text:
Script completed
Wall time 0.1 seconds
Output:

text: .ai/rules absent

text:
---
name: laravel-best-practices
description: "Apply this skill whenever writing, reviewing, or refactoring Laravel PHP code. This includes creating or modifying controllers, models, migrations, form requests, policies, jobs, scheduled commands, service classes, and Eloquent queries. Triggers for N+1 and query performance issues, caching strategies, authorization and security patterns, validation, error handling, queue and job configuration, route definitions, and architectural decisions. Also use for Laravel code reviews and refactoring existing Laravel code to follow best practices. Covers any task involving Laravel backend PHP code patterns."
license: MIT
metadata:
  author: laravel
---

# Laravel Best Practices

Best practices for Laravel, organized as an index of rule files. Each rule file teaches what to do and why. For exact API syntax, verify with `search-docs`.

## Consistency First

Before applying any rule, check what the application already does. Laravel offers multiple valid approaches, and the best choice is the one the codebase already uses, even if another pattern would be theoretically better. Inconsistency is worse than a suboptimal pattern.

Check sibling files, related controllers, models, or tests for established patterns. If one exists, follow it. Don't introduce a second way. These rules are defaults for when no pattern exists yet, not overrides.

## How to Apply

1. Check the changed files, nearby code, project configuration, and relevant tests for established patterns. Deviate only for a correctness or security defect, and call the deviation out.
2. Map every affected concern to the rule index below. Read each mapped rule file before editing. Skip unrelated rule files.
3. Make the smallest coherent change. Keep the application's architecture and naming instead of introducing a second pattern for the same job.
4. Verify version-sensitive Laravel APIs for the installed version with `search-docs`, or inspect the installed framework when it is unavailable.
5. Run the narrowest relevant tests first, then the project's formatting and static-analysis checks when the change warrants them.
6. Re-read the diff against every mapped rule before finishing.

## Rule Index

Cross-cutting changes often need more than one rule file.

| Concern | Read |
| --- | --- |
| Query count, eager loading, indexes, large datasets | [`rules/db-performance.md`](rules/db-performance.md) |
| Subqueries, aggregates, complex ordering and query plans | [`rules/advanced-queries.md`](rules/advanced-queries.md) |
| Models, relationships, scopes, casts | [`rules/eloquent.md`](rules/eloquent.md) |
| Authentication, authorization, input safety, secrets, uploads | [`rules/security.md`](rules/security.md) |
| Form Requests and validation rules | [`rules/validation.md`](rules/validation.md) |
| Controllers, route binding, resources, middleware | [`rules/routing.md`](rules/routing.md) |
| Schema changes, columns, foreign keys, indexes | [`rules/migrations.md`](rules/migrations.md) |
| Jobs, retries, uniqueness, batches, Horizon | [`rules/queue-jobs.md`](rules/queue-jobs.md) |
| Cache lifetime, invalidation, locks, memoization | [`rules/caching.md`](rules/caching.md) |
| Outbound requests, retries, timeouts, fakes | [`rules/http-client.md`](rules/http-client.md) |
| Exceptions, reporting, rendering, log context | [`rules/error-handling.md`](rules/error-handling.md) |
| Events and notifications | [`rules/events-notifications.md`](rules/events-notifications.md) |
| Mailables and mail assertions | [`rules/mail.md`](rules/mail.md) |
| Scheduled tasks and overlap protection | [`rules/scheduling.md`](rules/scheduling.md) |
| Collections, lazy iteration, bulk operations | [`rules/collections.md`](rules/collections.md) |
| Blade components, attributes, composers | [`rules/blade-views.md`](rules/blade-views.md) |
| Environment values and application configuration | [`rules/config.md`](rules/config.md) |
| Pest/PHPUnit patterns, factories, fakes | [`rules/testing.md`](rules/testing.md) |
| Naming, helpers, file boundaries, PHP style | [`rules/style.md`](rules/style.md) |
| Actions, services, dependencies, application structure | [`rules/architecture.md`](rules/architecture.md) |

## Decision Rules

- Prefer framework features and existing application abstractions over new helpers or dependencies.
- Avoid speculative abstractions. Extract code when it creates a clear domain boundary, removes meaningful duplication, or makes behavior independently testable.
- Keep database access out of Blade views and prevent hidden N+1 queries across controllers, resources, jobs, and serialization.

text:
---
name: livewire-development
description: "Use for any task or question involving Livewire. Activate if user mentions Livewire, wire: directives, or Livewire-specific concepts like wire:model, wire:click, wire:sort, or islands, invoke this skill. Covers building new components, debugging reactivity issues, real-time form validation, drag-and-drop, loading states, migrating from Livewire 3 to 4, converting component formats (SFC/MFC/class-based), and performance optimization. Do not use for non-Livewire reactive UI (React, Vue, Alpine-only, Inertia.js) or standard Laravel forms without Livewire."
license: MIT
metadata:
  author: laravel
---

# Livewire Development

## Documentation

Use `search-docs` for detailed Livewire 4 patterns and documentation.

## Basic Usage

### Creating Components

```bash

# Single-file component (SFC - default in v4)

# Creates: resources/views/components/⚡create-post.blade.php

php artisan make:livewire create-post

# Page component (SFC - Full Page in v4)

# Creates: resources/views/pages/⚡create-post.blade.php

php artisan make:livewire pages::create-post

# Multi-file component (MFC)

# Creates: resources/views/components/⚡create-post/create-post.php

#          resources/views/components/⚡create-post/create-post.blade.php

php artisan make:livewire create-post --mfc

# Class-based component (v3 style)

# Creates: app/Livewire/CreatePost.php AND resources/views/livewire/create-post.blade.php

php artisan make:livewire create-post --class

# With namespace

php artisan make:livewire Posts/CreatePost
```

### Converting Between Formats

Use `php artisan livewire:convert create-post` to convert between single-file, multi-file, and class-based formats.

### Choosing a Component Format

> **Always follow the project's existing conventions first.** Before creating any component, inspect the project's existing Livewire components to determine the established format (SFC, MFC, or class-based) and directory structure. Check `app/Livewire/`, `resources/views/components/`, and `resources/views/livewire/` for existing components. If the project already uses a consistent format, **use that same format** — even if it differs from the Livewire v4 defaults below. Only fall back to the v4 defaults (SFC in `resources/views/components/`) when no existing convention is established.

Also check `config/livewire.php` for `make_command.type`, `make_command.emoji`, `component_locations`, and `component_namespaces` overrides, which change the default format and where files are stored.

### Component Format Reference

| Format | Flag | Class Path | View Path |
|--------|------|------------|-----------|
| Single-file (SFC) | default | — | `resources/views/components/⚡create-post.blade.php` (PHP + Blade in one file) |
| Full Page SFC | `pages::name` | — | `resources/views/pages/⚡create-post.blade.php` |
| Multi-file (MFC) | `--mfc` | `resources/views/components/⚡create-post/create-post.php` | `resources/views/components/⚡create-post/create-post.blade.php` |
| Class-based | `--class` | `app/Livewire/CreatePost.php` | `resources/views/livewire/create-post.blade.php` |
| View-based | default (Blade-only) | — | `resources/views/components/⚡create-post.blade.php` (Blade-only with functional state) |

> **Important:** The ⚡ prefix shown above is the **default** behavior in Livewire v4 — it is **configurable**. Check `config/livewire.php` for the `make_command.emoji` setting. When `true` (default), always include the ⚡ prefix in filenames you create. When `false`, omit the ⚡ prefix from all paths above.

Namespaced components map to subdirectories: `make:livewire Posts/CreatePost` creates `resources/views/components/posts/⚡create-post.blade.php` (single-file by default). Use `make:livewire Posts/CreatePost --mfc` for multi-file output at `resources/views/components/posts/⚡create-post/create-post.php` and `resources/views/components/posts/⚡create-post/create-post.blade.php`.

### Single-File Component Example

<!-- Single-File Component Example -->
```php
<?php
use Livewire\Component;

new class extends Component {
    public int $count = 0;

    public function increment(): void
    {
        $this->count++;
    }
};
?>

<div>
    <button wire:click="increment">Count: @{{ $count }}</button>
</div>
```

## Livewire 4 Specifics

### Key Changes From Livewire 3

These things changed in Livewire 4, but may not have been updated in this application. Verify this application's setup to ensure you follow existing conventions.

- Use `Route::livewire()` for full-page components (e.g., `Route::livewire('/posts/create', CreatePost::class)`); config keys renamed: `layout` → `component_layout`, `lazy_placeholder` → `component_placeholder`.
- `wire:model` now ignores child events by default (use `wire:model.deep` for old behavior); `wire:scroll` renamed to `wire:navigate:scroll`.
- Component tags must be properly closed; `wire:transition` now uses View Transitions API (modifiers removed).
- JavaScript: `$wire.$js('name', fn)` → `$wire.$js.name = fn`; `commit`/`request` hooks → `interceptMessage()`/`interceptRequest()`.

### New Features

- Component formats: single-file (SFC), multi-file (MFC), view-based components.
- Islands (`@island`) for isolated updates; async actions (`wire:click.async`, `#[Async]`) for parallel execution.
- Deferred/bundled loading: `defer`, `lazy.bundle` for optimized component loading.

| Feature | Usage | Purpose |
|---------|-------|---------|
| Islands | `@island(name: 'stats')` | Isolated update regions |
| Async | `wire:click.async` or `#[Async]` | Non-blocking actions |
| Deferred | `defer` attribute | Load after page render |
| Bundled | `lazy.bundle` | Load multiple together |

### New Directives

- `wire:sort`, `wire:intersect`, `wire:ref`, `.renderless`, `.preserve-scroll` are available for use.
- `data-loading` attribute automatically added to elements triggering network requests.

| Directive | Purpose |
|-----------|---------|
| `wire:sort` | Drag-and-drop sorting |
| `wire:intersect` | Viewport intersection detection |
| `wire:ref` | Element references for JS |
| `.renderless` | Component without rendering |
| `.preserve-scroll` | Preserve scroll position |

## Best Practices

- Always use `wire:key` in loops
- Use `wire:loading` for loading states
- Use `wire:model.live` for live updates; `wire:model` is deferred by default
- Validate and authorize in actions (treat like HTTP requests)

## Configuration

- `smart_wire_keys` defaults to `true`; new configs: `component_locations`, `component_namespaces`, `make_command`, `csp_safe`.

## Alpine & JavaScript

- `wire:transition` uses browser View Transitions API; `$errors` and `$intercept` magic properties available.
- Non-blocking `wire:poll` and parallel `wire:model.live` updates improve performance.

For interceptors and hooks, see [reference/javascript-hooks.md](reference/javascript-hooks.md).

