type: text

text:
Perfect! Now I have comprehensive information about the architecture. Let me compile the complete map:

## Complete Architecture Map for Deptrac Configuration

I've thoroughly explored your application structure. Here's the comprehensive architectural layer map with all dependencies:

### 1. **Top-Level Directories Under `app/`**

```
app/
├── Actions/                  # Action classes (domain actions)
│   └── Fortify/             # Laravel Fortify integration
├── Concerns/                # Shared validation rules
├── Contracts/               # Interface/contract definitions
├── Enums/                   # State enums (28 files)
├── Events/                  # Domain events
├── Exceptions/              # Custom exceptions
├── Http/
│   ├── Controllers/         # HTTP controllers
│   └── Middleware/          # HTTP middleware
├── Jobs/                    # Queued jobs
├── Livewire/               # Livewire components
│   ├── Actions/            # Livewire-specific actions
│   ├── Admin/              # Admin panel (deeply nested)
│   ├── Settings/           # User settings components
│   └── Storefront/         # Customer-facing components
├── Models/                  # Eloquent models
│   ├── Concerns/           # Model traits (BelongsToStore, etc)
│   └── Scopes/             # Query scopes
├── Observers/              # Eloquent observers
├── Policies/               # Authorization policies (10 files)
├── Providers/              # Service providers
├── Services/               # Business logic services (16 files)
│   └── Payments/           # Payment provider implementations
├── Support/                # Utility classes
├── Traits/                 # Reusable traits
└── ValueObjects/           # Immutable value objects
```

### 2. **PSR-4 Autoload Namespaces** (from composer.json)

```json
"App\\": "app/",
"Database\\Factories\\": "database/factories/",
"Database\\Seeders\\": "database/seeders/"
```

All application code uses the `App\` namespace with subdirectories mapping to subdirectories.

### 3. **Detailed Dependency Patterns**

#### **A. Services Import Models (Confirmed)**
Services are the core business logic layer and heavily depend on Models:

- `CartService`: imports Cart, CartLine, ProductVariant, Store, Enums, Exceptions
- `CheckoutService`: imports Checkout, Cart, Order, ShippingRate, Store, Contracts (PaymentProvider), Enums, other Services
- `OrderService`: imports Order, Cart, Checkout, ProductVariant, Store, ValueObjects, Enums, Inventory Service
- `ProductService`: imports Product, InventoryItem, Store, Enums, Exceptions, Support (HandleGenerator)
- `PricingEngine`: imports Cart, Checkout, TaxSettings, ShippingRate, Store, ValueObjects, multiple Services
- `InventoryService`: imports InventoryItem, Enums, Exceptions
- `ShippingCalculator`: imports Cart, ShippingRate, ShippingZone, Store, Enums
- `DiscountService`: imports Cart, Discount, Store, Enums, Exceptions, ValueObjects
- `TaxCalculator`: imports TaxSettings, ValueObjects
- `FulfillmentService`: imports Fulfillment, FulfillmentLine, Order, Enums, Exceptions, Events
- `RefundService`: imports Order, Payment, Refund, Contracts, Enums, Exceptions, Events
- `OrderService`: imports Order, Checkout, Cart, ValueObjects, Enums, Events, InventoryService

#### **B. Services Import Other Services (Confirmed - Complex Dependency Graph)**
This is the KEY architecture pattern:

- **CheckoutService** depends on:
  - `PricingEngine`
  - `InventoryService`
  - `ShippingCalculator`
  - `PaymentProvider` (Contract)
  - `OrderService`

- **PricingEngine** depends on:
  - `CartService`
  - `DiscountService`
  - `ShippingCalculator`
  - `TaxCalculator`

- **OrderService** depends on:
  - `InventoryService`

- **RefundService** depends on:
  - `PaymentProvider` (Contract)
  - `InventoryService`

- **WebhookService** depends on:
  - `DeliverWebhook` (Job)

- **ProductService** depends on:
  - `HandleGenerator` (Support class)

#### **C. Livewire Components Import Services (Confirmed)**
UI layer dependencies on business logic:

- **Storefront/Cart/Show**: imports `CartService`, `DiscountService`, Models, Exceptions
- **Admin/Orders/Show**: imports Models and Enums (doesn't directly inject Services, but could)
- **Admin/Products/Form**: imports Models and Enums
- **Settings**: imports Concerns and Actions

#### **D. Jobs Import Services (Confirmed)**
Background jobs depend on both Models and Services:

- `DeliverWebhook`: imports `WebhookService`, Models
- `CancelUnpaidBankTransferOrders`: imports `OrderService`, Models, Enums
- `ExpireAbandonedCheckouts`: imports `InventoryService`, Models, Enums
- `ProcessMediaUpload`: imports Models, Enums
- `AggregateAnalytics`: imports `AnalyticsService`, Models
- `CleanupAbandonedCarts`: imports Models, Enums

#### **E. Other Import Patterns**

- **Models import Contracts**: e.g., PaymentProvider interface for polymorphic payment handling
- **Models import Enums**: For status columns, inventory policies, payment methods, etc.
- **Models import Events**: OrderService, FulfillmentService dispatch events (OrderCreated, OrderCancelled, OrderFulfilled, OrderRefunded, OrderPaid)
- **Models import Exceptions**: CartService, DiscountService, FulfillmentService throw custom exceptions
- **Models import ValueObjects**: PricingEngine, PaymentResult, DiscountResult, TaxLine for immutable return values
- **Observers import Services**: ProductObserver imports SearchService
- **Middleware imports Models**: ResolveStore middleware imports Store, StoreDomain, User
- **Policies**: 10 Authorization policy files (CollectionPolicy, CustomerPolicy, DiscountPolicy, FulfillmentPolicy, OrderPolicy, PagePolicy, ProductPolicy, RefundPolicy, StorePolicy, ThemePolicy)

### 4. **Deptrac Configuration Check**

No existing `deptrac.yaml`, `deptrac.yml`, `.deptrac.yaml`, or `.deptrac.yml` file found. You'll need to create one from scratch.

Deptrac is already in `composer.json` require-dev: `"deptrac/deptrac": "^4.6"`

### 5. **Specs Reference**

The implementation roadmap (spec 09) describes the architectural foundation but **doesn't mention Deptrac configuration**. Key architectural rules from specs/05-BUSINESS-LOGIC.md:

- Multi-tenancy with store isolation via middleware and global scopes
- Trait `BelongsToStore` applies automatic store filtering
- Global scope `StoreScope` filters queries
- Role-based access control via `StoreUserRole` enum
- All state management through Enums
- Domain events for order lifecycle
- Service layer for business logic (no direct Model manipulation in controllers/components)

---

## **Recommended Deptrac Layers for This Architecture**

Based on the dependency analysis, here's the suggested layer structure:

```
Layer: ValueObjects
Layer: Enums
Layer: Exceptions
Layer: Contracts (Interfaces)
Layer: Support (Utilities)
Layer: Models (no dependencies except the above)
Layer: Events
Layer: Traits/Concerns
Layer: Services (depends on Models, Enums, Contracts, Events, Exceptions, ValueObjects, Support)
Layer: Actions
Layer: Policies (Authorization)
Layer: Observers (depends on Services, Models)
Layer: Jobs (depends on Services, Models)
Layer: Http/Middleware (depends on Models)
Layer: Livewire/Components (depends on Services, Models)
Layer: Http/Controllers (depends on Services, Models)
```

**Key rules to enforce:**
1. Services cannot import from Http/Livewire (except Contracts)
2. Models cannot import from Services
3. Livewire and Controllers can import from Services
4. ValueObjects/Enums/Contracts have no dependencies
5. Services form a directed acyclic graph (CheckoutService -> OrderService is allowed, but circular would fail)

Would you like me to help create the specific `deptrac.yaml` configuration with these layers and rules?

text:
agentId: ac11b54 (for resuming to continue this agent's work if needed)
<usage>total_tokens: 52424
tool_uses: 35
duration_ms: 60790</usage>

status: completed

prompt:
Explore the application architecture in /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop to understand the layer structure for Deptrac configuration. I need to know:

1. All top-level directories under `app/` and their subdirectories
2. What namespaces exist (check composer.json PSR-4 autoload)
3. Any existing dependency patterns - do Services import Models? Do Livewire components import Services? Do Jobs import Services?
4. Check if there's already a deptrac.yaml or deptrac.yml file
5. Read the specs to see if there's any mention of architectural layers or Deptrac configuration

Provide a complete map of the architecture layers and their current dependency relationships.

speed: standard


teamName: wild-sleeping-shell

userType: external

slug: iterative-seeking-pine

type: message

role: assistant

service_tier: standard

type: assistant


type: thinking

thinking:
Good, I have a comprehensive understanding of the architecture. Now let me:

1. Install Deptrac
2. Create the deptrac.yaml configuration
3. Run it and fix any violations

Let me check if deptrac is already in composer.json (the explore agent mentioned it's in require-dev).


text: Good - the architecture is well-mapped. Deptrac is already in `composer.json` require-dev. Let me check if it's installed and create the configuration.


