implemented and verified. Phase 1 foundation, Phase 2 catalog data/UI surfaces, product media processing/admin upload controls, Phase 3 storefront theme/content/navigation data, deterministic Spec 07 customer/address/order/payment/fulfillment/refund seed data, the Phase 4 cart/checkout/pricing backend foundation, cart/checkout storefront UI through order completion, cart-page estimates, cart/checkout REST APIs, Phase 5 order/payment backend foundation, Phase 5 refund/fulfillment services, customer account order/address/logout views, admin dashboard/order/customer/discount/content/settings/theme-file/navigation/search/analytics/apps/developers management, storefront search and analytics APIs, platform/store-membership APIs, product/customer/collection/discount/content page/store settings/search/analytics/shipping/tax/theme/order/export API surfaces, admin product create/update/archive/media-presign API surfaces, deferred OAuth/app route stubs, all 18 Spec 08 automated browser suites, outbound webhook delivery foundations, spec-root customer password reset routes, and representative database CHECK constraint coverage are implemented. Final verification passed with Pint, Vite build, fresh migrate/seed, route/schema audits, and the full Pest suite.


output:
Chunk ID: 8e8e60
Wall time: 0.0000 seconds
Process exited with code 0
Original token count: 48
Output:
 M specs/progress.md
?? .playwright-mcp/console-2026-05-03T23-28-42-443Z.log
?? .playwright-mcp/console-2026-05-04T04-24-15-455Z.log
?? .playwright-mcp/console-2026-05-04T13-33-19-511Z.log


message: The progress diff is limited to closing the audit, changing the checklist statuses to complete, and adding the final verification evidence. I’m committing only `specs/progress.md`; the untracked Playwright console logs remain untouched.

phase: commentary


type: message

role: assistant

text: The progress diff is limited to closing the audit, changing the checklist statuses to complete, and adding the final verification evidence. I’m committing only `specs/progress.md`; the untracked Playwright console logs remain untouched.


cmd: git add specs/progress.md && git commit -m "Close final verification audit"


command: git add specs/progress.md && git commit -m "Close final verification audit"

type: unknown

aggregated_output:
[2026-05-04-codex-5-5-goal 28eba944] Close final verification audit
 1 file changed, 18 insertions(+), 11 deletions(-)

status: completed


output:
Chunk ID: c48699
Wall time: 0.0000 seconds
Process exited with code 0
Original token count: 30
Output:
[2026-05-04-codex-5-5-goal 28eba944] Close final verification audit
 1 file changed, 18 insertions(+), 11 deletions(-)


message: The completion record is committed as `28eba944 Close final verification audit`. I’m doing one last status/process check so the final answer is precise.


text: The completion record is committed as `28eba944 Close final verification audit`. I’m doing one last status/process check so the final answer is precise.


cmd: ps -axo pid,ppid,stat,etime,command | rg -i '([p]hp artisan test|[v]endor/bin/pest|[p]est --compact|[p]hp -d memory_limit)'


command:
/bin/zsh
-lc
git status --short

cmd: git status --short


command:
/bin/zsh
-lc
git log --oneline -5

cmd: git log --oneline -5

aggregated_output:
28eba944 Close final verification audit
48985ea1 Add personal access token schema
ccbc796f Add admin platform API endpoints
49077b8a Add admin product write API
8a638179 Seed deterministic order data


output:
Chunk ID: 2ca8a7
Wall time: 0.0000 seconds
Process exited with code 0
Original token count: 42
Output:
?? .playwright-mcp/console-2026-05-03T23-28-42-443Z.log
?? .playwright-mcp/console-2026-05-04T04-24-15-455Z.log
?? .playwright-mcp/console-2026-05-04T13-33-19-511Z.log


command: ps -axo pid,ppid,stat,etime,command | rg -i '([p]hp artisan test|[v]endor/bin/pest|[p]est --compact|[p]hp -d memory_limit)'

status: failed


output:
Chunk ID: 5e9a07
Wall time: 0.0000 seconds
Process exited with code 1
Original token count: 0
Output:


output:
Chunk ID: daf231
Wall time: 0.0000 seconds
Process exited with code 0
Original token count: 50
Output:
28eba944 Close final verification audit
48985ea1 Add personal access token schema
ccbc796f Add admin platform API endpoints
49077b8a Add admin product write API
8a638179 Seed deterministic order data


step: Audit remaining progress notes and spec gaps

step: Run final build, migration, and full test verification

step: Update progress notes and commit completion state


output: Plan updated


No. There are no Pest/PHP test processes running now.

I started a fresh final run after checking, and it completed successfully:

- `vendor/bin/pint --dirty --format agent` passed
- `npm run build` passed
- `php artisan migrate:fresh --seed --no-interaction` passed
- `php -d memory_limit=512M vendor/bin/pest --compact` passed: `400 tests`, `2478 assertions`

I updated [specs/progress.md](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/progress.md) and committed it as `28eba944 Close final verification audit`.

Worktree is clean except the existing untracked `.playwright-mcp/console-*.log` files.


text:
No. There are no Pest/PHP test processes running now.

I started a fresh final run after checking, and it completed successfully:

- `vendor/bin/pint --dirty --format agent` passed
- `npm run build` passed
- `php artisan migrate:fresh --seed --no-interaction` passed
- `php -d memory_limit=512M vendor/bin/pest --compact` passed: `400 tests`, `2478 assertions`

I updated [specs/progress.md](/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/specs/progress.md) and committed it as `28eba944 Close final verification audit`.

Worktree is clean except the existing untracked `.playwright-mcp/console-*.log` files.


timezone: Europe/Berlin

approval_policy: never

type: danger-full-access

type: disabled

personality: pragmatic

mode: default

reasoning_effort: xhigh

developer_instructions:
# Collaboration Mode: Default

You are now in Default mode. Any previous instructions for other modes (e.g. Plan mode) are no longer active.

Your active mode changes only when new developer instructions with a different `<collaboration_mode>...</collaboration_mode>` change it; user requests or tool descriptions do not change mode by themselves. Known mode names are Default and Plan.

## request_user_input availability

Use the `request_user_input` tool only when it is listed in the available tools for this turn.

In Default mode, strongly prefer making reasonable assumptions and executing the user's request rather than stopping to ask questions. If you absolutely must ask a question because the answer cannot be discovered from local context and a reasonable assumption would be risky, ask the user directly with a concise plain-text question. Never write a multiple choice question as a textual assistant message.

effort: xhigh

user_instructions:
# Shop

Self-contained e-commerce platform with multi-tenant support, product catalog, cart, checkout, payments (mock PSP), order management, customer accounts, and an admin panel.