## Testing

<!-- Testing Example -->
```php
Livewire::test(Counter::class)
    ->assertSet('count', 0)
    ->call('increment')
    ->assertSet('count', 1);
```

## Verification

1. Browser console: Check for JS errors
2. Network tab: Verify Livewire requests return 200
3. Ensure `wire:key` on all `@foreach` loops

## Common Pitfalls

- Missing `wire:key` in loops → unexpected re-rendering
- Expecting `wire:model` real-time → use `wire:model.live`
- Unclosed component tags → syntax errors in v4
- Using deprecated config keys or JS hooks
- Including Alpine.js separately (already bundled in Livewire 4)
---
name: fluxui-development
description: "Use this skill for Flux UI development in Livewire applications only. Trigger when working with <flux:*> components, building or customizing Livewire component UIs, creating forms, modals, tables, or other interactive elements. Covers: flux: components (buttons, inputs, modals, forms, tables, date-pickers, kanban, badges, tooltips, etc.), component composition, Tailwind CSS styling, Heroicons/Lucide icon integration, validation patterns, responsive design, and theming. Do not use for non-Livewire frameworks or non-component styling."
license: MIT
metadata:
  author: laravel
---

# Flux UI Development

## Documentation

Use `search-docs` for detailed Flux UI patterns and documentation.

## Basic Usage

This project uses the free edition of Flux UI, which includes all free components and variants but not Pro components.

Flux UI is a component library for Livewire built with Tailwind CSS. It provides components that are easy to use and customize.

Use Flux UI components when available. Fall back to standard Blade components when no Flux component exists for your needs.

<!-- Basic Button -->
```blade
<flux:button variant="primary">Click me</flux:button>
```

## Available Components (Free Edition)

Available: avatar, badge, brand, breadcrumbs, button, callout, card, checkbox, dropdown, field, heading, icon, input, modal, navbar, otp-input, pagination, profile, progress, radio, select, separator, skeleton, switch, table, text, textarea, toast, tooltip

## Icons

Flux includes [Heroicons](https://heroicons.com/) as its default icon set. Search for exact icon names on the Heroicons site - do not guess or invent icon names.

<!-- Icon Button -->
```blade
<flux:button icon="arrow-down-tray">Export</flux:button>
```

For icons not available in Heroicons, use [Lucide](https://lucide.dev/). Import the icons you need with the Artisan command:

```bash
php artisan flux:icon crown grip-vertical github
```

## Common Patterns

### Form Fields

<!-- Form Field -->
```blade
<flux:field>
    <flux:label>Email</flux:label>
    <flux:input type="email" wire:model="email" />
    <flux:error name="email" />
</flux:field>
```

### Modals

<!-- Modal -->
```blade
<flux:modal wire:model="showModal">
    <flux:heading>Title</flux:heading>
    <p>Content</p>
</flux:modal>
```

## Verification

1. Check component renders correctly
2. Test interactive states
3. Verify mobile responsiveness

## Common Pitfalls

- Trying to use Pro-only components in the free edition
- Not checking if a Flux component exists before creating custom implementations
- Forgetting to use the `search-docs` tool for component-specific documentation
- Not following existing project patterns for Flux usage
---
name: tailwindcss-development
description: "Always invoke when the user's message includes 'tailwind' in any form. Also invoke for: building responsive grid layouts (multi-column card grids, product grids), flex/grid page structures (dashboards with sidebars, fixed topbars, mobile-toggle navs), styling UI components (cards, tables, navbars, pricing sections, forms, inputs, badges), adding dark mode variants, fixing spacing or typography, and Tailwind v3/v4 work. The core use case: writing or fixing Tailwind utility classes in HTML templates (Blade, JSX, Vue). Skip for backend PHP logic, database queries, API routes, JavaScript with no HTML/CSS component, CSS file audits, build tool configuration, and vanilla CSS."
license: MIT
metadata:
  author: laravel
---

# Tailwind CSS Development

## Documentation

Use `search-docs` for detailed Tailwind CSS v4 patterns and documentation.

## Basic Usage

- Use Tailwind CSS classes to style HTML. Check and follow existing Tailwind conventions in the project before introducing new patterns.
- Offer to extract repeated patterns into components that match the project's conventions (e.g., Blade, JSX, Vue).
- Consider class placement, order, priority, and defaults. Remove redundant classes, add classes to parent or child elements carefully to reduce repetition, and group elements logically.

## Tailwind CSS v4 Specifics

- Always use Tailwind CSS v4 and avoid deprecated utilities.
- `corePlugins` is not supported in Tailwind v4.

### CSS-First Configuration

In Tailwind v4, configuration is CSS-first using the `@theme` directive — no separate `tailwind.config.js` file is needed:

<!-- CSS-First Config -->
```css
@theme {
  --color-brand: oklch(0.72 0.11 178);
}
```

### Import Syntax

In Tailwind v4, import Tailwind with a regular CSS `@import` statement instead of the `@tailwind` directives used in v3:

<!-- v4 Import Syntax -->
```diff
- @tailwind base;
- @tailwind components;
- @tailwind utilities;
+ @import "tailwindcss";
```

### Replaced Utilities

Tailwind v4 removed deprecated utilities. Use the replacements shown below. Opacity values remain numeric.

| Deprecated | Replacement |
|------------|-------------|
| bg-opacity-* | bg-black/* |
| text-opacity-* | text-black/* |
| border-opacity-* | border-black/* |
| divide-opacity-* | divide-black/* |
| ring-opacity-* | ring-black/* |
| placeholder-opacity-* | placeholder-black/* |
| flex-shrink-* | shrink-* |
| flex-grow-* | grow-* |
| overflow-ellipsis | text-ellipsis |
| decoration-slice | box-decoration-slice |
| decoration-clone | box-decoration-clone |

## Spacing

Use `gap` utilities instead of margins for spacing between siblings:

<!-- Gap Utilities -->
```html
<div class="flex gap-8">
    <div>Item 1</div>
    <div>Item 2</div>
</div>
```

## Dark Mode

If existing pages and components support dark mode, new pages and components must support it the same way, typically using the `dark:` variant:

<!-- Dark Mode -->
```html
<div class="bg-white dark:bg-gray-900 text-gray-900 dark:text-white">
    Content adapts to color scheme
</div>
```

## Common Patterns

### Flexbox Layout

<!-- Flexbox Layout -->
```html
<div class="flex items-center justify-between gap-4">
    <div>Left content</div>
    <div>Right content</div>
</div>
```

### Grid Layout

<!-- Grid Layout -->
```html
<div class="grid grid-cols-1 md:grid-cols-2 lg:grid-cols-3 gap-6">
    <div>Card 1</div>
    <div>Card 2</div>
    <div>Card 3</div>
</div>
```

## Common Pitfalls

- Using deprecated v3 utilities (bg-opacity-*, flex-shrink-*, etc.)
- Using `@tailwind` directives instead of `@import "tailwindcss"`
- Trying to use `tailwind.config.js` instead of CSS `@theme` directive
- Using margins for spacing between siblings instead of gap utilities
- Forgetting to add dark mode variants when the project uses dark mode
---
name: pest-testing
description: "Use this skill for Pest PHP testing in Laravel projects only. Trigger whenever any test is being written, edited, fixed, or refactored — including fixing tests that broke after a code change, adding assertions, converting PHPUnit to Pest, adding datasets, and TDD workflows. Always activate when the user asks how to write something in Pest, mentions test files or directories (tests/Feature, tests/Unit, tests/Browser), or needs browser testing, smoke testing multiple pages for JS errors, or architecture tests. Covers: test()/it()/expect() syntax, datasets, mocking, browser testing (visit/click/fill), smoke testing, arch(), Livewire component tests, RefreshDatabase, and all Pest 4 features. Do not use for factories, seeders, migrations, controllers, models, or non-test PHP code."
license: MIT
metadata:
  author: laravel
---

# Pest Testing 4

## Documentation

Use `search-docs` for detailed Pest 4 patterns and documentation.

## Basic Usage

### Creating Tests

All tests must be written using Pest. Use `php artisan make:test --pest {name}`.

The `{name}` argument should include only the path and test name, but should not include the test suite.
- Incorrect: `php artisan make:test --pest Feature/SomeFeatureTest` will generate `tests/Feature/Feature/SomeFeatureTest.php`
- Correct: `php artisan make:test --pest SomeControllerTest` will generate `tests/Feature/SomeControllerTest.php`
- Incorrect: `php artisan make:test --pest --unit Unit/SomeServiceTest` will generate `tests/Unit/Unit/SomeServiceTest.php`
- Correct: `php artisan make:test --pest --unit SomeServiceTest` will generate `tests/Unit/SomeServiceTest.php`

### Test Organization

- Unit/Feature tests: `tests/Feature` and `tests/Unit` directories.
- Browser tests: `tests/Browser/` directory.
- Do NOT remove tests without approval - these are core application code.

### Basic Test Structure

Pest supports both `test()` and `it()` functions. Before writing new tests, check existing test files in the same directory to match the project's convention. Use `test()` if existing tests use `test()`, or `it()` if they use `it()`.

<!-- Basic Pest Test Example -->
```php
it('is true', function () {
    expect(true)->toBeTrue();
});
```

### Running Tests

- Run minimal tests with filter before finalizing: `php artisan test --compact --filter=testName`.
- Run all tests: `php artisan test --compact`.
- Run file: `php artisan test --compact tests/Feature/ExampleTest.php`.

## Assertions

Use specific assertions (`assertSuccessful()`, `assertNotFound()`) instead of `assertStatus()`:

<!-- Pest Response Assertion -->
```php
it('returns all', function () {
    $this->postJson('/api/docs', [])->assertSuccessful();
});
```

| Use | Instead of |
|-----|------------|
| `assertSuccessful()` | `assertStatus(200)` |
| `assertNotFound()` | `assertStatus(404)` |
| `assertForbidden()` | `assertStatus(403)` |

## Mocking

Import mock function before use: `use function Pest\Laravel\mock;`

## Datasets

Use datasets for repetitive tests (validation rules, etc.):

<!-- Pest Dataset Example -->
```php
it('has emails', function (string $email) {
    expect($email)->not->toBeEmpty();
})->with([
    'james' => 'james@laravel.com',
    'taylor' => 'taylor@laravel.com',
]);
```

## Pest 4 Features

| Feature | Purpose |
|---------|---------|
| Browser Testing | Full integration tests in real browsers |
| Smoke Testing | Validate multiple pages quickly |
| Visual Regression | Compare screenshots for visual changes |
| Test Sharding | Parallel CI runs |
| Architecture Testing | Enforce code conventions |

### Browser Test Example

Browser tests run in real browsers for full integration testing:

- Browser tests live in `tests/Browser/`.
- Use Laravel features like `Event::fake()`, `assertAuthenticated()`, and model factories.
- Use `RefreshDatabase` for clean state per test.
- Interact with page: click, type, scroll, select, submit, drag-and-drop, touch gestures.
- Test on multiple browsers (Chrome, Firefox, Safari) if requested.
- Test on different devices/viewports (iPhone 14 Pro, tablets) if requested.
- Switch color schemes (light/dark mode) when appropriate.
- Take screenshots or pause tests for debugging.

<!-- Pest Browser Test Example -->
```php
it('may reset the password', function () {
    Notification::fake();

    $this->actingAs(User::factory()->create());

    $page = visit('/sign-in');

    $page->assertSee('Sign In')
        ->assertNoJavaScriptErrors()
        ->click('Forgot Password?')
        ->fill('email', 'nuno@laravel.com')
        ->click('Send Reset Link')
        ->assertSee('We have emailed your password reset link!');

    Notification::assertSent(ResetPassword::class);
});
```

### Smoke Testing

Quickly validate multiple pages have no JavaScript errors:

<!-- Pest Smoke Testing Example -->
```php
$pages = visit(['/', '/about', '/contact']);

$pages->assertNoJavaScriptErrors()->assertNoConsoleLogs();
```

### Visual Regression Testing

Capture and compare screenshots to detect visual changes.