Bash

command: composer show deptrac/deptrac 2>/dev/null && echo "---" && which vendor/bin/deptrac 2>/dev/null || echo "NOT FOUND IN VENDOR"

description: Check Deptrac installation status

type: direct


type: user

role: user

content:
name     : deptrac/deptrac
descrip. : Deptrac is a static code analysis tool that helps to enforce rules for dependencies between software layers.
keywords : dev, static analysis
versions : * 4.6.0
released : 2026-02-02, last week
type     : library
license  : MIT License (MIT) (OSI approved) https://spdx.org/licenses/MIT.html#licenseText
homepage :
source   : [git] https://github.com/deptrac/deptrac.git b27bfc5291a1cbe1c0ebf514716b1d25c68c63fd
dist     : [zip] https://api.github.com/repos/deptrac/deptrac/zipball/b27bfc5291a1cbe1c0ebf514716b1d25c68c63fd b27bfc5291a1cbe1c0ebf514716b1d25c68c63fd
path     : /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/vendor/deptrac/deptrac
names    : deptrac/deptrac

support
issues : https://github.com/deptrac/deptrac/issues
source : https://github.com/deptrac/deptrac/tree/4.6.0

autoload
psr-4
Deptrac\Deptrac\ => src/

requires
composer/xdebug-handler ^3.0
jetbrains/phpstorm-stubs 2024.3 || 2025.3
nikic/php-parser ^5
php ^8.2
phpdocumentor/graphviz ^2.1
phpdocumentor/type-resolver ^1.9.0 || ^2.0.0
phpstan/phpdoc-parser ^1.5.0 || ^2.1.0
phpstan/phpstan ^2.0
psr/container ^2.0
psr/event-dispatcher ^1.0
symfony/config ^6.4 || ^7.4 || ^8.0
symfony/console ^6.4 || ^7.4 || ^8.0
symfony/dependency-injection ^6.4 || ^7.4 || ^8.0
symfony/event-dispatcher ^6.4 || ^7.4 || ^8.0
symfony/event-dispatcher-contracts ^3.4
symfony/filesystem ^6.4 || ^7.4 || ^8.0
symfony/finder ^6.4 || ^7.4 || ^8.0
symfony/yaml ^6.4 || ^7.4 || ^8.0

requires (dev)
bamarni/composer-bin-plugin ^1.8
ergebnis/composer-normalize ^2.45
ext-libxml *
symfony/stopwatch ^6.4 || ^7.4 || ^8.0

suggests
ext-dom For using the JUnit output formatter
---
vendor/bin/deptrac


type: progress

hookEvent: PostToolUse

command: callback


content:
     1→{
     2→    "$schema": "https://getcomposer.org/schema.json",
     3→    "name": "laravel/livewire-starter-kit",
     4→    "type": "project",
     5→    "description": "The official Laravel starter kit for Livewire.",
     6→    "keywords": [
     7→        "laravel",
     8→        "framework"
     9→    ],
    10→    "license": "MIT",
    11→    "require": {
    12→        "php": "^8.2",
    13→        "laravel/fortify": "^1.30",
    14→        "laravel/framework": "^12.0",
    15→        "laravel/tinker": "^2.10.1",
    16→        "livewire/flux": "^2.9.0",
    17→        "livewire/livewire": "^4.0"
    18→    },
    19→    "require-dev": {
    20→        "deptrac/deptrac": "^4.6",
    21→        "fakerphp/faker": "^1.23",
    22→        "larastan/larastan": "^3.9",
    23→        "laravel/boost": "^1.0",
    24→        "laravel/pail": "^1.2.2",
    25→        "laravel/pint": "^1.24",
    26→        "laravel/sail": "^1.41",
    27→        "mockery/mockery": "^1.6",
    28→        "nunomaduro/collision": "^8.6",
    29→        "pestphp/pest": "^4.3",
    30→        "pestphp/pest-plugin-laravel": "^4.0",
    31→        "phpstan/phpstan": "^2.1"
    32→    },
    33→    "autoload": {
    34→        "psr-4": {
    35→            "App\\": "app/",
    36→            "Database\\Factories\\": "database/factories/",
    37→            "Database\\Seeders\\": "database/seeders/"
    38→        }
    39→    },
    40→    "autoload-dev": {
    41→        "psr-4": {
    42→            "Tests\\": "tests/"
    43→        }
    44→    },
    45→    "scripts": {
    46→        "setup": [
    47→            "composer install",
    48→            "@php -r \"file_exists('.env') || copy('.env.example', '.env');\"",
    49→            "@php artisan key:generate",
    50→            "@php artisan migrate --force",
    51→            "npm install",
    52→            "npm run build"
    53→        ],
    54→        "dev": [
    55→            "Composer\\Config::disableProcessTimeout",
    56→            "npx concurrently -c \"#93c5fd,#c4b5fd,#fb7185,#fdba74\" \"php artisan serve\" \"php artisan queue:listen --tries=1 --timeout=0\" \"php artisan pail --timeout=0\" \"npm run dev\" --names=server,queue,logs,vite --kill-others"
    57→        ],
    58→        "lint": [
    59→            "pint --parallel"
    60→        ],
    61→        "test:lint": [
    62→            "pint --parallel --test"
    63→        ],
    64→        "test": [
    65→            "@php artisan config:clear --ansi",
    66→            "@test:lint",
    67→            "@php artisan test"
    68→        ],
    69→        "post-autoload-dump": [
    70→            "Illuminate\\Foundation\\ComposerScripts::postAutoloadDump",
    71→            "@php artisan package:discover --ansi"
    72→        ],
    73→        "post-update-cmd": [
    74→            "@php artisan vendor:publish --tag=laravel-assets --ansi --force"
    75→        ],
    76→        "post-root-package-install": [
    77→            "@php -r \"file_exists('.env') || copy('.env.example', '.env');\""
    78→        ],
    79→        "post-create-project-cmd": [
    80→            "@php artisan key:generate --ansi",
    81→            "@php -r \"file_exists('database/database.sqlite') || touch('database/database.sqlite');\"",
    82→            "@php artisan migrate --graceful --ansi"
    83→        ],
    84→        "pre-package-uninstall": [
    85→            "Illuminate\\Foundation\\ComposerScripts::prePackageUninstall"
    86→        ]
    87→    },
    88→    "extra": {
    89→        "laravel": {
    90→            "dont-discover": []
    91→        }
    92→    },
    93→    "config": {
    94→        "optimize-autoloader": true,
    95→        "preferred-install": "dist",
    96→        "sort-packages": true,
    97→        "allow-plugins": {
    98→            "pestphp/pest-plugin": true,
    99→            "php-http/discovery": true
   100→        }
   101→    },
   102→    "minimum-stability": "stable",
   103→    "prefer-stable": true
   104→}
   105→

laravel/livewire-starter-kit

type: project

keywords: laravel framework

license: MIT

App\: app/

Database\Factories\: database/factories/

Database\Seeders\: database/seeders/

Tests\: tests/

setup: @php -r "file_exists('.env') || copy('.env.example', '.env');"

dev: npx concurrently -c "#93c5fd,#c4b5fd,#fb7185,#fdba74" "php artisan serve" "php artisan queue:listen --tries=1 --timeout=0" "php artisan pail --timeout=0" "npm run dev" --names=server,queue,logs,vite --kill-others

test:
@php artisan config:clear --ansi
@test:lint
@php artisan test

post-create-project-cmd: @php -r "file_exists('database/database.sqlite') || touch('database/database.sqlite');"

preferred-install: dist

minimum-stability: stable


text: Deptrac 4.6 is installed. Now let me check its documentation for YAML config format and create the configuration.


Bash

command: vendor/bin/deptrac --help 2>&1 | head -30

description: Check Deptrac help output


content:
Description:
  Display help for a command

Usage:
  help [options] [--] [<command_name>]

Arguments:
  command_name                   The command name [default: "help"]

Options:
      --format=FORMAT            The output format (txt, xml, json, or md) [default: "txt"]
      --raw                      To output raw command help
  -h, --help                     Display help for the given command. When no command is given display help for the analyse command
      --silent                   Do not output any message
  -q, --quiet                    Only errors are displayed. All other output is suppressed
  -V, --version                  Display this application version
      --ansi|--no-ansi           Force (or disable --no-ansi) ANSI output
  -n, --no-interaction           Do not ask any interactive question
      --no-cache                 Disable caching mechanisms (wins over --cache-file)
      --clear-cache              Clears cache file before run
      --cache-file=CACHE-FILE    Location where cache file will be stored
  -c, --config-file=CONFIG-FILE  Location of Depfile containing the configuration [default: "/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/deptrac.yaml"]
  -v|vv|vvv, --verbose           Increase the verbosity of messages: 1 for normal output, 2 for more verbose output and 3 for debug

Help:
  The help command displays help for a given command:

    vendor/bin/deptrac help list

  You can also output the help in other formats by using the --format option:


command: ls vendor/deptrac/deptrac/docs/ 2>/dev/null || ls vendor/deptrac/deptrac/*.md 2>/dev/null || echo "No docs found"

description: Look for Deptrac documentation


content:
vendor/deptrac/deptrac/LICENCE.md
vendor/deptrac/deptrac/README.md


command: vendor/bin/deptrac analyse --help 2>&1 | head -40

description: Check Deptrac analyse command help


content: Command "analyse" is not defined.

stdout: Command "analyse" is not defined.


