type: FileChange

type: update

unified_diff:
@@ -1,2 +1,2 @@
-

+

@@ -5,4 +5,7 @@
         @if($cart->lines->isEmpty())

Your cart is empty
Browse collections

@else
-
@foreach($cart->lines as $line)
id }}">
⌂

variant->product->handle) }}" wire:navigate>{{ $line->variant->product->title }}
{{ $line->variant->title }} · {{ $line->quantity }}

€{{ number_format($line->line_total_amount / 100, 2) }}

@endforeach

-

Subtotal€{{ number_format($cart->subtotalAmount() / 100, 2) }}
View cart<button type="button" wire:click="close" class="mt-3 block w-full rounded-full bg-blue-600 px-5 py-3 text-center font-semibold text-white">Continue shopping</button>

+
@foreach($cart->lines as $line)
id }}">
⌂

variant->product->handle) }}" wire:navigate wire:click="close">{{ $line->variant->product->title }}
{{ $line->variant->title }}

<button type="button" wire:click="decrease({{ $line->id }})" class="h-8 w-8 rounded-full border" aria-label="Decrease quantity">−</button>{{ $line->quantity }}<button type="button" wire:click="increase({{ $line->id }})" class="h-8 w-8 rounded-full border" aria-label="Increase quantity">+</button><button type="button" wire:click="remove({{ $line->id }})" class="ml-auto text-xs text-red-600 underline">Remove</button>

{{ $this->formatMoney($line->line_total_amount) }}

@endforeach

+            @error('cart')
{{ $message }}
@enderror
+            @error('discountCode')
{{ $message }}
@enderror
+            @if($message)
{{ $message }}
@endif
+
<form wire:submit="applyDiscount" class="flex gap-2">Discount code<input id="drawer-discount" type="text" wire:model.blur="discountCode" placeholder="Discount code" class="min-w-0 flex-1 rounded-lg border px-3 py-2 text-sm dark:bg-zinc-950"><button class="rounded-lg border px-3 py-2 text-sm font-semibold">Apply</button></form>

Subtotal

{{ $this->formatMoney($cart->subtotalAmount()) }}

@if($discountAmount > 0)

Discount

-{{ $this->formatMoney($discountAmount) }}

@endif

Total before shipping

{{ $this->formatMoney(max(0, $cart->subtotalAmount() - $discountAmount)) }}

<button type="button" wire:click="checkout" wire:loading.attr="disabled" class="mt-4 block w-full rounded-full bg-blue-600 px-5 py-3 text-center font-semibold text-white">CheckoutStarting checkout…</button>View cart

         @endif

unified_diff:
@@ -4,4 +4,8 @@

+use App\Exceptions\InsufficientInventoryException;
+use App\Exceptions\InvalidDiscountException;
 use App\Models\Cart;
 use App\Services\CartService;
+use App\Services\CheckoutService;
+use App\Services\DiscountService;
 use Livewire\Attributes\On;
@@ -15,2 +19,8 @@

+    public string $discountCode = '';
+
+    public int $discountAmount = 0;
+
+    public string $message = '';
+
     public function mount(CartService $carts): void
@@ -18,2 +28,3 @@
         $this->cart = $carts->getOrCreateForSession(app('current_store'), auth('customer')->user());
+        $this->discountCode = (string) ($this->cart->discount_code ?? '');
     }
@@ -31,2 +42,4 @@
         $this->cart = app(CartService::class)->getOrCreateForSession(app('current_store'), auth('customer')->user());
+        $this->discountCode = (string) ($this->cart->discount_code ?? '');
+        $this->discountAmount = $this->calculateDiscountAmount();
         $this->open = true;
@@ -34,2 +47,82 @@

+    public function increase(int $lineId): void
+    {
+        $line = $this->cart->lines->firstWhere('id', $lineId);
+
+        if ($line === null) {
+            return;
+        }
+
+        try {
+            app(CartService::class)->updateLineQuantity($this->cart, $lineId, $line->quantity + 1);
+            $this->refreshCart();
+        } catch (InsufficientInventoryException $exception) {
+            $this->addError('cart', $exception->getMessage());
+        }
+    }
+
+    public function decrease(int $lineId): void
+    {
+        $line = $this->cart->lines->firstWhere('id', $lineId);
+
+        if ($line === null || $line->quantity < 2) {
+            return;
+        }
+
+        app(CartService::class)->updateLineQuantity($this->cart, $lineId, $line->quantity - 1);
+        $this->refreshCart();
+    }
+
+    public function remove(int $lineId): void
+    {
+        if (! $this->cart->lines->contains('id', $lineId)) {
+            return;
+        }
+
+        app(CartService::class)->removeLine($this->cart, $lineId);
+        $this->message = 'Item removed from your cart.';
+        $this->refreshCart();
+    }
+
+    public function applyDiscount(DiscountService $discounts): void
+    {
+        $this->validate(['discountCode' => ['required', 'string', 'max:64']]);
+
+        try {
+            $discount = $discounts->validate(trim($this->discountCode), app('current_store'), $this->cart);
+            $this->cart->update(['discount_code' => $discount->code]);
+            $this->message = 'Discount applied.';
+            $this->resetValidation('discountCode');
+            $this->refreshCart();
+        } catch (InvalidDiscountException $exception) {
+            $this->addError('discountCode', $exception->getMessage());
+        }
+    }
+
+    public function removeDiscount(): void
+    {
+        $this->cart->update(['discount_code' => null]);
+        $this->discountCode = '';
+        $this->message = 'Discount removed.';
+        $this->resetValidation('discountCode');
+        $this->refreshCart();
+    }
+
+    public function checkout(CheckoutService $checkouts): void
+    {
+        if ($this->cart->lines->isEmpty()) {
+            $this->addError('cart', 'Your cart is empty.');
+
+            return;
+        }
+
+        $checkout = $checkouts->create($this->cart, auth('customer')->user()?->email ?? 'guest@example.com', auth('customer')->user());
+        $this->redirect(route('checkout.show', $checkout), navigate: true);
+    }
+
+    public function formatMoney(int|float $amount): string
+    {
+        return number_format((float) $amount / 100, 2, '.', ',').' '.($this->cart->currency ?: 'EUR');
+    }
+
     public function close(): void
@@ -43,2 +136,22 @@
     }
+
+    private function calculateDiscountAmount(): int
+    {
+        if ($this->cart->discount_code === null || $this->cart->lines->isEmpty()) {
+            return 0;
+        }
+
+        try {
+            $discount = app(DiscountService::class)->validate($this->cart->discount_code, app('current_store'), $this->cart);
+        } catch (InvalidDiscountException) {
+            return 0;
+        }
+
+        return app(DiscountService::class)->calculate($discount, (int) $this->cart->lines->sum('line_subtotal_amount'), $this->cart->lines->map(fn ($line): array => [
+            'line_id' => $line->id,
+            'amount' => $line->line_subtotal_amount,
+            'product_id' => $line->variant->product_id,
+            'collection_ids' => $line->variant->product->collections->modelKeys(),
+        ])->all())->amount;
+    }
 }

stdout:
Success. Updated the following files:
M /Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Livewire/Storefront/CartDrawer.php
M /Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/livewire/storefront/cart-drawer.blade.php


text:
Script completed
Wall time 0.0 seconds
Output:


type: message

role: user

text:
<subagent_notification>
{"agent_path":"01a021ae-4641-7d70-97fa-a13af2f3ed44","status":{"completed":"Read-only audit completed. No files were modified. Browser verification was unavailable; findings are based on route listing, source/config/schema inspection, and direct HTTP probes.\n\n## Route coverage\n\n- Storefront API: all documented paths exist in [`routes/api.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/api.php:13).\n- Admin API: all documented paths exist, including exports at [`routes/api.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/api.php:78).\n- OAuth endpoints exist and return `501`, matching the specification’s explicit deferral.\n- Inbound webhooks are correctly absent.\n- App API endpoints are absent; this is acceptable only while the specification’s OAuth/app deferral remains in effect.\n\n## Critical findings\n\n### 1. Any store admin can mint a platform-superuser token\n\n`manage-platform` is available in the token-creation UI, and token creation is authorized for any store owner/admin:\n\n- [`app/Livewire/Admin/Developers/Index.php:27-52`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Livewire/Admin/Developers/Index.php:27)\n- [`app/Http/Controllers/Api/PlatformController.php:24-44`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/PlatformController.php:24)\n\nThe specification reserves `manage-platform` for super-admin/platform management. A store admin can therefore create a token that creates organizations/stores outside the current tenant.\n\n### 2. Customer password-reset POST routes use Fortify’s admin `users` broker\n\nFortify enables global reset/registration routes:\n\n- [`config/fortify.php:146-155`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/config/fortify.php:146)\n- [`app/Actions/Fortify/ResetUserPassword.php:19-27`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Actions/Fortify/ResetUserPassword.php:19)\n\nThe documented customer reset flow requires the `customers` broker and `customer_password_reset_tokens`, scoped to the current store. The custom Livewire component does this correctly, but the documented `POST /forgot-password` and `POST /reset-password` endpoints are intercepted by Fortify and use the admin user broker.\n\n### 3. Public global registration creates unscoped admin users\n\nFortify’s registration feature is enabled and `CreateNewUser` creates an admin `User` without store membership:\n\n- [`config/fortify.php:146-149`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/config/fortify.php:146)\n- [`app/Actions/Fortify/CreateNewUser.php:20-31`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Actions/Fortify/CreateNewUser.php:20)\n\nThe specification defines customer registration at `/account/register`, not public admin registration.\n\n## High-severity findings\n\n### 4. API role enforcement does not match the permission matrix\n\nThe base admin API group permits every role, then several routes fail to narrow permissions:\n\n- Product archive allows staff, but only owner/admin may archive: [`routes/api.php:48`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/api.php:48)\n- Collection deletion permits support/staff through the base group: [`routes/api.php:51-54`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/api.php:51)\n- Discount updates permit support: [`routes/api.php:58-61`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/api.php:58)\n- Shipping/tax reads permit support, although only owner/admin may access settings: [`routes/api.php:62-67`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/api.php:62)\n- Page listing permits support, although page access is owner/admin/staff: [`routes/api.php:68-71`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/api.php:68)\n- Analytics permits support, although analytics is owner/admin/staff: [`routes/api.php:77`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/api.php:77)\n- Search settings use the general role group and are not restricted to owner/admin: [`routes/api.php:75-76`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/api.php:75)\n\n### 5. Policies/gates are not actually wired as specified\n\nNo required gates are registered in `AppServiceProvider`, and write requests often authorize using read policies:\n\n- [`app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php:45-59`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php:45)\n- [`app/Http/Requests/CreateFulfillmentRequest.php:14-17`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Requests/CreateFulfillmentRequest.php:14)\n- [`app/Http/Requests/CreateRefundRequest.php:14-17`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Requests/CreateRefundRequest.php:14)\n\nThe API controllers generally use route middleware instead of `$this->authorize(...)` on the target model, contrary to the documented authorization contract.\n\n### 6. Checkout payment response and failure contract are incorrect\n\nThe payment endpoint omits documented fields such as `checkout_id`, checkout status, payment method, currency, and bank-transfer instructions. Declines are collapsed to generic `payment_failed` instead of the required `card_declined` and `insufficient_funds` codes/messages:\n\n- [`app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontCheckoutController.php:103-126`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontCheckoutController.php:103)\n- Failure causes are generated distinctly in [`app/Services/MockPaymentProvider.php:22-29`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/MockPaymentProvider.php:22)\n\n### 7. Storefront order access returns the wrong status and schema\n\nInvalid or missing HMAC tokens return `404`; the specification requires `401`. The response is wrapped in `data` and omits documented order fields, nested totals, billing address, variant/ SKU snapshots, and detailed line totals:\n\n- [`app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontOrderController.php:14-20`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontOrderController.php:14)\n\n### 8. Theme API does not implement the documented upload contract\n\nThe specification requires a required ZIP upload, max 50 MB, structure validation, optional name, and `settings_json`. The implementation instead accepts JSON fields, requires `name`, does not process an archive, and expects `settings`:\n\n- [`app/Http/Requests/StoreThemeRequest.php:22-25`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Requests/StoreThemeRequest.php:22)\n- [`app/Http/Requests/UpdateThemeSettingsRequest.php:22-25`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Requests/UpdateThemeSettingsRequest.php:22)\n- [`app/Http/Controllers/Api/AdminController.php:303-329`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/AdminController.php:303)\n\nPublishing also does not set `published_at`.\n\n### 9. Tax and shipping request contracts are wrong\n\n- Shipping zones do not require at least one valid ISO country: [`app/Http/Requests/StoreShippingZoneRequest.php:22-25`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Requests/StoreShippingZoneRequest.php:22)\n- Shipping rates require undocumented `price_amount` and `currency`, while `config_json` is optional: [`app/Http/Requests/StoreShippingRateRequest.php:22-25`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Requests/StoreShippingRateRequest.php:22)\n- Tax settings accept legacy optional fields and do not validate required `mode`, conditional `provider`, `prices_include_tax`, or `config_json`: [`app/Http/Requests/UpdateTaxSettingsRequest.php:22-25`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Requests/UpdateTaxSettingsRequest.php:22)\n\n### 10. Admin analytics and search responses do not match the specification\n\nAnalytics does not require/validate `from`, `to`, max 365 days, or `granularity`, and returns a different sparse schema:\n\n- [`app/Http/Controllers/Api/AdminController.php:347-353`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/AdminController.php:347)\n\nSearch accepts an empty/missing query, lacks documented filters/sorting/facets, and returns a different response shape. Suggestions require minimum length 2 instead of 1 and omit collection/image/price data:\n\n- [`app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontSearchController.php:14-27`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontSearchController.php:14)\n\n### 11. Analytics ingestion accepts invalid events and wrong limits\n\nThe documented contract requires 1–50 events, exact event types, required IDs, max length 100, property depth, and timestamps within ±1 hour. Current validation allows 1–100 events, nullable IDs, arbitrary types, and nullable timestamps:\n\n- [`app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontAnalyticsController.php:14-35`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontAnalyticsController.php:14)\n\nInvalid event types can reach service code and become server errors rather than `422`.\n\n### 12. Owner invariant is not enforced\n\nThe schema has no database constraint ensuring exactly one owner per store:\n\n- [`database/migrations/2026_08_20_000000_create_shop_schema.php:50-61`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/database/migrations/2026_08_20_000000_create_shop_schema.php:50)\n\nInvitations also allow `owner`:\n\n- [`app/Http/Requests/StoreInvitationRequest.php:22-27`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Requests/StoreInvitationRequest.php:22)\n\nThis conflicts with the security specification’s ownership-transfer and one-owner requirements.\n\n## Medium-severity findings\n\n### 13. Customer authentication redirects to `/login`, not `/account/login`\n\nThe application uses Laravel’s built-in `auth:customer` middleware and has no custom `CustomerAuthenticate` middleware or redirect configuration:\n\n- [`routes/web.php:83-88`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/web.php:83)\n- [`bootstrap/app.php:28-32`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/bootstrap/app.php:28)\n\nDirect probing showed unauthenticated `/account/orders` redirects to `/login`, not `/account/login`, and the documented intended-URL behavior is not implemented.\n\n### 14. Unauthenticated admin web requests return 403 instead of redirecting to `/admin/login`\n\n`ResolveStore` runs before authentication and aborts with 403 when no admin store is resolved:\n\n- [`bootstrap/app.php:15-18`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/bootstrap/app.php:15)\n- [`app/Http/Middleware/ResolveStore.php:37-45`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Middleware/ResolveStore.php:37)\n\nDirect probing of `/admin` returned `403`, contrary to the documented admin login flow.\n\n### 15. Platform routes omit `store.resolve`\n\nThe platform API group uses `auth:sanctum`, ability checking, and throttling, but omits `store.resolve`:\n\n- [`routes/api.php:33-36`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/api.php:33)\n\nThis differs from the documented admin API middleware stack. More importantly, `storeStore()` does not validate organization ownership before creating a store:\n\n- [`app/Http/Controllers/Api/PlatformController.php:36-44`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/PlatformController.php:36)\n\n### 16. Storefront checkout accepts inactive carts\n\nCheckout creation loads a cart by ID but does not require `status = active`:\n\n- [`app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontCheckoutController.php:25-39`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontCheckoutController.php:25)\n\nThe specification requires an active, non-empty cart.\n\n### 17. Several storefront validation/error contracts differ\n\n- Cart currency checks only three characters, not ISO 4217: [`app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontCartController.php:17-24`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontCartController.php:17)\n- Country validation accepts any uppercase two-letter value, not ISO 3166-1: [`app/Http/Requests/SetCheckoutAddressRequest.php:47-60`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Requests/SetCheckoutAddressRequest.php:47)\n- Discount codes allow 64 characters instead of 50: [`app/Http/Requests/ApplyDiscountRequest.php:22-25`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Requests/ApplyDiscountRequest.php:22)\n- Invalid/expired discount failures return `422` uniformly instead of the specified `400` cases.\n- Removing a discount always succeeds, rather than returning `404` when none is applied: [`app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontCheckoutController.php:94-100`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontCheckoutController.php:94)\n\n### 18. Rate-limit key differs between the two specifications\n\nThe API-route specification requires `api.admin` to be keyed by Sanctum token ID; the security specification requires user ID/IP. The implementation uses user ID/IP:\n\n- [`app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php:53-59`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php:53)\n\nIt matches `06-AUTH-AND-SECURITY.md`, but not `02-API-ROUTES.md`.\n\nThe Livewire login components also implement separate manual limiters (`admin-login|IP` and `customer-login|IP`) instead of using the documented `login` limiter:\n\n- [`app/Livewire/Admin/Auth/Login.php:17-44`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Livewire/Admin/Auth/Login.php:17)\n- [`app/Livewire/Storefront/Account/Auth/Login.php:19-52`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Livewire/Storefront/Account/Auth/Login.php:19)\n\n### 19. API exceptions are not forced to JSON\n\nThe exception configuration is empty:\n\n- [`bootstrap/app.php:34-36`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/bootstrap/app.php:34)\n\nThe API contract requires consistent JSON error responses. Some validation paths return JSON, but unhandled `404/403/500` responses can be HTML depending on request headers.\n\n### 20. Payment encryption schema does not match the security contract\n\nThe specification requires `payments.raw_json` with an `encrypted:array` cast. The implementation uses `raw_json_encrypted` with an `encrypted` string cast and manually JSON-encodes the value:\n\n- [`app/Models/Payment.php:10-18`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Models/Payment.php:10)\n- [`app/Services/PaymentService.php:50-52`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/PaymentService.php:50)\n- [`database/migrations/2026_08_20_000000_create_shop_schema.php:441`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/database/migrations/2026_08_20_000000_create_shop_schema.php:441)\n\n### 21. Admin password storage still uses Laravel’s `password` column\n\nThe security specification requires `password_hash` and an overridden auth password accessor. `User` synchronizes both columns but authenticates through the default `password` attribute:\n\n- [`app/Models/User.php:25-69`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Models/User.php:25)\n\n`Customer` correctly overrides the auth password accessor; `User` does not.\n\n### 22. Session/CORS/Sanctum production settings are not safely constrained\n\n- `SESSION_SECURE_COOKIE` defaults to `null`, not explicitly secure: [`config/session.php:159-170`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/config/session.php:159)\n- CORS defaults to wildcard origins while credentials are enabled: [`config/cors.php:4-12`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/config/cors.php:4)\n- Sanctum stateful domains default to localhost values and do not include the tenant domains such as `shop.test`: [`config/sanctum.php:21-26`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/config/sanctum.php:21)\n\n## Auditability finding\n\n### 23. Required authentication/security audit events are missing\n\nOnly `ProductObserver` is registered. There are no listeners for login, failed login, logout, token creation/revocation, or equivalent customer authentication events:\n\n- [`app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php:45-59`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php:45)\n\nThe logger schema also uses `subject_type`/`subject_id` and puts the event in the log message instead of recording the required structured `event`, `resource_type`, `resource_id`, `timestamp`, `store_id`, and `changes` fields:\n\n- [`app/Services/AuditLogger.php:8-20`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/AuditLogger.php:8)\n\nThe main tenant scoping pattern for storefront carts, checkouts, orders, and admin resources is present, but the platform-token escalation, ownership invariant, and missing organization authorization are material tenant-isolation defects."}}
</subagent_notification>