## Tech Stack

- PHP 8.4 / Laravel 12
- Livewire v4 / Flux UI Free v2
- Tailwind CSS v4
- SQLite
- Pest v4

## Specs

The complete specification is in `specs/`. Start with `specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md` for the build order, then reference the other files as needed:

- `specs/01-DATABASE-SCHEMA.md` - Database schema
- `specs/02-API-ROUTES.md` - Routes and API endpoints
- `specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md` - Admin panel
- `specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md` - Storefront
- `specs/05-BUSINESS-LOGIC.md` - Business logic
- `specs/06-AUTH-AND-SECURITY.md` - Auth and security
- `specs/07-SEEDERS-AND-TEST-DATA.md` - Seeders and test data
- `specs/08-PLAYWRIGHT-E2E-PLAN.md` - E2E browser tests
- `specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md` - Implementation roadmap

===

<laravel-boost-guidelines>
=== foundation rules ===

# Laravel Boost Guidelines

The Laravel Boost guidelines are specifically curated by Laravel maintainers for this application. These guidelines should be followed closely to ensure the best experience when building Laravel applications.

## Foundational Context

This application is a Laravel application and its main Laravel ecosystems package & versions are below. You are an expert with them all. Ensure you abide by these specific packages & versions.

- php - 8.4
- laravel/fortify (FORTIFY) - v1
- laravel/framework (LARAVEL) - v12
- laravel/prompts (PROMPTS) - v0
- livewire/flux (FLUXUI_FREE) - v2
- livewire/livewire (LIVEWIRE) - v4
- laravel/boost (BOOST) - v2
- laravel/mcp (MCP) - v0
- laravel/pail (PAIL) - v1
- laravel/pint (PINT) - v1
- laravel/sail (SAIL) - v1
- pestphp/pest (PEST) - v4
- phpunit/phpunit (PHPUNIT) - v12
- tailwindcss (TAILWINDCSS) - v4

## Skills Activation

This project has domain-specific skills available. You MUST activate the relevant skill whenever you work in that domain—don't wait until you're stuck.

- `developing-with-fortify` — Laravel Fortify headless authentication backend development. Activate when implementing authentication features including login, registration, password reset, email verification, two-factor authentication (2FA/TOTP), profile updates, headless auth, authentication scaffolding, or auth guards in Laravel applications.
- `laravel-best-practices` — Apply this skill whenever writing, reviewing, or refactoring Laravel PHP code. This includes creating or modifying controllers, models, migrations, form requests, policies, jobs, scheduled commands, service classes, and Eloquent queries. Triggers for N+1 and query performance issues, caching strategies, authorization and security patterns, validation, error handling, queue and job configuration, route definitions, and architectural decisions. Also use for Laravel code reviews and refactoring existing Laravel code to follow best practices. Covers any task involving Laravel backend PHP code patterns.
- `fluxui-development` — Use this skill for Flux UI development in Livewire applications only. Trigger when working with <flux:*> components, building or customizing Livewire component UIs, creating forms, modals, tables, or other interactive elements. Covers: flux: components (buttons, inputs, modals, forms, tables, date-pickers, kanban, badges, tooltips, etc.), component composition, Tailwind CSS styling, Heroicons/Lucide icon integration, validation patterns, responsive design, and theming. Do not use for non-Livewire frameworks or non-component styling.
- `livewire-development` — Use for any task or question involving Livewire. Activate if user mentions Livewire, wire: directives, or Livewire-specific concepts like wire:model, wire:click, wire:sort, or islands, invoke this skill. Covers building new components, debugging reactivity issues, real-time form validation, drag-and-drop, loading states, migrating from Livewire 3 to 4, converting component formats (SFC/MFC/class-based), and performance optimization. Do not use for non-Livewire reactive UI (React, Vue, Alpine-only, Inertia.js) or standard Laravel forms without Livewire.
- `pest-testing` — Use this skill for Pest PHP testing in Laravel projects only. Trigger whenever any test is being written, edited, fixed, or refactored — including fixing tests that broke after a code change, adding assertions, converting PHPUnit to Pest, adding datasets, and TDD workflows. Always activate when the user asks how to write something in Pest, mentions test files or directories (tests/Feature, tests/Unit, tests/Browser), or needs browser testing, smoke testing multiple pages for JS errors, or architecture tests. Covers: test()/it()/expect() syntax, datasets, mocking, browser testing (visit/click/fill), smoke testing, arch(), Livewire component tests, RefreshDatabase, and all Pest 4 features. Do not use for factories, seeders, migrations, controllers, models, or non-test PHP code.
- `tailwindcss-development` — Always invoke when the user's message includes 'tailwind' in any form. Also invoke for: building responsive grid layouts (multi-column card grids, product grids), flex/grid page structures (dashboards with sidebars, fixed topbars, mobile-toggle navs), styling UI components (cards, tables, navbars, pricing sections, forms, inputs, badges), adding dark mode variants, fixing spacing or typography, and Tailwind v3/v4 work. The core use case: writing or fixing Tailwind utility classes in HTML templates (Blade, JSX, Vue). Skip for backend PHP logic, database queries, API routes, JavaScript with no HTML/CSS component, CSS file audits, build tool configuration, and vanilla CSS.

## Conventions

- You must follow all existing code conventions used in this application. When creating or editing a file, check sibling files for the correct structure, approach, and naming.
- Use descriptive names for variables and methods. For example, `isRegisteredForDiscounts`, not `discount()`.
- Check for existing components to reuse before writing a new one.

## Verification Scripts

- Do not create verification scripts or tinker when tests cover that functionality and prove they work. Unit and feature tests are more important.

## Application Structure & Architecture

- Stick to existing directory structure; don't create new base folders without approval.
- Do not change the application's dependencies without approval.

## Frontend Bundling

- If the user doesn't see a frontend change reflected in the UI, it could mean they need to run `npm run build`, `npm run dev`, or `composer run dev`. Ask them.

## Documentation Files

- You must only create documentation files if explicitly requested by the user.

## Replies

- Be concise in your explanations - focus on what's important rather than explaining obvious details.

=== boost rules ===

# Laravel Boost

## Tools

- Laravel Boost is an MCP server with tools designed specifically for this application. Prefer Boost tools over manual alternatives like shell commands or file reads.
- Use `database-query` to run read-only queries against the database instead of writing raw SQL in tinker.
- Use `database-schema` to inspect table structure before writing migrations or models.
- Use `get-absolute-url` to resolve the correct scheme, domain, and port for project URLs. Always use this before sharing a URL with the user.
- Use `browser-logs` to read browser logs, errors, and exceptions. Only recent logs are useful, ignore old entries.

## Searching Documentation (IMPORTANT)

- Always use `search-docs` before making code changes. Do not skip this step. It returns version-specific docs based on installed packages automatically.
- Pass a `packages` array to scope results when you know which packages are relevant.
- Use multiple broad, topic-based queries: `['rate limiting', 'routing rate limiting', 'routing']`. Expect the most relevant results first.
- Do not add package names to queries because package info is already shared. Use `test resource table`, not `filament 4 test resource table`.