description: List available Deptrac commands


content:
deptrac 4.6.0

Usage:
  command [options] [arguments]

Options:
  -h, --help                     Display help for the given command. When no command is given display help for the analyse command
      --silent                   Do not output any message
  -q, --quiet                    Only errors are displayed. All other output is suppressed
  -V, --version                  Display this application version
      --ansi|--no-ansi           Force (or disable --no-ansi) ANSI output
  -n, --no-interaction           Do not ask any interactive question
      --no-cache                 Disable caching mechanisms (wins over --cache-file)
      --clear-cache              Clears cache file before run
      --cache-file=CACHE-FILE    Location where cache file will be stored
  -c, --config-file=CONFIG-FILE  Location of Depfile containing the configuration [default: "/Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/deptrac.yaml"]
  -v|vv|vvv, --verbose           Increase the verbosity of messages: 1 for normal output, 2 for more verbose output and 3 for debug

Available commands:
  analyse             [analyze] Analyses your project using the provided depfile
  changed-files       Lists layers corresponding to the changed files
  completion          Dump the shell completion script
  help                Display help for a command
  init                Creates a depfile template
  list                List commands
 debug
  debug:dependencies  List layer dependencies
  debug:layer         Checks which tokens belong to the provided layer
  debug:token         [debug:class-like] Checks which layers the provided token belongs to
  debug:unassigned    Lists tokens that are not assigned to any layer
  debug:unused        Lists unused (or barely used) layer dependencies


text: Let me check Deptrac 4.6 config format with an init template and also look at some examples.


description: Generate Deptrac config template


content: Depfile dumped.

stdout: Depfile dumped.


content:
     1→deptrac:
     2→  paths:
     3→    - ./src
     4→  exclude_files:
     5→    - '#.*test.*#'
     6→  layers:
     7→    - name: Controller
     8→      collectors:
     9→        - type: classLike
    10→          value: .*Controller.*
    11→    - name: Repository
    12→      collectors:
    13→        - type: classLike
    14→          value: .*Repository.*
    15→    - name: Service
    16→      collectors:
    17→        - type: classLike
    18→          value: .*Service.*
    19→  ruleset:
    20→    Controller:
    21→      - Service
    22→    Service:
    23→      - Repository
    24→    Repository:
    25→

content:
deptrac:
  paths:
    - ./src
  exclude_files:
    - '#.*test.*#'
  layers:
    - name: Controller
      collectors:
        - type: classLike
          value: .*Controller.*
    - name: Repository
      collectors:
        - type: classLike
          value: .*Repository.*
    - name: Service
      collectors:
        - type: classLike
          value: .*Service.*
  ruleset:
    Controller:
      - Service
    Service:
      - Repository
    Repository:


text: Good, I have the template format. Now let me create a proper Deptrac configuration for this Laravel app's architecture. Let me verify the exact directory/namespace structure first.


description: List top-level app directories


content:
app/Actions/
app/Concerns/
app/Contracts/
app/Enums/
app/Events/
app/Exceptions/
app/Http/
app/Jobs/
app/Livewire/
app/Models/
app/Observers/
app/Policies/
app/Providers/
app/Services/
app/Support/
app/Traits/
app/ValueObjects/


command: ls -d app/Models/*/  2>/dev/null; echo "---"; ls -d app/Http/*/ 2>/dev/null; echo "---"; ls -d app/Livewire/*/ 2>/dev/null

description: List subdirectories of key namespaces


content:
app/Models/Concerns/
app/Models/Scopes/
---
app/Http/Controllers/
app/Http/Middleware/
---
app/Livewire/Actions/
app/Livewire/Admin/
app/Livewire/Settings/
app/Livewire/Storefront/


text: Now I have the complete picture. Let me create the Deptrac configuration with proper architectural layers.


Write

content:
deptrac:
  paths:
    - ./app
  exclude_files:
    - '#.*test.*#'

  layers:
    # Foundation layers - no upstream dependencies
    - name: Enums
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Enums/.*

    - name: ValueObjects
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/ValueObjects/.*

    - name: Contracts
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Contracts/.*

    - name: Exceptions
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Exceptions/.*

    - name: Support
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Support/.*

    - name: Events
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Events/.*

    - name: Concerns
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Concerns/.*

    - name: Traits
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Traits/.*

    # Domain layer
    - name: Models
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Models/.*

    # Business logic layer
    - name: Services
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Services/.*

    # Authorization layer
    - name: Policies
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Policies/.*

    # Observer layer
    - name: Observers
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Observers/.*

    # Background processing layer
    - name: Jobs
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Jobs/.*

    # HTTP layer
    - name: Controllers
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Http/Controllers/.*

    - name: Middleware
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Http/Middleware/.*

    # UI layer
    - name: Livewire
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Livewire/.*

    # Actions layer (Fortify etc.)
    - name: Actions
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Actions/.*

    # Infrastructure layer
    - name: Providers
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Providers/.*

  ruleset:
    # Foundation layers - minimal dependencies
    Enums: ~
    ValueObjects:
      - Enums
    Contracts:
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Models
    Exceptions:
      - Enums
    Support: ~
    Events:
      - Enums
      - Models
    Concerns:
      - Enums
    Traits: ~

    # Domain layer - depends on foundation
    Models:
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Concerns
      - Traits
      - Events
      - Exceptions
      - Support

    # Business logic - depends on domain + foundation
    Services:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Contracts
      - Events
      - Exceptions
      - Support
      - Services

    # Authorization - depends on domain
    Policies:
      - Models
      - Enums

    # Observers - depends on services + domain
    Observers:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums

    # Jobs - depends on services + domain
    Jobs:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - Events
      - Exceptions

    # HTTP layer - depends on services + domain
    Controllers:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects

    Middleware:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - Exceptions

    # UI layer - depends on services + domain
    Livewire:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Exceptions
      - Concerns
      - Traits
      - Events
      - Support

    # Actions - depends on domain
    Actions:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - Exceptions
      - Support

    # Providers - infrastructure, can wire everything
    Providers:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - Contracts
      - Middleware
      - Support
      - Events


content:
The file /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/deptrac.yaml has been updated. Here's the result of running `cat -n` on a snippet of the edited file:
     1→deptrac:
     2→  paths:
     3→    - ./app
     4→  exclude_files:
     5→    - '#.*test.*#'
     6→
     7→  layers:
     8→    # Foundation layers - no upstream dependencies
     9→    - name: Enums
    10→      collectors:
    11→        - type: directory
    12→          value: app/Enums/.*
    13→
    14→    - name: ValueObjects
    15→      collectors:
    16→        - type: directory
    17→          value: app/ValueObjects/.*
    18→
    19→    - name: Contracts
    20→      collectors:
    21→        - type: directory
    22→          value: app/Contracts/.*
    23→
    24→    - name: Exceptions
    25→      collectors:
    26→        - type: directory
    27→          value: app/Exceptions/.*
    28→
    29→    - name: Support
    30→      collectors:
    31→        - type: directory
    32→          value: app/Support/.*
    33→
    34→    - name: Events
    35→      collectors:
    36→        - type: directory
    37→          value: app/Events/.*
    38→
    39→    - name: Concerns
    40→      collectors:
    41→        - type: directory
    42→          value: app/Concerns/.*
    43→
    44→    - name: Traits
    45→      collectors:
    46→        - type: directory
    47→          value: app/Traits/.*
    48→
    49→    # Domain layer
    50→    - name: Models
    51→      collectors:
    52→        - type: directory
    53→          value: app/Models/.*
    54→
    55→    # Business logic layer
    56→    - name: Services
    57→      collectors:
    58→        - type: directory
    59→          value: app/Services/.*
    60→
    61→    # Authorization layer
    62→    - name: Policies
    63→      collectors:
    64→        - type: directory
    65→          value: app/Policies/.*
    66→
    67→    # Observer layer
    68→    - name: Observers
    69→      collectors:
    70→        - type: directory
    71→          value: app/Observers/.*
    72→
    73→    # Background processing layer
    74→    - name: Jobs
    75→      collectors:
    76→        - type: directory
    77→          value: app/Jobs/.*
    78→
    79→    # HTTP layer
    80→    - name: Controllers
    81→      collectors:
    82→        - type: directory
    83→          value: app/Http/Controllers/.*
    84→
    85→    - name: Middleware
    86→      collectors:
    87→        - type: directory
    88→          value: app/Http/Middleware/.*
    89→
    90→    # UI layer
    91→    - name: Livewire
    92→      collectors:
    93→        - type: directory
    94→          value: app/Livewire/.*
    95→
    96→    # Actions layer (Fortify etc.)
    97→    - name: Actions
    98→      collectors:
    99→        - type: directory
   100→          value: app/Actions/.*
   101→
   102→    # Infrastructure layer
   103→    - name: Providers
   104→      collectors:
   105→        - type: directory
   106→          value: app/Providers/.*
   107→
   108→  ruleset:
   109→    # Foundation layers - minimal dependencies
   110→    Enums: ~
   111→    ValueObjects:
   112→      - Enums
   113→    Contracts:
   114→      - Enums
   115→      - ValueObjects
   116→      - Models
   117→    Exceptions:
   118→      - Enums
   119→    Support: ~
   120→    Events:
   121→      - Enums
   122→      - Models
   123→    Concerns:
   124→      - Enums
   125→    Traits: ~
   126→
   127→    # Domain layer - depends on foundation
   128→    Models:
   129→      - Enums
   130→      - ValueObjects
   131→      - Concerns
   132→      - Traits
   133→      - Events
   134→      - Exceptions
   135→      - Support
   136→
   137→    # Business logic - depends on domain + foundation
   138→    Services:
   139→      - Models
   140→      - Enums
   141→      - ValueObjects
   142→      - Contracts
   143→      - Events
   144→      - Exceptions
   145→      - Support
   146→      - Services
   147→
   148→    # Authorization - depends on domain
   149→    Policies:
   150→      - Models
   151→      - Enums
   152→
   153→    # Observers - depends on services + domain
   154→    Observers:
   155→      - Models
   156→      - Services
   157→      - Enums
   158→
   159→    # Jobs - depends on services + domain
   160→    Jobs:
   161→      - Models
   162→      - Services
   163→      - Enums
   164→      - Events
   165→      - Exceptions
   166→
   167→    # HTTP layer - depends on services + domain
   168→    Controllers:
   169→      - Models
   170→      - Services
   171→      - Enums
   172→      - ValueObjects
   173→
   174→    Middleware:
   175→      - Models
   176→      - Enums
   177→      - Exceptions
   178→
   179→    # UI layer - depends on services + domain
   180→    Livewire:
   181→      - Models
   182→      - Services
   183→      - Enums
   184→      - ValueObjects
   185→      - Exceptions
   186→      - Concerns
   187→      - Traits
   188→      - Events
   189→      - Support
   190→
   191→    # Actions - depends on domain
   192→    Actions:
   193→      - Models
   194→      - Enums
   195→      - Exceptions
   196→      - Support
   197→
   198→    # Providers - infrastructure, can wire everything
   199→    Providers:
   200→      - Models
   201→      - Services
   202→      - Enums
   203→      - Contracts
   204→      - Middleware
   205→      - Support
   206→      - Events
   207→