### Test Sharding

Split tests across parallel processes for faster CI runs.

### Architecture Testing

Pest 4 includes architecture testing (from Pest 3):

<!-- Architecture Test Example -->
```php
arch('controllers')
    ->expect('App\Http\Controllers')
    ->toExtendNothing()
    ->toHaveSuffix('Controller');
```

## Common Pitfalls

- Not importing `use function Pest\Laravel\mock;` before using mock
- Using `assertStatus(200)` instead of `assertSuccessful()`
- Forgetting datasets for repetitive validation tests
- Deleting tests without approval
- Forgetting `assertNoJavaScriptErrors()` in browser tests
- Prefixing `Feature/` or `Unit/` in `{name}` when using `make:test`


exec

status: completed

input:
const tasks = [
  {
    message:"Perform a read-only exhaustive audit of specs/01-DATABASE-SCHEMA.md and specs/02-API-ROUTES.md against the current repo. List every missing/mismatched table/column/model/route/controller/auth requirement, prioritized with exact files and suggested fixes. Do not edit files.",
    fork_context:true
  },
  {
    message:"Perform a read-only exhaustive audit of specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md and specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md against the current repo. Check every required Livewire component, route, interaction, layout/theme behavior, responsive/accessibility requirement. List gaps with exact files. Do not edit files.",
    fork_context:true
  },
  {
    message:"Perform a read-only exhaustive audit of specs/05-BUSINESS-LOGIC.md, 06-AUTH-AND-SECURITY.md, 07-SEEDERS-AND-TEST-DATA.md, 08-PLAYWRIGHT-E2E-PLAN.md, and current Pest tests. Identify unimplemented rules, security flaws, missing fixtures/tests, and acceptance gaps. Do not edit files.",
    fork_context:true
  }
];
const results = await Promise.all(tasks.map(t => tools.multi_agent_v1__spawn_agent(t)));
for (const r of results) text(r);


type: CollabAgentToolCall

status: completed

agent_nickname: Faraday

prompt: Perform a read-only exhaustive audit of specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md and specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md against the current repo. Check every required Livewire component, route, interaction, layout/theme behavior, responsive/accessibility requirement. List gaps with exact files. Do not edit files.

reasoning_effort: xhigh


type: CollabAgentToolCall

status: completed

agent_nickname: Linnaeus

prompt: Perform a read-only exhaustive audit of specs/05-BUSINESS-LOGIC.md, 06-AUTH-AND-SECURITY.md, 07-SEEDERS-AND-TEST-DATA.md, 08-PLAYWRIGHT-E2E-PLAN.md, and current Pest tests. Identify unimplemented rules, security flaws, missing fixtures/tests, and acceptance gaps. Do not edit files.

reasoning_effort: xhigh


type: CollabAgentToolCall

status: failed

prompt: Perform a read-only exhaustive audit of specs/01-DATABASE-SCHEMA.md and specs/02-API-ROUTES.md against the current repo. List every missing/mismatched table/column/model/route/controller/auth requirement, prioritized with exact files and suggested fixes. Do not edit files.

reasoning_effort: medium


text:
Script failed
Wall time 0.2 seconds
Output:

text:
Script error:
collab spawn failed: agent thread limit reached


type: AgentMessage

type: Text

text: The first delegation attempt hit the agent-thread limit because prior completed audit threads were still open. I’m closing those finished threads and immediately restarting the independent spec audits; no implementation work is being skipped.

phase: commentary


type: message

role: assistant


status: completed

input:
const ids=["01a020f5-0ab7-7cb3-924d-49c79ac78c69","01a020f5-0ae9-7b20-aac3-f4cd917791fb","01a020f5-0b48-7680-ac22-e8f0dad974d6","01a02133-8dd6-7d00-a5f3-1537db0e7034"];
const results=await Promise.all(ids.map(target=>tools.multi_agent_v1__close_agent({target})));
for (const r of results) text(r);


type: CollabAgentToolCall

status: completed

agent_nickname: Sartre

completed:
## Audit outcome

The repo is still the Laravel Livewire starter kit, not the specified shop system. No files were edited.

Evidence:

- Only starter routes exist in [routes/web.php](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/web.php:5) and [routes/settings.php](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/settings.php:10).
- Required shop URLs return 404; `/` returns the Laravel welcome page.
- Only the `User` model, four starter migrations, and one test user seeder exist.
- There are no admin/storefront Livewire components and no `tests/Browser` directory.
- `specs/progress.md` is missing.
- Current Pest inventory is 33 starter tests, all unit/feature tests.
- Existing uncommitted change: `boost.json` changes the agent name from `opencode` to `codex`; it was left untouched.

## Required web routes/components

Defined primarily in [02-API-ROUTES.md](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/specs/02-API-ROUTES.md:9), [03-ADMIN-UI.md](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md:14), and [04-STOREFRONT-UI.md](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md:237).

### Admin

- `/admin/login`, `/admin/forgot-password`, `/admin/reset-password/{token}`
  - `Admin\Auth\Login`, `ForgotPassword`, `ResetPassword`
- `/admin`
  - `Admin\Dashboard`
- `/admin/products`, `/admin/products/create`, `/admin/products/{product}/edit`
  - `Admin\Products\Index`, shared `Form`
- `/admin/inventory`
  - `Admin\Inventory\Index`
- `/admin/collections`, create/edit routes
  - `Admin\Collections\Index`, shared `Form`
- `/admin/orders`, `/admin/orders/{order}`
  - `Admin\Orders\Index`, `Show`
- `/admin/customers`, `/admin/customers/{customer}`
  - `Admin\Customers\Index`, `Show`
- `/admin/discounts`, create/edit routes
  - `Admin\Discounts\Index`, shared `Form`
- `/admin/settings`, `/admin/settings/shipping`, `/admin/settings/taxes`
  - Settings general/domains/shipping/taxes components
- `/admin/themes`, `/admin/themes/{theme}/editor`
  - `Admin\Themes\Index`, `Editor`
- `/admin/pages`, create/edit routes
  - `Admin\Pages\Index`, shared `Form`
- `/admin/navigation`
  - `Admin\Navigation\Index`
- `/admin/apps`, `/admin/apps/{installation}`
  - `Admin\Apps\Index`, `Show`
- `/admin/developers`
  - `Admin\Developers\Index`
- `/admin/analytics`
  - `Admin\Analytics\Index`
- `/admin/search/settings`
  - `Admin\Search\Settings`

Every admin page also needs the persistent `Admin\Layout\Sidebar` and `Admin\Layout\TopBar`.

### Storefront

- `/`
  - `Storefront\Home`
- `/collections`, `/collections/{handle}`
  - `Collections\Index`, `Show`
- `/products/{handle}`
  - `Products\Show`
- `/cart`
  - `Cart\Show`, with global `CartDrawer`
- `/search`
  - `Search\Index`, with global `Search\Modal`
- `/pages/{handle}`
  - `Pages\Show`
- `/checkout/{checkoutId}`
  - `Checkout\Show`
- `/checkout/{checkoutId}/confirmation`
  - `Checkout\Confirmation`
- `/account/login`, `/account/register`
  - customer auth components
- `/account`, `/account/orders`, `/account/orders/{orderNumber}`, `/account/addresses`
  - customer dashboard, orders, and address components
- `/forgot-password`, `/reset-password/{token}`
  - customer password reset flow

Additional reusable components: featured products, newsletter signup, product card, price, badge, quantity selector, address form, order summary, breadcrumbs, and pagination.

## Acceptance-critical UI strings

Storefront strings include:

`Acme Fashion`, `Collections`, `T-Shirts`, `New Arrivals`, `Classic Cotton T-Shirt`, `Premium Slim Fit Jeans`, `24.99`, `Add to cart`, `Size`, `Color`, `S`, `M`, `L`, `XL`, `Black`, `White`, `Navy`, `Your Cart`, `Your cart is empty`, `Checkout`, `No results`, `Sold out`, `Available on backorder`, `Subtotal`, `Discount`, `Free shipping`.

Admin strings include:

`Sign in`, `Dashboard`, `Products`, `Orders`, `Customers`, `Discounts`, `Settings`, `Analytics`, `Themes`, `Add product`, `Product saved`, `Product archived`, `WELCOME10`, `FLAT5`, `FREESHIP`, `Active`, `Expired`, `Store Settings`, `Settings saved`, `Domestic`, `Standard Shipping`, `4.99`, `Shipping rate saved`, `Tax Settings`, `Tax settings saved`, `acme-fashion.test`, `Confirm payment`, `Payment confirmed`, `Fulfillment created`, `Refund processed`, `Partially refunded`.

There is a spec inconsistency: the admin UI toast table says `Refund issued`, while the browser plan expects `Refund processed`. Choose one canonical string before writing tests.

## Recommended Pest browser flows

The plan in [08-PLAYWRIGHT-E2E-PLAN.md](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/specs/08-PLAYWRIGHT-E2E-PLAN.md:7) defines 18 suites:

1. Smoke all major storefront/admin pages.
2. Admin login, invalid credentials, validation, authorization, logout, sidebar navigation.
3. Product create/edit/archive/search/status filtering.
4. Orders, fulfillment, refunds, bank-transfer confirmation, fulfillment guard, shipped/delivered states.
5. Discount listing, creation, editing, status indicators.
6. Store settings, shipping rates, tax settings, domains.
7. Storefront browsing, variants, pricing, search, draft exclusion, inventory messages.
8. Cart add/update/remove and discount codes.
9. Checkout contact/address/shipping/payment/confirmation flows, including PayPal, bank transfer, card decline, and insufficient funds.
10. Customer registration/login/order history/address CRUD/logout.
11. Inventory deny versus continue policies.
12. Tenant isolation across stores.
13. Mobile/tablet responsive behavior.
14. Accessibility, keyboard navigation, labels, focus traps, ARIA.
15–18. Admin collections, customers, pages, and analytics.

The top summary claims 143 tests. The final count table contains 7 order tests and 8 checkout tests, which sums to 134, not 143. Reconcile the source of truth before implementing the browser suite.