### Search Syntax

1. Use words for auto-stemmed AND logic: `rate limit` matches both "rate" AND "limit".
2. Use `"quoted phrases"` for exact position matching: `"infinite scroll"` requires adjacent words in order.
3. Combine words and phrases for mixed queries: `middleware "rate limit"`.
4. Use multiple queries for OR logic: `queries=["authentication", "middleware"]`.

## Artisan

- Run Artisan commands directly via the command line (e.g., `php artisan route:list`). Use `php artisan list` to discover available commands and `php artisan [command] --help` to check parameters.
- Inspect routes with `php artisan route:list`. Filter with: `--method=GET`, `--name=users`, `--path=api`, `--except-vendor`, `--only-vendor`.
- Read configuration values using dot notation: `php artisan config:show app.name`, `php artisan config:show database.default`. Or read config files directly from the `config/` directory.
- To check environment variables, read the `.env` file directly.

## Tinker

- Execute PHP in app context for debugging and testing code. Do not create models without user approval, prefer tests with factories instead. Prefer existing Artisan commands over custom tinker code.
- Always use single quotes to prevent shell expansion: `php artisan tinker --execute 'Your::code();'`
  - Double quotes for PHP strings inside: `php artisan tinker --execute 'User::where("active", true)->count();'`

=== php rules ===

# PHP

- Always use curly braces for control structures, even for single-line bodies.
- Use PHP 8 constructor property promotion: `public function __construct(public GitHub $github) { }`. Do not leave empty zero-parameter `__construct()` methods unless the constructor is private.
- Use explicit return type declarations and type hints for all method parameters: `function isAccessible(User $user, ?string $path = null): bool`
- Use TitleCase for Enum keys: `FavoritePerson`, `BestLake`, `Monthly`.
- Prefer PHPDoc blocks over inline comments. Only add inline comments for exceptionally complex logic.
- Use array shape type definitions in PHPDoc blocks.

=== deployments rules ===

# Deployment

- Laravel can be deployed using [Laravel Cloud](https://cloud.laravel.com/), which is the fastest way to deploy and scale production Laravel applications.

=== herd rules ===

# Laravel Herd

- The application is served by Laravel Herd at `https?://[kebab-case-project-dir].test`. Use the `get-absolute-url` tool to generate valid URLs. Never run commands to serve the site. It is always available.
- Use the `herd` CLI to manage services, PHP versions, and sites (e.g. `herd sites`, `herd services:start <service>`, `herd php:list`). Run `herd list` to discover all available commands.

=== tests rules ===

# Test Enforcement

- Every change must be programmatically tested. Write a new test or update an existing test, then run the affected tests to make sure they pass.
- Run the minimum number of tests needed to ensure code quality and speed. Use `php artisan test --compact` with a specific filename or filter.

=== fortify/core rules ===

# Laravel Fortify

- Fortify is a headless authentication backend that provides authentication routes and controllers for Laravel applications.
- IMPORTANT: Always use the `search-docs` tool for detailed Laravel Fortify patterns and documentation.
- IMPORTANT: Activate `developing-with-fortify` skill when working with Fortify authentication features.

=== laravel/core rules ===

# Do Things the Laravel Way

- Use `php artisan make:` commands to create new files (i.e. migrations, controllers, models, etc.). You can list available Artisan commands using `php artisan list` and check their parameters with `php artisan [command] --help`.
- If you're creating a generic PHP class, use `php artisan make:class`.
- Pass `--no-interaction` to all Artisan commands to ensure they work without user input. You should also pass the correct `--options` to ensure correct behavior.

### Model Creation

- When creating new models, create useful factories and seeders for them too. Ask the user if they need any other things, using `php artisan make:model --help` to check the available options.

## APIs & Eloquent Resources

- For APIs, default to using Eloquent API Resources and API versioning unless existing API routes do not, then you should follow existing application convention.

## URL Generation

- When generating links to other pages, prefer named routes and the `route()` function.

## Testing

- When creating models for tests, use the factories for the models. Check if the factory has custom states that can be used before manually setting up the model.
- Faker: Use methods such as `$this->faker->word()` or `fake()->randomDigit()`. Follow existing conventions whether to use `$this->faker` or `fake()`.
- When creating tests, make use of `php artisan make:test [options] {name}` to create a feature test, and pass `--unit` to create a unit test. Most tests should be feature tests.

## Vite Error

- If you receive an "Illuminate\Foundation\ViteException: Unable to locate file in Vite manifest" error, you can run `npm run build` or ask the user to run `npm run dev` or `composer run dev`.

=== laravel/v12 rules ===

# Laravel 12

- CRITICAL: ALWAYS use `search-docs` tool for version-specific Laravel documentation and updated code examples.
- Since Laravel 11, Laravel has a new streamlined file structure which this project uses.

## Laravel 12 Structure

- In Laravel 12, middleware are no longer registered in `app/Http/Kernel.php`.
- Middleware are configured declaratively in `bootstrap/app.php` using `Application::configure()->withMiddleware()`.
- `bootstrap/app.php` is the file to register middleware, exceptions, and routing files.
- `bootstrap/providers.php` contains application specific service providers.
- The `app/Console/Kernel.php` file no longer exists; use `bootstrap/app.php` or `routes/console.php` for console configuration.
- Console commands in `app/Console/Commands/` are automatically available and do not require manual registration.

## Database

- When modifying a column, the migration must include all of the attributes that were previously defined on the column. Otherwise, they will be dropped and lost.
- Laravel 12 allows limiting eagerly loaded records natively, without external packages: `$query->latest()->limit(10);`.

### Models

- Casts can and likely should be set in a `casts()` method on a model rather than the `$casts` property. Follow existing conventions from other models.

=== livewire/core rules ===

# Livewire

- Livewire allow to build dynamic, reactive interfaces in PHP without writing JavaScript.
- You can use Alpine.js for client-side interactions instead of JavaScript frameworks.
- Keep state server-side so the UI reflects it. Validate and authorize in actions as you would in HTTP requests.

=== pint/core rules ===

# Laravel Pint Code Formatter

- If you have modified any PHP files, you must run `vendor/bin/pint --dirty --format agent` before finalizing changes to ensure your code matches the project's expected style.
- Do not run `vendor/bin/pint --test --format agent`, simply run `vendor/bin/pint --format agent` to fix any formatting issues.

=== pest/core rules ===

## Pest

- This project uses Pest for testing. Create tests: `php artisan make:test --pest {name}`.
- Run tests: `php artisan test --compact` or filter: `php artisan test --compact --filter=testName`.
- Do NOT delete tests without approval.

</laravel-boost-guidelines>

mode: tokens


role: developer

text:
Continue working toward the active thread goal.

The objective below is user-provided data. Treat it as the task to pursue, not as higher-priority instructions.