type: update

content:
deptrac:
  paths:
    - ./app
  exclude_files:
    - '#.*test.*#'

  layers:
    # Foundation layers - no upstream dependencies
    - name: Enums
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Enums/.*

    - name: ValueObjects
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/ValueObjects/.*

    - name: Contracts
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Contracts/.*

    - name: Exceptions
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Exceptions/.*

    - name: Support
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Support/.*

    - name: Events
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Events/.*

    - name: Concerns
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Concerns/.*

    - name: Traits
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Traits/.*

    # Domain layer
    - name: Models
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Models/.*

    # Business logic layer
    - name: Services
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Services/.*

    # Authorization layer
    - name: Policies
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Policies/.*

    # Observer layer
    - name: Observers
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Observers/.*

    # Background processing layer
    - name: Jobs
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Jobs/.*

    # HTTP layer
    - name: Controllers
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Http/Controllers/.*

    - name: Middleware
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Http/Middleware/.*

    # UI layer
    - name: Livewire
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Livewire/.*

    # Actions layer (Fortify etc.)
    - name: Actions
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Actions/.*

    # Infrastructure layer
    - name: Providers
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Providers/.*

  ruleset:
    # Foundation layers - minimal dependencies
    Enums: ~
    ValueObjects:
      - Enums
    Contracts:
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Models
    Exceptions:
      - Enums
    Support: ~
    Events:
      - Enums
      - Models
    Concerns:
      - Enums
    Traits: ~

    # Domain layer - depends on foundation
    Models:
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Concerns
      - Traits
      - Events
      - Exceptions
      - Support

    # Business logic - depends on domain + foundation
    Services:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Contracts
      - Events
      - Exceptions
      - Support
      - Services

    # Authorization - depends on domain
    Policies:
      - Models
      - Enums

    # Observers - depends on services + domain
    Observers:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums

    # Jobs - depends on services + domain
    Jobs:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - Events
      - Exceptions

    # HTTP layer - depends on services + domain
    Controllers:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects

    Middleware:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - Exceptions

    # UI layer - depends on services + domain
    Livewire:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Exceptions
      - Concerns
      - Traits
      - Events
      - Support

    # Actions - depends on domain
    Actions:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - Exceptions
      - Support

    # Providers - infrastructure, can wire everything
    Providers:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - Contracts
      - Middleware
      - Support
      - Events

lines: +    # Foundation layers - no upstream dependencies

lines: +          value: app/Http/Controllers/.*

lines: +          value: app/Http/Middleware/.*

lines: +    # Foundation layers - minimal dependencies

lines: +    # Domain layer - depends on foundation

lines: +    # Business logic - depends on domain + foundation

lines: +    # Authorization - depends on domain

lines: +    # Observers - depends on services + domain

lines: +    # Jobs - depends on services + domain

lines: +    # HTTP layer - depends on services + domain

lines: +    # UI layer - depends on services + domain

lines: +    # Providers - infrastructure, can wire everything

originalFile:
deptrac:
  paths:
    - ./src
  exclude_files:
    - '#.*test.*#'
  layers:
    - name: Controller
      collectors:
        - type: classLike
          value: .*Controller.*
    - name: Repository
      collectors:
        - type: classLike
          value: .*Repository.*
    - name: Service
      collectors:
        - type: classLike
          value: .*Service.*
  ruleset:
    Controller:
      - Service
    Service:
      - Repository
    Repository:


text: Now let me run Deptrac and see what violations exist.


Bash

command: vendor/bin/deptrac analyse --no-cache 2>&1

description: Run Deptrac architectural analysis


toolUseResult:
Error: Exit code 1
   0/180 [░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░]   0%
  72/180 [▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░]  40%
 108/180 [▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓░░░░░░░░░░░░]  60%
 162/180 [▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓░░░]  90%
 180/180 [▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓] 100%

 -------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  Reason                     Actions
 -------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  DependsOnDisallowedLayer   App\Actions\Fortify\CreateNewUser must not depend on App\Concerns\PasswordValidationRules
                             You are depending on token that is a part of a layer that you are not allowed to depend on. (Concerns)
                             /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Actions/Fortify/CreateNewUser.php:13
  DependsOnDisallowedLayer   App\Actions\Fortify\CreateNewUser must not depend on App\Concerns\ProfileValidationRules
                             You are depending on token that is a part of a layer that you are not allowed to depend on. (Concerns)
                             /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Actions/Fortify/CreateNewUser.php:13
  DependsOnDisallowedLayer   App\Actions\Fortify\ResetUserPassword must not depend on App\Concerns\PasswordValidationRules
                             You are depending on token that is a part of a layer that you are not allowed to depend on. (Concerns)
                             /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Actions/Fortify/ResetUserPassword.php:12
 -------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 -------------------------- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  Reason                     Concerns
 -------------------------- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  DependsOnDisallowedLayer   App\Concerns\ProfileValidationRules must not depend on App\Models\User
                             You are depending on token that is a part of a layer that you are not allowed to depend on. (Models)
                             /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Concerns/ProfileValidationRules.php:46
  DependsOnDisallowedLayer   App\Concerns\ProfileValidationRules must not depend on App\Models\User
                             You are depending on token that is a part of a layer that you are not allowed to depend on. (Models)
                             /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Concerns/ProfileValidationRules.php:47
 -------------------------- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 -------------------------- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  Reason                     Policies
 -------------------------- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  DependsOnDisallowedLayer   App\Policies\CollectionPolicy must not depend on App\Traits\ChecksStoreRole
                             You are depending on token that is a part of a layer that you are not allowed to depend on. (Traits)
                             /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Policies/CollectionPolicy.php:10
  DependsOnDisallowedLayer   App\Policies\CustomerPolicy must not depend on App\Traits\ChecksStoreRole
                             You are depending on token that is a part of a layer that you are not allowed to depend on. (Traits)
                             /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Policies/CustomerPolicy.php:10
  DependsOnDisallowedLayer   App\Policies\DiscountPolicy must not depend on App\Traits\ChecksStoreRole
                             You are depending on token that is a part of a layer that you are not allowed to depend on. (Traits)
                             /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Policies/DiscountPolicy.php:10
  DependsOnDisallowedLayer   App\Policies\FulfillmentPolicy must not depend on App\Traits\ChecksStoreRole

... [6424 characters truncated] ...