Important seeded acceptance data:

- Admin: `admin@acme.test` / `password`
- Customer: `customer@acme.test` / `password`
- Store: `Acme Fashion`, domain `acme-fashion.test`, EUR
- Products: Classic Cotton T-Shirt, Premium Slim Fit Jeans, draft product, deny-policy sold-out product, continue-policy backorder product
- Discounts: `WELCOME10`, `FLAT5`, `FREESHIP`, `EXPIRED20`, `MAXED`
- Orders: `#1001`, `#1002`, `#1004`, and pending bank-transfer order `#1005`

## Package/API pitfalls

- Installed versions are Laravel 12.51, Livewire 4.1.4, Flux 2.12, Tailwind 4.1.18, and Pest 4.3.2.
- `pestphp/pest-plugin-browser` is not installed.
- `node_modules/playwright` is missing.
- No Playwright browser binaries are available to the in-app browser runtime; browser discovery returned an empty list, so no real browser flow was executed.
- `.env.testing` is missing. The plan requires a dedicated SQLite database, `APP_URL`, mock payments, array mail, and synchronous queues.
- Current `APP_URL` is `http://localhost`, while the plan expects `http://acme-fashion.test`. The Herd app currently responds at `shop.test`; tenant-host setup must be made explicit.
- [tests/Pest.php](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/tests/Pest.php:14) only registers `Feature` tests, with `RefreshDatabase` commented out globally.
- [phpunit.xml](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/phpunit.xml:7) only lists Unit and Feature suites.
- `assertNoJavascriptErrors()` in the spec is incorrectly cased. Pest documentation uses `assertNoJavaScriptErrors()`.
- The spec’s browser `fill()` field names are logical names, not guaranteed selectors. Use actual labels or stable `data-test` attributes.
- Livewire v4 `wire:model` is deferred by default. Search, filters, sort controls, checkout totals, and autocomplete need explicit `.live`/`.debounce` bindings.
- Use `Route::livewire()` for full-page components and preserve the existing class-based Livewire convention.
- Add `wire:key` to every repeated product, order, line-item, variant, and address row.
- Flux Free must be distinguished from Flux Pro. Build unsupported controls with plain Tailwind/native inputs; do not assume Pro combobox, date-picker, or rich-text components exist.
- Tailwind setup is correctly v4-style in [resources/css/app.css](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/css/app.css:1) and [vite.config.js](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/vite.config.js:7). Keep CSS-first `@theme`/`@custom-variant` configuration.
- The admin spec requires Chart.js, but no `chart.js` dependency exists.
- The specs require Sanctum API authentication and many REST endpoints, but Sanctum is not a direct dependency in [composer.json](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/composer.json:11); make that dependency/configuration explicit before implementing APIs.
- Current Fortify is configured around the default `web` guard. The shop needs separate admin/customer session guards, password brokers, store scoping, and Sanctum token authentication.
- SQLite FTS5, media uploads, sortable lists, webhooks, scheduled jobs, and mock PSP behavior all require dedicated migrations/services/tests; none are present.

## Recommended implementation order

1. Resolve route/component naming inconsistencies and the 143-vs-134 browser test count.
2. Build database schema, models, factories, seeders, store resolution, guards, and policies.
3. Add canonical admin/storefront layouts and `Route::livewire()` page routes.
4. Implement core browsing → cart → checkout → orders before secondary admin modules.
5. Add exact acceptance strings and stable selectors.
6. Install/configure Pest browser tooling and add smoke tests first.
7. Run browser suites in dependency order, fixing JavaScript/Livewire errors before expanding coverage.


agent_nickname: Einstein

completed:
Implemented and committed as `ac0e33a2`.

Changed:

- Tenancy config, SQLite defaults, middleware groups, enums, models, factories, scopes, and `ResolveStore`.
- `BelongsToStore` and store-role policy scaffolding.
- Tenancy migrations and progress tracking.
- Focused Pest tests for resolution, isolation, caching, suspension, and authorization.

Verification:

- Focused tests: 10 passed, 21 assertions.
- Full Pest suite: 43 passed, 96 assertions.
- Pint completed successfully.

No catalog, cart, checkout, order, or storefront UI files were staged. Unrelated existing worktree changes remain unstaged.


agent_nickname: Pasteur

completed:
## Verdict

The repository is a Laravel starter plus a partially scaffolded domain layer, not acceptance-ready.

Evidence:

- Current route list has only `/`, `/dashboard`, and `/settings`.
- `app/Http/Middleware/ResolveStore.php` is a no-op.
- `php artisan test --compact`: 33 starter tests pass; no shop behavior is covered.
- No `tests/Browser/`, Playwright dependency, or Pest browser plugin.
- `database/database.sqlite` is absent, so migration status cannot run.
- No `specs/progress.md`.
- No files were edited.

## Prioritized gap list

### P0 — Schema contract is incomplete and contradictory

The monolithic migration creates 45 shop tables, but the schema specification also requires `personal_access_tokens` and `customer_password_reset_tokens`. Neither migration exists.

Critical current/spec mismatches include:

- [`database/migrations/2026_08_20_000000_create_shop_schema.php:35-43`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/database/migrations/2026_08_20_000000_create_shop_schema.php:35) lacks `store_domains.tls_mode`; its follow-up migration is empty.
- [`:60-67`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/database/migrations/2026_08_20_000000_create_shop_schema.php:60) uses `general_json`, `checkout_json`, etc.; the spec requires `store_settings.settings_json`.
- [`:366-383`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/database/migrations/2026_08_20_000000_create_shop_schema.php:366) lacks `checkouts.payment_method` and uses `shipping_rate_id` instead of the specified `shipping_method_id`.
- Tax columns differ substantially: current `default_rate_basis_points`/`rates_json`; spec requires `provider`, `prices_include_tax`, and `config_json`.
- Orders and order lines use different snapshot/status fields from the schema spec.
- [`:457-467`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/database/migrations/2026_08_20_000000_create_shop_schema.php:457) uses `fulfilled_at`; the specs require `shipped_at`, while business/UI specs also require `delivered_at`.
- Apps, OAuth, webhook, and analytics column names/relationships differ materially from `specs/01-DATABASE-SCHEMA.md`.

### P0 — Tenant resolution and authentication are nonfunctional

- [`ResolveStore.php:16-19`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Middleware/ResolveStore.php:16) does nothing.
- No admin session-based `current_store_id` resolution.
- No `CheckStoreRole`, customer authentication middleware, custom store-scoped customer provider, or middleware aliases in [`bootstrap/app.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/bootstrap/app.php).
- [`config/auth.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/config/auth.php) only defines the `web` guard.
- [`User.php:24-55`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Models/User.php:24) uses `password`, while the schema/auth spec requires the `password_hash` contract.
- Sanctum source exists in `vendor`, but it is not declared in `composer.json`; there is no token migration/configuration/API auth.
- Existing policies are mostly generated stubs; [`StorePolicy.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Policies/StorePolicy.php) returns `false` for every action.

### P0 — Nearly all routes and acceptance surfaces are absent

[`routes/web.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/web.php) has none of the required:

- Admin routes: `/admin`, products, collections, inventory, orders, customers, discounts, settings, themes, pages, navigation, apps, developers, analytics, search.
- Storefront routes: `/collections`, `/products/{handle}`, `/cart`, `/search`, `/pages/{handle}`, `/account/*`, `/checkout/{checkoutId}/*`.
- Storefront API: `/api/storefront/v1/*`.
- Admin API: `/api/admin/v1/*`.
- OAuth stub routes returning `501`.

### P1 — Business logic is absent

Models exist for much of the domain, but no services, contracts, jobs, value objects, events, or form requests exist.

Missing exact core classes include:

- `App\Services\ProductService`
- `VariantMatrixService`
- `InventoryService`
- `CartService`
- `PricingEngine`
- `CheckoutService`
- `DiscountService`
- `ShippingCalculator`
- `TaxCalculator`
- `PaymentService`
- `OrderService`
- `RefundService`
- `FulfillmentService`
- `CustomerService`
- `SearchService`
- `WebhookService`
- `App\Contracts\PaymentProvider`
- `App\Jobs\ProcessMediaUpload`
- `DeliverWebhook`
- `AggregateAnalytics`
- `CleanupAbandonedCarts`
- `ExpireAbandonedCheckouts`
- `CancelUnpaidBankTransferOrders`

Current enums also conflict with acceptance behavior:

- [`CheckoutStatus.php:5-13`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Enums/CheckoutStatus.php:5) has `payment_pending`; specs require `payment_selected`.
- [`OrderStatus.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Enums/OrderStatus.php) uses `processing`/`completed`; business rules use `paid`/`fulfilled`.
- [`FulfillmentStatus.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Enums/FulfillmentStatus.php) uses `partially_fulfilled`; specs use `partial`.

### P1 — Admin and storefront UI are absent

No `app/Livewire/Admin/*`, `app/Livewire/Storefront/*`, or `resources/views/storefront/*` exists.

Required components include:

- `App\Livewire\Admin\Dashboard`
- `Admin\Products\Index/Form`
- `Admin\Orders\Index/Show`
- `Admin\Customers\Index/Show`
- `Admin\Settings\General/Domains/Shipping/Taxes`
- `Admin\Themes\Index/Editor`
- `Admin\Pages\Index/Form`
- `Storefront\Home`
- `Storefront\Products\Show`
- `Storefront\Collections\Index/Show`
- `Storefront\CartPage`
- `Storefront\CheckoutPage`
- `Storefront\Account\Login/Register/Orders/Addresses`

### P1 — Seed data, factories, and tests are largely missing

Only five mostly empty shop seeders and five empty foundation factories exist. [`DatabaseSeeder.php:14-21`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/database/seeders/DatabaseSeeder.php:14) still creates only `test@example.com`.

Missing acceptance fixtures include:

- `acme-fashion.test`, `admin.acme-fashion.test`, `acme-electronics.test`
- `admin@acme.test/password`
- `customer@acme.test/password`
- stores, products, collections, discounts, orders `#1001–#1015` and `#5001–#5003`
- sold-out deny, backorder continue, draft, archived, digital, and expensive products
- 18 ordered seeders and factories for the full domain

### P2 — Verification and operational requirements are absent

[`config/database.php:34-44`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/config/database.php:34) does not configure the required SQLite `WAL`, `busy_timeout=5000`, `synchronous=NORMAL`, or cache-size settings.

Also absent:

- `config/cors.php`
- audit logging and `AuditLogger`
- HTML sanitizer
- FTS5/search index
- analytics aggregation
- webhook delivery/retry logic
- required scheduled jobs
- 18 browser test files / 143 browser tests

## Hidden-test likely requirements

Expect hidden tests to check:

- `migrate:fresh --seed` succeeds and creates all required tables.
- Exact tenant hosts, handles, credentials, order numbers, discount codes, and product lifecycle fixtures.
- `Host: acme-fashion.test` resolves Store 1; Store 2 data never leaks.
- Admin uses session `current_store_id`; suspended stores allow reads but reject mutations.
- Exact route paths, middleware, status codes, JSON error envelopes, Sanctum abilities, and rate limits.
- `payment_selected` checkout state, not `payment_pending`.
- Integer-cent pricing, per-line rounding, discount-before-tax, remainder allocation, and `24.99 EUR` formatting.
- Cart version conflicts return `409`; inventory deny/continue policies behave correctly.
- Checkout completion is idempotent and creates one order.
- Magic payment numbers support both spaced and unspaced formats; bank transfer remains pending.
- Fulfillment guards unpaid orders; shipped/delivered timestamps and refund/restock behavior work.
- Customer emails are store-scoped; passwords/reset tokens use the customer guard.
- Sensitive payment/webhook/OAuth fields are encrypted.
- Browser pages have required text, responsive layouts, accessibility labels, and no console errors.

## Contradictions to resolve before implementation

1. `zip` in schema/seed data vs `postal_code` in API/business/UI.
2. `PaymentPending` in roadmap/current enum vs `payment_selected` everywhere else.
3. `App\Services\Payment\MockPaymentProvider` vs roadmap’s `App\Services\Payments\MockPaymentProvider`.
4. Async `POST /api/admin/v1/stores/{storeId}/exports/orders` vs synchronous `GET /api/admin/v1/orders/export`.
5. Schema has `fulfilled_at`; UI/business require `shipped_at` and `delivered_at`.
6. Schema requires `settings_json`; current migration uses multiple JSON columns.
7. Current order statuses differ from business statuses.
8. Admin UI says “soft delete/archive,” while business rules allow hard deletion only for eligible drafts and the schema has no `deleted_at`.
9. E2E suite summary says 143 tests, but its detailed count table totals 134; order and checkout counts disagree.
10. Roadmap says “28 feature test files,” but lists 41.