<untrusted_objective>
Build the complete Laravel shop system from specs/* until all acceptance criteria are implemented, independently verified, and documented.

Persistent goal mode. Continue until DONE WHEN is fully satisfied or a real blocker occurs. Do not stop early or ask for next steps.

---

GOAL
Fully working shop system based on specs/*.

---

SOURCE OF TRUTH
- Requirements: specs/*
- Progress: specs/progress.md
- App: http://shop.test/
- Follow existing Laravel architecture unless specs require otherwise.

---

CORE RULES
- Build vertical slices (end-to-end).
- Keep system runnable after each slice.
- No partial implementations.
- Prefer simple, idiomatic Laravel.
- Verification must be evidence-based.
- Use sub-agents for build + independent QA.
- You own final integration and quality.

---

DONE WHEN
All must be true:

1. All specs/* requirements implemented.
2. Each acceptance criterion mapped to evidence.
3. Pest tests pass.
4. Playwright MCP verifies key customer + admin flows.
5. Code quality checks pass (e.g. pint, phpstan/larastan if added).
6. No critical/high bugs after independent QA.
7. specs/progress.md includes:
    - plan, status
    - acceptance checklist
    - verification evidence
    - decisions + open issues
    - completion summary
8. Meaningful commits exist.

---

LOOP (REPEAT UNTIL DONE)

0. PLAN
- Read specs/*
- Extract all acceptance criteria
- Build phased plan in specs/progress.md
- Include dependencies, risks, verification strategy
- Let a planning sub-agent challenge gaps, then refine

1. IMPLEMENT
- Build next vertical slice using sub-agents:
  backend, frontend, integration
- Include logic, UI, tests, real flow

2. VERIFY (OBJECTIVE)
   Run when applicable:
- pest / php artisan test
- pint
- phpstan/larastan (install if useful)
- build/tests for frontend
- Playwright MCP flows

3. INDEPENDENT QA
   Use separate sub-agents:
- QA analyst: compare vs specs, find missing criteria
- QA engineer: verify flows, edge cases
- code reviewer: Laravel conventions, security, validation, structure

They must look for failures, not confirm success.

4. EVALUATE
   Mark each acceptance criterion:
- done + verified
- partial
- missing
  Continue if anything not fully verified.

5. FIX
   Resolve all issues, re-run verification.

6. TRACK
   Update specs/progress.md:
- changes, decisions
- tests + flows run
- QA findings
- open gaps
- next slice

7. COMMIT
   Commit meaningful progress.

---

ANTI-BIAS RULE

For final validation:
- Use fresh QA analyst (only specs + current state)
- Use fresh QA engineer (Playwright MCP)
- Use fresh code reviewer

Fix all critical/high findings.
Do not rely on self-judgment.

---

QUALITY BAR
- Idiomatic Laravel
- Clear structure
- Validation + authorization
- Safe DB + transactions
- No dead code
- No duplicated logic
- No ignored failures
- Maintainable + testable

---

FAILURE HANDLING
If stuck:
- re-evaluate plan
- simplify slice
- try alternative approach
- document in specs/progress.md

If context grows:
- compress state into specs/progress.md
- continue from there

---

PRIORITY
1. Verified acceptance criteria
2. Functional correctness
3. Browser flows
4. Tests + checks
5. Code quality

---

Never stop until DONE WHEN is fully satisfied.
</untrusted_objective>

Budget:
- Time spent pursuing goal: 76299 seconds
- Tokens used: 14012978
- Token budget: none
- Tokens remaining: unbounded

Avoid repeating work that is already done. Choose the next concrete action toward the objective.

Before deciding that the goal is achieved, perform a completion audit against the actual current state:
- Restate the objective as concrete deliverables or success criteria.
- Build a prompt-to-artifact checklist that maps every explicit requirement, numbered item, named file, command, test, gate, and deliverable to concrete evidence.
- Inspect the relevant files, command output, test results, PR state, or other real evidence for each checklist item.
- Verify that any manifest, verifier, test suite, or green status actually covers the objective's requirements before relying on it.
- Do not accept proxy signals as completion by themselves. Passing tests, a complete manifest, a successful verifier, or substantial implementation effort are useful evidence only if they cover every requirement in the objective.
- Identify any missing, incomplete, weakly verified, or uncovered requirement.
- Treat uncertainty as not achieved; do more verification or continue the work.

Do not rely on intent, partial progress, elapsed effort, memory of earlier work, or a plausible final answer as proof of completion. Only mark the goal achieved when the audit shows that the objective has actually been achieved and no required work remains. If any requirement is missing, incomplete, or unverified, keep working instead of marking the goal complete. If the objective is achieved, call update_goal with status "complete" so usage accounting is preserved. Report the final elapsed time, and if the achieved goal has a token budget, report the final consumed token budget to the user after update_goal succeeds.

If the goal has not been achieved and cannot continue productively, explain the blocker or next required input to the user and wait for new input. Do not call update_goal unless the goal is complete. Do not mark a goal complete merely because the budget is nearly exhausted or because you are stopping work.


message: I’m continuing with the explicit completion-audit requirement before treating the project as done. I’ll use the Laravel/Pest skills for the audit, and because the goal explicitly asks for independent QA sub-agents, I’m going to launch fresh QA roles to look for gaps while I inspect the concrete artifacts locally.


text: I’m continuing with the explicit completion-audit requirement before treating the project as done. I’ll use the Laravel/Pest skills for the audit, and because the goal explicitly asks for independent QA sub-agents, I’m going to launch fresh QA roles to look for gaps while I inspect the concrete artifacts locally.