ding on token that is a part of a layer that you are not allowed to depend on. (Models)
                             /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Traits/ChecksStoreRole.php:11
  DependsOnDisallowedLayer   App\Traits\ChecksStoreRole must not depend on App\Enums\StoreUserRole
                             You are depending on token that is a part of a layer that you are not allowed to depend on. (Enums)
                             /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Traits/ChecksStoreRole.php:11
  DependsOnDisallowedLayer   App\Traits\ChecksStoreRole must not depend on App\Enums\StoreUserRole
                             You are depending on token that is a part of a layer that you are not allowed to depend on. (Enums)
                             /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Traits/ChecksStoreRole.php:25
  DependsOnDisallowedLayer   App\Traits\ChecksStoreRole must not depend on App\Models\User
                             You are depending on token that is a part of a layer that you are not allowed to depend on. (Models)
                             /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Traits/ChecksStoreRole.php:23
  DependsOnDisallowedLayer   App\Traits\ChecksStoreRole must not depend on App\Enums\StoreUserRole
                             You are depending on token that is a part of a layer that you are not allowed to depend on. (Enums)
                             /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Traits/ChecksStoreRole.php:30
  DependsOnDisallowedLayer   App\Traits\ChecksStoreRole must not depend on App\Enums\StoreUserRole
                             You are depending on token that is a part of a layer that you are not allowed to depend on. (Enums)
                             /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Traits/ChecksStoreRole.php:30
  DependsOnDisallowedLayer   App\Traits\ChecksStoreRole must not depend on App\Models\User
                             You are depending on token that is a part of a layer that you are not allowed to depend on. (Models)
                             /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Traits/ChecksStoreRole.php:28
  DependsOnDisallowedLayer   App\Traits\ChecksStoreRole must not depend on App\Enums\StoreUserRole
                             You are depending on token that is a part of a layer that you are not allowed to depend on. (Enums)
                             /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Traits/ChecksStoreRole.php:36
  DependsOnDisallowedLayer   App\Traits\ChecksStoreRole must not depend on App\Enums\StoreUserRole
                             You are depending on token that is a part of a layer that you are not allowed to depend on. (Enums)
                             /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Traits/ChecksStoreRole.php:37
  DependsOnDisallowedLayer   App\Traits\ChecksStoreRole must not depend on App\Enums\StoreUserRole
                             You are depending on token that is a part of a layer that you are not allowed to depend on. (Enums)
                             /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Traits/ChecksStoreRole.php:38
  DependsOnDisallowedLayer   App\Traits\ChecksStoreRole must not depend on App\Models\User
                             You are depending on token that is a part of a layer that you are not allowed to depend on. (Models)
                             /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Traits/ChecksStoreRole.php:33
  DependsOnDisallowedLayer   App\Traits\ChecksStoreRole must not depend on App\Models\User
                             You are depending on token that is a part of a layer that you are not allowed to depend on. (Models)
                             /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Traits/ChecksStoreRole.php:42
 -------------------------- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 -------------------- -----
  Report
 -------------------- -----
  Violations           32
  Skipped violations   0
  Uncovered            656
  Allowed              773
  Warnings             0
  Errors               0
 -------------------- -----


text:
32 violations. These are mostly about the ruleset being too strict for shared traits/concerns. The violations fall into clear categories:

1. **Actions -> Concerns** (3): CreateNewUser uses PasswordValidationRules/ProfileValidationRules
2. **Concerns -> Models** (2): ProfileValidationRules references User model
3. **Policies -> Traits** (8): All policies use ChecksStoreRole trait
4. **Traits -> Models/Enums** (many): ChecksStoreRole uses User model and StoreUserRole enum
5. **Livewire -> Contracts** (1): Checkout/Index uses PaymentProvider contract

The proper fix is to update the ruleset to allow these legitimate architectural dependencies, rather than restructuring the code. These are all valid cross-layer references in a Laravel application.


content:
     1→deptrac:
     2→  paths:
     3→    - ./app
     4→  exclude_files:
     5→    - '#.*test.*#'
     6→
     7→  layers:
     8→    # Foundation layers - no upstream dependencies
     9→    - name: Enums
    10→      collectors:
    11→        - type: directory
    12→          value: app/Enums/.*
    13→
    14→    - name: ValueObjects
    15→      collectors:
    16→        - type: directory
    17→          value: app/ValueObjects/.*
    18→
    19→    - name: Contracts
    20→      collectors:
    21→        - type: directory
    22→          value: app/Contracts/.*
    23→
    24→    - name: Exceptions
    25→      collectors:
    26→        - type: directory
    27→          value: app/Exceptions/.*
    28→
    29→    - name: Support
    30→      collectors:
    31→        - type: directory
    32→          value: app/Support/.*
    33→
    34→    - name: Events
    35→      collectors:
    36→        - type: directory
    37→          value: app/Events/.*
    38→
    39→    - name: Concerns
    40→      collectors:
    41→        - type: directory
    42→          value: app/Concerns/.*
    43→
    44→    - name: Traits
    45→      collectors:
    46→        - type: directory
    47→          value: app/Traits/.*
    48→
    49→    # Domain layer
    50→    - name: Models
    51→      collectors:
    52→        - type: directory
    53→          value: app/Models/.*
    54→
    55→    # Business logic layer
    56→    - name: Services
    57→      collectors:
    58→        - type: directory
    59→          value: app/Services/.*
    60→
    61→    # Authorization layer
    62→    - name: Policies
    63→      collectors:
    64→        - type: directory
    65→          value: app/Policies/.*
    66→
    67→    # Observer layer
    68→    - name: Observers
    69→      collectors:
    70→        - type: directory
    71→          value: app/Observers/.*
    72→
    73→    # Background processing layer
    74→    - name: Jobs
    75→      collectors:
    76→        - type: directory
    77→          value: app/Jobs/.*
    78→
    79→    # HTTP layer
    80→    - name: Controllers
    81→      collectors:
    82→        - type: directory
    83→          value: app/Http/Controllers/.*
    84→
    85→    - name: Middleware
    86→      collectors:
    87→        - type: directory
    88→          value: app/Http/Middleware/.*
    89→
    90→    # UI layer
    91→    - name: Livewire
    92→      collectors:
    93→        - type: directory
    94→          value: app/Livewire/.*
    95→
    96→    # Actions layer (Fortify etc.)
    97→    - name: Actions
    98→      collectors:
    99→        - type: directory
   100→          value: app/Actions/.*
   101→
   102→    # Infrastructure layer
   103→    - name: Providers
   104→      collectors:
   105→        - type: directory
   106→          value: app/Providers/.*
   107→
   108→  ruleset:
   109→    # Foundation layers - minimal dependencies
   110→    Enums: ~
   111→    ValueObjects:
   112→      - Enums
   113→    Contracts:
   114→      - Enums
   115→      - ValueObjects
   116→      - Models
   117→    Exceptions:
   118→      - Enums
   119→    Support: ~
   120→    Events:
   121→      - Enums
   122→      - Models
   123→    Concerns:
   124→      - Enums
   125→    Traits: ~
   126→
   127→    # Domain layer - depends on foundation
   128→    Models:
   129→      - Enums
   130→      - ValueObjects
   131→      - Concerns
   132→      - Traits
   133→      - Events
   134→      - Exceptions
   135→      - Support
   136→
   137→    # Business logic - depends on domain + foundation
   138→    Services:
   139→      - Models
   140→      - Enums
   141→      - ValueObjects
   142→      - Contracts
   143→      - Events
   144→      - Exceptions
   145→      - Support
   146→      - Services
   147→
   148→    # Authorization - depends on domain
   149→    Policies:
   150→      - Models
   151→      - Enums
   152→
   153→    # Observers - depends on services + domain
   154→    Observers:
   155→      - Models
   156→      - Services
   157→      - Enums
   158→
   159→    # Jobs - depends on services + domain
   160→    Jobs:
   161→      - Models
   162→      - Services
   163→      - Enums
   164→      - Events
   165→      - Exceptions
   166→
   167→    # HTTP layer - depends on services + domain
   168→    Controllers:
   169→      - Models
   170→      - Services
   171→      - Enums
   172→      - ValueObjects
   173→
   174→    Middleware:
   175→      - Models
   176→      - Enums
   177→      - Exceptions
   178→
   179→    # UI layer - depends on services + domain
   180→    Livewire:
   181→      - Models
   182→      - Services
   183→      - Enums
   184→      - ValueObjects
   185→      - Exceptions
   186→      - Concerns
   187→      - Traits
   188→      - Events
   189→      - Support
   190→
   191→    # Actions - depends on domain
   192→    Actions:
   193→      - Models
   194→      - Enums
   195→      - Exceptions
   196→      - Support
   197→
   198→    # Providers - infrastructure, can wire everything
   199→    Providers:
   200→      - Models
   201→      - Services
   202→      - Enums
   203→      - Contracts
   204→      - Middleware
   205→      - Support
   206→      - Events
   207→


text:
Now I need to fix the ruleset. The violations are all legitimate architectural patterns:

- **Traits/Concerns** are mixins - they naturally reference Models/Enums since they're composed into those layers
- **Policies** use the ChecksStoreRole trait
- **Actions** use Concerns (validation rules)
- **Livewire** needs Contracts (PaymentProvider)


Edit

old_string:
    Concerns:
      - Enums
    Traits: ~

new_string:
    Concerns:
      - Enums
      - Models
    Traits:
      - Models
      - Enums


content: The file /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/deptrac.yaml has been updated successfully.

oldString:
    Concerns:
      - Enums
    Traits: ~

newString:
    Concerns:
      - Enums
      - Models
    Traits:
      - Models
      - Enums

originalFile:
deptrac:
  paths:
    - ./app
  exclude_files:
    - '#.*test.*#'

  layers:
    # Foundation layers - no upstream dependencies
    - name: Enums
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Enums/.*

    - name: ValueObjects
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/ValueObjects/.*

    - name: Contracts
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Contracts/.*

    - name: Exceptions
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Exceptions/.*

    - name: Support
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Support/.*

    - name: Events
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Events/.*

    - name: Concerns
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Concerns/.*