text:
<subagent_notification>
{"agent_path":"01a021ae-46e6-7403-b288-76b3738f772b","status":{"completed":"Read-only audit findings below. No files were edited. Browser verification was not used; findings are based on the repository, migrations, database schema, seeders, services, jobs, and tests. Current tests pass: **87 tests / 296 assertions**.\n\n### Major\n\n1. **Required database enum constraints are missing**\n\n   Status/type/method columns are unrestricted strings; the required SQLite `CHECK` constraints are absent.\n\n   Paths: `database/migrations/2026_08_20_000000_create_shop_schema.php`, compatibility migrations.\n\n   Not covered by tests: no schema test inserts invalid enum values.\n\n2. **Core schema contract mismatches remain**\n\n   Examples:\n\n   - `product_media.storage_key` nullable; status defaults to `ready` instead of `processing`.\n   - `theme_files.storage_key` and `sha256` nullable.\n   - Search JSON fields nullable without `[]` defaults.\n   - `cart_lines.variant_id` and `checkouts.cart_id` use `RESTRICT`, not required `CASCADE`.\n   - `refunds.payment_id` nullable with `SET NULL`, not required cascading FK.\n   - Checkout/order/customer required fields differ from the specification.\n\n   Paths: `database/migrations/2026_08_20_000000_create_shop_schema.php`, `database/migrations/2026_08_20_223045_add_remaining_schema_contract_columns.php`.\n\n   Not covered by tests: no migration contract tests.\n\n3. **OAuth and webhook schemas retain incompatible legacy contracts**\n\n   OAuth `app_id`/`installation_id` fields are nullable and lack required foreign keys. Legacy token/hash and redirect URI columns remain alongside the specified fields.\n\n   Webhook installation and delivery relationships are also nullable or missing required FKs.\n\n   Paths: `database/migrations/2026_08_20_230144_add_remaining_spec_contract_fields.php`, `database/migrations/2026_08_20_234417_align_theme_settings_password_reset_and_webhook_contracts.php`.\n\n4. **`order.paid` webhooks are never dispatched**\n\n   `OrderPaid` is emitted, but `DispatchWebhooks` does not listen for it. The required `order.paid` subscription type therefore never receives deliveries.\n\n   Paths: `app/Services/OrderService.php`, `app/Listeners/DispatchWebhooks.php`, `app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php`.\n\n   Not covered by tests: webhook tests only exercise `order.created`.\n\n5. **Webhook signature format conflicts with the specification**\n\n   `DeliverWebhook` signs `timestamp.payload`; the specification requires the HMAC of the payload itself.\n\n   Path: `app/Jobs/DeliverWebhook.php`.\n\n   Not covered by tests: tests check that a signature exists, not its interoperability format.\n\n6. **Required fulfillment and email side effects are missing**\n\n   `FulfillmentService::create()` does not dispatch `FulfillmentCreated`. No customer notification handlers were found for order confirmation, refund, shipping, delivery, or cancellation emails.\n\n   Paths: `app/Services/FulfillmentService.php`, `app/Events/`, `app/Listeners/`.\n\n7. **Guest orders are not linked to customers**\n\n   `OrderService::createFromCheckout()` copies `checkout.customer_id`; it does not find or create a customer by store and email.\n\n   Path: `app/Services/OrderService.php`.\n\n   Not covered by tests: guest checkout tests do not assert customer creation/linking.\n\n8. **Checkout state transitions are not strictly enforced**\n\n   `selectPaymentMethod()` checks address/rate fields but not the current state. `setAddress()` permits changes after payment selection.\n\n   Path: `app/Services/CheckoutService.php`.\n\n   Not covered by tests: no invalid-transition coverage.\n\n9. **Automatic discounts are unsupported**\n\n   `PricingEngine` only applies `checkout.discount_code`; it never evaluates or stacks active automatic discounts.\n\n   Paths: `app/Services/PricingEngine.php`, `app/Services/DiscountService.php`.\n\n10. **Tax provider selection and snapshots are incomplete**\n\n    The application always binds `ManualTaxProvider`, ignores `tax_settings.provider`, and never stores `tax_provider_snapshot_json`.\n\n    Paths: `app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php`, `app/Services/TaxCalculator.php`, `app/Services/PricingEngine.php`.\n\n11. **Configurable expiration settings are ignored**\n\n    - Cart cleanup hardcodes 14 days.\n    - Bank-transfer cancellation uses global config instead of `store_settings.settings_json.bank_transfer_cancel_days`.\n    - Checkout expiration uses `expires_at`, not the specified inactivity check.\n\n    Paths: `app/Jobs/CleanupAbandonedCarts.php`, `app/Jobs/CancelUnpaidBankTransferOrders.php`, `app/Jobs/ExpireAbandonedCheckouts.php`.\n\n12. **Analytics aggregation is incorrect**\n\n    `visits_count` counts page-view rows instead of distinct sessions. Revenue/order metrics are not derived from `checkout_completed` event properties. Required analytics fields are nullable at ingestion.\n\n    Paths: `app/Jobs/AggregateAnalytics.php`, `app/Services/AnalyticsService.php`, `app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontAnalyticsController.php`.\n\n    Existing test coverage codifies the bug: `tests/Feature/SearchAnalyticsWebhookTest.php` expects two visits for two events from one session.\n\n13. **Media processing violates required dimensions and paths**\n\n    Current targets are 320/800/1600, omit `small`, do not create the specified predictable media paths, and do not generate WebP alongside the original.\n\n    Paths: `app/Jobs/ProcessMediaUpload.php`, `app/Http/Controllers/Api/PlatformController.php`.\n\n    Not covered by tests: media tests only check that files exist.\n\n14. **Shipping matching and calculation are incorrect**\n\n    `ShippingCalculator` treats empty zones as wildcards, does not tie-break by lowest zone ID, uses `price_amount` instead of flat-rate config, and returns `0` for unmatched ranges instead of unavailable/null.\n\n    Path: `app/Services/ShippingCalculator.php`.\n\n### Seed and test-data findings\n\n15. **Four required seeders are empty**\n\n    Paths:\n\n    - `database/seeders/PageSeeder.php`\n    - `database/seeders/NavigationSeeder.php`\n    - `database/seeders/AnalyticsSeeder.php`\n    - `database/seeders/SearchSettingsSeeder.php`\n\n    `tests/Feature/SeedDataTest.php` does not verify any of them.\n\n16. **Seeded catalog data does not match the specification**\n\n    - Collections write `description`, not required `description_html`.\n    - Product descriptions are generic generated text.\n    - SKU patterns differ from the specified fixtures.\n    - Draft `Unreleased Winter Jacket` has a non-null `published_at`.\n    - `ShopSeeder` mutates `Limited Edition Sneakers` into an extra legacy product.\n\n    Paths: `database/seeders/CollectionSeeder.php`, `database/seeders/ProductSeeder.php`, `database/seeders/ShopSeeder.php`.\n\n17. **Variant and handle rules are incomplete**\n\n    More than three product options are accepted. Existing variants can lack inventory after matrix rebuild. Handle collisions start at `-2`, skipping required `-1`.\n\n    Paths: `app/Services/ProductService.php`, `app/Services/VariantMatrixService.php`, `app/Support/HandleGenerator.php`.\n\n18. **Search does not implement the specified FTS behavior**\n\n    It indexes `description` directly, does not order by FTS relevance, and applies prefix matching to every token instead of only the last token.\n\n    Path: `app/Services/SearchService.php`.\n\n19. **Factories produce incorrect or inconsistent fixtures**\n\n    `PageFactory::archived()` creates draft pages; `CustomerFactory` stores marketing opt-in in metadata; analytics factories favor legacy payload fields; related factories can create cross-store parent/child records.\n\n    Paths: `database/factories/PageFactory.php`, `CustomerFactory.php`, `AnalyticsEventFactory.php`, and related factories.\n\n"}}
</subagent_notification>


exec

status: completed

input:
const ids=["01a021ae-45c6-7540-8912-baba502a2606","01a021ae-4641-7d70-97fa-a13af2f3ed44","01a021ae-46e6-7403-b288-76b3738f772b"];
const out=[];
for (const target of ids) out.push(await tools.multi_agent_v1__close_agent({target}));
text(out);


type: CollabAgentToolCall

status: completed

agent_nickname: Meitner

completed:
Audit completed read-only; no files were edited.

Public routes returned HTTP 200, and protected admin routes correctly returned HTTP 403 unauthenticated. Authenticated browser flows could not be re-run: the in-app browser was unavailable and Playwright MCP was locked. Existing Boost browser logs still exposed concrete JavaScript failures.

## Findings

1. **High — Flux/Alpine runtime errors break interactions**

   Latest browser logs show:

   - `/login`: `fluxInputViewable is not defined`, followed by `Illegal invocation`. The failing control is the password visibility input in [resources/views/livewire/auth/login.blade.php:25](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/livewire/auth/login.blade.php:25).
   - `/admin/settings`: `fluxModal is not defined` when opening the Add Domain modal in [resources/views/livewire/admin/settings/domains.blade.php:2](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/livewire/admin/settings/domains.blade.php:2).

   These prevent expected login/password visibility and domain-modal interactions.

2. **High — The planned Playwright acceptance suite is absent**

   Spec 08 defines 18 browser test files and 143 tests, but:

   - `tests/Browser/` does not exist.
   - `.env.testing` does not exist.
   - `composer.json` does not include `pestphp/pest-plugin-browser`.
   - [phpunit.xml:8-15](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/phpunit.xml:8) only registers Unit and Feature suites.

   This leaves the specified browser acceptance matrix unimplemented. See [specs/08-PLAYWRIGHT-E2E-PLAN.md:11](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/specs/08-PLAYWRIGHT-E2E-PLAN.md:11).

3. **Major — Admin shell is missing required navigation and account interactions**

   [resources/views/layouts/admin.blade.php:8](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/layouts/admin.blade.php:8) hardcodes the complete shell. Missing or incomplete criteria include:

   - sidebar grouping, separators, active route state, and `aria-current`;
   - store switcher;
   - notifications/unread count;
   - profile dropdown with settings/logout;
   - reusable Sidebar/TopBar Livewire components;
   - breadcrumbs on pages;
   - typed, stacked toasts with the specified duration.

   The spec requires these in [specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md:130](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md:130) and [specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md:2292](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md:2292).

4. **Major — Admin product listing and CRUD are substantially incomplete**

   The component [app/Livewire/Admin/Products/Index.php:12](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Livewire/Admin/Products/Index.php:12) lacks sorting, pagination handling, bulk delete, bulk activate, and bulk confirmation actions.

   The view [resources/views/livewire/admin/products/index.blade.php:9](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/livewire/admin/products/index.blade.php:9) lacks the specified sortable columns, product images/type/vendor data, proper status badges, filtered-empty state, loading state, and bulk actions.