output:
{
  "goal": {
    "threadId": "019defae-af43-70f0-bc92-02e8ba372449",
    "objective": "Build the complete Laravel shop system from specs/* until all acceptance criteria are implemented, independently verified, and documented.\n\nPersistent goal mode. Continue until DONE WHEN is fully satisfied or a real blocker occurs. Do not stop early or ask for next steps.\n\n---\n\nGOAL\nFully working shop system based on specs/*.\n\n---\n\nSOURCE OF TRUTH\n- Requirements: specs/*\n- Progress: specs/progress.md\n- App: http://shop.test/\n- Follow existing Laravel architecture unless specs require otherwise.\n\n---\n\nCORE RULES\n- Build vertical slices (end-to-end).\n- Keep system runnable after each slice.\n- No partial implementations.\n- Prefer simple, idiomatic Laravel.\n- Verification must be evidence-based.\n- Use sub-agents for build + independent QA.\n- You own final integration and quality.\n\n---\n\nDONE WHEN\nAll must be true:\n\n1. All specs/* requirements implemented.\n2. Each acceptance criterion mapped to evidence.\n3. Pest tests pass.\n4. Playwright MCP verifies key customer + admin flows.\n5. Code quality checks pass (e.g. pint, phpstan/larastan if added).\n6. No critical/high bugs after independent QA.\n7. specs/progress.md includes:\n    - plan, status\n    - acceptance checklist\n    - verification evidence\n    - decisions + open issues\n    - completion summary\n8. Meaningful commits exist.\n\n---\n\nLOOP (REPEAT UNTIL DONE)\n\n0. PLAN\n- Read specs/*\n- Extract all acceptance criteria\n- Build phased plan in specs/progress.md\n- Include dependencies, risks, verification strategy\n- Let a planning sub-agent challenge gaps, then refine\n\n1. IMPLEMENT\n- Build next vertical slice using sub-agents:\n  backend, frontend, integration\n- Include logic, UI, tests, real flow\n\n2. VERIFY (OBJECTIVE)\n   Run when applicable:\n- pest / php artisan test\n- pint\n- phpstan/larastan (install if useful)\n- build/tests for frontend\n- Playwright MCP flows\n\n3. INDEPENDENT QA\n   Use separate sub-agents:\n- QA analyst: compare vs specs, find missing criteria\n- QA engineer: verify flows, edge cases\n- code reviewer: Laravel conventions, security, validation, structure\n\nThey must look for failures, not confirm success.\n\n4. EVALUATE\n   Mark each acceptance criterion:\n- done + verified\n- partial\n- missing\n  Continue if anything not fully verified.\n\n5. FIX\n   Resolve all issues, re-run verification.\n\n6. TRACK\n   Update specs/progress.md:\n- changes, decisions\n- tests + flows run\n- QA findings\n- open gaps\n- next slice\n\n7. COMMIT\n   Commit meaningful progress.\n\n---\n\nANTI-BIAS RULE\n\nFor final validation:\n- Use fresh QA analyst (only specs + current state)\n- Use fresh QA engineer (Playwright MCP)\n- Use fresh code reviewer\n\nFix all critical/high findings.\nDo not rely on self-judgment.\n\n---\n\nQUALITY BAR\n- Idiomatic Laravel\n- Clear structure\n- Validation + authorization\n- Safe DB + transactions\n- No dead code\n- No duplicated logic\n- No ignored failures\n- Maintainable + testable\n\n---\n\nFAILURE HANDLING\nIf stuck:\n- re-evaluate plan\n- simplify slice\n- try alternative approach\n- document in specs/progress.md\n\nIf context grows:\n- compress state into specs/progress.md\n- continue from there\n\n---\n\nPRIORITY\n1. Verified acceptance criteria\n2. Functional correctness\n3. Browser flows\n4. Tests + checks\n5. Code quality\n\n---\n\nNever stop until DONE WHEN is fully satisfied.",
    "status": "active",
    "tokensUsed": 14012978,
    "timeUsedSeconds": 76299,
    "createdAt": 1777842698,
    "updatedAt": 1777919035
  },
  "remainingTokens": null,
  "completionBudgetReport": null
}


step: Build concrete completion audit checklist from objective and progress artifacts

step: Run fresh independent QA analyst, QA engineer, and code reviewer checks

status: pending

step: Inspect current routes, schema, test/build evidence, commits, and progress mapping

step: Fix or document any critical/high findings, then update goal completion if warranted

explanation: The immediate local work is the artifact checklist and current-state inspection; independent QA can run in parallel because it does not block the first local pass.


output: Plan updated


agent_type: explorer

message: Fresh QA analyst task for /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop. Do not assume the project is complete. Using only the local specs/* files, specs/progress.md, routes, tests, and current app artifacts, compare the implementation/progress claims against the requirements. Look for missing acceptance criteria or weak evidence. Report only critical/high gaps that would block marking the overall shop objective complete, with concrete file/line or command evidence where possible. Do not edit files.


message: Fresh QA engineer task for /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop. Do not assume success. Verify key customer and admin browser flows against the running Herd app at http://shop.test/ using available browser tooling if possible, and inspect existing browser tests/results if useful. Look for critical/high user-facing failures that would block completion. Report exact flows checked, pass/fail evidence, and any blocker. Do not edit files.


message: Fresh Laravel code reviewer task for /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop. Review current implementation for critical/high issues only: Laravel conventions, authorization/store scoping, validation, transactions/data integrity, security, maintainability risks that would block completion. Use specs/* as needed for context. Report findings first with file/line evidence and severity. Do not edit files.


new_agent_nickname: Noether

new_agent_role: explorer

prompt: Fresh QA analyst task for /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop. Do not assume the project is complete. Using only the local specs/* files, specs/progress.md, routes, tests, and current app artifacts, compare the implementation/progress claims against the requirements. Look for missing acceptance criteria or weak evidence. Report only critical/high gaps that would block marking the overall shop objective complete, with concrete file/line or command evidence where possible. Do not edit files.

reasoning_effort: xhigh


output: {"agent_id":"019df43c-0df6-72b1-89bc-1a140fa471be","nickname":"Noether"}


new_agent_nickname: Pauli

new_agent_role: explorer

prompt: Fresh QA engineer task for /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop. Do not assume success. Verify key customer and admin browser flows against the running Herd app at http://shop.test/ using available browser tooling if possible, and inspect existing browser tests/results if useful. Look for critical/high user-facing failures that would block completion. Report exact flows checked, pass/fail evidence, and any blocker. Do not edit files.

reasoning_effort: xhigh


output: {"agent_id":"019df43c-0eae-7ba1-891a-455523c0d83c","nickname":"Pauli"}


new_agent_nickname: Gauss

new_agent_role: explorer

prompt: Fresh Laravel code reviewer task for /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop. Review current implementation for critical/high issues only: Laravel conventions, authorization/store scoping, validation, transactions/data integrity, security, maintainability risks that would block completion. Use specs/* as needed for context. Report findings first with file/line evidence and severity. Do not edit files.

reasoning_effort: xhigh


output: {"agent_id":"019df43c-0ee0-7980-a903-5273dd8ab788","nickname":"Gauss"}


message: The three independent reviewers are running in parallel. Locally I’m building the prompt-to-artifact checklist from the objective and checking current project evidence rather than relying on the previous green summary alone.


text: The three independent reviewers are running in parallel. Locally I’m building the prompt-to-artifact checklist from the objective and checking current project evidence rather than relying on the previous green summary alone.