## Recommended phase order

0. **Contract gate**
   Resolve the contradictions above before writing behavior. Canonicalize `CheckoutStatus`, order/fulfillment statuses, address keys, fulfillment timestamps, export contract, provider namespace, and schema column names.

1. **Foundation and auth**
   Repair migrations/configuration and implement:

   - `Organization`, `Store`, `StoreDomain`, `StoreUser`, `StoreSettings`, `User`, `Customer`
   - `BelongsToStore`, `StoreScope`
   - `ResolveStore`, `CheckStoreRole`
   - `config/auth.php`, `config/database.php`, `config/session.php`, `config/cors.php`
   - `personal_access_tokens`, `customer_password_reset_tokens`
   - all policies and auth form requests

2. **Catalog and inventory**
   Implement `Product`, `ProductVariant`, options, media, `Collection`, `InventoryItem`, then `ProductService`, `VariantMatrixService`, `InventoryService`, and their feature tests.

3. **Themes and storefront**
   Add `routes/web.php`, storefront Livewire components, `resources/views/storefront/*`, theme/page/navigation models and `NavigationService`.

4. **Cart, pricing, checkout**
   Add `routes/api.php`, `CartService`, `PricingEngine`, `DiscountService`, `ShippingCalculator`, `TaxCalculator`, `CheckoutService`, and checkout form requests.

5. **Payments, orders, fulfillment**
   Add `PaymentProvider`, canonical `App\Services\Payment\MockPaymentProvider`, `PaymentService`, `OrderService`, `RefundService`, `FulfillmentService`, order events, and scheduled jobs.

6. **Customer accounts**
   Implement the customer guard/provider, password broker, account routes, address management, order history, and `CustomerService`.

7. **Admin panel**
   Add the `/admin/*` routes and exact `App\Livewire\Admin\...` components from `specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md`.

8. **Search and analytics**
   Implement `SearchService`, FTS5, `AnalyticsService`, `AggregateAnalytics`, and the analytics API/UI.

9. **Apps, webhooks, OAuth stubs**
   Implement webhook subscriptions/delivery and return `501` for deferred OAuth routes.

10. **Seeders, browser tests, polish**
    Build the 18 seeders/factory set, then implement `tests/Browser/*` and reconcile the E2E test-count contradiction before treating the project as complete.


agent_nickname: Boole

completed:
## Verdict

The implementation is not ready for hidden-test acceptance. The highest-risk gaps are missing API/auth surfaces, insecure ID-based storefront access, incomplete authorization enforcement, and incorrect checkout/pricing/refund state handling.

No files were edited and no destructive commands were run.

## Critical findings

1. **Admin API and Sanctum are absent**

`routes/api.php` contains only 13 storefront routes; there are no `/api/admin/v1/*`, token-authenticated routes, product/order management endpoints, or admin exports. The project also has no Sanctum dependency or guard in [`config/auth.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/config/auth.php:38).

This directly conflicts with the required API and token tests in [`specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md:1189).

Recommended fix: add Sanctum token support, `HasApiTokens`, admin API controllers/resources, abilities, `auth:sanctum`, `api.admin`, analytics/search/webhook throttles, and all specified `/api/admin/v1` routes.

2. **Cart, checkout, and confirmation resources are enumerable and not owner-bound**

The API retrieves carts and checkouts by ID with store scoping only:

- [`StorefrontCartController.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontCartController.php:83)
- [`StorefrontCheckoutController.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontCheckoutController.php:104)
- [`Confirmation.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Livewire/Storefront/Checkout/Confirmation.php:12)

A caller who learns an ID can read or mutate another guest’s cart/checkout, and potentially view order confirmation data.

Recommended fix: bind resources to the current session/customer, require a signed/opaque checkout token for guests, and verify cart ownership before every read or mutation. The `Customer` model itself is store-scoped, but these anonymous resource paths are not sufficiently protected.

3. **Admin Livewire actions bypass the role matrix**

The broad admin group permits Support access to order/customer/discount pages:

[`routes/web.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/web.php:88)

However, mutating Livewire methods do not authorize internally:

- [`Admin/Orders/Show.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Livewire/Admin/Orders/Show.php:24)
- [`Admin/Products/Form.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Livewire/Admin/Products/Form.php:42)
- [`Admin/Discounts/Form.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Livewire/Admin/Discounts/Form.php:31)

Support can invoke payment confirmation, fulfillment, and refund methods; Staff can invoke refunds. `FulfillmentPolicy` and `RefundPolicy` also attempt to read `store_id` from models that do not contain it:

- [`FulfillmentPolicy.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Policies/FulfillmentPolicy.php:20)
- [`RefundPolicy.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Policies/RefundPolicy.php:20)

Recommended fix: call `authorize()` inside every mutating action, use the related Order for fulfillment/refund authorization, and align policy methods with the exact Owner/Admin/Staff/Support matrix.

4. **Checkout state transitions are insufficiently guarded**

[`CheckoutService.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/CheckoutService.php:52) allows payment selection without requiring address or shipping selection. `PaymentService` can also reserve and charge when the checkout is not in the correct state:

[`PaymentService.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/PaymentService.php:32)

Digital-only carts are not given a dedicated no-shipping path, and paid digital orders are not automatically fulfilled. Shipping calculation also includes every line and uses `weight_grams`, without filtering `requires_shipping`:

[`ShippingCalculator.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/ShippingCalculator.php:17)

Recommended fix: implement explicit state guards, skip address/shipping requirements for all-digital carts, reject payment when physical shipping is unresolved, and auto-create delivered fulfillment for digital orders.

5. **Tax-inclusive pricing is calculated incorrectly**

`TaxSettings` exposes `prices_include_tax`, but [`TaxCalculator.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/TaxCalculator.php:15) uses the legacy `mode` field instead. [`PricingEngine.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/PricingEngine.php:45) calculates tax on one aggregate amount and then adds extracted inclusive tax to the total, which can double-count tax.

Recommended fix: use `prices_include_tax`, calculate tax per line with required rounding, include taxable shipping correctly, and ensure inclusive totals remain gross totals.

6. **Refund, cancellation, and fulfillment state handling is incomplete**

Refunds validate against one payment rather than the order’s remaining refundable balance and do not update payment status:

[`RefundService.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/RefundService.php:47)

Cancellation only changes the order status and reservation state; it does not void the financial/payment state:

[`OrderService.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/OrderService.php:83)

`markAsShipped()` updates fields but dispatches no shipping event, email, or webhook, and the admin UI exposes no shipped/delivered actions:

[`FulfillmentService.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/FulfillmentService.php:47)

Recommended fix: track refundable totals across all captured payments, update payment/order financial states atomically, persist refund line quantities, emit the required fulfillment events, and expose authorized transition actions.

## High-priority findings

7. **Several schema contracts differ from specs/01**

Notable mismatches include:

- `users.password` remains instead of the specified `password_hash` contract; [`User.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Models/User.php:24)
- customer reset tokens lack `store_id`; [`add_search_and_auth_support.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/database/migrations/2026_08_20_220000_add_search_and_auth_support.php:23)
- pages use `content`, not `body_html`; [`create_shop_schema.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/database/migrations/2026_08_20_000000_create_shop_schema.php:208)
- product media lacks width/height and processing metadata; [`create_shop_schema.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/database/migrations/2026_08_20_000000_create_shop_schema.php:165)
- analytics, OAuth, webhook, theme-file, navigation, payment, and order-line snapshot columns do not match the specified names/shapes.

Recommended fix: reconcile migrations, models, factories, and serializers against specs/01 before relying on hidden schema tests.

8. **Required admin screens are placeholders**

Inventory, collections, themes, pages, navigation, apps, developers, analytics, and search settings all route to the generic `Admin\Section` component:

[`routes/web.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/web.php:103)
[`Section.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Livewire/Admin/Section.php:7)

The component only renders a heading. The sidebar also omits most required admin destinations:

[`layouts/admin.blade.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/layouts/admin.blade.php:4)

Recommended fix: implement the specified Livewire components and CRUD/actions, then wire the exact route names expected by specs/03 and specs/08.

9. **Storefront UI is incomplete and not theme-driven**

There is no `Storefront\CartDrawer`; the layout has a static announcement/navigation and the checkout confirmation only displays an order number and total:

- [`layouts/storefront.blade.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/layouts/storefront.blade.php:12)
- [`confirmation.blade.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/livewire/storefront/checkout/confirmation.blade.php:1)

Product option selection uses string matching against variant titles rather than a complete option matrix:

[`products/show.blade.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/livewire/storefront/products/show.blade.php:1)

Recommended fix: add the cart drawer, dynamic theme/menu/settings rendering, complete variant selection, checkout fields, bank-transfer instructions, line-item summaries, and confirmation states.

10. **Seed data is far below specs/07**

[`ShopSeeder.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/database/seeders/ShopSeeder.php:35) creates one store, one admin, one customer, five products, one shipping zone/rate, and one order. The specification requires multiple stores, users/roles, customers, products, digital products, international shipping, analytics, and a larger order corpus.

Recommended fix: build deterministic factories/seeders matching the exact fixture counts, statuses, prices, discounts, international zones, and digital-order cases.

11. **HTML sanitization and audit logging are missing**

Pages render raw HTML:

[`pages/show.blade.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/livewire/storefront/pages/show.blade.php:1)

Product descriptions are also persisted without a sanitizer:

[`ProductService.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/ProductService.php:27)

There is no audit logger/channel or event recording for authentication, product, order, refund, or settings changes:

[`config/logging.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/config/logging.php:53)

Recommended fix: add `SanitizeHtml`, sanitize before persistence, render only sanitized content, and implement the required audit event pipeline.

12. **Livewire authentication throttling is not applied to action requests**

The custom Livewire update route only uses `web` and `store.resolve`:

[`AppServiceProvider.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php:43)

The page GET route is throttled, but login attempts occur through the Livewire update request. This can bypass the intended five-attempt limiter. `ResolveStore` also identifies admin Livewire requests by referer while excluding only literal admin auth paths:

[`ResolveStore.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Middleware/ResolveStore.php:99)

Recommended fix: apply login throttling to the Livewire action path and explicitly exempt admin login/reset Livewire updates from tenant resolution.

## Medium-priority findings

13. **Search, media, and event side effects are incomplete**

Search uses SQL `LIKE` despite an FTS table:

[`SearchService.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/SearchService.php:18)

Media processing only changes status and does not create resized/WebP assets or dimensions:

[`ProcessMediaUpload.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Jobs/ProcessMediaUpload.php:18)

Core events are dispatched, but there are no listeners for confirmation mail, analytics, audit, or webhook side effects. Webhook dispatch exists only as a service:

[`WebhookService.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/WebhookService.php:11)

14. **Product lifecycle and inventory edge cases remain exposed**

`ProductService::update()` writes status directly instead of using transition validation:

[`ProductService.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/ProductService.php:44)

There is no store-scoped SKU uniqueness constraint, and orphan variants with order history remain active:

[`VariantMatrixService.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/VariantMatrixService.php:44)

Inventory methods also lack direct positive-quantity validation.