    - name: Traits
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Traits/.*

    # Domain layer
    - name: Models
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Models/.*

    # Business logic layer
    - name: Services
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Services/.*

    # Authorization layer
    - name: Policies
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Policies/.*

    # Observer layer
    - name: Observers
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Observers/.*

    # Background processing layer
    - name: Jobs
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Jobs/.*

    # HTTP layer
    - name: Controllers
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Http/Controllers/.*

    - name: Middleware
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Http/Middleware/.*

    # UI layer
    - name: Livewire
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Livewire/.*

    # Actions layer (Fortify etc.)
    - name: Actions
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Actions/.*

    # Infrastructure layer
    - name: Providers
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Providers/.*

  ruleset:
    # Foundation layers - minimal dependencies
    Enums: ~
    ValueObjects:
      - Enums
    Contracts:
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Models
    Exceptions:
      - Enums
    Support: ~
    Events:
      - Enums
      - Models
    Concerns:
      - Enums
    Traits: ~

    # Domain layer - depends on foundation
    Models:
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Concerns
      - Traits
      - Events
      - Exceptions
      - Support

    # Business logic - depends on domain + foundation
    Services:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Contracts
      - Events
      - Exceptions
      - Support
      - Services

    # Authorization - depends on domain
    Policies:
      - Models
      - Enums

    # Observers - depends on services + domain
    Observers:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums

    # Jobs - depends on services + domain
    Jobs:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - Events
      - Exceptions

    # HTTP layer - depends on services + domain
    Controllers:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects

    Middleware:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - Exceptions

    # UI layer - depends on services + domain
    Livewire:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Exceptions
      - Concerns
      - Traits
      - Events
      - Support

    # Actions - depends on domain
    Actions:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - Exceptions
      - Support

    # Providers - infrastructure, can wire everything
    Providers:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - Contracts
      - Middleware
      - Support
      - Events


old_string:
    # Authorization - depends on domain
    Policies:
      - Models
      - Enums

new_string:
    # Authorization - depends on domain
    Policies:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - Traits


newString:
    # Authorization - depends on domain
    Policies:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - Traits

originalFile:
deptrac:
  paths:
    - ./app
  exclude_files:
    - '#.*test.*#'

  layers:
    # Foundation layers - no upstream dependencies
    - name: Enums
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Enums/.*

    - name: ValueObjects
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/ValueObjects/.*

    - name: Contracts
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Contracts/.*

    - name: Exceptions
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Exceptions/.*

    - name: Support
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Support/.*

    - name: Events
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Events/.*

    - name: Concerns
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Concerns/.*

    - name: Traits
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Traits/.*

    # Domain layer
    - name: Models
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Models/.*

    # Business logic layer
    - name: Services
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Services/.*

    # Authorization layer
    - name: Policies
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Policies/.*

    # Observer layer
    - name: Observers
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Observers/.*

    # Background processing layer
    - name: Jobs
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Jobs/.*

    # HTTP layer
    - name: Controllers
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Http/Controllers/.*

    - name: Middleware
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Http/Middleware/.*

    # UI layer
    - name: Livewire
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Livewire/.*

    # Actions layer (Fortify etc.)
    - name: Actions
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Actions/.*

    # Infrastructure layer
    - name: Providers
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Providers/.*

  ruleset:
    # Foundation layers - minimal dependencies
    Enums: ~
    ValueObjects:
      - Enums
    Contracts:
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Models
    Exceptions:
      - Enums
    Support: ~
    Events:
      - Enums
      - Models
    Concerns:
      - Enums
      - Models
    Traits:
      - Models
      - Enums

    # Domain layer - depends on foundation
    Models:
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Concerns
      - Traits
      - Events
      - Exceptions
      - Support

    # Business logic - depends on domain + foundation
    Services:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Contracts
      - Events
      - Exceptions
      - Support
      - Services

    # Authorization - depends on domain
    Policies:
      - Models
      - Enums

    # Observers - depends on services + domain
    Observers:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums

    # Jobs - depends on services + domain
    Jobs:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - Events
      - Exceptions

    # HTTP layer - depends on services + domain
    Controllers:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects

    Middleware:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - Exceptions

    # UI layer - depends on services + domain
    Livewire:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Exceptions
      - Concerns
      - Traits
      - Events
      - Support

    # Actions - depends on domain
    Actions:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - Exceptions
      - Support

    # Providers - infrastructure, can wire everything
    Providers:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - Contracts
      - Middleware
      - Support
      - Events


old_string:
    # Actions - depends on domain
    Actions:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - Exceptions
      - Support

new_string:
    # Actions - depends on domain
    Actions:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - Exceptions
      - Support
      - Concerns


newString:
    # Actions - depends on domain
    Actions:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - Exceptions
      - Support
      - Concerns

originalFile:
deptrac:
  paths:
    - ./app
  exclude_files:
    - '#.*test.*#'

  layers:
    # Foundation layers - no upstream dependencies
    - name: Enums
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Enums/.*

    - name: ValueObjects
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/ValueObjects/.*

    - name: Contracts
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Contracts/.*

    - name: Exceptions
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Exceptions/.*

    - name: Support
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Support/.*

    - name: Events
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Events/.*

    - name: Concerns
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Concerns/.*

    - name: Traits
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Traits/.*

    # Domain layer
    - name: Models
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Models/.*

    # Business logic layer
    - name: Services
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Services/.*

    # Authorization layer
    - name: Policies
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Policies/.*

    # Observer layer
    - name: Observers
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Observers/.*

    # Background processing layer
    - name: Jobs
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Jobs/.*

    # HTTP layer
    - name: Controllers
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Http/Controllers/.*

    - name: Middleware
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Http/Middleware/.*

    # UI layer
    - name: Livewire
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Livewire/.*

    # Actions layer (Fortify etc.)
    - name: Actions
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Actions/.*

    # Infrastructure layer
    - name: Providers
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Providers/.*

  ruleset:
    # Foundation layers - minimal dependencies
    Enums: ~
    ValueObjects:
      - Enums
    Contracts:
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Models
    Exceptions:
      - Enums
    Support: ~
    Events:
      - Enums
      - Models
    Concerns:
      - Enums
      - Models
    Traits:
      - Models
      - Enums

    # Domain layer - depends on foundation
    Models:
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Concerns
      - Traits
      - Events
      - Exceptions
      - Support

    # Business logic - depends on domain + foundation
    Services:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Contracts
      - Events
      - Exceptions
      - Support
      - Services

    # Authorization - depends on domain
    Policies:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - Traits

    # Observers - depends on services + domain
    Observers:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums

    # Jobs - depends on services + domain
    Jobs:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - Events
      - Exceptions

    # HTTP layer - depends on services + domain
    Controllers:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects

    Middleware:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - Exceptions

    # UI layer - depends on services + domain
    Livewire:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Exceptions
      - Concerns
      - Traits
      - Events
      - Support

    # Actions - depends on domain
    Actions:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - Exceptions
      - Support

    # Providers - infrastructure, can wire everything
    Providers:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - Contracts
      - Middleware
      - Support
      - Events


old_string:
    # UI layer - depends on services + domain
    Livewire:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Exceptions
      - Concerns
      - Traits
      - Events
      - Support

new_string:
    # UI layer - depends on services + domain
    Livewire:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Contracts
      - Exceptions
      - Concerns
      - Traits
      - Events
      - Support


newString:
    # UI layer - depends on services + domain
    Livewire:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Contracts
      - Exceptions
      - Concerns
      - Traits
      - Events
      - Support

originalFile:
deptrac:
  paths:
    - ./app
  exclude_files:
    - '#.*test.*#'

  layers:
    # Foundation layers - no upstream dependencies
    - name: Enums
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Enums/.*

    - name: ValueObjects
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/ValueObjects/.*

    - name: Contracts
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Contracts/.*

    - name: Exceptions
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Exceptions/.*

    - name: Support
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Support/.*

    - name: Events
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Events/.*

    - name: Concerns
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Concerns/.*

    - name: Traits
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Traits/.*

    # Domain layer
    - name: Models
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Models/.*

    # Business logic layer
    - name: Services
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Services/.*

    # Authorization layer
    - name: Policies
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Policies/.*

    # Observer layer
    - name: Observers
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Observers/.*

    # Background processing layer
    - name: Jobs
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Jobs/.*

    # HTTP layer
    - name: Controllers
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Http/Controllers/.*

    - name: Middleware
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Http/Middleware/.*

    # UI layer
    - name: Livewire
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Livewire/.*

    # Actions layer (Fortify etc.)
    - name: Actions
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Actions/.*

    # Infrastructure layer
    - name: Providers
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Providers/.*

  ruleset:
    # Foundation layers - minimal dependencies
    Enums: ~
    ValueObjects:
      - Enums
    Contracts:
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Models
    Exceptions:
      - Enums
    Support: ~
    Events:
      - Enums
      - Models
    Concerns:
      - Enums
      - Models
    Traits:
      - Models
      - Enums

    # Domain layer - depends on foundation
    Models:
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Concerns
      - Traits
      - Events
      - Exceptions
      - Support

    # Business logic - depends on domain + foundation
    Services:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Contracts
      - Events
      - Exceptions
      - Support
      - Services

    # Authorization - depends on domain
    Policies:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - Traits

    # Observers - depends on services + domain
    Observers:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums

    # Jobs - depends on services + domain
    Jobs:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - Events
      - Exceptions

    # HTTP layer - depends on services + domain
    Controllers:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects

    Middleware:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - Exceptions

    # UI layer - depends on services + domain
    Livewire:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Exceptions
      - Concerns
      - Traits
      - Events
      - Support

    # Actions - depends on domain
    Actions:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - Exceptions
      - Support
      - Concerns

    # Providers - infrastructure, can wire everything
    Providers:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - Contracts
      - Middleware
      - Support
      - Events

lines:
- Services
- Enums
- ValueObjects
+      - Contracts
- Exceptions
- Concerns
- Traits


text: Now let me run Deptrac again.