   The form [app/Livewire/Admin/Products/Form.php:12](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Livewire/Admin/Products/Form.php:12) and [resources/views/livewire/admin/products/form.blade.php:1](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/livewire/admin/products/form.blade.php:1) only support basic title, description, vendor, type, price, status, and one default variant. Media, options, variant generation, collections, SEO, publishing, reorder/remove media, and delete-product flows are absent. See [specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md:345](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md:345) and [specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md:464](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md:464).

5. **Major — Dashboard does not meet the specified analytics UI**

   [app/Livewire/Admin/Dashboard.php:13](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Livewire/Admin/Dashboard.php:13) only supports a simple 7/30/90 range. [resources/views/livewire/admin/dashboard.blade.php:8](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/livewire/admin/dashboard.blade.php:8) lacks custom date selection, KPI trend percentages, the required daily order-count chart, and the specified funnel states. It renders CSS bars instead of the planned chart implementation. See [specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md:202](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md:202).

6. **Major — Storefront global layout fails several responsive/theme criteria**

   [resources/views/layouts/storefront.blade.php:3](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/layouts/storefront.blade.php:3) has:

   - hardcoded `lang="en"` and page-independent title;
   - hardcoded navigation/footer instead of configured menus;
   - no mobile navigation drawer;
   - search rendered as a normal link rather than a header modal trigger;
   - no cart item-count badge;
   - no announcement dismissal/configuration;
   - no storefront dark-mode control;
   - no configured logo/social/payment/address content.

   These contradict [specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md:92](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md:92).

7. **Major — Home page is hardcoded rather than theme/configuration driven**

   [app/Livewire/Storefront/Home.php:19](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Livewire/Storefront/Home.php:19) hardcodes collection/product queries and section counts. [resources/views/livewire/storefront/home.blade.php:2](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/livewire/storefront/home.blade.php:2) hardcodes hero copy, has no configurable hero media/rich-text sections, and the newsletter form posts to `#` without Livewire validation, success, error, or loading behavior. See [specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md:237](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md:237).

8. **Major — Collection and product browsing omit required commerce interactions**

   Collections:

   - [app/Livewire/Storefront/Collections/Show.php:10](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Livewire/Storefront/Collections/Show.php:10) has only sort and in-stock filtering, with no price/type/vendor filters or pagination.
   - [resources/views/livewire/storefront/collections/show.blade.php:8](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/livewire/storefront/collections/show.blade.php:8) lacks filter drawers, active filter pills, pagination, and loading states.
   - [resources/views/components/storefront/product-card.blade.php:1](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/components/storefront/product-card.blade.php:1) lacks secondary images and quick-add/choose-options behavior.

   Product detail:

   - thumbnails in [resources/views/livewire/storefront/products/show.blade.php:6](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/livewire/storefront/products/show.blade.php:6) are not selectable;
   - stock messaging lacks “In stock” / “Only X left in stock” states;
   - quantity controls have no increment/decrement buttons or max enforcement;
   - tags, product breadcrumbs, and configurable currency are missing.

   These map to [specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md:376](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md:376) and [specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md:555](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md:555).

9. **Major — Cart drawer is not functionally usable for checkout**

   [app/Livewire/Storefront/CartDrawer.php:16](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Livewire/Storefront/CartDrawer.php:16) only opens, closes, and refreshes. [resources/views/livewire/storefront/cart-drawer.blade.php:4](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/livewire/storefront/cart-drawer.blade.php:4) lacks quantity controls, remove actions, discount entry, total breakdown, and a Checkout button. It also lacks focus trapping, focus restoration, and body scroll locking required by [specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md:746](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md:746).

10. **Medium — Required seeded acceptance data is not guaranteed**

   These seeders are effectively empty:

   - [database/seeders/NavigationSeeder.php:14](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/database/seeders/NavigationSeeder.php:14)
   - [database/seeders/AnalyticsSeeder.php:14](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/database/seeders/AnalyticsSeeder.php:14)
   - [database/seeders/SearchSettingsSeeder.php:14](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/database/seeders/SearchSettingsSeeder.php:14)

   Fresh test data therefore cannot reliably satisfy the navigation, analytics, and search prerequisites described in Spec 08.

No files were modified during the audit.


agent_nickname: Lovelace

completed:
Read-only audit completed. No files were modified. Browser verification was unavailable; findings are based on route listing, source/config/schema inspection, and direct HTTP probes.

## Route coverage

- Storefront API: all documented paths exist in [`routes/api.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/api.php:13).
- Admin API: all documented paths exist, including exports at [`routes/api.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/api.php:78).
- OAuth endpoints exist and return `501`, matching the specification’s explicit deferral.
- Inbound webhooks are correctly absent.
- App API endpoints are absent; this is acceptable only while the specification’s OAuth/app deferral remains in effect.

## Critical findings

### 1. Any store admin can mint a platform-superuser token

`manage-platform` is available in the token-creation UI, and token creation is authorized for any store owner/admin:

- [`app/Livewire/Admin/Developers/Index.php:27-52`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Livewire/Admin/Developers/Index.php:27)
- [`app/Http/Controllers/Api/PlatformController.php:24-44`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/PlatformController.php:24)

The specification reserves `manage-platform` for super-admin/platform management. A store admin can therefore create a token that creates organizations/stores outside the current tenant.

### 2. Customer password-reset POST routes use Fortify’s admin `users` broker

Fortify enables global reset/registration routes:

- [`config/fortify.php:146-155`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/config/fortify.php:146)
- [`app/Actions/Fortify/ResetUserPassword.php:19-27`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Actions/Fortify/ResetUserPassword.php:19)

The documented customer reset flow requires the `customers` broker and `customer_password_reset_tokens`, scoped to the current store. The custom Livewire component does this correctly, but the documented `POST /forgot-password` and `POST /reset-password` endpoints are intercepted by Fortify and use the admin user broker.

### 3. Public global registration creates unscoped admin users

Fortify’s registration feature is enabled and `CreateNewUser` creates an admin `User` without store membership:

- [`config/fortify.php:146-149`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/config/fortify.php:146)
- [`app/Actions/Fortify/CreateNewUser.php:20-31`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Actions/Fortify/CreateNewUser.php:20)

The specification defines customer registration at `/account/register`, not public admin registration.

## High-severity findings

### 4. API role enforcement does not match the permission matrix

The base admin API group permits every role, then several routes fail to narrow permissions:

- Product archive allows staff, but only owner/admin may archive: [`routes/api.php:48`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/api.php:48)
- Collection deletion permits support/staff through the base group: [`routes/api.php:51-54`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/api.php:51)
- Discount updates permit support: [`routes/api.php:58-61`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/api.php:58)
- Shipping/tax reads permit support, although only owner/admin may access settings: [`routes/api.php:62-67`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/api.php:62)
- Page listing permits support, although page access is owner/admin/staff: [`routes/api.php:68-71`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/api.php:68)
- Analytics permits support, although analytics is owner/admin/staff: [`routes/api.php:77`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/api.php:77)
- Search settings use the general role group and are not restricted to owner/admin: [`routes/api.php:75-76`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/api.php:75)

### 5. Policies/gates are not actually wired as specified

No required gates are registered in `AppServiceProvider`, and write requests often authorize using read policies:

- [`app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php:45-59`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php:45)
- [`app/Http/Requests/CreateFulfillmentRequest.php:14-17`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Requests/CreateFulfillmentRequest.php:14)
- [`app/Http/Requests/CreateRefundRequest.php:14-17`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Requests/CreateRefundRequest.php:14)

The API controllers generally use route middleware instead of `$this->authorize(...)` on the target model, contrary to the documented authorization contract.

### 6. Checkout payment response and failure contract are incorrect

The payment endpoint omits documented fields such as `checkout_id`, checkout status, payment method, currency, and bank-transfer instructions. Declines are collapsed to generic `payment_failed` instead of the required `card_declined` and `insufficient_funds` codes/messages:

- [`app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontCheckoutController.php:103-126`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontCheckoutController.php:103)
- Failure causes are generated distinctly in [`app/Services/MockPaymentProvider.php:22-29`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/MockPaymentProvider.php:22)

### 7. Storefront order access returns the wrong status and schema

Invalid or missing HMAC tokens return `404`; the specification requires `401`. The response is wrapped in `data` and omits documented order fields, nested totals, billing address, variant/ SKU snapshots, and detailed line totals:

- [`app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontOrderController.php:14-20`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontOrderController.php:14)

### 8. Theme API does not implement the documented upload contract

The specification requires a required ZIP upload, max 50 MB, structure validation, optional name, and `settings_json`. The implementation instead accepts JSON fields, requires `name`, does not process an archive, and expects `settings`:

- [`app/Http/Requests/StoreThemeRequest.php:22-25`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Requests/StoreThemeRequest.php:22)
- [`app/Http/Requests/UpdateThemeSettingsRequest.php:22-25`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Requests/UpdateThemeSettingsRequest.php:22)
- [`app/Http/Controllers/Api/AdminController.php:303-329`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/AdminController.php:303)

Publishing also does not set `published_at`.

### 9. Tax and shipping request contracts are wrong

- Shipping zones do not require at least one valid ISO country: [`app/Http/Requests/StoreShippingZoneRequest.php:22-25`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Requests/StoreShippingZoneRequest.php:22)
- Shipping rates require undocumented `price_amount` and `currency`, while `config_json` is optional: [`app/Http/Requests/StoreShippingRateRequest.php:22-25`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Requests/StoreShippingRateRequest.php:22)
- Tax settings accept legacy optional fields and do not validate required `mode`, conditional `provider`, `prices_include_tax`, or `config_json`: [`app/Http/Requests/UpdateTaxSettingsRequest.php:22-25`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Requests/UpdateTaxSettingsRequest.php:22)

### 10. Admin analytics and search responses do not match the specification

Analytics does not require/validate `from`, `to`, max 365 days, or `granularity`, and returns a different sparse schema:

- [`app/Http/Controllers/Api/AdminController.php:347-353`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/AdminController.php:347)

Search accepts an empty/missing query, lacks documented filters/sorting/facets, and returns a different response shape. Suggestions require minimum length 2 instead of 1 and omit collection/image/price data:

- [`app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontSearchController.php:14-27`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontSearchController.php:14)

### 11. Analytics ingestion accepts invalid events and wrong limits

The documented contract requires 1–50 events, exact event types, required IDs, max length 100, property depth, and timestamps within ±1 hour. Current validation allows 1–100 events, nullable IDs, arbitrary types, and nullable timestamps:

- [`app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontAnalyticsController.php:14-35`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontAnalyticsController.php:14)

Invalid event types can reach service code and become server errors rather than `422`.