15. **Scheduled cleanup uses the wrong retention period**

Abandoned carts are marked after 30 days:

[`CleanupAbandonedCarts.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Jobs/CleanupAbandonedCarts.php:17)

The roadmap requires 14 days.

16. **Session/security defaults do not match the security specification**

Session encryption defaults to false, the cookie name is framework-derived rather than `shop_session`, and secure cookies are not enabled by default:

[`config/session.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/config/session.php:50)

Recommended fix: set the required production-safe defaults and explicitly configure CORS/API security.

The existing `specs/progress.md` completion claims should not be treated as verification: route inspection, schema inspection, and component inspection show substantial unimplemented areas.


text:
Script completed
Wall time 0.0 seconds
Output:

text: {"previous_status":{"completed":"Implemented and committed as `ac0e33a2`.\n\nChanged:\n\n- Tenancy config, SQLite defaults, middleware groups, enums, models, factories, scopes, and `ResolveStore`.\n- `BelongsToStore` and store-role policy scaffolding.\n- Tenancy migrations and progress tracking.\n- Focused Pest tests for resolution, isolation, caching, suspension, and authorization.\n\nVerification:\n\n- Focused tests: 10 passed, 21 assertions.\n- Full Pest suite: 43 passed, 96 assertions.\n- Pint completed successfully.\n\nNo catalog, cart, checkout, order, or storefront UI files were staged. Unrelated existing worktree changes remain unstaged."}}

text: {"previous_status":{"completed":"## Verdict\n\nThe repository is a Laravel starter plus a partially scaffolded domain layer, not acceptance-ready.\n\nEvidence:\n\n- Current route list has only `/`, `/dashboard`, and `/settings`.\n- `app/Http/Middleware/ResolveStore.php` is a no-op.\n- `php artisan test --compact`: 33 starter tests pass; no shop behavior is covered.\n- No `tests/Browser/`, Playwright dependency, or Pest browser plugin.\n- `database/database.sqlite` is absent, so migration status cannot run.\n- No `specs/progress.md`.\n- No files were edited.\n\n## Prioritized gap list\n\n### P0 — Schema contract is incomplete and contradictory\n\nThe monolithic migration creates 45 shop tables, but the schema specification also requires `personal_access_tokens` and `customer_password_reset_tokens`. Neither migration exists.\n\nCritical current/spec mismatches include:\n\n- [`database/migrations/2026_08_20_000000_create_shop_schema.php:35-43`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/database/migrations/2026_08_20_000000_create_shop_schema.php:35) lacks `store_domains.tls_mode`; its follow-up migration is empty.\n- [`:60-67`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/database/migrations/2026_08_20_000000_create_shop_schema.php:60) uses `general_json`, `checkout_json`, etc.; the spec requires `store_settings.settings_json`.\n- [`:366-383`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/database/migrations/2026_08_20_000000_create_shop_schema.php:366) lacks `checkouts.payment_method` and uses `shipping_rate_id` instead of the specified `shipping_method_id`.\n- Tax columns differ substantially: current `default_rate_basis_points`/`rates_json`; spec requires `provider`, `prices_include_tax`, and `config_json`.\n- Orders and order lines use different snapshot/status fields from the schema spec.\n- [`:457-467`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/database/migrations/2026_08_20_000000_create_shop_schema.php:457) uses `fulfilled_at`; the specs require `shipped_at`, while business/UI specs also require `delivered_at`.\n- Apps, OAuth, webhook, and analytics column names/relationships differ materially from `specs/01-DATABASE-SCHEMA.md`.\n\n### P0 — Tenant resolution and authentication are nonfunctional\n\n- [`ResolveStore.php:16-19`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Middleware/ResolveStore.php:16) does nothing.\n- No admin session-based `current_store_id` resolution.\n- No `CheckStoreRole`, customer authentication middleware, custom store-scoped customer provider, or middleware aliases in [`bootstrap/app.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/bootstrap/app.php).\n- [`config/auth.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/config/auth.php) only defines the `web` guard.\n- [`User.php:24-55`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Models/User.php:24) uses `password`, while the schema/auth spec requires the `password_hash` contract.\n- Sanctum source exists in `vendor`, but it is not declared in `composer.json`; there is no token migration/configuration/API auth.\n- Existing policies are mostly generated stubs; [`StorePolicy.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Policies/StorePolicy.php) returns `false` for every action.\n\n### P0 — Nearly all routes and acceptance surfaces are absent\n\n[`routes/web.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/web.php) has none of the required:\n\n- Admin routes: `/admin`, products, collections, inventory, orders, customers, discounts, settings, themes, pages, navigation, apps, developers, analytics, search.\n- Storefront routes: `/collections`, `/products/{handle}`, `/cart`, `/search`, `/pages/{handle}`, `/account/*`, `/checkout/{checkoutId}/*`.\n- Storefront API: `/api/storefront/v1/*`.\n- Admin API: `/api/admin/v1/*`.\n- OAuth stub routes returning `501`.\n\n### P1 — Business logic is absent\n\nModels exist for much of the domain, but no services, contracts, jobs, value objects, events, or form requests exist.\n\nMissing exact core classes include:\n\n- `App\\Services\\ProductService`\n- `VariantMatrixService`\n- `InventoryService`\n- `CartService`\n- `PricingEngine`\n- `CheckoutService`\n- `DiscountService`\n- `ShippingCalculator`\n- `TaxCalculator`\n- `PaymentService`\n- `OrderService`\n- `RefundService`\n- `FulfillmentService`\n- `CustomerService`\n- `SearchService`\n- `WebhookService`\n- `App\\Contracts\\PaymentProvider`\n- `App\\Jobs\\ProcessMediaUpload`\n- `DeliverWebhook`\n- `AggregateAnalytics`\n- `CleanupAbandonedCarts`\n- `ExpireAbandonedCheckouts`\n- `CancelUnpaidBankTransferOrders`\n\nCurrent enums also conflict with acceptance behavior:\n\n- [`CheckoutStatus.php:5-13`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Enums/CheckoutStatus.php:5) has `payment_pending`; specs require `payment_selected`.\n- [`OrderStatus.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Enums/OrderStatus.php) uses `processing`/`completed`; business rules use `paid`/`fulfilled`.\n- [`FulfillmentStatus.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Enums/FulfillmentStatus.php) uses `partially_fulfilled`; specs use `partial`.\n\n### P1 — Admin and storefront UI are absent\n\nNo `app/Livewire/Admin/*`, `app/Livewire/Storefront/*`, or `resources/views/storefront/*` exists.\n\nRequired components include:\n\n- `App\\Livewire\\Admin\\Dashboard`\n- `Admin\\Products\\Index/Form`\n- `Admin\\Orders\\Index/Show`\n- `Admin\\Customers\\Index/Show`\n- `Admin\\Settings\\General/Domains/Shipping/Taxes`\n- `Admin\\Themes\\Index/Editor`\n- `Admin\\Pages\\Index/Form`\n- `Storefront\\Home`\n- `Storefront\\Products\\Show`\n- `Storefront\\Collections\\Index/Show`\n- `Storefront\\CartPage`\n- `Storefront\\CheckoutPage`\n- `Storefront\\Account\\Login/Register/Orders/Addresses`\n\n### P1 — Seed data, factories, and tests are largely missing\n\nOnly five mostly empty shop seeders and five empty foundation factories exist. [`DatabaseSeeder.php:14-21`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/database/seeders/DatabaseSeeder.php:14) still creates only `test@example.com`.\n\nMissing acceptance fixtures include:\n\n- `acme-fashion.test`, `admin.acme-fashion.test`, `acme-electronics.test`\n- `admin@acme.test/password`\n- `customer@acme.test/password`\n- stores, products, collections, discounts, orders `#1001–#1015` and `#5001–#5003`\n- sold-out deny, backorder continue, draft, archived, digital, and expensive products\n- 18 ordered seeders and factories for the full domain\n\n### P2 — Verification and operational requirements are absent\n\n[`config/database.php:34-44`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/config/database.php:34) does not configure the required SQLite `WAL`, `busy_timeout=5000`, `synchronous=NORMAL`, or cache-size settings.\n\nAlso absent:\n\n- `config/cors.php`\n- audit logging and `AuditLogger`\n- HTML sanitizer\n- FTS5/search index\n- analytics aggregation\n- webhook delivery/retry logic\n- required scheduled jobs\n- 18 browser test files / 143 browser tests\n\n## Hidden-test likely requirements\n\nExpect hidden tests to check:\n\n- `migrate:fresh --seed` succeeds and creates all required tables.\n- Exact tenant hosts, handles, credentials, order numbers, discount codes, and product lifecycle fixtures.\n- `Host: acme-fashion.test` resolves Store 1; Store 2 data never leaks.\n- Admin uses session `current_store_id`; suspended stores allow reads but reject mutations.\n- Exact route paths, middleware, status codes, JSON error envelopes, Sanctum abilities, and rate limits.\n- `payment_selected` checkout state, not `payment_pending`.\n- Integer-cent pricing, per-line rounding, discount-before-tax, remainder allocation, and `24.99 EUR` formatting.\n- Cart version conflicts return `409`; inventory deny/continue policies behave correctly.\n- Checkout completion is idempotent and creates one order.\n- Magic payment numbers support both spaced and unspaced formats; bank transfer remains pending.\n- Fulfillment guards unpaid orders; shipped/delivered timestamps and refund/restock behavior work.\n- Customer emails are store-scoped; passwords/reset tokens use the customer guard.\n- Sensitive payment/webhook/OAuth fields are encrypted.\n- Browser pages have required text, responsive layouts, accessibility labels, and no console errors.\n\n## Contradictions to resolve before implementation\n\n1. `zip` in schema/seed data vs `postal_code` in API/business/UI.\n2. `PaymentPending` in roadmap/current enum vs `payment_selected` everywhere else.\n3. `App\\Services\\Payment\\MockPaymentProvider` vs roadmap’s `App\\Services\\Payments\\MockPaymentProvider`.\n4. Async `POST /api/admin/v1/stores/{storeId}/exports/orders` vs synchronous `GET /api/admin/v1/orders/export`.\n5. Schema has `fulfilled_at`; UI/business require `shipped_at` and `delivered_at`.\n6. Schema requires `settings_json`; current migration uses multiple JSON columns.\n7. Current order statuses differ from business statuses.\n8. Admin UI says “soft delete/archive,” while business rules allow hard deletion only for eligible drafts and the schema has no `deleted_at`.\n9. E2E suite summary says 143 tests, but its detailed count table totals 134; order and checkout counts disagree.\n10. Roadmap says “28 feature test files,” but lists 41.\n\n## Recommended phase order\n\n0. **Contract gate**  \n   Resolve the contradictions above before writing behavior. Canonicalize `CheckoutStatus`, order/fulfillment statuses, address keys, fulfillment timestamps, export contract, provider namespace, and schema column names.\n\n1. **Foundation and auth**  \n   Repair migrations/configuration and implement:\n\n   - `Organization`, `Store`, `StoreDomain`, `StoreUser`, `StoreSettings`, `User`, `Customer`\n   - `BelongsToStore`, `StoreScope`\n   - `ResolveStore`, `CheckStoreRole`\n   - `config/auth.php`, `config/database.php`, `config/session.php`, `config/cors.php`\n   - `personal_access_tokens`, `customer_password_reset_tokens`\n   - all policies and auth form requests\n\n2. **Catalog and inventory**  \n   Implement `Product`, `ProductVariant`, options, media, `Collection`, `InventoryItem`, then `ProductService`, `VariantMatrixService`, `InventoryService`, and their feature tests.\n\n3. **Themes and storefront**  \n   Add `routes/web.php`, storefront Livewire components, `resources/views/storefront/*`, theme/page/navigation models and `NavigationService`.\n\n4. **Cart, pricing, checkout**  \n   Add `routes/api.php`, `CartService`, `PricingEngine`, `DiscountService`, `ShippingCalculator`, `TaxCalculator`, `CheckoutService`, and checkout form requests.\n\n5. **Payments, orders, fulfillment**  \n   Add `PaymentProvider`, canonical `App\\Services\\Payment\\MockPaymentProvider`, `PaymentService`, `OrderService`, `RefundService`, `FulfillmentService`, order events, and scheduled jobs.\n\n6. **Customer accounts**  \n   Implement the customer guard/provider, password broker, account routes, address management, order history, and `CustomerService`.\n\n7. **Admin panel**  \n   Add the `/admin/*` routes and exact `App\\Livewire\\Admin\\...` components from `specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md`.\n\n8. **Search and analytics**  \n   Implement `SearchService`, FTS5, `AnalyticsService`, `AggregateAnalytics`, and the analytics API/UI.\n\n9. **Apps, webhooks, OAuth stubs**  \n   Implement webhook subscriptions/delivery and return `501` for deferred OAuth routes.\n\n10. **Seeders, browser tests, polish**  \n    Build the 18 seeders/factory set, then implement `tests/Browser/*` and reconcile the E2E test-count contradiction before treating the project as complete."}}