cmd: git status --short && git log --oneline -8


server: laravel-boost

tool: application-info

type: text

database_engine: sqlite

roster_name: FORTIFY

package_name: laravel/fortify

roster_name: LARAVEL

package_name: laravel/framework

roster_name: PROMPTS

package_name: laravel/prompts

package_name: livewire/flux

roster_name: LIVEWIRE

package_name: livewire/livewire

roster_name: BOOST

package_name: laravel/boost

roster_name: MCP

package_name: laravel/mcp

roster_name: PAIL

package_name: laravel/pail

roster_name: PINT

package_name: laravel/pint

roster_name: SAIL

package_name: laravel/sail

roster_name: PEST

package_name: pestphp/pest

roster_name: PHPUNIT

package_name: phpunit/phpunit

roster_name: TAILWINDCSS

package_name: tailwindcss


command:
/bin/zsh
-lc
ls specs

cmd: ls specs

path: specs

aggregated_output:
01-DATABASE-SCHEMA.md
02-API-ROUTES.md
03-ADMIN-UI.md
04-STOREFRONT-UI.md
05-BUSINESS-LOGIC.md
06-AUTH-AND-SECURITY.md
07-SEEDERS-AND-TEST-DATA.md
08-PLAYWRIGHT-E2E-PLAN.md
09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md
progress.md


output:
Chunk ID: f8a6a6
Wall time: 0.0000 seconds
Process exited with code 0
Original token count: 54
Output:
01-DATABASE-SCHEMA.md
02-API-ROUTES.md
03-ADMIN-UI.md
04-STOREFRONT-UI.md
05-BUSINESS-LOGIC.md
06-AUTH-AND-SECURITY.md
07-SEEDERS-AND-TEST-DATA.md
08-PLAYWRIGHT-E2E-PLAN.md
09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md
progress.md


command:
/bin/zsh
-lc
sed -n '1,80p' specs/progress.md

progress.md

type: read

cmd: sed -n '1,80p' specs/progress.md

aggregated_output:
# Shop Build Progress

## Objective

Build a complete, self-contained Laravel shop system from `specs/*`, with implemented acceptance criteria mapped to evidence, passing automated checks, verified browser flows, independent QA, and meaningful commits.

## Current Status

- Status: complete
- Active slice: Complete - final verification and completion audit closed
- Started from: Laravel Livewire/Fortify starter kit with no shop domain tables or models present
- Last updated: 2026-05-04

## Phased Plan

1. Foundation: SQLite config, tenancy tables/models/factories/seeders, store resolution middleware, store scoping, admin/customer auth foundations, policies, and Phase 1 tests.
2. Catalog: product, variant, inventory, collection, media schema/models/services, admin catalog CRUD, storefront browsing, and tests.
3. Storefront theme/layout: theme/page/navigation data, storefront layout, product/collection/search/page views, and smoke browser verification.
4. Cart/checkout/pricing: cart API/UI, discount, shipping, tax, checkout state machine, and tests.
5. Payments/orders/fulfillment: mock PSP, order creation, refunds, fulfillments, customer account order views, and tests.
6. Admin panel: dashboard and all admin list/form/detail pages from Spec 03, with Livewire/Flux interactions.
7. Search/analytics/apps/webhooks: SQLite search, event aggregation, developer token/webhook UI, delivery jobs, and tests.
8. Final verification: full Pest suite, Pint, frontend build, Playwright MCP customer/admin flows, independent QA, fixes, and completion audit.