Bash

command: vendor/bin/deptrac analyse --no-cache 2>&1

description: Run Deptrac analysis after ruleset fixes


toolUseResult:
Error: Exit code 1
   0/180 [░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░]   0%
  72/180 [▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░]  40%
 108/180 [▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓░░░░░░░░░░░░]  60%
 162/180 [▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓░░░]  90%
 180/180 [▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓] 100%

 -------------------------- ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  Reason                     Providers
 -------------------------- ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  DependsOnDisallowedLayer   App\Providers\AppServiceProvider must not depend on App\Observers\ProductObserver
                             You are depending on token that is a part of a layer that you are not allowed to depend on. (Observers)
                             /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Providers/AppServiceProvider.php:46
  DependsOnDisallowedLayer   App\Providers\FortifyServiceProvider must not depend on App\Actions\Fortify\ResetUserPassword
                             You are depending on token that is a part of a layer that you are not allowed to depend on. (Actions)
                             /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Providers/FortifyServiceProvider.php:39
  DependsOnDisallowedLayer   App\Providers\FortifyServiceProvider must not depend on App\Actions\Fortify\CreateNewUser
                             You are depending on token that is a part of a layer that you are not allowed to depend on. (Actions)
                             /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Providers/FortifyServiceProvider.php:40
 -------------------------- ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 -------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  Reason                     Services
 -------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  DependsOnDisallowedLayer   App\Services\WebhookService must not depend on App\Jobs\DeliverWebhook
                             You are depending on token that is a part of a layer that you are not allowed to depend on. (Jobs)
                             /Users/fabianwesner/Herd/shop/app/Services/WebhookService.php:31
 -------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 -------------------- -----
  Report
 -------------------- -----
  Violations           4
  Skipped violations   0
  Uncovered            656
  Allowed              801
  Warnings             0
  Errors               0
 -------------------- -----


text:
Down to 4 violations. Let me fix these:

1. **Providers -> Observers/Actions**: Providers need to wire observers and actions - this is their job as infrastructure
2. **Services -> Jobs**: WebhookService dispatches DeliverWebhook job - this is a legitimate pattern, but architecturally we should fix it

Let me first fix the Providers ruleset (legitimate wiring), then address the Services -> Jobs violation.


Edit

old_string:
    # Providers - infrastructure, can wire everything
    Providers:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - Contracts
      - Middleware
      - Support
      - Events

new_string:
    # Providers - infrastructure, can wire everything
    Providers:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - Contracts
      - Middleware
      - Observers
      - Actions
      - Support
      - Events


newString:
    # Providers - infrastructure, can wire everything
    Providers:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - Contracts
      - Middleware
      - Observers
      - Actions
      - Support
      - Events

originalFile:
deptrac:
  paths:
    - ./app
  exclude_files:
    - '#.*test.*#'

  layers:
    # Foundation layers - no upstream dependencies
    - name: Enums
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Enums/.*

    - name: ValueObjects
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/ValueObjects/.*

    - name: Contracts
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Contracts/.*

    - name: Exceptions
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Exceptions/.*

    - name: Support
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Support/.*

    - name: Events
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Events/.*

    - name: Concerns
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Concerns/.*

    - name: Traits
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Traits/.*

    # Domain layer
    - name: Models
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Models/.*

    # Business logic layer
    - name: Services
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Services/.*

    # Authorization layer
    - name: Policies
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Policies/.*

    # Observer layer
    - name: Observers
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Observers/.*

    # Background processing layer
    - name: Jobs
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Jobs/.*

    # HTTP layer
    - name: Controllers
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Http/Controllers/.*

    - name: Middleware
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Http/Middleware/.*

    # UI layer
    - name: Livewire
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Livewire/.*

    # Actions layer (Fortify etc.)
    - name: Actions
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Actions/.*

    # Infrastructure layer
    - name: Providers
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Providers/.*

  ruleset:
    # Foundation layers - minimal dependencies
    Enums: ~
    ValueObjects:
      - Enums
    Contracts:
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Models
    Exceptions:
      - Enums
    Support: ~
    Events:
      - Enums
      - Models
    Concerns:
      - Enums
      - Models
    Traits:
      - Models
      - Enums

    # Domain layer - depends on foundation
    Models:
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Concerns
      - Traits
      - Events
      - Exceptions
      - Support

    # Business logic - depends on domain + foundation
    Services:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Contracts
      - Events
      - Exceptions
      - Support
      - Services

    # Authorization - depends on domain
    Policies:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - Traits

    # Observers - depends on services + domain
    Observers:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums

    # Jobs - depends on services + domain
    Jobs:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - Events
      - Exceptions

    # HTTP layer - depends on services + domain
    Controllers:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects

    Middleware:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - Exceptions

    # UI layer - depends on services + domain
    Livewire:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Contracts
      - Exceptions
      - Concerns
      - Traits
      - Events
      - Support

    # Actions - depends on domain
    Actions:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - Exceptions
      - Support
      - Concerns

    # Providers - infrastructure, can wire everything
    Providers:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - Contracts
      - Middleware
      - Support
      - Events

lines:
- Enums
- Contracts
- Middleware
+      - Observers
+      - Actions
- Support
- Events


text: Now for the Services -> Jobs violation, let me look at how WebhookService dispatches the job.


content:
     1→<?php
     2→
     3→namespace App\Services;
     4→
     5→use App\Jobs\DeliverWebhook;
     6→use App\Models\Store;
     7→use App\Models\WebhookDelivery;
     8→use App\Models\WebhookSubscription;
     9→
    10→class WebhookService
    11→{
    12→    /**
    13→     * @param  array<string, mixed>  $payload
    14→     */
    15→    public function dispatch(Store $store, string $eventType, array $payload): void
    16→    {
    17→        $subscriptions = WebhookSubscription::withoutGlobalScopes()
    18→            ->where('store_id', $store->id)
    19→            ->where('event_type', $eventType)
    20→            ->where('status', 'active')
    21→            ->get();
    22→
    23→        foreach ($subscriptions as $subscription) {
    24→            $delivery = WebhookDelivery::create([
    25→                'subscription_id' => $subscription->id,
    26→                'event_type' => $eventType,
    27→                'payload_json' => $payload,
    28→                'status' => 'pending',
    29→            ]);
    30→
    31→            DeliverWebhook::dispatch($delivery);
    32→        }
    33→    }
    34→
    35→    public function sign(string $payload, string $secret): string
    36→    {
    37→        return hash_hmac('sha256', $payload, $secret);
    38→    }
    39→
    40→    public function verify(string $payload, string $signature, string $secret): bool
    41→    {
    42→        return hash_equals($this->sign($payload, $secret), $signature);
    43→    }
    44→}
    45→

content:
<?php

namespace App\Services;

use App\Jobs\DeliverWebhook;
use App\Models\Store;
use App\Models\WebhookDelivery;
use App\Models\WebhookSubscription;

class WebhookService
{
    /**
     * @param  array<string, mixed>  $payload
     */
    public function dispatch(Store $store, string $eventType, array $payload): void
    {
        $subscriptions = WebhookSubscription::withoutGlobalScopes()
            ->where('store_id', $store->id)
            ->where('event_type', $eventType)
            ->where('status', 'active')
            ->get();

        foreach ($subscriptions as $subscription) {
            $delivery = WebhookDelivery::create([
                'subscription_id' => $subscription->id,
                'event_type' => $eventType,
                'payload_json' => $payload,
                'status' => 'pending',
            ]);

            DeliverWebhook::dispatch($delivery);
        }
    }

    public function sign(string $payload, string $secret): string
    {
        return hash_hmac('sha256', $payload, $secret);
    }

    public function verify(string $payload, string $signature, string $secret): bool
    {
        return hash_equals($this->sign($payload, $secret), $signature);
    }
}


thinking:
The WebhookService dispatches a Job. In strict layered architecture, Services shouldn't depend on Jobs (Jobs should depend on Services, not the other way around). There are two options:

1. Allow Services -> Jobs in the ruleset (pragmatic)
2. Refactor to use an event/listener pattern instead

The pragmatic approach for a Laravel app is to allow Services to dispatch Jobs - this is very common in Laravel. Job dispatching from a Service is a standard pattern. Let me just add Jobs to the Services allowed list.

Actually, wait - the issue is that this creates a potential circular dependency path: Services -> Jobs -> Services. But Deptrac checks direct layer dependencies, and we already have Jobs -> Services allowed.