### 12. Owner invariant is not enforced

The schema has no database constraint ensuring exactly one owner per store:

- [`database/migrations/2026_08_20_000000_create_shop_schema.php:50-61`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/database/migrations/2026_08_20_000000_create_shop_schema.php:50)

Invitations also allow `owner`:

- [`app/Http/Requests/StoreInvitationRequest.php:22-27`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Requests/StoreInvitationRequest.php:22)

This conflicts with the security specification’s ownership-transfer and one-owner requirements.

## Medium-severity findings

### 13. Customer authentication redirects to `/login`, not `/account/login`

The application uses Laravel’s built-in `auth:customer` middleware and has no custom `CustomerAuthenticate` middleware or redirect configuration:

- [`routes/web.php:83-88`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/web.php:83)
- [`bootstrap/app.php:28-32`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/bootstrap/app.php:28)

Direct probing showed unauthenticated `/account/orders` redirects to `/login`, not `/account/login`, and the documented intended-URL behavior is not implemented.

### 14. Unauthenticated admin web requests return 403 instead of redirecting to `/admin/login`

`ResolveStore` runs before authentication and aborts with 403 when no admin store is resolved:

- [`bootstrap/app.php:15-18`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/bootstrap/app.php:15)
- [`app/Http/Middleware/ResolveStore.php:37-45`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Middleware/ResolveStore.php:37)

Direct probing of `/admin` returned `403`, contrary to the documented admin login flow.

### 15. Platform routes omit `store.resolve`

The platform API group uses `auth:sanctum`, ability checking, and throttling, but omits `store.resolve`:

- [`routes/api.php:33-36`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/api.php:33)

This differs from the documented admin API middleware stack. More importantly, `storeStore()` does not validate organization ownership before creating a store:

- [`app/Http/Controllers/Api/PlatformController.php:36-44`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/PlatformController.php:36)

### 16. Storefront checkout accepts inactive carts

Checkout creation loads a cart by ID but does not require `status = active`:

- [`app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontCheckoutController.php:25-39`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontCheckoutController.php:25)

The specification requires an active, non-empty cart.

### 17. Several storefront validation/error contracts differ

- Cart currency checks only three characters, not ISO 4217: [`app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontCartController.php:17-24`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontCartController.php:17)
- Country validation accepts any uppercase two-letter value, not ISO 3166-1: [`app/Http/Requests/SetCheckoutAddressRequest.php:47-60`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Requests/SetCheckoutAddressRequest.php:47)
- Discount codes allow 64 characters instead of 50: [`app/Http/Requests/ApplyDiscountRequest.php:22-25`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Requests/ApplyDiscountRequest.php:22)
- Invalid/expired discount failures return `422` uniformly instead of the specified `400` cases.
- Removing a discount always succeeds, rather than returning `404` when none is applied: [`app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontCheckoutController.php:94-100`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontCheckoutController.php:94)

### 18. Rate-limit key differs between the two specifications

The API-route specification requires `api.admin` to be keyed by Sanctum token ID; the security specification requires user ID/IP. The implementation uses user ID/IP:

- [`app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php:53-59`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php:53)

It matches `06-AUTH-AND-SECURITY.md`, but not `02-API-ROUTES.md`.

The Livewire login components also implement separate manual limiters (`admin-login|IP` and `customer-login|IP`) instead of using the documented `login` limiter:

- [`app/Livewire/Admin/Auth/Login.php:17-44`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Livewire/Admin/Auth/Login.php:17)
- [`app/Livewire/Storefront/Account/Auth/Login.php:19-52`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Livewire/Storefront/Account/Auth/Login.php:19)

### 19. API exceptions are not forced to JSON

The exception configuration is empty:

- [`bootstrap/app.php:34-36`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/bootstrap/app.php:34)

The API contract requires consistent JSON error responses. Some validation paths return JSON, but unhandled `404/403/500` responses can be HTML depending on request headers.

### 20. Payment encryption schema does not match the security contract

The specification requires `payments.raw_json` with an `encrypted:array` cast. The implementation uses `raw_json_encrypted` with an `encrypted` string cast and manually JSON-encodes the value:

- [`app/Models/Payment.php:10-18`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Models/Payment.php:10)
- [`app/Services/PaymentService.php:50-52`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/PaymentService.php:50)
- [`database/migrations/2026_08_20_000000_create_shop_schema.php:441`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/database/migrations/2026_08_20_000000_create_shop_schema.php:441)

### 21. Admin password storage still uses Laravel’s `password` column

The security specification requires `password_hash` and an overridden auth password accessor. `User` synchronizes both columns but authenticates through the default `password` attribute:

- [`app/Models/User.php:25-69`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Models/User.php:25)

`Customer` correctly overrides the auth password accessor; `User` does not.

### 22. Session/CORS/Sanctum production settings are not safely constrained

- `SESSION_SECURE_COOKIE` defaults to `null`, not explicitly secure: [`config/session.php:159-170`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/config/session.php:159)
- CORS defaults to wildcard origins while credentials are enabled: [`config/cors.php:4-12`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/config/cors.php:4)
- Sanctum stateful domains default to localhost values and do not include the tenant domains such as `shop.test`: [`config/sanctum.php:21-26`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/config/sanctum.php:21)

## Auditability finding

### 23. Required authentication/security audit events are missing

Only `ProductObserver` is registered. There are no listeners for login, failed login, logout, token creation/revocation, or equivalent customer authentication events:

- [`app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php:45-59`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php:45)

The logger schema also uses `subject_type`/`subject_id` and puts the event in the log message instead of recording the required structured `event`, `resource_type`, `resource_id`, `timestamp`, `store_id`, and `changes` fields:

- [`app/Services/AuditLogger.php:8-20`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/AuditLogger.php:8)

The main tenant scoping pattern for storefront carts, checkouts, orders, and admin resources is present, but the platform-token escalation, ownership invariant, and missing organization authorization are material tenant-isolation defects.


agent_nickname: Ramanujan

completed:
Read-only audit findings below. No files were edited. Browser verification was not used; findings are based on the repository, migrations, database schema, seeders, services, jobs, and tests. Current tests pass: **87 tests / 296 assertions**.

### Major

1. **Required database enum constraints are missing**

   Status/type/method columns are unrestricted strings; the required SQLite `CHECK` constraints are absent.

   Paths: `database/migrations/2026_08_20_000000_create_shop_schema.php`, compatibility migrations.

   Not covered by tests: no schema test inserts invalid enum values.

2. **Core schema contract mismatches remain**

   Examples:

   - `product_media.storage_key` nullable; status defaults to `ready` instead of `processing`.
   - `theme_files.storage_key` and `sha256` nullable.
   - Search JSON fields nullable without `[]` defaults.
   - `cart_lines.variant_id` and `checkouts.cart_id` use `RESTRICT`, not required `CASCADE`.
   - `refunds.payment_id` nullable with `SET NULL`, not required cascading FK.
   - Checkout/order/customer required fields differ from the specification.

   Paths: `database/migrations/2026_08_20_000000_create_shop_schema.php`, `database/migrations/2026_08_20_223045_add_remaining_schema_contract_columns.php`.

   Not covered by tests: no migration contract tests.

3. **OAuth and webhook schemas retain incompatible legacy contracts**

   OAuth `app_id`/`installation_id` fields are nullable and lack required foreign keys. Legacy token/hash and redirect URI columns remain alongside the specified fields.

   Webhook installation and delivery relationships are also nullable or missing required FKs.

   Paths: `database/migrations/2026_08_20_230144_add_remaining_spec_contract_fields.php`, `database/migrations/2026_08_20_234417_align_theme_settings_password_reset_and_webhook_contracts.php`.

4. **`order.paid` webhooks are never dispatched**

   `OrderPaid` is emitted, but `DispatchWebhooks` does not listen for it. The required `order.paid` subscription type therefore never receives deliveries.

   Paths: `app/Services/OrderService.php`, `app/Listeners/DispatchWebhooks.php`, `app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php`.

   Not covered by tests: webhook tests only exercise `order.created`.

5. **Webhook signature format conflicts with the specification**

   `DeliverWebhook` signs `timestamp.payload`; the specification requires the HMAC of the payload itself.

   Path: `app/Jobs/DeliverWebhook.php`.

   Not covered by tests: tests check that a signature exists, not its interoperability format.

6. **Required fulfillment and email side effects are missing**

   `FulfillmentService::create()` does not dispatch `FulfillmentCreated`. No customer notification handlers were found for order confirmation, refund, shipping, delivery, or cancellation emails.

   Paths: `app/Services/FulfillmentService.php`, `app/Events/`, `app/Listeners/`.

7. **Guest orders are not linked to customers**

   `OrderService::createFromCheckout()` copies `checkout.customer_id`; it does not find or create a customer by store and email.

   Path: `app/Services/OrderService.php`.

   Not covered by tests: guest checkout tests do not assert customer creation/linking.

8. **Checkout state transitions are not strictly enforced**

   `selectPaymentMethod()` checks address/rate fields but not the current state. `setAddress()` permits changes after payment selection.

   Path: `app/Services/CheckoutService.php`.

   Not covered by tests: no invalid-transition coverage.

9. **Automatic discounts are unsupported**

   `PricingEngine` only applies `checkout.discount_code`; it never evaluates or stacks active automatic discounts.

   Paths: `app/Services/PricingEngine.php`, `app/Services/DiscountService.php`.

10. **Tax provider selection and snapshots are incomplete**

    The application always binds `ManualTaxProvider`, ignores `tax_settings.provider`, and never stores `tax_provider_snapshot_json`.

    Paths: `app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php`, `app/Services/TaxCalculator.php`, `app/Services/PricingEngine.php`.

11. **Configurable expiration settings are ignored**

    - Cart cleanup hardcodes 14 days.
    - Bank-transfer cancellation uses global config instead of `store_settings.settings_json.bank_transfer_cancel_days`.
    - Checkout expiration uses `expires_at`, not the specified inactivity check.

    Paths: `app/Jobs/CleanupAbandonedCarts.php`, `app/Jobs/CancelUnpaidBankTransferOrders.php`, `app/Jobs/ExpireAbandonedCheckouts.php`.