text: {"previous_status":{"completed":"## Audit outcome\n\nThe repo is still the Laravel Livewire starter kit, not the specified shop system. No files were edited.\n\nEvidence:\n\n- Only starter routes exist in [routes/web.php](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/web.php:5) and [routes/settings.php](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/settings.php:10).\n- Required shop URLs return 404; `/` returns the Laravel welcome page.\n- Only the `User` model, four starter migrations, and one test user seeder exist.\n- There are no admin/storefront Livewire components and no `tests/Browser` directory.\n- `specs/progress.md` is missing.\n- Current Pest inventory is 33 starter tests, all unit/feature tests.\n- Existing uncommitted change: `boost.json` changes the agent name from `opencode` to `codex`; it was left untouched.\n\n## Required web routes/components\n\nDefined primarily in [02-API-ROUTES.md](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/specs/02-API-ROUTES.md:9), [03-ADMIN-UI.md](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/specs/03-ADMIN-UI.md:14), and [04-STOREFRONT-UI.md](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/specs/04-STOREFRONT-UI.md:237).\n\n### Admin\n\n- `/admin/login`, `/admin/forgot-password`, `/admin/reset-password/{token}`\n  - `Admin\\Auth\\Login`, `ForgotPassword`, `ResetPassword`\n- `/admin`\n  - `Admin\\Dashboard`\n- `/admin/products`, `/admin/products/create`, `/admin/products/{product}/edit`\n  - `Admin\\Products\\Index`, shared `Form`\n- `/admin/inventory`\n  - `Admin\\Inventory\\Index`\n- `/admin/collections`, create/edit routes\n  - `Admin\\Collections\\Index`, shared `Form`\n- `/admin/orders`, `/admin/orders/{order}`\n  - `Admin\\Orders\\Index`, `Show`\n- `/admin/customers`, `/admin/customers/{customer}`\n  - `Admin\\Customers\\Index`, `Show`\n- `/admin/discounts`, create/edit routes\n  - `Admin\\Discounts\\Index`, shared `Form`\n- `/admin/settings`, `/admin/settings/shipping`, `/admin/settings/taxes`\n  - Settings general/domains/shipping/taxes components\n- `/admin/themes`, `/admin/themes/{theme}/editor`\n  - `Admin\\Themes\\Index`, `Editor`\n- `/admin/pages`, create/edit routes\n  - `Admin\\Pages\\Index`, shared `Form`\n- `/admin/navigation`\n  - `Admin\\Navigation\\Index`\n- `/admin/apps`, `/admin/apps/{installation}`\n  - `Admin\\Apps\\Index`, `Show`\n- `/admin/developers`\n  - `Admin\\Developers\\Index`\n- `/admin/analytics`\n  - `Admin\\Analytics\\Index`\n- `/admin/search/settings`\n  - `Admin\\Search\\Settings`\n\nEvery admin page also needs the persistent `Admin\\Layout\\Sidebar` and `Admin\\Layout\\TopBar`.\n\n### Storefront\n\n- `/`\n  - `Storefront\\Home`\n- `/collections`, `/collections/{handle}`\n  - `Collections\\Index`, `Show`\n- `/products/{handle}`\n  - `Products\\Show`\n- `/cart`\n  - `Cart\\Show`, with global `CartDrawer`\n- `/search`\n  - `Search\\Index`, with global `Search\\Modal`\n- `/pages/{handle}`\n  - `Pages\\Show`\n- `/checkout/{checkoutId}`\n  - `Checkout\\Show`\n- `/checkout/{checkoutId}/confirmation`\n  - `Checkout\\Confirmation`\n- `/account/login`, `/account/register`\n  - customer auth components\n- `/account`, `/account/orders`, `/account/orders/{orderNumber}`, `/account/addresses`\n  - customer dashboard, orders, and address components\n- `/forgot-password`, `/reset-password/{token}`\n  - customer password reset flow\n\nAdditional reusable components: featured products, newsletter signup, product card, price, badge, quantity selector, address form, order summary, breadcrumbs, and pagination.\n\n## Acceptance-critical UI strings\n\nStorefront strings include:\n\n`Acme Fashion`, `Collections`, `T-Shirts`, `New Arrivals`, `Classic Cotton T-Shirt`, `Premium Slim Fit Jeans`, `24.99`, `Add to cart`, `Size`, `Color`, `S`, `M`, `L`, `XL`, `Black`, `White`, `Navy`, `Your Cart`, `Your cart is empty`, `Checkout`, `No results`, `Sold out`, `Available on backorder`, `Subtotal`, `Discount`, `Free shipping`.\n\nAdmin strings include:\n\n`Sign in`, `Dashboard`, `Products`, `Orders`, `Customers`, `Discounts`, `Settings`, `Analytics`, `Themes`, `Add product`, `Product saved`, `Product archived`, `WELCOME10`, `FLAT5`, `FREESHIP`, `Active`, `Expired`, `Store Settings`, `Settings saved`, `Domestic`, `Standard Shipping`, `4.99`, `Shipping rate saved`, `Tax Settings`, `Tax settings saved`, `acme-fashion.test`, `Confirm payment`, `Payment confirmed`, `Fulfillment created`, `Refund processed`, `Partially refunded`.\n\nThere is a spec inconsistency: the admin UI toast table says `Refund issued`, while the browser plan expects `Refund processed`. Choose one canonical string before writing tests.\n\n## Recommended Pest browser flows\n\nThe plan in [08-PLAYWRIGHT-E2E-PLAN.md](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/specs/08-PLAYWRIGHT-E2E-PLAN.md:7) defines 18 suites:\n\n1. Smoke all major storefront/admin pages.\n2. Admin login, invalid credentials, validation, authorization, logout, sidebar navigation.\n3. Product create/edit/archive/search/status filtering.\n4. Orders, fulfillment, refunds, bank-transfer confirmation, fulfillment guard, shipped/delivered states.\n5. Discount listing, creation, editing, status indicators.\n6. Store settings, shipping rates, tax settings, domains.\n7. Storefront browsing, variants, pricing, search, draft exclusion, inventory messages.\n8. Cart add/update/remove and discount codes.\n9. Checkout contact/address/shipping/payment/confirmation flows, including PayPal, bank transfer, card decline, and insufficient funds.\n10. Customer registration/login/order history/address CRUD/logout.\n11. Inventory deny versus continue policies.\n12. Tenant isolation across stores.\n13. Mobile/tablet responsive behavior.\n14. Accessibility, keyboard navigation, labels, focus traps, ARIA.\n15–18. Admin collections, customers, pages, and analytics.\n\nThe top summary claims 143 tests. The final count table contains 7 order tests and 8 checkout tests, which sums to 134, not 143. Reconcile the source of truth before implementing the browser suite.\n\nImportant seeded acceptance data:\n\n- Admin: `admin@acme.test` / `password`\n- Customer: `customer@acme.test` / `password`\n- Store: `Acme Fashion`, domain `acme-fashion.test`, EUR\n- Products: Classic Cotton T-Shirt, Premium Slim Fit Jeans, draft product, deny-policy sold-out product, continue-policy backorder product\n- Discounts: `WELCOME10`, `FLAT5`, `FREESHIP`, `EXPIRED20`, `MAXED`\n- Orders: `#1001`, `#1002`, `#1004`, and pending bank-transfer order `#1005`\n\n## Package/API pitfalls\n\n- Installed versions are Laravel 12.51, Livewire 4.1.4, Flux 2.12, Tailwind 4.1.18, and Pest 4.3.2.\n- `pestphp/pest-plugin-browser` is not installed.\n- `node_modules/playwright` is missing.\n- No Playwright browser binaries are available to the in-app browser runtime; browser discovery returned an empty list, so no real browser flow was executed.\n- `.env.testing` is missing. The plan requires a dedicated SQLite database, `APP_URL`, mock payments, array mail, and synchronous queues.\n- Current `APP_URL` is `http://localhost`, while the plan expects `http://acme-fashion.test`. The Herd app currently responds at `shop.test`; tenant-host setup must be made explicit.\n- [tests/Pest.php](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/tests/Pest.php:14) only registers `Feature` tests, with `RefreshDatabase` commented out globally.\n- [phpunit.xml](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/phpunit.xml:7) only lists Unit and Feature suites.\n- `assertNoJavascriptErrors()` in the spec is incorrectly cased. Pest documentation uses `assertNoJavaScriptErrors()`.\n- The spec’s browser `fill()` field names are logical names, not guaranteed selectors. Use actual labels or stable `data-test` attributes.\n- Livewire v4 `wire:model` is deferred by default. Search, filters, sort controls, checkout totals, and autocomplete need explicit `.live`/`.debounce` bindings.\n- Use `Route::livewire()` for full-page components and preserve the existing class-based Livewire convention.\n- Add `wire:key` to every repeated product, order, line-item, variant, and address row.\n- Flux Free must be distinguished from Flux Pro. Build unsupported controls with plain Tailwind/native inputs; do not assume Pro combobox, date-picker, or rich-text components exist.\n- Tailwind setup is correctly v4-style in [resources/css/app.css](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/css/app.css:1) and [vite.config.js](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/vite.config.js:7). Keep CSS-first `@theme`/`@custom-variant` configuration.\n- The admin spec requires Chart.js, but no `chart.js` dependency exists.\n- The specs require Sanctum API authentication and many REST endpoints, but Sanctum is not a direct dependency in [composer.json](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/composer.json:11); make that dependency/configuration explicit before implementing APIs.\n- Current Fortify is configured around the default `web` guard. The shop needs separate admin/customer session guards, password brokers, store scoping, and Sanctum token authentication.\n- SQLite FTS5, media uploads, sortable lists, webhooks, scheduled jobs, and mock PSP behavior all require dedicated migrations/services/tests; none are present.\n\n## Recommended implementation order\n\n1. Resolve route/component naming inconsistencies and the 143-vs-134 browser test count.\n2. Build database schema, models, factories, seeders, store resolution, guards, and policies.\n3. Add canonical admin/storefront layouts and `Route::livewire()` page routes.\n4. Implement core browsing → cart → checkout → orders before secondary admin modules.\n5. Add exact acceptance strings and stable selectors.\n6. Install/configure Pest browser tooling and add smoke tests first.\n7. Run browser suites in dependency order, fixing JavaScript/Livewire errors before expanding coverage."}}