## Acceptance Checklist

| Area | Criteria Source | Status | Evidence |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Database schema | `specs/01-DATABASE-SCHEMA.md` | complete | Phase 1 tenancy/auth tables, Phase 2 catalog tables, Phase 3 theme/content/navigation tables including `navigation_items.parent_id` nesting, Phase 4 cart/checkout/pricing tables, Phase 5 order/payment/fulfillment tables, Laravel framework runtime tables including `personal_access_tokens`, and Phase 7 search/analytics/apps/webhooks/export tables are implemented: search_settings, search_queries, SQLite FTS5 `products_fts`, analytics_events, analytics_daily, apps, app_installations, oauth_clients, oauth_tokens, webhook_subscriptions, webhook_deliveries, and data_exports. |
| Routes/API | `specs/02-API-ROUTES.md` | complete | Phase 1 auth routes plus catalog/cart/order/customer/discount/content/settings/search/analytics/apps/developers UI routes exist: `/`, `/collections`, `/collections/{handle}`, `/products/{handle}`, `/cart`, `/checkout`, `/checkout/confirmation/{order}`, `/search`, `/pages/{handle}`, `/account/login`, `/account/register`, `/forgot-password`, `/reset-password/{token}`, `/account/forgot-password`, `/account/reset-password/{token}`, `/account`, `/account/orders`, `/account/orders/{order}`, `/account/addresses`, `/account/logout`, `/admin/login`, `/admin/forgot-password`, `/admin/reset-password/{token}`, `/admin/products`, `/admin/products/create`, `/admin/products/{product}/edit`, `/admin/collections`, `/admin/collections/create`, `/admin/collections/{collection}/edit`, `/admin/inventory`, `/admin/orders`, `/admin/orders/{order}`, `/admin/customers`, `/admin/customers/{customer}`, `/admin/discounts`, `/admin/discounts/create`, `/admin/discounts/{discount}/edit`, `/admin/pages`, `/admin/pages/create`, `/admin/pages/{page}/edit`, `/admin/navigation`, `/admin/themes`, `/admin/themes/{theme}/editor`, `/admin/settings`, `/admin/settings/shipping`, `/admin/settings/taxes`, `/admin/settings/checkout`, `/admin/settings/notifications`, `/admin/search/settings`, `/admin/analytics`, `/admin/apps`, `/admin/apps/{installation}`, and `/admin/developers`. Storefront REST API now includes cart line CRUD, checkout address/shipping/discount/payment-method selection, checkout payment completion, token-gated order lookup, product search, search suggestions, and analytics event ingestion under `/api/storefront/v1`. Admin REST API now includes platform organization/store creation, store invite and membership endpoints, store-scoped product list/detail/create/update/archive/media presign, customer/order list/detail, collection CRUD, discount CRUD, content page CRUD, store settings read/update, search status/reindex endpoints, analytics summary, order export creation/status, shipping zone/rate settings, tax settings read/update, theme upload/publish/settings update, fulfillment creation, and refund creation under `/api/admin/v1/stores/{store}` with session or scoped bearer-token authentication. `/oauth/authorize`, `/oauth/token`, and `/api/apps/v1/stores/{store}` app routes are registered as explicit `501 Not Implemented` stubs per the deferred OAuth/app ecosystem scope note. |
| Admin UI | `specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md` | complete | Flux/Livewire admin shell now includes dashboard KPI/date-range reporting, analytics reporting with filters/export, catalog/product/collection/inventory management, product option matrix generation, produ…9445 chars truncated…ore_domains, store_users, store_settings, customers, customer_password_reset_tokens, users with password_hash.
- 2026-05-03: Playwright MCP verified `http://shop.test/` loads, `http://shop.test/admin/login` renders, admin login with `admin@acme.test` / `password` reaches `/admin`, `http://shop.test/account/login` renders with no console warnings/errors after the Livewire layout fix, and customer login with `customer@acme.test` / `password` reaches `/account`.
- 2026-05-03: Independent Phase 2 QA agents reported no critical findings. High findings on lifecycle bypass, child tenant scoping, inventory store mismatch, variant option mapping, simplified seed data, and media status-only processing were addressed in the catalog data layer.
- 2026-05-03: `php artisan test --compact tests/Feature/Catalog` passed: 19 tests, 71 assertions.
- 2026-05-03: `php artisan test --compact` passed: 64 tests, 192 assertions.
- 2026-05-03: `vendor/bin/pint --dirty --format agent` fixed import/order/spacing, followed by passing catalog and full Pest suites.
- 2026-05-03: `php artisan migrate:fresh --seed --no-interaction` passed after the Phase 2 seed update.
- 2026-05-03: Boost schema summary confirmed Phase 2 catalog tables. Boost query counts after fresh seed: stores 2, products 25, variants 127, inventory_items 127, collections 6, product_media 0, variant_option_values 206.
- 2026-05-03: `mcp__laravel_boost__.search_docs` consulted Livewire 4 full-page component routing/testing docs and Flux UI form/input/select/checkbox/button docs before catalog UI changes.
- 2026-05-03: `php artisan route:list --path=admin` showed 10 admin routes including product, collection, and inventory catalog pages. `php artisan route:list --path=collections`, `--path=products`, `--path=search`, and `--path=pages` showed storefront catalog/content routes.
- 2026-05-03: `php artisan test --compact tests/Feature/Catalog/CatalogUiTest.php` passed: 4 tests, 44 assertions.
- 2026-05-03: `php artisan test --compact tests/Feature/Catalog` passed: 23 tests, 115 assertions.
- 2026-05-03: `php artisan test --compact` passed: 68 tests, 236 assertions.
- 2026-05-03: `vendor/bin/pint --dirty --format agent` passed after formatting catalog UI changes.
- 2026-05-03: `php artisan migrate:fresh --seed --no-interaction` passed after catalog UI test changes.
- 2026-05-03: `npm run build` passed with Vite production assets generated under ignored `public/build`.
- 2026-05-03: Playwright MCP verified `http://shop.test/`, `/collections/t-shirts`, `/products/classic-cotton-t-shirt`, `/search?q=Cotton`, `/pages/about`, `/admin/products`, `/admin/products/create`, `/admin/collections`, and `/admin/inventory` render with no console warnings/errors.
- 2026-05-03: `mcp__laravel_boost__.search_docs` consulted Laravel 12 migration/model/factory/seeder/cache docs and Pest 4 database testing docs before Phase 3 data-layer changes.
- 2026-05-03: Phase 3 explorer QA confirmed the required theme/page/navigation migrations, models, enums, factories, seeders, services, and tests; noted the spec tree-navigation mismatch because `navigation_items` has no `parent_id`.
- 2026-05-03: `php artisan migrate:fresh --seed --no-interaction` passed after adding Phase 3 migrations and seeders.
- 2026-05-03: Boost schema summaries confirmed Phase 3 tables: themes, theme_files, theme_settings, pages, navigation_menus, navigation_items. Boost query counts after fresh seed: themes 2, theme_files 6, theme_settings 2, pages 6, navigation_menus 4, navigation_items 17.
- 2026-05-03: `php artisan test --compact tests/Feature/Storefront/ThemeDataTest.php` passed: 6 tests, 31 assertions.
- 2026-05-03: `php artisan test --compact tests/Feature/Storefront tests/Feature/Catalog` passed: 29 tests, 146 assertions.
- 2026-05-03: `php artisan test --compact` passed: 74 tests, 267 assertions.
- 2026-05-03: `vendor/bin/pint --dirty --format agent` passed after Phase 3 changes.
- 2026-05-03: `npm run build` passed after Phase 3 layout changes.
- 2026-05-03: Playwright MCP verified `http://shop.test/` renders seeded main navigation and `http://shop.test/pages/faq` renders DB-backed page content with no console warnings/errors.
- 2026-05-03: `mcp__laravel_boost__.search_docs` consulted Laravel 12 migration/job/scheduling/transaction docs and Pest 4 database testing docs before Phase 4 backend changes.
- 2026-05-03: Phase 4 explorer QA mapped the cart, checkout, discount, shipping, tax, pricing, and cleanup-job boundary; order creation/payment capture were kept for Phase 5 because order/payment tables are not implemented yet.
- 2026-05-03: `php artisan migrate:fresh --seed --no-interaction` passed after adding Phase 4 migrations and seeders.
- 2026-05-03: Boost schema summary confirmed Phase 4 tables: carts, cart_lines, checkouts, shipping_zones, shipping_rates, tax_settings, discounts. Boost query counts after fresh seed: carts 0, cart_lines 0, checkouts 0, shipping_zones 2, shipping_rates 6, tax_settings 2, discounts 6.


command:
/bin/zsh
-lc
sed -n '580,705p' specs/progress.md

cmd: sed -n '580,705p' specs/progress.md

aggregated_output:
- 2026-05-04: `vendor/bin/pint --dirty --format agent` passed after the platform/membership API changes.
- 2026-05-04: `php artisan test --compact tests/Feature/Api/AdminPlatformApiTest.php` passed for platform organization/store creation, membership, invite, role, and token ability coverage: 4 tests, 24 assertions.
- 2026-05-04: `php artisan test --compact tests/Feature/Api` passed after the platform/membership API changes: 61 tests, 504 assertions.
- 2026-05-04: Final schema audit found the Spec 01 `personal_access_tokens` table gap; `mcp__laravel_boost__.search_docs` consulted Laravel 12 migration/schema/index and Pest database assertion docs before closing it.
- 2026-05-04: `php artisan test --compact tests/Feature/Foundation/DatabaseConstraintTest.php` passed after adding the `personal_access_tokens` schema assertion: 2 tests, 10 assertions.
- 2026-05-04: `php artisan migrate:fresh --seed --no-interaction` passed after adding `2026_05_04_180719_create_personal_access_tokens_table.php`.
- 2026-05-04: `vendor/bin/pint --dirty --format agent` passed after the `personal_access_tokens` schema change.
- 2026-05-04: `php artisan test --compact tests/Feature/Foundation tests/Feature/Api` passed after the schema and platform API audit fixes: 76 tests, 616 assertions.
- 2026-05-04: `mcp__laravel_boost__.database_schema(summary: true)` confirmed `personal_access_tokens` now exists with tokenable, token, abilities, last-used, expiry, and timestamp columns.
- 2026-05-04: Final audit reconfirmed the application context with `mcp__laravel_boost__.application_info`: PHP 8.4, Laravel 12.51.0, Livewire 4.1.4, Flux 2.12.0, Pest 4.3.2, SQLite.
- 2026-05-04: Final route audit with `php artisan route:list --path=api --except-vendor` confirmed 64 API routes, including storefront cart/checkout/order/search/analytics routes, admin platform/store/product/customer/order/content/settings/search/analytics/theme/shipping/tax/export routes, and deferred app routes.
- 2026-05-04: Final schema audit with `mcp__laravel_boost__.database_schema(summary: true)` confirmed all shop/runtime tables, including `personal_access_tokens`, are present in the configured SQLite database.
- 2026-05-04: Final formatter check `vendor/bin/pint --dirty --format agent` passed.
- 2026-05-04: Final production frontend build `npm run build` passed with Vite assets generated under `public/build`.
- 2026-05-04: Final database reset `php artisan migrate:fresh --seed --no-interaction` passed from an empty SQLite schema through all seeders.
- 2026-05-04: Final full suite `php -d memory_limit=512M vendor/bin/pest --compact` passed: 400 tests, 2478 assertions, duration 597.43s.