12. **Analytics aggregation is incorrect**

    `visits_count` counts page-view rows instead of distinct sessions. Revenue/order metrics are not derived from `checkout_completed` event properties. Required analytics fields are nullable at ingestion.

    Paths: `app/Jobs/AggregateAnalytics.php`, `app/Services/AnalyticsService.php`, `app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontAnalyticsController.php`.

    Existing test coverage codifies the bug: `tests/Feature/SearchAnalyticsWebhookTest.php` expects two visits for two events from one session.

13. **Media processing violates required dimensions and paths**

    Current targets are 320/800/1600, omit `small`, do not create the specified predictable media paths, and do not generate WebP alongside the original.

    Paths: `app/Jobs/ProcessMediaUpload.php`, `app/Http/Controllers/Api/PlatformController.php`.

    Not covered by tests: media tests only check that files exist.

14. **Shipping matching and calculation are incorrect**

    `ShippingCalculator` treats empty zones as wildcards, does not tie-break by lowest zone ID, uses `price_amount` instead of flat-rate config, and returns `0` for unmatched ranges instead of unavailable/null.

    Path: `app/Services/ShippingCalculator.php`.

### Seed and test-data findings

15. **Four required seeders are empty**

    Paths:

    - `database/seeders/PageSeeder.php`
    - `database/seeders/NavigationSeeder.php`
    - `database/seeders/AnalyticsSeeder.php`
    - `database/seeders/SearchSettingsSeeder.php`

    `tests/Feature/SeedDataTest.php` does not verify any of them.

16. **Seeded catalog data does not match the specification**

    - Collections write `description`, not required `description_html`.
    - Product descriptions are generic generated text.
    - SKU patterns differ from the specified fixtures.
    - Draft `Unreleased Winter Jacket` has a non-null `published_at`.
    - `ShopSeeder` mutates `Limited Edition Sneakers` into an extra legacy product.

    Paths: `database/seeders/CollectionSeeder.php`, `database/seeders/ProductSeeder.php`, `database/seeders/ShopSeeder.php`.

17. **Variant and handle rules are incomplete**

    More than three product options are accepted. Existing variants can lack inventory after matrix rebuild. Handle collisions start at `-2`, skipping required `-1`.

    Paths: `app/Services/ProductService.php`, `app/Services/VariantMatrixService.php`, `app/Support/HandleGenerator.php`.

18. **Search does not implement the specified FTS behavior**

    It indexes `description` directly, does not order by FTS relevance, and applies prefix matching to every token instead of only the last token.

    Path: `app/Services/SearchService.php`.

19. **Factories produce incorrect or inconsistent fixtures**

    `PageFactory::archived()` creates draft pages; `CustomerFactory` stores marketing opt-in in metadata; analytics factories favor legacy payload fields; related factories can create cross-store parent/child records.

    Paths: `database/factories/PageFactory.php`, `CustomerFactory.php`, `AnalyticsEventFactory.php`, and related factories.


text:
Script completed
Wall time 0.0 seconds
Output:

text: [{"previous_status":{"completed":"Audit completed read-only; no files were edited.\n\nPublic routes returned HTTP 200, and protected admin routes correctly returned HTTP 403 unauthenticated. Authenticated browser flows could not be re-run: the in-app browser was unavailable and Playwright MCP was locked. Existing Boost browser logs still exposed concrete JavaScript failures.\n\n## Findings\n\n1. **High — Flux/Alpine runtime errors break interactions**\n\n   Latest browser logs show:\n\n   - `/login`: `fluxInputViewable is not defined`, followed by `Illegal invocation`. The failing control is the password visibility input in [resources/views/livewire/auth/login.blade.php:25](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/livewire/auth/login.blade.php:25).\n   - `/admin/settings`: `fluxModal is not defined` when opening the Add Domain modal in [resources/views/livewire/admin/settings/domains.blade.php:2](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/livewire/admin/settings/domains.blade.php:2).\n\n   These prevent expected login/password visibility and domain-modal interactions.\n\n2. **High — The planned Playwright acceptance suite is absent**\n\n   Spec 08 defines 18 browser test files and 143 tests, but:\n\n   - `tests/Browser/` does not exist.\n   - `.env.testing` does not exist.\n   - `composer.json` does not include `pestphp/pest-plugin-browser`.\n   - [phpunit.xml:8-15](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/phpunit.xml:8) only registers Unit and Feature suites.\n\n   This leaves the specified browser acceptance matrix unimplemented. See [specs/08-PLAYWRIGHT-E2E-PLAN.md:11](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/specs/08-PLAYWRIGHT-E2E-PLAN.md:11).\n\n3. **Major — Admin shell is missing required navigation and account interactions**\n\n   [resources/views/layouts/admin.blade.php:8](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/layouts/admin.blade.php:8) hardcodes the complete shell. Missing or incomplete criteria include:\n\n   - sidebar grouping, separators, active route state, and `aria-current`;\n   - store switcher;\n   - notifications/unread count;\n   - profile dropdown with settings/logout;\n   - reusable Sidebar/TopBar Livewire components;\n   - breadcrumbs on pages;\n   - typed, stacked toasts with the specified duration.\n\n   The spec requires these in [specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md:130](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md:130) and [specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md:2292](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md:2292).\n\n4. **Major — Admin product listing and CRUD are substantially incomplete**\n\n   The component [app/Livewire/Admin/Products/Index.php:12](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Livewire/Admin/Products/Index.php:12) lacks sorting, pagination handling, bulk delete, bulk activate, and bulk confirmation actions.\n\n   The view [resources/views/livewire/admin/products/index.blade.php:9](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/livewire/admin/products/index.blade.php:9) lacks the specified sortable columns, product images/type/vendor data, proper status badges, filtered-empty state, loading state, and bulk actions.\n\n   The form [app/Livewire/Admin/Products/Form.php:12](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Livewire/Admin/Products/Form.php:12) and [resources/views/livewire/admin/products/form.blade.php:1](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/livewire/admin/products/form.blade.php:1) only support basic title, description, vendor, type, price, status, and one default variant. Media, options, variant generation, collections, SEO, publishing, reorder/remove media, and delete-product flows are absent. See [specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md:345](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md:345) and [specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md:464](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md:464).\n\n5. **Major — Dashboard does not meet the specified analytics UI**\n\n   [app/Livewire/Admin/Dashboard.php:13](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Livewire/Admin/Dashboard.php:13) only supports a simple 7/30/90 range. [resources/views/livewire/admin/dashboard.blade.php:8](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/livewire/admin/dashboard.blade.php:8) lacks custom date selection, KPI trend percentages, the required daily order-count chart, and the specified funnel states. It renders CSS bars instead of the planned chart implementation. See [specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md:202](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md:202).\n\n6. **Major — Storefront global layout fails several responsive/theme criteria**\n\n   [resources/views/layouts/storefront.blade.php:3](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/layouts/storefront.blade.php:3) has:\n\n   - hardcoded `lang=\"en\"` and page-independent title;\n   - hardcoded navigation/footer instead of configured menus;\n   - no mobile navigation drawer;\n   - search rendered as a normal link rather than a header modal trigger;\n   - no cart item-count badge;\n   - no announcement dismissal/configuration;\n   - no storefront dark-mode control;\n   - no configured logo/social/payment/address content.\n\n   These contradict [specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md:92](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md:92).\n\n7. **Major — Home page is hardcoded rather than theme/configuration driven**\n\n   [app/Livewire/Storefront/Home.php:19](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Livewire/Storefront/Home.php:19) hardcodes collection/product queries and section counts. [resources/views/livewire/storefront/home.blade.php:2](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/livewire/storefront/home.blade.php:2) hardcodes hero copy, has no configurable hero media/rich-text sections, and the newsletter form posts to `#` without Livewire validation, success, error, or loading behavior. See [specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md:237](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md:237).\n\n8. **Major — Collection and product browsing omit required commerce interactions**\n\n   Collections:\n\n   - [app/Livewire/Storefront/Collections/Show.php:10](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Livewire/Storefront/Collections/Show.php:10) has only sort and in-stock filtering, with no price/type/vendor filters or pagination.\n   - [resources/views/livewire/storefront/collections/show.blade.php:8](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/livewire/storefront/collections/show.blade.php:8) lacks filter drawers, active filter pills, pagination, and loading states.\n   - [resources/views/components/storefront/product-card.blade.php:1](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/components/storefront/product-card.blade.php:1) lacks secondary images and quick-add/choose-options behavior.\n\n   Product detail:\n\n   - thumbnails in [resources/views/livewire/storefront/products/show.blade.php:6](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/livewire/storefront/products/show.blade.php:6) are not selectable;\n   - stock messaging lacks “In stock” / “Only X left in stock” states;\n   - quantity controls have no increment/decrement buttons or max enforcement;\n   - tags, product breadcrumbs, and configurable currency are missing.\n\n   These map to [specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md:376](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md:376) and [specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md:555](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md:555).\n\n9. **Major — Cart drawer is not functionally usable for checkout**\n\n   [app/Livewire/Storefront/CartDrawer.php:16](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Livewire/Storefront/CartDrawer.php:16) only opens, closes, and refreshes. [resources/views/livewire/storefront/cart-drawer.blade.php:4](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/livewire/storefront/cart-drawer.blade.php:4) lacks quantity controls, remove actions, discount entry, total breakdown, and a Checkout button. It also lacks focus trapping, focus restoration, and body scroll locking required by [specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md:746](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md:746).\n\n10. **Medium — Required seeded acceptance data is not guaranteed**\n\n   These seeders are effectively empty:\n\n   - [database/seeders/NavigationSeeder.php:14](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/database/seeders/NavigationSeeder.php:14)\n   - [database/seeders/AnalyticsSeeder.php:14](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/database/seeders/AnalyticsSeeder.php:14)\n   - [database/seeders/SearchSettingsSeeder.php:14](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/database/seeders/SearchSettingsSeeder.php:14)\n\n   Fresh test data therefore cannot reliably satisfy the navigation, analytics, and search prerequisites described in Spec 08.\n\nNo files were modified during the audit."}},{"previous_status":{"completed":"Read-only audit completed. No files were modified. Browser verification was unavailable; findings are based on route listing, source/config/schema inspection, and direct HTTP probes.\n\n## Route coverage\n\n- Storefront API: all documented paths exist in [`routes/api.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/api.php:13).\n- Admin API: all documented paths exist, including exports at [`routes/api.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/api.php:78).\n- OAuth endpoints exist and return `501`, matching the specification’s explicit deferral.\n- Inbound webhooks are correctly absent.\n- App API endpoints are absent; this is acceptable only while the specification’s OAuth/app deferral remains in effect.\n\n## Critical findings\n\n### 1. Any store admin can mint a platform-superuser token\n\n`manage-platform` is available in the token-creation UI, and token creation is authorized for any store owner/admin:\n\n- [`app/Livewire/Admin/Developers/Index.php:27-52`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Livewire/Admin/Developers/Index.php:27)\n- [`app/Http/Controllers/Api/PlatformController.php:24-44`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/PlatformController.php:24)\n\nThe specification reserves `manage-platform` for super-admin/platform management. A store admin can therefore create a token that creates organizations/stores outside the current tenant.\n\n### 2. Customer password-reset POST routes use Fortify’s admin `users` broker\n\nFortify enables global reset/registration routes:\n\n- [`config/fortify.php:146-155`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/config/fortify.php:146)\n- [`app/Actions/Fortify/ResetUserPassword.php:19-27`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Actions/Fortify/ResetUserPassword.php:19)\n\nThe documented customer reset flow requires the `customers` broker and `customer_password_reset_tokens`, scoped to the current store. The custom Livewire component does this correctly, but the documented `POST /forgot-password` and `POST /reset-password` endpoints are intercepted by Fortify and use the admin user broker.\n\n### 3. Public global registration creates unscoped admin users\n\nFortify’s registration feature is enabled and `CreateNewUser` creates an admin `User` without store membership:\n\n- [`config/fortify.php:146-149`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/config/fortify.php:146)\n- [`app/Actions/Fortify/CreateNewUser.php:20-31`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Actions/Fortify/CreateNewUser.php:20)\n\nThe specification defines customer registration at `/account/register`, not public admin registration.\n\n## High-severity findings\n\n### 4. API role enforcement does not match the permission matrix\n\nThe base admin API group permits every role, then several routes fail to narrow permissions:\n\n- Product archive allows staff, but only owner/admin may archive: [`routes/api.php:48`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/api.php:48)\n- Collection deletion permits support/staff through the base group: [`routes/api.php:51-54`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/api.php:51)\n- Discount updates permit support: [`routes/api.php:58-61`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/api.php:58)\n- Shipping/tax reads permit support, although only owner/admin may access settings: [`routes/api.php:62-67`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/api.php:62)\n- Page listing permits support, although page access is owner/admin/staff: [`routes/api.php:68-71`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/api.php:68)\n- Analytics permits support, although analytics is owner/admin/staff: [`routes/api.php:77`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/api.php:77)\n- Search settings use the general role group and are not restricted to owner/admin: [`routes/api.php:75-76`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/api.php:75)\n\n### 5. Policies/gates are not actually wired as specified\n\nNo required gates are registered in `AppServiceProvider`, and write requests often authorize using read policies:\n\n- [`app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php:45-59`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php:45)\n- [`app/Http/Requests/CreateFulfillmentRequest.php:14-17`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Requests/CreateFulfillmentRequest.php:14)\n- [`app/Http/Requests/CreateRefundRequest.php:14-17`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Requests/CreateRefundRequest.php:14)\n\nThe API controllers generally use route middleware instead of `$this->authorize(...)` on the target model, contrary to the documented authorization contract.\n\n### 6. Checkout payment response and failure contract are incorrect\n\nThe payment endpoint omits documented fields such as `checkout_id`, checkout status, payment method, currency, and bank-transfer instructions. Declines are collapsed to generic `payment_failed` instead of the required `card_declined` and `insufficient_funds` codes/messages:\n\n- [`app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontCheckoutController.php:103-126`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontCheckoutController.php:103)\n- Failure causes are generated distinctly in [`app/Services/MockPaymentProvider.php:22-29`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/MockPaymentProvider.php:22)\n\n### 7. Storefront order access returns the wrong status and schema\n\nInvalid or missing HMAC tokens return `404`; the specification requires `401`. The response is wrapped in `data` and omits documented order fields, nested totals, billing address, variant/ SKU snapshots, and detailed line totals:\n\n- [`app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontOrderController.php:14-20`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontOrderController.php:14)\n\n### 8. Theme API does not implement the documented upload contract\n\nThe specification requires a required ZIP upload, max 50 MB, structure validation, optional name, and `settings_json`. The implementation instead accepts JSON fields, requires `name`, does not process an archive, and expects `settings`:\n\n- [`app/Http/Requests/StoreThemeRequest.php:22-25`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Requests/StoreThemeRequest.php:22)\n- [`app/Http/Requests/UpdateThemeSettingsRequest.php:22-25`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Requests/UpdateThemeSettingsRequest.php:22)\n- [`app/Http/Controllers/Api/AdminController.php:303-329`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/AdminController.php:303)\n\nPublishing also does not set `published_at`.