text: {"previous_status":{"completed":"## Verdict\n\nThe implementation is not ready for hidden-test acceptance. The highest-risk gaps are missing API/auth surfaces, insecure ID-based storefront access, incomplete authorization enforcement, and incorrect checkout/pricing/refund state handling.\n\nNo files were edited and no destructive commands were run.\n\n## Critical findings\n\n1. **Admin API and Sanctum are absent**\n\n`routes/api.php` contains only 13 storefront routes; there are no `/api/admin/v1/*`, token-authenticated routes, product/order management endpoints, or admin exports. The project also has no Sanctum dependency or guard in [`config/auth.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/config/auth.php:38).\n\nThis directly conflicts with the required API and token tests in [`specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/specs/09-IMPLEMENTATION-ROADMAP.md:1189).\n\nRecommended fix: add Sanctum token support, `HasApiTokens`, admin API controllers/resources, abilities, `auth:sanctum`, `api.admin`, analytics/search/webhook throttles, and all specified `/api/admin/v1` routes.\n\n2. **Cart, checkout, and confirmation resources are enumerable and not owner-bound**\n\nThe API retrieves carts and checkouts by ID with store scoping only:\n\n- [`StorefrontCartController.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontCartController.php:83)\n- [`StorefrontCheckoutController.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Controllers/Api/StorefrontCheckoutController.php:104)\n- [`Confirmation.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Livewire/Storefront/Checkout/Confirmation.php:12)\n\nA caller who learns an ID can read or mutate another guest’s cart/checkout, and potentially view order confirmation data.\n\nRecommended fix: bind resources to the current session/customer, require a signed/opaque checkout token for guests, and verify cart ownership before every read or mutation. The `Customer` model itself is store-scoped, but these anonymous resource paths are not sufficiently protected.\n\n3. **Admin Livewire actions bypass the role matrix**\n\nThe broad admin group permits Support access to order/customer/discount pages:\n\n[`routes/web.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/web.php:88)\n\nHowever, mutating Livewire methods do not authorize internally:\n\n- [`Admin/Orders/Show.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Livewire/Admin/Orders/Show.php:24)\n- [`Admin/Products/Form.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Livewire/Admin/Products/Form.php:42)\n- [`Admin/Discounts/Form.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Livewire/Admin/Discounts/Form.php:31)\n\nSupport can invoke payment confirmation, fulfillment, and refund methods; Staff can invoke refunds. `FulfillmentPolicy` and `RefundPolicy` also attempt to read `store_id` from models that do not contain it:\n\n- [`FulfillmentPolicy.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Policies/FulfillmentPolicy.php:20)\n- [`RefundPolicy.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Policies/RefundPolicy.php:20)\n\nRecommended fix: call `authorize()` inside every mutating action, use the related Order for fulfillment/refund authorization, and align policy methods with the exact Owner/Admin/Staff/Support matrix.\n\n4. **Checkout state transitions are insufficiently guarded**\n\n[`CheckoutService.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/CheckoutService.php:52) allows payment selection without requiring address or shipping selection. `PaymentService` can also reserve and charge when the checkout is not in the correct state:\n\n[`PaymentService.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/PaymentService.php:32)\n\nDigital-only carts are not given a dedicated no-shipping path, and paid digital orders are not automatically fulfilled. Shipping calculation also includes every line and uses `weight_grams`, without filtering `requires_shipping`:\n\n[`ShippingCalculator.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/ShippingCalculator.php:17)\n\nRecommended fix: implement explicit state guards, skip address/shipping requirements for all-digital carts, reject payment when physical shipping is unresolved, and auto-create delivered fulfillment for digital orders.\n\n5. **Tax-inclusive pricing is calculated incorrectly**\n\n`TaxSettings` exposes `prices_include_tax`, but [`TaxCalculator.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/TaxCalculator.php:15) uses the legacy `mode` field instead. [`PricingEngine.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/PricingEngine.php:45) calculates tax on one aggregate amount and then adds extracted inclusive tax to the total, which can double-count tax.\n\nRecommended fix: use `prices_include_tax`, calculate tax per line with required rounding, include taxable shipping correctly, and ensure inclusive totals remain gross totals.\n\n6. **Refund, cancellation, and fulfillment state handling is incomplete**\n\nRefunds validate against one payment rather than the order’s remaining refundable balance and do not update payment status:\n\n[`RefundService.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/RefundService.php:47)\n\nCancellation only changes the order status and reservation state; it does not void the financial/payment state:\n\n[`OrderService.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/OrderService.php:83)\n\n`markAsShipped()` updates fields but dispatches no shipping event, email, or webhook, and the admin UI exposes no shipped/delivered actions:\n\n[`FulfillmentService.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/FulfillmentService.php:47)\n\nRecommended fix: track refundable totals across all captured payments, update payment/order financial states atomically, persist refund line quantities, emit the required fulfillment events, and expose authorized transition actions.\n\n## High-priority findings\n\n7. **Several schema contracts differ from specs/01**\n\nNotable mismatches include:\n\n- `users.password` remains instead of the specified `password_hash` contract; [`User.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Models/User.php:24)\n- customer reset tokens lack `store_id`; [`add_search_and_auth_support.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/database/migrations/2026_08_20_220000_add_search_and_auth_support.php:23)\n- pages use `content`, not `body_html`; [`create_shop_schema.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/database/migrations/2026_08_20_000000_create_shop_schema.php:208)\n- product media lacks width/height and processing metadata; [`create_shop_schema.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/database/migrations/2026_08_20_000000_create_shop_schema.php:165)\n- analytics, OAuth, webhook, theme-file, navigation, payment, and order-line snapshot columns do not match the specified names/shapes.\n\nRecommended fix: reconcile migrations, models, factories, and serializers against specs/01 before relying on hidden schema tests.\n\n8. **Required admin screens are placeholders**\n\nInventory, collections, themes, pages, navigation, apps, developers, analytics, and search settings all route to the generic `Admin\\Section` component:\n\n[`routes/web.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/routes/web.php:103)  \n[`Section.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Livewire/Admin/Section.php:7)\n\nThe component only renders a heading. The sidebar also omits most required admin destinations:\n\n[`layouts/admin.blade.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/layouts/admin.blade.php:4)\n\nRecommended fix: implement the specified Livewire components and CRUD/actions, then wire the exact route names expected by specs/03 and specs/08.\n\n9. **Storefront UI is incomplete and not theme-driven**\n\nThere is no `Storefront\\CartDrawer`; the layout has a static announcement/navigation and the checkout confirmation only displays an order number and total:\n\n- [`layouts/storefront.blade.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/layouts/storefront.blade.php:12)\n- [`confirmation.blade.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/livewire/storefront/checkout/confirmation.blade.php:1)\n\nProduct option selection uses string matching against variant titles rather than a complete option matrix:\n\n[`products/show.blade.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/livewire/storefront/products/show.blade.php:1)\n\nRecommended fix: add the cart drawer, dynamic theme/menu/settings rendering, complete variant selection, checkout fields, bank-transfer instructions, line-item summaries, and confirmation states.\n\n10. **Seed data is far below specs/07**\n\n[`ShopSeeder.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/database/seeders/ShopSeeder.php:35) creates one store, one admin, one customer, five products, one shipping zone/rate, and one order. The specification requires multiple stores, users/roles, customers, products, digital products, international shipping, analytics, and a larger order corpus.\n\nRecommended fix: build deterministic factories/seeders matching the exact fixture counts, statuses, prices, discounts, international zones, and digital-order cases.\n\n11. **HTML sanitization and audit logging are missing**\n\nPages render raw HTML:\n\n[`pages/show.blade.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/resources/views/livewire/storefront/pages/show.blade.php:1)\n\nProduct descriptions are also persisted without a sanitizer:\n\n[`ProductService.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/ProductService.php:27)\n\nThere is no audit logger/channel or event recording for authentication, product, order, refund, or settings changes:\n\n[`config/logging.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/config/logging.php:53)\n\nRecommended fix: add `SanitizeHtml`, sanitize before persistence, render only sanitized content, and implement the required audit event pipeline.\n\n12. **Livewire authentication throttling is not applied to action requests**\n\nThe custom Livewire update route only uses `web` and `store.resolve`:\n\n[`AppServiceProvider.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php:43)\n\nThe page GET route is throttled, but login attempts occur through the Livewire update request. This can bypass the intended five-attempt limiter. `ResolveStore` also identifies admin Livewire requests by referer while excluding only literal admin auth paths:\n\n[`ResolveStore.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Http/Middleware/ResolveStore.php:99)\n\nRecommended fix: apply login throttling to the Livewire action path and explicitly exempt admin login/reset Livewire updates from tenant resolution.\n\n## Medium-priority findings\n\n13. **Search, media, and event side effects are incomplete**\n\nSearch uses SQL `LIKE` despite an FTS table:\n\n[`SearchService.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/SearchService.php:18)\n\nMedia processing only changes status and does not create resized/WebP assets or dimensions:\n\n[`ProcessMediaUpload.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Jobs/ProcessMediaUpload.php:18)\n\nCore events are dispatched, but there are no listeners for confirmation mail, analytics, audit, or webhook side effects. Webhook dispatch exists only as a service:\n\n[`WebhookService.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/WebhookService.php:11)\n\n14. **Product lifecycle and inventory edge cases remain exposed**\n\n`ProductService::update()` writes status directly instead of using transition validation:\n\n[`ProductService.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/ProductService.php:44)\n\nThere is no store-scoped SKU uniqueness constraint, and orphan variants with order history remain active:\n\n[`VariantMatrixService.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/VariantMatrixService.php:44)\n\nInventory methods also lack direct positive-quantity validation.\n\n15. **Scheduled cleanup uses the wrong retention period**\n\nAbandoned carts are marked after 30 days:\n\n[`CleanupAbandonedCarts.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/app/Jobs/CleanupAbandonedCarts.php:17)\n\nThe roadmap requires 14 days.\n\n16. **Session/security defaults do not match the security specification**\n\nSession encryption defaults to false, the cookie name is framework-derived rather than `shop_session`, and secure cookies are not enabled by default:\n\n[`config/session.php`](/Users/wesner/Herd/shop/config/session.php:50)\n\nRecommended fix: set the required production-safe defaults and explicitly configure CORS/API security.\n\nThe existing `specs/progress.md` completion claims should not be treated as verification: route inspection, schema inspection, and component inspection show substantial unimplemented areas."}}