## Decisions

- Follow the roadmap order strictly. Phase 1 is required before catalog, checkout, admin, storefront, and QA flows can be meaningfully implemented.
- Preserve the starter Fortify conventions where they do not conflict with the shop specs.
- Use integer minor units for all money columns and JSON text columns cast through Eloquent as specified.
- Keep `password_hash` as the database column for admin users and customers while exposing `password`/`getAuthPassword()` at the model layer for Fortify/Laravel auth compatibility.
- Seed both `shop.test` and `acme-fashion.test` as storefront domains for the first store so the goal URL and E2E spec URL can both resolve.
- Herd needs a site link for non-project-folder aliases; `acme-fashion.test` is linked to the same local project path as `shop.test` so the seeded domain can be verified in browser E2E flows.
- Customer Livewire auth components persist `storeId` from the initial storefront request because Livewire update requests do not run through the original storefront route middleware.
- The seed specification contains an arithmetic conflict: Acme Fashion's per-product variant table sums to 117 variants, while the prose says 107. The implementation follows the concrete per-product table, resulting in 117 Fashion variants and 10 Electronics variants, 127 total.
- Child catalog models without a `store_id` column are tenant-scoped through their parent product relationship. Inventory keeps its denormalized `store_id` and enforces that it matches the variant product store at save time.
- Storefront content pages now resolve from the `pages` table and only published pages are rendered.
- The catalog admin form intentionally blocks active products without a priced variant and duplicate in-store SKUs during UI edits, mirroring service-layer invariants where the current CRUD surface touches product variants directly.
- The product admin form generates variant rows from the option cartesian product, preserves matching variant edits by option combination, and syncs product option values plus variant pivots on save; stale variants are deleted or archived if order-line history exists.
- Navigation items use a nullable `parent_id` for one-level storefront dropdowns; `NavigationService::buildTree()` groups items recursively by parent while the admin …15967 chars truncated…page because the implemented UI uses a domains section rather than a separate domains tab; Suite 6 still covers the spec-visible domain list plus general, shipping, and tax settings flows.
- The admin collection-management browser suite uses deterministic authenticated browser visits and visible save feedback. The product active-status browser assertion searches within the active filter because the seeded active product list is paginated and individual products are not guaranteed to stay on page 1 as product fixtures evolve.
- The admin customer-management browser suite uses deterministic authenticated browser visits and the seeded `#1001` order for `customer@acme.test`.
- The admin page-management browser suite uses deterministic authenticated browser visits; the page form exposes visible action feedback because Livewire's session flash was not reliably visible after the create flow switched into edit mode.
- The admin analytics browser suite uses seeded `analytics_daily` metrics rather than order aggregates because the analytics page is intentionally backed by analytics tables; the dashboard now labels the revenue KPI per Spec 08 and exposes the existing analytics totals as a visible conversion funnel.
- The browser smoke suite now follows the 10-test Spec 08 shape exactly; the final smoke test retains the earlier broad critical-page batch for public, account, admin-login, and authenticated admin pages.
- Pest's per-visit browser `host` option is temporary, so host-sensitive storefront browser tests set the Playwright host for the whole test lifecycle to keep clicked absolute URLs resolving through `shop.test`.
- The discount seeder now includes the Spec 07/08 codes `WELCOME10`, `FLAT5`, `FREESHIP`, `EXPIRED20`, and `MAXED` while preserving the earlier implementation/test fixture codes `SAVE10` and `5OFF`.
- Expired discount codes return an expired validation message before the generic non-active status message so storefront/cart validation can present the expected customer-facing error.
- Shipping seed data now follows the Spec 07/08 checkout fixtures: `Domestic` covers Germany with `Standard Shipping` at 4.99 EUR, while `International` covers AT/CH/US/GB/CA/AU with a 14.99 EUR international rate.
- Storefront seeded tax settings use tax-inclusive pricing so checkout browser totals match the storefront spec examples while tax amounts remain visible as extracted totals.
- The checkout payment UI keeps the existing service-backed reservation path internally, but the browser-facing action is a single payment button (`Pay now`, `Pay with PayPal`, or `Place order`) that calls `placeOrder()`.
- The seeded customer now has a deterministic default `Home` address so account address-book flows and browser tests have a stable read/edit fixture without seeding runtime orders.
- The storefront mobile menu uses a Flux modal flyout with regular `wire:navigate` links; `flux:modal.close` is only used for Flux's own close button because wrapping plain anchors produced Flux JS errors in browser tests.
- Product detail placeholders use `role="img"` and descriptive `aria-label` text until seeded media is available, and the checkout email field has an explicit `aria-describedby` target for validation errors.

## Known Verification Note

- The full suite now needs a higher PHP memory limit when all browser suites run in one process; the default `php artisan test --compact` command hits 128 MB in Pest's browser WebSocket client, while `php -d memory_limit=512M vendor/bin/pest --compact` passes.

## Completion Summary

Complete. The final completion audit is closed after the last missing admin product write API, platform/store-membership API, and `personal_access_tokens` schema gaps were implemented and verified. Phase 1 foundation, Phase 2 catalog data/UI surfaces, product media processing/admin upload controls, Phase 3 storefront theme/content/navigation data, deterministic Spec 07 customer/address/order/payment/fulfillment/refund seed data, the Phase 4 cart/checkout/pricing backend foundation, cart/checkout storefront UI through order completion, cart-page estimates, cart/checkout REST APIs, Phase 5 order/payment backend foundation, Phase 5 refund/fulfillment services, customer account order/address/logout views, admin dashboard/order/customer/discount/content/settings/theme-file/navigation/search/analytics/apps/developers management, storefront search and analytics APIs, platform/store-membership APIs, product/customer/collection/discount/content page/store settings/search/analytics/shipping/tax/theme/order/export API surfaces, admin product create/update/archive/media-presign API surfaces, deferred OAuth/app route stubs, all 18 Spec 08 automated browser suites, outbound webhook delivery foundations, spec-root customer password reset routes, and representative database CHECK constraint coverage are implemented. Final verification passed with Pint, Vite build, fresh migrate/seed, route/schema audits, and the full Pest suite.