\n\n### 9. Tax and shipping request contracts are wrong\n\n- Shipping zones do not require at least one valid ISO country: [`app/Http/Requests/StoreShippingZoneRequest.php:22-25`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Requests/StoreShippingZoneRequest.php:22)\n- Shipping rates require undocumented `price_amount` and `currency`, while `config_json` is optional: [`app/Http/Requests/StoreShippingRateRequest.php:22-25`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Requests/StoreShippingRateRequest.php:22)\n- Tax settings accept legacy optional fields and do not validate required `mode`, conditional `provider`, `prices_include_tax`, or `config_json`: [`app/Http/Requests/UpdateTaxSettingsRequest.php:22-25`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Requests/UpdateTaxSettingsRequest.php:22)\n\n### 10. Admin analytics and search responses do not match the specification\n\nAnalytics does not require/validate `from`, `to`, max 365 days, or `granularity`, and returns a different sparse schema:\n\n- [`app/Http/Controllers/Api/AdminController.php:347-353`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/AdminController.php:347)\n\nSearch accepts an empty/missing query, lacks documented filters/sorting/facets, and returns a different response shape. Suggestions require minimum length 2 instead of 1 and omit collection/image/price data:\n\n- [`app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontSearchController.php:14-27`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontSearchController.php:14)\n\n### 11. Analytics ingestion accepts invalid events and wrong limits\n\nThe documented contract requires 1–50 events, exact event types, required IDs, max length 100, property depth, and timestamps within ±1 hour. Current validation allows 1–100 events, nullable IDs, arbitrary types, and nullable timestamps:\n\n- [`app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontAnalyticsController.php:14-35`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontAnalyticsController.php:14)\n\nInvalid event types can reach service code and become server errors rather than `422`.\n\n### 12. Owner invariant is not enforced\n\nThe schema has no database constraint ensuring exactly one owner per store:\n\n- [`database/migrations/2026_08_20_000000_create_shop_schema.php:50-61`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/database/migrations/2026_08_20_000000_create_shop_schema.php:50)\n\nInvitations also allow `owner`:\n\n- [`app/Http/Requests/StoreInvitationRequest.php:22-27`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Requests/StoreInvitationRequest.php:22)\n\nThis conflicts with the security specification’s ownership-transfer and one-owner requirements.\n\n## Medium-severity findings\n\n### 13. Customer authentication redirects to `/login`, not `/account/login`\n\nThe application uses Laravel’s built-in `auth:customer` middleware and has no custom `CustomerAuthenticate` middleware or redirect configuration:\n\n- [`routes/web.php:83-88`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/web.php:83)\n- [`bootstrap/app.php:28-32`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/bootstrap/app.php:28)\n\nDirect probing showed unauthenticated `/account/orders` redirects to `/login`, not `/account/login`, and the documented intended-URL behavior is not implemented.\n\n### 14. Unauthenticated admin web requests return 403 instead of redirecting to `/admin/login`\n\n`ResolveStore` runs before authentication and aborts with 403 when no admin store is resolved:\n\n- [`bootstrap/app.php:15-18`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/bootstrap/app.php:15)\n- [`app/Http/Middleware/ResolveStore.php:37-45`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Middleware/ResolveStore.php:37)\n\nDirect probing of `/admin` returned `403`, contrary to the documented admin login flow.\n\n### 15. Platform routes omit `store.resolve`\n\nThe platform API group uses `auth:sanctum`, ability checking, and throttling, but omits `store.resolve`:\n\n- [`routes/api.php:33-36`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/api.php:33)\n\nThis differs from the documented admin API middleware stack. More importantly, `storeStore()` does not validate organization ownership before creating a store:\n\n- [`app/Http/Controllers/Api/PlatformController.php:36-44`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/PlatformController.php:36)\n\n### 16. Storefront checkout accepts inactive carts\n\nCheckout creation loads a cart by ID but does not require `status = active`:\n\n- [`app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontCheckoutController.php:25-39`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontCheckoutController.php:25)\n\nThe specification requires an active, non-empty cart.\n\n### 17. Several storefront validation/error contracts differ\n\n- Cart currency checks only three characters, not ISO 4217: [`app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontCartController.php:17-24`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontCartController.php:17)\n- Country validation accepts any uppercase two-letter value, not ISO 3166-1: [`app/Http/Requests/SetCheckoutAddressRequest.php:47-60`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Requests/SetCheckoutAddressRequest.php:47)\n- Discount codes allow 64 characters instead of 50: [`app/Http/Requests/ApplyDiscountRequest.php:22-25`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Requests/ApplyDiscountRequest.php:22)\n- Invalid/expired discount failures return `422` uniformly instead of the specified `400` cases.\n- Removing a discount always succeeds, rather than returning `404` when none is applied: [`app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontCheckoutController.php:94-100`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontCheckoutController.php:94)\n\n### 18. Rate-limit key differs between the two specifications\n\nThe API-route specification requires `api.admin` to be keyed by Sanctum token ID; the security specification requires user ID/IP. The implementation uses user ID/IP:\n\n- [`app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php:53-59`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php:53)\n\nIt matches `06-AUTH-AND-SECURITY.md`, but not `02-API-ROUTES.md`.\n\nThe Livewire login components also implement separate manual limiters (`admin-login|IP` and `customer-login|IP`) instead of using the documented `login` limiter:\n\n- [`app/Livewire/Admin/Auth/Login.php:17-44`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Livewire/Admin/Auth/Login.php:17)\n- [`app/Livewire/Storefront/Account/Auth/Login.php:19-52`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Livewire/Storefront/Account/Auth/Login.php:19)\n\n### 19. API exceptions are not forced to JSON\n\nThe exception configuration is empty:\n\n- [`bootstrap/app.php:34-36`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/bootstrap/app.php:34)\n\nThe API contract requires consistent JSON error responses. Some validation paths return JSON, but unhandled `404/403/500` responses can be HTML depending on request headers.\n\n### 20. Payment encryption schema does not match the security contract\n\nThe specification requires `payments.raw_json` with an `encrypted:array` cast. The implementation uses `raw_json_encrypted` with an `encrypted` string cast and manually JSON-encodes the value:\n\n- [`app/Models/Payment.php:10-18`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Models/Payment.php:10)\n- [`app/Services/PaymentService.php:50-52`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/PaymentService.php:50)\n- [`database/migrations/2026_08_20_000000_create_shop_schema.php:441`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/database/migrations/2026_08_20_000000_create_shop_schema.php:441)\n\n### 21. Admin password storage still uses Laravel’s `password` column\n\nThe security specification requires `password_hash` and an overridden auth password accessor. `User` synchronizes both columns but authenticates through the default `password` attribute:\n\n- [`app/Models/User.php:25-69`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Models/User.php:25)\n\n`Customer` correctly overrides the auth password accessor; `User` does not.\n\n### 22. Session/CORS/Sanctum production settings are not safely constrained\n\n- `SESSION_SECURE_COOKIE` defaults to `null`, not explicitly secure: [`config/session.php:159-170`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/config/session.php:159)\n- CORS defaults to wildcard origins while credentials are enabled: [`config/cors.php:4-12`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/config/cors.php:4)\n- Sanctum stateful domains default to localhost values and do not include the tenant domains such as `shop.test`: [`config/sanctum.php:21-26`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/config/sanctum.php:21)\n\n## Auditability finding\n\n### 23. Required authentication/security audit events are missing\n\nOnly `ProductObserver` is registered. There are no listeners for login, failed login, logout, token creation/revocation, or equivalent customer authentication events:\n\n- [`app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php:45-59`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php:45)\n\nThe logger schema also uses `subject_type`/`subject_id` and puts the event in the log message instead of recording the required structured `event`, `resource_type`, `resource_id`, `timestamp`, `store_id`, and `changes` fields:\n\n- [`app/Services/AuditLogger.php:8-20`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/AuditLogger.php:8)\n\nThe main tenant scoping pattern for storefront carts, checkouts, orders, and admin resources is present, but the platform-token escalation, ownership invariant, and missing organization authorization are material tenant-isolation defects."}},{"previous_status":{"completed":"Read-only audit findings below. No files were edited. Browser verification was not used; findings are based on the repository, migrations, database schema, seeders, services, jobs, and tests. Current tests pass: **87 tests / 296 assertions**.\n\n### Major\n\n1. **Required database enum constraints are missing**\n\n   Status/type/method columns are unrestricted strings; the required SQLite `CHECK` constraints are absent.\n\n   Paths: `database/migrations/2026_08_20_000000_create_shop_schema.php`, compatibility migrations.\n\n   Not covered by tests: no schema test inserts invalid enum values.\n\n2. **Core schema contract mismatches remain**\n\n   Examples:\n\n   - `product_media.storage_key` nullable; status defaults to `ready` instead of `processing`.\n   - `theme_files.storage_key` and `sha256` nullable.\n   - Search JSON fields nullable without `[]` defaults.\n   - `cart_lines.variant_id` and `checkouts.cart_id` use `RESTRICT`, not required `CASCADE`.\n   - `refunds.payment_id` nullable with `SET NULL`, not required cascading FK.\n   - Checkout/order/customer required fields differ from the specification.\n\n   Paths: `database/migrations/2026_08_20_000000_create_shop_schema.php`, `database/migrations/2026_08_20_223045_add_remaining_schema_contract_columns.php`.\n\n   Not covered by tests: no migration contract tests.\n\n3. **OAuth and webhook schemas retain incompatible legacy contracts**\n\n   OAuth `app_id`/`installation_id` fields are nullable and lack required foreign keys. Legacy token/hash and redirect URI columns remain alongside the specified fields.\n\n   Webhook installation and delivery relationships are also nullable or missing required FKs.\n\n   Paths: `database/migrations/2026_08_20_230144_add_remaining_spec_contract_fields.php`, `database/migrations/2026_08_20_234417_align_theme_settings_password_reset_and_webhook_contracts.php`.\n\n4. **`order.paid` webhooks are never dispatched**\n\n   `OrderPaid` is emitted, but `DispatchWebhooks` does not listen for it. The required `order.paid` subscription type therefore never receives deliveries.\n\n   Paths: `app/Services/OrderService.php`, `app/Listeners/DispatchWebhooks.php`, `app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php`.\n\n   Not covered by tests: webhook tests only exercise `order.created`.\n\n5. **Webhook signature format conflicts with the specification**\n\n   `DeliverWebhook` signs `timestamp.payload`; the specification requires the HMAC of the payload itself.\n\n   Path: `app/Jobs/DeliverWebhook.php`.\n\n   Not covered by tests: tests check that a signature exists, not its interoperability format.\n\n6. **Required fulfillment and email side effects are missing**\n\n   `FulfillmentService::create()` does not dispatch `FulfillmentCreated`. No customer notification handlers were found for order confirmation, refund, shipping, delivery, or cancellation emails.\n\n   Paths: `app/Services/FulfillmentService.php`, `app/Events/`, `app/Listeners/`.\n\n7. **Guest orders are not linked to customers**\n\n   `OrderService::createFromCheckout()` copies `checkout.customer_id`; it does not find or create a customer by store and email.\n\n   Path: `app/Services/OrderService.php`.\n\n   Not covered by tests: guest checkout tests do not assert customer creation/linking.\n\n8. **Checkout state transitions are not strictly enforced**\n\n   `selectPaymentMethod()` checks address/rate fields but not the current state. `setAddress()` permits changes after payment selection.\n\n   Path: `app/Services/CheckoutService.php`.\n\n   Not covered by tests: no invalid-transition coverage.\n\n9. **Automatic discounts are unsupported**\n\n   `PricingEngine` only applies `checkout.discount_code`; it never evaluates or stacks active automatic discounts.\n\n   Paths: `app/Services/PricingEngine.php`, `app/Services/DiscountService.php`.\n\n10. **Tax provider selection and snapshots are incomplete**\n\n    The application always binds `ManualTaxProvider`, ignores `tax_settings.provider`, and never stores `tax_provider_snapshot_json`.\n\n    Paths: `app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php`, `app/Services/TaxCalculator.php`, `app/Services/PricingEngine.php`.\n\n11. **Configurable expiration settings are ignored**\n\n    - Cart cleanup hardcodes 14 days.\n    - Bank-transfer cancellation uses global config instead of `store_settings.settings_json.bank_transfer_cancel_days`.\n    - Checkout expiration uses `expires_at`, not the specified inactivity check.\n\n    Paths: `app/Jobs/CleanupAbandonedCarts.php`, `app/Jobs/CancelUnpaidBankTransferOrders.php`, `app/Jobs/ExpireAbandonedCheckouts.php`.\n\n12. **Analytics aggregation is incorrect**\n\n    `visits_count` counts page-view rows instead of distinct sessions. Revenue/order metrics are not derived from `checkout_completed` event properties. Required analytics fields are nullable at ingestion.\n\n    Paths: `app/Jobs/AggregateAnalytics.php`, `app/Services/AnalyticsService.php`, `app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontAnalyticsController.php`.\n\n    Existing test coverage codifies the bug: `tests/Feature/SearchAnalyticsWebhookTest.php` expects two visits for two events from one session.\n\n13. **Media processing violates required dimensions and paths**\n\n    Current targets are 320/800/1600, omit `small`, do not create the specified predictable media paths, and do not generate WebP alongside the original.\n\n    Paths: `app/Jobs/ProcessMediaUpload.php`, `app/Http/Controllers/Api/PlatformController.php`.\n\n    Not covered by tests: media tests only check that files exist.\n\n14. **Shipping matching and calculation are incorrect**\n\n    `ShippingCalculator` treats empty zones as wildcards, does not tie-break by lowest zone ID, uses `price_amount` instead of flat-rate config, and returns `0` for unmatched ranges instead of unavailable/null.\n\n    Path: `app/Services/ShippingCalculator.php`.\n\n### Seed and test-data findings\n\n15. **Four required seeders are empty**\n\n    Paths:\n\n    - `database/seeders/PageSeeder.php`\n    - `database/seeders/NavigationSeeder.php`\n    - `database/seeders/AnalyticsSeeder.php`\n    - `database/seeders/SearchSettingsSeeder.php`\n\n    `tests/Feature/SeedDataTest.php` does not verify any of them.\n\n16. **Seeded catalog data does not match the specification**\n\n    - Collections write `description`, not required `description_html`.\n    - Product descriptions are generic generated text.\n    - SKU patterns differ from the specified fixtures.\n    - Draft `Unreleased Winter Jacket` has a non-null `published_at`.\n    - `ShopSeeder` mutates `Limited Edition Sneakers` into an extra legacy product.\n\n    Paths: `database/seeders/CollectionSeeder.php`, `database/seeders/ProductSeeder.php`, `database/seeders/ShopSeeder.php`.\n\n17. **Variant and handle rules are incomplete**\n\n    More than three product options are accepted. Existing variants can lack inventory after matrix rebuild. Handle collisions start at `-2`, skipping required `-1`.\n\n    Paths: `app/Services/ProductService.php`, `app/Services/VariantMatrixService.php`, `app/Support/HandleGenerator.php`.\n\n18. **Search does not implement the specified FTS behavior**\n\n    It indexes `description` directly, does not order by FTS relevance, and applies prefix matching to every token instead of only the last token.\n\n    Path: `app/Services/SearchService.php`.\n\n19. **Factories produce incorrect or inconsistent fixtures**\n\n    `PageFactory::archived()` creates draft pages; `CustomerFactory` stores marketing opt-in in metadata; analytics factories favor legacy payload fields; related factories can create cross-store parent/child records.\n\n    Paths: `database/factories/PageFactory.php`, `CustomerFactory.php`, `AnalyticsEventFactory.php`, and related factories.\n\n"}}]


status: completed

input:
const r = await tools.exec_command({cmd:"sed -n '846,950p' specs/02-API-ROUTES.md; sed -n '1020,1165p' specs/02-API-ROUTES.md; sed -n '1230,1395p' specs/02-API-ROUTES.md; sed -n '2260,2785p' specs/02-API-ROUTES.md","workdir":"/Users/wesner/Herd/shop","yield_time_ms":10000,"max_output_tokens":50000});
text(r.output);