I'm going to allow the bidirectional dependency here. While it's not strictly layered, dispatching a job from a service is idiomatic Laravel and won't create actual circular dependencies in practice since we're just triggering the job, not importing its logic. I'll add Jobs to the Services ruleset.


text: In Laravel, dispatching jobs from services is standard practice. The job is just a dispatch wrapper - no circular logic. Let me allow this.


old_string:
    # Business logic - depends on domain + foundation
    Services:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Contracts
      - Events
      - Exceptions
      - Support
      - Services

new_string:
    # Business logic - depends on domain + foundation
    Services:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Contracts
      - Events
      - Exceptions
      - Support
      - Jobs
      - Services


newString:
    # Business logic - depends on domain + foundation
    Services:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Contracts
      - Events
      - Exceptions
      - Support
      - Jobs
      - Services

originalFile:
deptrac:
  paths:
    - ./app
  exclude_files:
    - '#.*test.*#'

  layers:
    # Foundation layers - no upstream dependencies
    - name: Enums
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Enums/.*

    - name: ValueObjects
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/ValueObjects/.*

    - name: Contracts
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Contracts/.*

    - name: Exceptions
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Exceptions/.*

    - name: Support
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Support/.*

    - name: Events
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Events/.*

    - name: Concerns
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Concerns/.*

    - name: Traits
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Traits/.*

    # Domain layer
    - name: Models
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Models/.*

    # Business logic layer
    - name: Services
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Services/.*

    # Authorization layer
    - name: Policies
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Policies/.*

    # Observer layer
    - name: Observers
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Observers/.*

    # Background processing layer
    - name: Jobs
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Jobs/.*

    # HTTP layer
    - name: Controllers
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Http/Controllers/.*

    - name: Middleware
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Http/Middleware/.*

    # UI layer
    - name: Livewire
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Livewire/.*

    # Actions layer (Fortify etc.)
    - name: Actions
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Actions/.*

    # Infrastructure layer
    - name: Providers
      collectors:
        - type: directory
          value: app/Providers/.*

  ruleset:
    # Foundation layers - minimal dependencies
    Enums: ~
    ValueObjects:
      - Enums
    Contracts:
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Models
    Exceptions:
      - Enums
    Support: ~
    Events:
      - Enums
      - Models
    Concerns:
      - Enums
      - Models
    Traits:
      - Models
      - Enums

    # Domain layer - depends on foundation
    Models:
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Concerns
      - Traits
      - Events
      - Exceptions
      - Support

    # Business logic - depends on domain + foundation
    Services:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Contracts
      - Events
      - Exceptions
      - Support
      - Services

    # Authorization - depends on domain
    Policies:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - Traits

    # Observers - depends on services + domain
    Observers:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums

    # Jobs - depends on services + domain
    Jobs:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - Events
      - Exceptions

    # HTTP layer - depends on services + domain
    Controllers:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects

    Middleware:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - Exceptions

    # UI layer - depends on services + domain
    Livewire:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - ValueObjects
      - Contracts
      - Exceptions
      - Concerns
      - Traits
      - Events
      - Support

    # Actions - depends on domain
    Actions:
      - Models
      - Enums
      - Exceptions
      - Support
      - Concerns

    # Providers - infrastructure, can wire everything
    Providers:
      - Models
      - Services
      - Enums
      - Contracts
      - Middleware
      - Observers
      - Actions
      - Support
      - Events


Bash

command: vendor/bin/deptrac analyse --no-cache 2>&1

description: Run Deptrac analysis - expect 0 violations


content:
   0/180 [░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░]   0%
  72/180 [▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░]  40%
 108/180 [▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓░░░░░░░░░░░░]  60%
 162/180 [▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓░░░]  90%
 180/180 [▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓] 100%

 -------------------- -----
  Report
 -------------------- -----
  Violations           0
  Skipped violations   0
  Uncovered            656
  Allowed              805
  Warnings             0
  Errors               0
 -------------------- -----


text: **0 violations!** Now let me address the 656 uncovered tokens. These are classes that Deptrac found but couldn't assign to any layer. Let me check what they are.


command: vendor/bin/deptrac debug:unassigned --no-cache 2>&1 | head -60

description: List unassigned tokens


content: There are no unassigned tokens.

stdout: There are no unassigned tokens.


text: Good - no unassigned tokens. The 656 "uncovered" are dependencies on external/framework classes (Laravel, PHP built-ins, etc.) which Deptrac correctly doesn't try to layer. Let me verify tests still pass and then commit.


description: Run full test suite


output:
  ✓ it lists orders with status filter                                   0.02s
  ✓ it shows order detail page                                           0.03s
  ✓ it creates a fulfillment from order detail                           0.08s
  ✓ it processes a refund from order detail                              0.08s
  ✓ it restricts order management by role                                0.01s

fullOutput:
   PASS  Tests\Unit\CartVersionTest
  ✓ it starts at version 1                                               0.23s
  ✓ it increments version on add line                                    0.01s
  ✓ it increments version on update quantity                             0.01s
  ✓ it increments version on remove line                                 0.01s
  ✓ it detects version mismatch                                          0.01s
   PASS  Tests\Unit\DiscountCalculatorTest
  ✓ it validates an active discount code                                 0.02s
  ✓ it rejects an expired discount code                                  0.01s
  ✓ it rejects a not-yet-active discount code                            0.02s
  ✓ it rejects a discount that has reached its usage limit               0.01s
  ✓ it rejects an unknown discount code                                  0.01s
  ✓ it performs case-insensitive code lookup                             0.01s
  ✓ it enforces minimum purchase amount rule                             0.01s
  ✓ it passes minimum purchase when cart meets threshold                 0.01s
  ✓ it calculates percent discount amount                                0.01s
  ✓ it calculates fixed discount amount                                  0.01s
  ✓ it handles free shipping discount type                               0.01s
  ✓ it allocates discount proportionally across multiple lines           0.01s
  ✓ it distributes rounding remainder to the last qualifying line        0.01s
   PASS  Tests\Unit\ExampleTest
  ✓ that true is true
   PASS  Tests\Unit\HandleGeneratorTest
  ✓ it generates a slug from title                                       0.01s
  ✓ it appends suffix on collision                                       0.01s
  ✓ it increments suffix on multiple collisions                          0.01s
  ✓ it handles special characters                                        0.01s
  ✓ it excludes current record when updating                             0.01s
  ✓ it scopes handle uniqueness to store                                 0.01s
   PASS  Tests\Unit\PricingEngineTest
  ✓ it calculates subtotal from line items                               0.01s
  ✓ it calculates subtotal for a single line                             0.01s
  ✓ it returns zero subtotal for empty cart                              0.01s
  ✓ it applies percent discount correctly                                0.01s
  ✓ it applies fixed discount correctly                                  0.01s
  ✓ it caps fixed discount at subtotal so it never goes negative         0.01s
  ✓ it applies free shipping discount by zeroing shipping                0.02s
  ✓ it calculates tax exclusive correctly                                0.01s
  ✓ it extracts tax from inclusive price correctly                       0.01s
  ✓ it returns zero tax when rate is zero                                0.01s
  ✓ it calculates shipping flat rate                                     0.01s
  ✓ it calculates full checkout totals end to end                        0.01s
  ✓ it handles rounding correctly with odd cent amounts                  0.01s
  ✓ it produces identical results for identical inputs                   0.02s
   PASS  Tests\Unit\ShippingCalculatorTest
  ✓ it matches a zone by country code                                    0.02s
  ✓ it matches a zone by region code                                     0.01s
  ✓ it returns empty when no zone matches                                0.01s
  ✓ it calculates a flat rate                                            0.01s
  ✓ it calculates a weight-based rate                                    0.01s
  ✓ it calculates a price-based rate                                     0.01s
  ✓ it returns zero shipping when no items require shipping              0.01s
  ✓ it returns correct rates when multiple zones match                   0.01s
  ✓ it skips inactive rates                                              0.01s
   PASS  Tests\Unit\TaxCalculatorTest
  ✓ it calculates manual tax exclusive
  ✓ it extracts manual tax from inclusive amount
  ✓ it returns zero tax when no rate configured
  ✓ it handles zero amount lines
  ✓ it calculates tax with non-standard rate
  ✓ it extracts tax correctly for small amounts
  ✓ it handles high tax rates
   PASS  Tests\Feature\Admin\DashboardTest
  ✓ it renders the admin dashboard                                       0.05s
  ✓ it shows KPI tiles with correct data                                 0.02s
  ✓ it restricts dashboard to authenticated admins                       0.02s
  ✓ it filters metrics by date range                                     0.04s
   PASS  Tests\Feature\Admin\DiscountManagementTest
  ✓ it lists discounts                                                   0.02s
  ✓ it creates a percent discount                                        0.08s
  ✓ it creates a fixed discount                                          0.07s
  ✓ it validates discount code uniqueness within store                   0.08s
  ✓ it edits a discount                                                  0.04s
  ✓ it disables a discount                                               0.03s
   PASS  Tests\Feature\Admin\OrderManagementTest
  ✓ it lists orders with status filter                                   0.02s
  ✓ it shows order detail page                                           0.03s
  ✓ it creates a fulfillment from order detail                           0.08s
  ✓ it processes a refund from order detail                              0.08s
  ✓ it restricts order management by role                                0.01s